AOP Framed! Informatics Center Federal University of Pernambuco

Transcription

1 AOP Framed! Henrique Rebêlo Informatics Center Federal University of Pernambuco Henrique Rebêlo 2009

2 Contacting Me Ph.D. student Henrique Rebêlo Specialist on AOSD, DbC, Static Metrics, JML Software Architecture, Product Lines, Empirical Studies Informatics Center Federal University of Pernambuco, UFPE Brazil

3 Talk Material - Contributions Prof. Paulo Borba (expert on aspect-oriented languages and refactoring) Prof. Sérgio Soares (expert on aspect-oriented software development) Prof. Alessandro Garcia (expert on aspect-oriented software assessment metrics) Prof. Fernando Castor Filho (expert on exception handling)

4 talk timeline OO, concerns, tangle, scatter, crosscut AOP AOSD and AspectJ overview research with AOP AOP in industry conclusion UCF 2009

5 OO scatter tangle exploring some of the terms we use crosscut and all that Copyright 2009, Henrique Rebêlo.

6 Object-Oriented Paradigm (OOP) object oriented decomposition modularization objects classes encapsulated data and procedures problem:? CLOS Simula 67 Smalltalk Eiffel C++ Java

7 Bad OO Design G D COMUNICATION BUSINESST A P bl t li f d ith Problem: tangling of code with different purposes

8 Good OO Design Graphical user interface (GUI) Comunication Business Data

9 Layered Architecture The various kinds of code should be written separately Separation of concepts concerns kinds of code separation of concerns

10 Need for Separation of Concerns Large complex distributed software systems Development requires focusing on one concern at a time

11 Separation of Concerns A concern is a specific requirement or consideration that must be addressed in order to satisfy the overall system goal The principle was coined by Edsger Dijkstra 1974 paper "On the Role of Scientific Thought" ht" he received the 1972 A. M. Turing Award for fundamental contributions in the area of programming languages

12 Effective Separation of Concerns improve... Quality attributtes stability reusability evolvability traceability composability maintainability reliability testability...

13 Good modularization without persistence, distribution,... public class Programa { Data [STAThread] public static void Main(string[] args) { Banco fachada = Banco.GetInstance(); Programa.menu(fachada); public static void menu(banco fachada) { string numero = null; double valor = 0.0; Conta conta = null; int opcao = 1; while (opcao!= 0) { try { System.Console.Out.WriteLine("Aperte <Enter> para continuar"); Util.Util.waitEnter(); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("\n\n\n\n\n\n\n"); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("Escolha uma das alternativas abaixo:"); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("1 - Cadastrar Conta"); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("2 - Creditar"); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("3 - Debitar"); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("4 - Transferir"); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("5 - Ver Saldo"); System.Console.Out.WriteLine("0 - Sair"); opcao = Util.Util.readInt(); switch (opcao) { Interface Business public class Banco { private CadastroContas contas; private Banco() { contas = new CadastroConta (new RepositorioContasAccess()); public class CadastroContas { private RepositorioContas contas; public void Debitar(string numero, double valor) { Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); c.debitar(valor); public class RepositorioContasArray : RepositorioContas { private Conta[] contas; private int indice; public RepositorioContasArray() { contas = new Conta[100]; indice = 0; public void Cadastrar(Conta conta) { public void Transferir(string numerode, string n contas.cadastrar(conta); umeropara, double valor) { public void Inserir(Conta conta) { Conta de = contas.procurar(numerode); contas[indice] = conta; Conta para = contas.procurar(numeropara); indice = indice + 1; de.debitar(valor); para.creditar(valor); public void Transferir(string numerode, string n umeropara, double valor) { contas.transferir(numerode, numeropara, valor); public double Saldo(string numero) { Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); return c.saldo; public void Atualizar(Conta conta) { int i = GetIndice(conta.Numero); if (i == indice) { throw new ContaNaoEncontradaException(conta.Numero); else { contas[i].atualizar(conta); [] public class Conta { private string numero; private double saldo; public void Creditar(double valor) { this.saldo = this.saldo + valor; public void Debitar(double valor) { if (valor > saldo) { throw new SaldoInsuficienteException)); else { this.saldo = this.saldo - valor; public void Atualizar(Conta c) { this.numero = c.numero; this.saldo = c.saldo;

14 We have problems with persistence using JDBC public class Banco { private CadastroContas contas; private Banco() { contas = new CadastroConta (new RepositorioContasAccess()); public void Cadastrar(Conta conta) { Persistence.DBHandler.StartTransaction(); try { contas.cadastrar(conta); Persistence.DBHandler.CommitTransaction(); catch (System.Exception ex){ Persistence.DBHandler.RollBackTransaction(); throw ex; public void Transferir(string numerode, string n umeropara, double valor) { Persistence.DBHandler.StartTransaction(); try { contas.transferir(numerode, numeropara, valor); Persistence.DBHandler.CommitTransaction(); catch (System.Exception ex){ Persistence.DBHandler.RollBackTransaction(); throw ex; public class CadastroContas { private RepositorioContas contas; public void Debitar(string numero, double valor) { Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); c.debitar(valor); contas.atualizar(c); public void Transferir(string numerode, string n umeropara, double valor) { Conta de = contas.procurar(numerode); Conta para = contas.procurar(numeropara); de.debitar(valor); para.creditar(valor); contas.atualizar(de); contas.atualizar(para); public double Saldo(string numero) { Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); return c.saldo; public class RepositorioContasAccess : RepositorioContas { public void Inserir(Conta conta) { string sql = "INSERT INTO Conta (NUMERO,SALDO) VALUES ('" + conta.numero + "'," + conta.saldo + ")"; OleDbCommand insertcommand = new OleDbCommand (sql,dbhandler.connection,dbhandler.transaction); insertcommand.executenonquery(); public void Atualizar(Conta conta) { string sql = "UPDATE Conta SET SALDO = (" + conta.as ldo + ") WHERE NUMERO = '" + conta.numero + "'"; OleDbCommand updatecommand = new OleDbCommand(s ql,dbhandler.connection,dbhandler.transaction); int linhasafetadas; linhasafetadas = updatecommand.executenonquery(); if (linhasafetadas == 0) { throw new ContaNaoEncontradaException(conta.Numero); public class DBHandler { private static OleDbConnection connection; public static OleDbConnection Connection { get { if (connection == null) { string datasource = "BancoCS.mdb"; string strconexao = "Provider= Microsoft.Jet.OLEDB.4.0; " + "Data Source=" + datasource; connection = new OleDbConnection(strConexao); return connection; public class Conta { private string numero; private double saldo; public void Creditar(double valor) { this.saldo = this.saldo + valor; public void Debitar(double valor) { if (valor > saldo) { throw new SaldoInsuficienteException)); else { this.saldo = this.saldo - valor; public void Atualizar(Conta c) { this.numero = c.numero; this.saldo = c.saldo; JDBC code in red public static OleDbConnection GetOpenConnection() { Connection.Open(); return Connection; public static void StartTransaction() { Connection.Open(); transaction = Connection.BeginTransaction();

15 What is the problem? Bad modularization of system-wide, peripheral p concerns at the implementation level Symptoms Code tangling Code scattering

16 Problems with OO implementation Code tangling public class Banco { private CadastroContas contas; private Banco() { contas = new CadastroConta (new RepositorioContasAccess()); public void Cadastrar(Conta conta) { Persistence.DBHandler.StartTransaction(); try { contas.cadastrar(conta); Persistence.DBHandler.CommitTransaction(); catch (System.Exception ex){ Persistence.DBHandler.RollBackTransaction(); throw ex; public void Transferir(string numerode, string n umeropara, double valor) { Persistence.DBHandler.StartTransaction(); try { contas.transferir(numerode, numeropara, valor); Persistence.DBHandler.CommitTransaction(); catch (System.Exception ex){ Persistence.DBHandler.RollBackTransaction(); ll i throw ex; public class CadastroContas { private RepositorioContas contas; public void Debitar(string numero, double valor) { Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); c.debitar(valor); contas.atualizar(c); public void Transferir(string numerode, string n umeropara, double valor) { Conta de = contas.procurar(numerode); Conta para = contas.procurar(numeropara); de.debitar(valor); para.creditar(valor); contas.atualizar(de); contas.atualizar(para); public double Saldo(string numero) { Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); return c.saldo; public class DBHandler { private static OleDbConnection connection; public static OleDbConnection Connection { get { if (connection == null) { string datasource = "BancoCS.mdb"; string strconexao = "Provider= Microsoft.Jet.OLEDB.4.0; " + "Data Source=" + datasource; connection = new OleDbConnection(strConexao); return connection; public static OleDbConnection GetOpenConnection() { Connection.Open(); return Connection; public static void StartTransaction() { Connection.Open(); transaction = Connection.BeginTransaction(); Code scattering

17 Problem with OO Code related to such concerns are crosscutting Scattered across several modules of implementation (classes) Each color is one different concern

18 Redundance More OO Problems several similar code fragments in several places of the source code Weak cohesion methods of the affected classes contain instructions that are not directed related to the core concern in which they implement Strong coupling methods of the affected classes need to be aware of methods from classes s which implement the scattered funcionality

19 The Problem of Crosscutting Concerns Certain properties naturally have global, pervasive effects over the system decompositions examples: exception handling, distribution, persistence OO Decomposition Crosscutting Concerns Classes Hamper software reusability, maintainability, and the like p y, y, Domain-specific programming languages started to emerge...

20 Persistence is a crosscutting concern public class Banco { private CadastroContas contas; public class CadastroContas { private RepositorioContas contas; public class RepositorioContasAccess : RepositorioContas { public void Inserir(Conta conta) { string sql = "INSERT INTO Conta (NUMERO,SALDO) private Banco() { public void Debitar(string numero, double valor) { VALUES ('" + conta.numero + "'," + conta.saldo + ")"; contas = new CadastroConta Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); OleDbCommand insertcommand = new OleDbCommand (new RepositorioContasAccess()); c.debitar(valor); (sql,dbhandler.connection,dbhandler.transaction); contas.atualizar(c); insertcommand.executenonquery(); public void Cadastrar(Conta conta) { Persistence.DBHandler.StartTransaction(); public void Transferir(string numerode, string n public void Atualizar(Conta conta) { try { umeropara, double valor) { string sql = "UPDATE Conta SET SALDO = (" + conta.as contas.cadastrar(conta); Conta de = contas.procurar(numerode); ldo + ") WHERE NUMERO = '" + conta.numero + "'"; Persistence.DBHandler.CommitTransaction(); Conta para = contas.procurar(numeropara); OleDbCommand updatecommand = new OleDbCommand(s catch (System.Exception ti ex){ de.debitar(valor); ql,dbhandler.connection,dbhandler.transaction); public void Atualizar(Conta c) Persistence.DBHandler.RollBackTransaction(); para.creditar(valor); int linhasafetadas; throw ex; contas.atualizar(de); linhasafetadas = updatecommand.executenonquery(); contas.atualizar(para); if (linhasafetadas == 0) { throw new ContaNaoEncontradaException(conta.Numero); public void Transferir(string numerode, string n public double Saldo(string numero) { umeropara, double valor) { Conta c = contas.procurar(numero); Persistence.DBHandler.StartTransaction(); return c.saldo; try { contas.transferir(numerode, numeropara, valor); Persistence.DBHandler.CommitTransaction(); public class DBHandler { catch (System.Exception ex){ Persistence.DBHandler.RollBackTransaction(); throw ex; Persistence code in red crosscuts business private static OleDbConnection connection; public static OleDbConnection Connection { get { if (connection == null) { string datasource = "BancoCS.mdb"; string strconexao = "Provider= Microsoft.Jet.OLEDB.4.0; " + "Data Source=" + datasource; connection = new OleDbConnection(strConexao); return connection; public static OleDbConnection GetOpenConnection() { Connection.Open(); return Connection; public static void StartTransaction() { Connection.Open(); transaction = Connection.BeginTransaction(); public class Conta { private string numero; private double saldo; public void Creditar(double valor) { this.saldo = this.saldo + valor; public void Debitar(double valor) { if (valor > saldo) { throw new SaldoInsuficienteException)); else { this.saldo = this.saldo - valor; bli id At li (C t ) { this.numero = c.numero; this.saldo = c.saldo;

21 Crosscutting concerns... cannot be properly modularized by OO constructs because their realization affects the behavior of several methods, possibly in several classes, cutting across class structures

22 Tangling and scattering of... Concerns Persistence Use cases Concurrency Performance control Design by Logging Contract Security Events

23 Generalizing the Problem Primary Functionality Persistence distribution Data Classes Account Loan Customer User Interface ATM Web PC Terminal

24 Root of Cause Copyright 2002, Silvio do Lago Pereira. Persistence The concern is crosscutting to the dimension of the implementation

25 AOP AOSD and exploring another way to promote modularization AspectJ overview Copyright 2009, Henrique Rebêlo.

26 Aspect-oriented languages are quite popular... due to the promise of modularizing crosscutting concerns

27 Aspect-Oriented Programming (AOP) Distribution Security Data Management AOP tools, techniques and methodology Distribution Security Data Management

28 Revisiting the Example Primary Functionality Persistence Distribution Data Classes Account Loan Customer User Interface ATM Web PC Terminal

29 Wouldn t itbeniceif if Data Classes Account aspect Persistence Loan aspect Distribution Customer User Interface ATM Web PC Terminal

30 From your experience Which other system concerns are typically y crosscutting?

31 Quantification is the basic concept of AOP T m() T m() Advice = m() m() m() m() m() m() m() m() m() m() m() m()

32 The success of AOP Persistence code is localized, can be understood in isolation, part of it can be reused Business code can be reused to work with other persistence APIs Business code is not invaded by changes to persistence APIs Less code, more code units

33 Towards to Aspect Oriented Software Development (AOSD)

34 Step 1: Concern identification (decomposition) Concern Identification Concerns Requirements Requirements engineering

35 Examples of Identified Concerns Graphical user interface Distribution Data management Business rules Concurrency control

36 Step 2: Concern Implementation

37 Step 3: System Recomposition classes and interfaces aspects W E A V E R Executable System

38 Aspect Oriented Software Development Requisitos concern identification concerns W OOP Classes e a v AOP Aspects e r Program Business rules Concurrency control Data management Graphical user interface Distribution

39 OOP vs. AOP Business rules Concurrency control Data management Graphical user interface Distribution

40 Context: Objects vs. Aspects Aspect-oriented programming (AOP) modularizing crosscutting concerns (CCCs) OO Decomposition Crosscutting Concerns Aspect-Oriented Decomposition Aspect Join Points Classes enhancing reusability, maintainability, and the like AspectJ: most popular aspect-oriented language

41 Aspect-Oriented Programming (AOP): The AspectJ Approach Classes Class A Class B Aspect Weaver Composed Code Aspect X Aspects Aspect Y Legend Class Aspect Join Points: Reference points in classes used by aspects for specifying relationships with classes

42 Pointcuts define a set of join points join points can be: calls and executions of methods (and also constructors) field access exception handling static initialization joint point composition &&, e!

43 Advice in AspectJ provides extra behavior at join points Define additional code that should be executed... before after after returning after throwing or around join points

44 Persistence at facade public class Banco { private CadastroContas contas;... public void cadastrar(conta t conta) { try { getpm().starttransaction(); contas.cadastrar(conta);... getpm().committransaction(); catch (Exception ex){ getpm().rollbacktransaction();......

45 Pointcut (with a simple alternative) pointcut transmethods(): execution (public * Banco.cadastrar(..)) execution (public * Banco.creditar(..)) execution (public * Banco.deditar(..))... pointcut transmethods(): execution (public * Banco.*(..));

46 Advice for normal flow public aspect PersistenceAspect { before(): transmethods() { getpm().starttransaction(); after() returning(): transmethods() { getpm().committransaction();

47 Advice for exceptional flow Exception is not captured after() throwing(): transmethods() { getpm().rollbacktransaction();...

48 Besides dynamic crosscutting with advice... AspectJ also supports static crosscutting change the relation of subtypes add members into classes Inter-type declarations

49 Static crosscutting pointcut TransMethods(): execution (public * Trans.*(..)); private interface Trans { public void cadastrar(conta conta);... declare parents: Banco implements Trans; interface locall to the aspect changing the hierarchy

50 Research with discussing about some researches that use AOP AOP Copyright 2009, Henrique Rebêlo.

51 Research with AOP There are several other Exception handling improvement Exception handling refactoring AO refactoring...

52 AOP in discussing about the adoption of AOP in idustry industry Copyright 2009, Henrique Rebêlo.

53 AOP in Industry Used tools Spring AOP JBoss AOP AspectJ PostSharp (.NET) Compose* EOS (.NET) Glassbox

54 Aspects in some Brazilian companies In most cases this means Spring AOP, but AspectJ is used too Popular concerns Transactional control Access control Logging Security Business code with reduced Business code with reduced maintenance and more reuse

55 IBM Aspects in some known supports AspectJ Motorola WEAVR Microsoft companies Policy Injection Application Block

56 Conclusions OO appeared with Simula 67 became popular in the industry after years? design patterns AOP has 15 years some use in big companies

57 AOP Framed! Henrique Rebêlo Informatics Center Federal University of Pernambuco Henrique Rebêlo 2009