Power Xpert C445 Competitive Comparison

Transcription

1 Power Xpert C445 Competitive Comparison CPCD Product Line April 2015 Benefit over all competitors Advanced monitoring / control algorithms Motor efficiency, peak demand alarming, motor torque

2 Eaton C445 vs Eaton C440 & C441 Product C440 / XT C441 Motor Insight Range A (standard); 1500A (with external CTs) Up to 690 Vac 1 90A (standard); 540A (with external CTs) Up to 600 Vac A (standard); 800A (with external CTs) Up to 690 Vac (standard); 4160 Vac (with external PTs) Features Selectable trip class (10 A, 10, 20,30), ground fault and phase imbalance protections Flexible communication options for both monitoring and control Highly configurable line (voltage), load(power) and motor (current) monitoring and protection Optional remote user interface allows user to configure and monitor without opening a panel door All-in-one design reduces inventory costs by covering A applications with only two SKU numbers Full line, load and motor system coverage, including advanced monitoring and protection algorithms USB connectivity (both inside and outside the control panel door) provide monitoring and configuration with a PC Multiple predefined operating modes with corresponding control station options Global modular design allows for customization of system to match exact customer needs Extends the life of plant assets with selectable motor protection features Advanced diagnostics allow for quick and accurate identification of the root source of motor, pump or power quality faults Calculated motor efficiency and deviation algorithms learn average and peak usage values, notifying users when potential issues arise Benefits Status LED provides added assurance that valuable assets are protected by indicating the overload operational status Configurable low-power trip capability provides superior protection for smaller motors, slow speed motors and lightly loaded large motors Voltage Loss Restart ability removes the need for users to manually restart motors after momentary voltage dips by automatically staggering restarts Multiple embedded fieldbus options allow integration into widest range of PLC and DCS control systems without additional modules or supply power 2

3 Eaton C445 vs Siemens Simocode ProC Simocode ProC Limited communication options PROFIBUS, PROFINET Will not fit in smallest high-density Power Xpert CXH drawer Extremely limited motor protection functions Extensive onboard communications PROFIBUS, ModBus TCP / RTU, Ethernes/IP, USB Fits in all Power Xpert CXH high-density applications Best-in-class protections (most in the industry) with full configurability Ability to reach 630A FLA on standard unit and 820A with external CTs Ability to reach 136A FLA on standard unit and 800A with external CTs 3

4 Eaton C445 vs Siemens Simocode ProV Simocode ProV Limited communication options PROFIBUS, PROFINET Will not fit in smallest high-density Power Xpert CXH drawer Extensive onboard communications PROFIBUS, ModBus TCP / RTU, Ethernes/IP, USB Fits in all Power Xpert CXH high-density applications No advanced monitoring / control algorithms Advanced monitoring and control algorithms motor efficiency, peak demand alarming, motor torque, voltage loss restart for reacceleration. Soft starter, positioner, pole-changing reversing starter, dahlander reversing starter, star/delta reversing starter pre-defined operating modes Autotransformer, contactor control, and general purpose starter pre-defined operating modes 4

5 Eaton C445 vs Rockwell E3 Plus EC5 Limited communication options Ethernet/IP, DeviceNet E3+ Powered from DeviceNet network so if the communication network fails, overload powers down Extensive onboard communications PROFIBUS, ModBus TCP / RTU, Ethernes/IP, USB Universal AC (120/240) and DC (24) power options with self-powered communications Limited monitoring and control capabilities Advanced monitoring and control algorithms motor efficiency, peak demand alarming, motor torque, voltage loss restart for reacceleration. With external CTs, it is able to provide protection up to 5,000A With external CTs, it is able to provide protection up to 800A Provides external CT ground fault protection Will not be available until

6 Eaton C445 vs Rockwell E300 E300 Limited communication options Ethernet/IP, DeviceNet Temperature rating: -20 C to +55 C (Open) -20 C to +40 C (Enclosed) Extensive onboard communications PROFIBUS, ModBus TCP / RTU, Ethernes/IP, USB Temperature rating: -25 C to +65 C (Open and Enclosed) Limited monitoring and control capabilities Advanced monitoring and control algorithms motor efficiency, peak demand alarming, motor torque, voltage loss restart for reacceleration. Standard 6I/2O Expandable DIgital I/O Module (additional 4I/2O) Expandable Analog I/O Module (additional 3I/1O) Standard 4I/3O No expandable module until 2016 Provides external CT ground fault protection Will not be available until

7 Eaton C445 vs Schneider Tesys T Tesys T Will not fit in smallest high-density Power Xpert CXH drawer All-in-one packaging significantly reduces mounting flexibility within control panel Base module limited to 100 A and current only. Expansion modules required for voltage and power protections increase size by 33% Standard 6I/4O Expandable I/O Module (additional 4I/1O) Fits in all Power Xpert CXH high-density applications Modular design enables flexible installation for a variety of applications Voltage and power protection options are integrated into the existing footprint of the C445 system Standard 4I/3O No expandable module until 2016 Provides external CT ground fault protection Will not be available until

8 Eaton C445 vs Schweitzer SEL MOTORMAX SEL 849 Will not fit in smallest high-density Power Xpert CXH drawer All-in-one packaging significantly reduces mounting flexibility within control panel Supports four (4) operation modes Fits in all Power Xpert CXH high-density applications Modular design enables flexible installation for a variety of applications Supports ten (10) operation modes Provides external CT ground fault protection Will not be available until 2016 Built in arc-flash protection No arc flash protection 8

9 Eaton C445 vs ABB UMC 100 UMC 100 No Ethernet (Modbus TCP or EtherNet/IP) support No voltage / power monitoring and protection Base module only provides support up to 63A Ethernet communication option provides dualport EtherNet with EtherNet/IP, Modbus TCP, and built-in web pages Voltage and power protection options are integrated into the existing footprint Support up to 136A with measurement modules Expandable I/O Module (additional 8I/5O) Only 4I/3O until 2016 Provides external CT ground fault protection Will not be available until

10 10