INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATION FOR STANDARDISATION ORGANISATION INTERNATIONALE DE NORMALISATION ISO/IEC JTC1//WG1 CODING OF STILL PICTURES TITLE: Meeting Report, 52 nd Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 2010-07-12 to 2010-07-16, Brussels, Belgium SOURCE: WG1 Convener ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 N5528 Date: 2010-07-16 1 1. Open meeting The 52 nd WG1 Brussels Meeting was held on July 12 16, 2010 in Brussels, hosted by the Vrije Universiteit Brussels, the Interdisciplinary Institute for Broadband Technology (IBBT) and the Belgian National Body. The meeting was organized by Dr. Peter Schelkens of Brije Universiteit Brussels. 1.1 Roll call There were 41 delegates from 12 national bodies attended the meeting. The meeting attendance is contained in WG1N5409. 5409 2010-03-19 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting, Registration/Attendance List WG1 2. Approval of agenda The meeting agenda was approved in WG1N5408. 5408 2010-03-19 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting, Draft Meeting Agenda WG1 wg1n5408.doc 3. Organisation of this meeting 3.1 Registration and allocation of contributions 5408 2010-03-19 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting, Draft Meeting Agenda WG1 wg1n5408.doc 3.2 Nomination of Resolutions/Liaisons Drafting Committee The Resolutions Drafting Committee was nominated and approved. Japan Korea France Germany USA Dr. Fumitaka Ono (Chair) Dr. Youngseop Kim Dr. Chaker Larabi Siegfried Foessel Dr. Gary Sullivan - 1 -
3.3 Finalize meeting time allocation 5408 2010-03-19 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting, Draft Meeting Agenda WG1 wg1n5408.doc 2 4. Report on the previous meeting and interim period 4.1 Reports from after 51st WG1 Boston Meeting Notice of Publications: 5430 2010-04-27 5448 2010-07-07 Notice of Publication: ISO/IEC 24800-3:2010, Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 3: Query format Notice of Publication: ISO/IEC 15444-8:2007/Amd.1:2010, Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Secure JPEG 2000, AMENDMENT 1: File format security wg1n5430.zip wg1n5448.zip 5425 2010-04-27 5426 2010-04-27 5428 2010-04-27 5429 2010-04-27 5443 2010-07-06 5446 2010-07-06 5453 2010-07-07 5454 2010-07-07 Summary of Voting: Table of Replies on ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/FDAM 4: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Core coding system, AMENDMENT 4: Profiles for broadcast applications Table of Replies on ISO/IEC FDIS 24800-3: Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 3: Query format Summary of Voting on Combined PDAM Registration and PDAM Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC 14496-12:2008/PDAM 2 & ISO/IEC 15444-12:2008/PDAM 2 Summary of Response to Proposal of Minor Enhancement to the SC 29 Project, JTC 1.29.13.212.02 (14496-12/AMD2) and JTC.1.29.14.212.02 (15444-12/AMD2) Summary of Response to Request for Appointment of Project Editors, ISO/IEC 15444-11, 24800-5, 24800-6, 29199-2 2nd Edition, and 29199-5 Summary of Response to Request for JTC 1 Approval to Extend ISO limit dates for ISO/IEC 29170 [JTC 1 N 10053] Table of Replies on ISO/IEC FDIS 29199-4: Information technology -- image coding system -- Part 4: Conformance testing Table of Replies on ISO/IEC 29199-5: Information technology -- image coding system -- Part 5: Reference software wg1n5425.zip wg1n5426.zip wg1n5428.zip wg1n5429.zip wg1n5443.zip wg1n5446.zip wg1n5453.zip wg1n5454.zip 5410 2010-03-26 Progression of WG1 work items: ISO/IEC 14492:2001/FPDAM 3: Information technology -- Lossy/lossless coding of bi-level images, AMENDMENT 3: Extension to colour coding wg1n5410.zip - 2 -
3 5411 2010-03-26 Disposition of Comments Report on Combined PDAM Registration and PDAM Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/PDAM 3: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Core coding system, AMENDMENT 3: Guidelines for digital cinema applications wg1n5411.zip 5412 2010-03-26 ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/FPDAM 3: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Core coding system, AMENDMENT 3: Guidelines for digital cinema applications wg1n5412.zip 5413 2010-03-26 ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/FPDAM 5: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Core coding system, AMENDMENT 5: Enhancements for digital cinema and archive profiles (additional frame rates) wg1n5413.zip 5414 2010-03-26 ISO/IEC 15444-11:2007/FPDAM 1: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Wireless, AMENDMENT 1: IP based wireless networks wg1n5414.zip 5415 2010-03-26 Text of ISO/IEC 15444-3:2007/FDAM 1: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Motion JPEG 2000, AMENDMENT 1: Additional profiles for archiving applications wg1n5415.zip 5416 2010-03-26 Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to SMPTE on ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/FDAM 4 wg1n5416.zip 5423 2010-04-27 Request for Appointment of Project Editors, ISO/IEC 15444-11, 24800-5, 24800-6, 29199-2 2nd Edition, and 29199-5 wg1n5423.zip 5424 2010-04-27 Final Text of ISO/IEC 29199-2 2nd Edition: Information technology -- image coding system -- Part 2: Image coding specification wg1n5424.zip 5427 2010-04-27 Combined PDAM Registration and PDAM Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC 15444-2:2004/PDAM 3: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Extensions, AMENDMENT 3: Extended ROI boxes, XML boxing, compressed channel definition boxes, representation of floating point data and box-based file format for JPEG-XR wg1n5427.zip 5431 2010-05-13 Draft Corrigendum for 29199-5: image coding system Reference software wg1n5431.zip 5432 2010-05-26 Disposition of Comments Report on Combined CD Registration and CD Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC CD 24800-5, Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 5: Data interchange format between image wg1n5432.zip - 3 -
4 repositories 5433 2010-05-26 ISO/IEC FCD 24800-5, Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 5: Data interchange format between image repositories wg1n5433.zip 5434 2010-05-26 Disposition of Comments Report on ISO/IEC FCD 29199-3: Information technology -- image coding system: Motion wg1n5434.zip 5435 2010-05-26 Text of ISO/IEC FDIS 29199-3: Information technology -- image coding system: Motion wg1n5435.zip 5444 2010-07-06 Disposition of Comments Report on ISO/IEC FCD 24800-4: Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 4: File format for metadata embedded in image data (JPEG and JPEG 2000) wg1n5444.zip 5445 2010-07-06 Text of ISO/IEC FDIS 24800-4: Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 4: File format for metadata embedded in image data (JPEG and JPEG 2000) wg1n5445.zip Notices and Reports: 5438 2010-06-28 Report of April 2010 SCIT meeting SCIT wg1n5438.ppt 5446 2010-07-06 5447 2010-07-06 Summary of Response to Request for JTC 1 Approval to Extend ISO limit dates for ISO/IEC 29170 [JTC 1 N 10053] Announcement of ISO/IEC Directives Supplement - Procedures specific to JTC 1 (First edition, 2010) /IEC 29170 [JTC 1 N 10053] wg1n5446.zip wg1n5447.zip 5449 2010-07-07 UK National Body Contribution on Facilities Fee wg1n5449.zip 5450 2010-07-07 UK National Body Contribution on SC 29/Advisory Group on Management (AGM) wg1n5450.zip 5451 2010-07-07 UK National Body Contribution on Plenary Meeting wg1n5451.zip 5452 2010-07-07 UK National Body Contribution on Visibility of Calls for Proposals, Calls for Technology and Calls for Evidence in SC 29 wg1n5452.zip 5. Liaisons, correspondences, etc. 5416 2010-03-26 5417 2010-03-26 Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to SMPTE on ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/FDAM 4 Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to SMPTE on ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004/Amd.5 wg1n5416.zip wg1n5417.zip - 4 -
5418 2010-03-26 5419 2010-03-26 5420 2010-03-26 5421 2010-03-26 5422 2010-03-26 Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to WG 11 on Professional Archival Application Format Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to ISO TC 42 on Call for Technologies of Advanced Image Coding for Camera Sensor Data Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to DICOM on Call for Technologies of Advanced Image Coding for Camera Sensor Data Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to DICOM on Call for Medical Image Databases Liaison Statement from SC 29/WG 1 to ISO TC 223/WG 5 on Call for Advanced Image Coding for Security Applications wg1n5418.zip wg1n5419.zip wg1n5420.zip wg1n5421.zip wg1n5422.zip 5461 2010-07-09 FNB Concerns about WG-1 activities French NB wg1n5461.doc 5465 2010-07-11 Presentation on test imaging in JPEG Elysium Ltd 5523 2010-07-16 Statement of benefits from establishing a Category C liaison with CIE 5525 2010-07-13 JPEG-LS - thoughts on parallelization Tokyo Polytechnic 5 wg1n5523.doc wg1n5525.pdf 6. Project JTC 1.29.04.03 (10918-1) JPEG Part 1 5442 2010-07-06 Guidelines for the Support of JPEG Images in Print Applications InfoPrint Solutions Company 5465 2010-07-11 Presentation on test imaging in JPEG Elysium Ltd 5511 2010-07-15 5512 2010-07-15 5516 2010-07-15 5522 2010-07-16 DOCR for ISO/IEC FCD 10918-5: JPEG File Interchange Format (JFIF) ISO/IEC FDIS 10918-5: JPEG File Interchange Format (JFIF) Potential amendment to ISO/IEC 10918-5: Support of JPEG images for print applications Summary of ISO/IEC 10918-5: JPEG File Interchange Format (JFIF) Microsoft Corp. Microsoft Corp. InfoPrint Solutions Company Microsoft Corp. wg1n5442.zip wg1n5511.doc wg1n5516.doc - 5 -
6 7. Project JTC 1.29.12 (14495) JPEG - LS : Lossless Compression of Continuous-tone Still Pictures The following presentation was given at the Wednesday WG1 Plenary meeting. 5525 2010-07-13 JPEG-LS - thoughts on parallelization wg1n5525.pdf 8. Project JTC 1.29.03 (11544) JBIG: Progressive Bi-level Image Compression 9. Project JTC 1.29.10 (14492) JBIG2: Lossy/Lossless Coding of Bi-level Images 5508 2010-07-15 Brussels JBIG meeting Report 5526 2010-07-16 FDAM text for JBIG2 AMD3(ISO/IEC 14492 AMD3) Tokyo Polytechnic Tokyo Polytechnic wg1n5508.ppt 10. Project JTC 1.29.14 (15444) JPEG 2000 Image Coding System 10.1 Report on results from 51 st WG1 Boston meeting National Bodies/Liaison Comments, correspondences, presentations, etc 5439 2010-07-01 JNB Response to N5379 Sony Corporation wg1n5439.pdf 5440 2010-07-01 5441 2010-07-02 5482 2010-07-14 5484 2010-07-14 5527 2010-07-16 JPEG 2000 codec executables with JNB proposal on Enhanced Lazy Mode Coding Continuous Experimental Results of the Extension of Lazy Mode for JPEG2000 Lossless Coding Quality metrics requirements for forensics Stereoscopic Disparity map using the belief propagation and the edge algorithm Geometric Representation Integrated Dataspace Takushoku university Sony Corporation Thales Communications Dankook Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency wg1n5440.zip wg1n5441.pdf wg1n5482.pdf wg1n5484.ppt wg1n5527.ppt Historical Archive AHG 5465 2010-07-11 Presentation on test imaging in JPEG Elysium Ltd - 6 -
5521 2010-07-16 5527 2010-07-16 JPEG Innovations JPEG Innovations report at 52nd WG1 meeting, Brussels, 12-16 July, 2010 Geometric Representation Integrated Dataspace EPFL Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency 7 wg1n5521.pdf wg1n5527.ppt 5471 2010-07-13 Digital Cinema AHG FDAM 5 of JPEG2000 part 1 Additional Frame Rates Dolby Labs wg1n5471.doc 5472 2010-07-13 ITU-T Summary on FDAM 5 of ISO15444-1 Dolby Labs wg1n5472.doc 5473 2010-07-13 WG1 liaison to SMPTE Dolby Labs wg1n5473.doc 5475 2010-07-13 WG1 liaison to WG 11 Systems 5476 2010-07-13 WG1 liaison to VSF Analog Devices, Inc Analog Devices, Inc 5478 2010-07-13 Meeting Report DCinema AHG Fraunhofer IIS 5488 2010-07-14 Summary of Amendment 3: 15444-1/AMD3 Guidelines for digital cinema applications wg1n5475.doc wg1n5476.doc wg1n5488.doc wg1n5488-1.doc 10.3 JPEG 2000 Part 1: Core Coding System 5439 2010-07-01 JNB Response to N5379 5440 2010-07-01 5441 2010-07-02 5471 2010-07-13 JPEG 2000 codec executables with JNB proposal on Enhanced Lazy Mode Coding Continuous Experimental Results of the Extension of Lazy Mode for JPEG2000 Lossless Coding FDAM 5 of JPEG2000 part 1 Additional Frame Rates Sony Corporation Takushoku university Sony Corporation Dolby Labs wg1n5439.pdf wg1n5440.zip wg1n5441.pdf wg1n5471.doc 5472 2010-07-13 ITU-T Summary on FDAM 5 of ISO15444-1 Dolby Labs wg1n5472.doc 5473 2010-07-13 WG1 liaison to SMPTE Dolby Labs wg1n5473.doc 5488 2010-07-14 Summary of Amendment 3: 15444-1/AMD3 Guidelines for digital cinema applications wg1n5488.doc wg1n5488-1.doc - 7 -
10.4 JPEG 2000 Part 2: Extensions 5464 2010-07-11 5467 2010-07-12 Proposed NWI - Update to ISO 15444-1, JP2 file format Summary of Voting on ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29 N 11162 : Combined PDAM Registration and PDAM Consideration Ballot on ISO/IEC 15444-2:2004/PDAM 3: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system: Extensions, AMENDMENT 3: Extended ROI boxes, XML boxing, compressed channel definition boxes, representation of floating point data and box-based file format for JPEG-XR Elysium Ltd and Rob Buckley Consulting 8 wg1n5464.pdf wg1n5467.zip 10.5 JPEG 2000 Part 3: Motion JPEG 2000 (MJ2) No action. 10.6 JPEG 2000 Part 4: Conformance Testing No action. 10.7 JPEG 2000 Part 5: Reference Software No action. 10.8 JPEG 2000 Part 6: JPM No action. 10.9 JPEG 2000 Part 8: JPSEC 5477 2010-07-13 Decision request from JPSEC RA 5520 2010-07-16 JPEG Registraton Authority AhG Meeting Report at Brussels 52nd WG1 meeting JuGeMu Co.,Ltd. EPFL wg1n5477.pdf wg1n5520.pdf 10.10 JPEG 2000 Part 9: JPIP 5518 2010-07-15 WD3 of AMD 5 of 15444-9, JPIP over UDP 5519 2010-07-15 Corrigendum for AMD.4 of 15444-9 (JPIP Interop) wg1n5518.doc wg1n5519.doc - 8 -
5524 2010-07-16 Meeting Report for JPIP Interop (15444-9) 9 10.11 JPEG 2000 Part 10: JP3D 5483 2010-07-14 ISO/IEC 15444-10:2008/Cor.1: Information technology -- JPEG 2000 image coding system -- Part 10: Extensions for three-dimensional data Vrije Universiteit Brussel - IBBT 10.12 JPEG 2000 Part 11: JPWL 5480 2010-07-14 JPWL AHG Brussels Meeting Report Thales Communications wg1n5480.ppt 5481 2010-07-14 JPWL FDAM1 Study Text Thales Communications wg1n5481.doc 10.13 JPEG 2000 Part 12: ISO Base Media File Format No action. 10.14 JPEG 2000 Part 13: Entry Level JPEG 2000 Encoder No action. 10.15 JPEG 2000 Part 14, JPXML: Structural Representation and Reference of File Format 5470 2010-07-12 Text of committee draft for JPEG 2000 Part-14 JPXML JPXML AHG 5485 2010-07-14 JPXML Tokyo Interim Meeting Report JPXML AHG 5494 2010-07-15 5495 2010-07-16 JP3D Ad Hoc Group Meeting Report, Brussels, Belgium, July 12-16, 2010 JPXML Ad Hoc Group Meeting Report, Brussels, Belgium, July 12-16, 2010 Vrije Universiteit Brussel - IBBT JPXML AHG wg1n5470pre.doc wg1n5494.doc 11. Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800) JPSearch 5502 2010-07-15 5503 2010-07-15 JPSearch ad-hoc meeting report of 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting Preliminary Call for JPSearch Metadata Registration Authority Konkuk Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya - 9 -
Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-1) JPSearch: Part 1 5502 2010-07-15 JPSearch ad-hoc meeting report of 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting Konkuk 10 Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-2) JPSearch: Part 2: Schema and Ontology Registration and Identification 5468 2010-07-12 JPsearch part 2 reference software image identifier Dankook wg1n5468.pdf Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-3) JPSearch: Part 3: System framework and components 5430 2010-04-27 Notice of Publication: ISO/IEC 24800-3:2010, Information technology -- JPSearch -- Part 3: Query format wg1n5430.zip Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-4) JPSearch: Part 4: Metadata Format 5358 2010-03-17 Tex of ISO/IEC FDIS 24800-4: File format for metadata embedded in image data (JPEG and JPEG 2000) NEC wg1n5358.zip Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-5) JPSearch: Part 5: Interchange format 5501 2010-07-15 Study text of ISO/IEC FDIS 24800-5 NEC Project JTC 1.29.20 (24800-6) JPSearch: Part 6: Reference Software 5460 2010-07-08 Proposal for Reference Software for JPSearch File Format 5459 2010-07-08 5504 2010-07-15 Proposal for Reference Software for JPSearch Transformation Rules Text of ISO/IEC CD 24800-6 JPSearch Part 6 Reference software Passau Passau Konkuk 12. Project JTC 1.29.21 (29199) 5431 2010-05-13 Draft Corrigendum for 29199-5: image coding system Reference software 5436 2010-06-12 Defect report for 29199-5 Reference Software 5437 2010-06-12 5453 2010-07-07 Combined defect report for 29199-4 Conformance Testing and 29199-1 Table of Replies on ISO/IEC FDIS 29199-4: Information technology -- image coding system -- Part 4: Conformance testing wg1n5431.zip wg1n5436.doc wg1n5436-1.doc wg1n5437.doc wg1n5453.zip - 10 -
5454 2010-07-07 Table of Replies on ISO/IEC 29199-5: Information technology -- image coding system -- Part 5: Reference software 5462 2010-07-09 errata issues 5463 2010-07-10 Miscellaneous guidance on editing practices 5474 2010-07-13 5479 2010-07-13 5510 2010-07-15 5513 2010-07-15 5514 2010-07-15 5515 2010-07-15 5517 2010-07-15 Text of ISO/IEC DTR 29199-1: Information technology -- image coding system -- Part 1: System architecture Ad Hoc Group Opening Plenary Status Report - 52nd (Brussels) Meeting Ad Hoc Group Mid-Week Plenary Status Report - 52nd (Brussels) Meeting DOCR on ISO/IEC FDIS 29199-4 image coding system - Conformance testing DOCR on ISO/IEC FDIS 29199-5 image coding system - Reference software Combined defect report for ISO/IEC 29199-2, 29199-4, and 29199-5 Ad Hoc Group Closing Plenary Status Report - 52nd (Brussels) Meeting Microsoft Corp. Microsoft Corp. AHG AHG AHG AHG Editors AHG wg1n5454.zip 11 wg1n5462.doc wg1n5462_r1.zip wg1n5463.doc wg1n5463_r1.doc wg1n5463_r2.doc wg1n5474.zip wg1n5479.ppt wg1n5510.ppt wg1n5513.doc wg1n5514.doc wg1n5517.ppt 13. JTC 1.29.28 (29170) Advanced Image Coding and Evaluation Methodologies (AIC) 5469 2010-07-12 Guidelines for subjective evaluation metholodogy for compressed medical images 5487 2010-07-14 AIC Brussels meeting report 5489 2010-07-15 5490 2010-07-15 5491 2010-07-15 5492 2010-07-15 DoCR on Extension of ISO limit dates for ISO/IEC 29170 ISO/IEC 29170: AIC technical report on evaluation methodologies - Working draft v2 AIC core experiment on evaluation of LAR proposal (CO-LAR-01) Second call for technologies of Advanced Image Coding for Camera Sensor Data Seoul National wg1n5492.doc wg1n5492-2.doc - 11 -
5493 2010-07-15 Second call for Advanced Image Coding (AIC) for security applications 5496 2010-07-15 Second call for medical image databases 5497 2010-07-15 5498 2010-07-15 5499 2010-07-15 5500 2010-07-15 Second call for Advanced Image Coding (AIC) for Medical Imaging WG1 Liaison to CIPA on call for technologies of Advanced Image Coding for Camera Sensor Data Evaluation of the fast mode of JPEG 2000: Core Experiments Description 1.0 Study Text for new work item of the fast mode for JPEG2000 lossless coding AIC AHG Sony Corporation 12 wg1n5493.doc wg1n5496.doc wg1n5497.doc 13. WG1 Webmaster Report 5466 2010-07-11 Webmaster's Report Elysium Ltd 14. Identify hosts and specify dates for future meetings The standing document for hosting WG1 meeting is given in: 3597 2005-03-17 Standing Document #1 - Meeting Requirements (V.4) Elysium Ltd wg1n3597.doc 5486 2010-07-14 53rd WG1 Guangzhou Meeting, Meeting Website wg1n5486.pdf 5509 2010-07-15 Calling Notice, the 54th Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 Tokyo Polytechnic wg1n5509.doc The following future WG1 Meetings dates were discussed and approved. WG1 Meeting Year Mon Day City, Country 53 rd 2010 Oct 11-15 Guangzhou, China (co-located with WG11 meeting) 54 th 2011 Feb 21-25 Tokyo, Japan 55 th 2011 Jul 11-15 Berlin, Germany 56 th 2011 Nov 28-02 USA or Geneva, or Lausanne Switzerland (co-located with WG11, to be confirmed) 57 th 2012 Mar Korea (to be confirmed) or USA 58 th 2012 Jul 9-13 Paris, France (to be confirmed) 59 th 2012 Nov North America or Korea 60 th 2013 Mar Asia 61 st 2013 Jul Europe 62 nd 2013 Nov Rochester, New York, USA (To be confirmed) - 12 -
13 15. PR AHG The Press Release was approved at the WG1 Plenary Meeting. 5505 2010-07-15 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting, Press Release WG1 16. Resolutions The Resolutions was approved at the WG1 Plenary Meeting, Friday, July 16, 2010. 5506 2010-07-15 52nd WG1 Brussels Meeting, Resolutions WG1 17. Other Business There was no other business. 18. Close of Meeting The meeting was closed on 1:20pm, Friday, July 15, 2010. - 13 -