Best practices for making switchgear safer. www.sea.siemens.com www.usa.siemens.com/switchgear Prepared by: Ken Newsome - Consulting Business Developer Kevin Mullins - Consulting Business Developer Joe Flocco, PE - Strategic Marketing Manager Allan Worthy - Product Manager Introduction What could be more important than protecting the safety of our most valuable assets, our people? Today s workers hold the keys to an abundance of information, both documented and undocumented. They understand the most important features and functions in a manufacturing environment and to protect them from dangerous conditions must be a priority consideration, especially when it comes to electrical distribution equipment and low voltage switchgear. An innocuous grey box standing against the wall may not appear to be dangerous at all, and that is why in many cases the dangers go unmitigated. However, with the current technologies available in Siemens Low Voltage WL Switchgear, reducing dangerous situations has become that much easier. A few of the techniques that can be employed to make switchgear safer are: the implementation of arc resistant gear, dynamic breaker parameter changes to reduce arc fault levels, and remote operation and monitoring. This paper will discuss each of the techniques and explain how in combination they can work together to provide a safer work environment.
White Paper Best practices for making switchgear safer 2 Arc Resistant Switchgear J Insulated and isolated bus J Separation barriers and top venting J Breaker shutters Arc resistant metal-enclosed low voltage switchgear is an optional product offering that contains and channels internal arcing fault energy. This new switchgear construction provides an additional degree of protection to the personnel performing normal operating duties in close proximity to the equipment while the equipment is operating under normal conditions. In each of the descriptions below, additional design features are indicated, all of which aid in directing faults upward away from personnel or reduce the chances of a fault by insulating and isolating live parts. Front view Door gaskets and sealing trims Extra hinges Thumb screw latches added One piece breaker door Enhanced sill channel with internal plenum for arc venting Type 2B accessibility rating allows auxiliary/control compartment door to be open and still maintain arc resistant rating Breaker sealing frame maintains arc resistant rating with breaker in Connect, Test or Disconnect position. Rear view Pressure release vent in rear top cover Extra bolts and pressure dams in rear covers/doors Rear vent covers extended for vent flaps Extra bolts on end trim sheets
Size: WLL 800A Max A/Plug/Setting: 800 / 800 Size: WLL 1600A Max A/Plug/Setting: 1600 / 1600 Size: WLL 800A Max A/Plug/Setting: 800 / 800 Size: WLL 1600A Max A/Plug/Setting: 1600 / 1600 GRID White Paper Best practices for making switchgear safer 3 TX-4 BUS 1 Dynamic Arc Sentry One of the trip units available for the Siemens WL Family of breakers is the ETU 776. It offers dual parameter sets that enable the trip unit to automatically lower the instantaneous setting and thereby lower the available energy in a fault condition. Commonly referred to as maintenance mode, making a breaker trip faster while engaged in any form of GEN 1 maintenance or just by being in proximity to energized BUS 2 BUS 3 Vs:480 V equipment is an effective way to minimize arc flash dangers. If one is concerned about the effects of temporarily inhibiting selectivity, then rest assured that with the ETU 776 single step changes are possible giving engineers the ability to clear faults faster with minimum effect on coordination. In the example below the effects of the DAS system may be seen. Example 1 PPE: 3 AHE: 10.6 cal/cm^2(100%) AFB: 105.68 in WD: 24 in 1600 WL 1600 PPE: 0 AHE: 0.74 cal/cm^2(100%) AFB: 17.38 in WD: 24 in 1600 WL 1600 800 800 800 600 600 600 800 800 800 WL WL WL WL WL WL 800 800 800 600 600 600 800 800 800 WL WL WL WL WL WL.01.1 1 Time in Seconds 10 100 1000 Main WLL 1600A 1600 Amp 800A FEEDER WLL 800A 800 Amp.5 1 10 100 1000 10000 Current in Amperes X 100.01.1 1 Time in Seconds 10 100 1000 Main WLL 1600A 1600 Amp PANEL 2 PANEL 3 POWER POWER PANEL 2 POWER PANEL 3 800A FEEDER WLL 800A 800 Amp.5 1 10 100 1000 10000 Current in Amperes X 100 480 Volt Phase Time-Current Characteristic Curves 02-15-2010 TCC 1 14:00:27 Parameter Set A C:\EDSA2005\Projects\DAS SWGR whitepaper.pdc 480 Volt Phase Time-Current Characteristic Curves 02-15-2010 TCC 2 13:48:48 Parameter Set B C:\EDSA2005\Projects\DAS SWGR whitepaper.pdc Parameter set "A" Parameter set "B" D WL Breaker with ETU 776 Dual Parameter sets enable maintenance mode - can be set remotely via software or automatically via digital input.
White Paper Best practices for making switchgear safer 4 Under normal conditions, the switchgear s calculated arc flash energy will require PPE level 3 protection for anyone within the arc flash boundary. Incorporating the features built into the DAS system, and using the ETU776 trip unit, the system changes to parameter set B. In the second figure the instantaneous has been changed to a lower setting and the calculation shows a reduction of arc flash energy. The resultant PPE level has been reduced to 0. Below is another example of the benefit of the DAS, or even manual switching, of breaker parameter set. The reduced settings set available in the ETU 776 can also be used to reduce the arc flash energy at downstream equipment. In the first figure on the left with normal settings the arc energy at panel 1 requires PPE level 2. After switching to the parameter B settings, the PPE level at Panel 1 is reduced to 0. Example 2 WL 1600 1600 WL 800 800 PPE: 2 AHE: 5.9 cal/cm^2(85%) AFB: 47.36 in WD: 17.9 in Arc Flash in parameter A Arc Flash in parameter B.01.1 1 Time in Seconds 10 100 1000 Size: WLL 800A Max A/Plug/Setting: 800 / 800 Size: WLL 1600A Max A/Plug/Setting: 1600 / 1600 Main WLL 1600A 1600 Amp 800A FEEDER WLL 800A 800 Amp.5 1 10 100 1000 10000 Current in Amperes X 100.01.1 1 Time in Seconds 10 100 1000 Size: WLL 800A Max A/Plug/Setting: 800 / 800 Size: WLL 1600A Max A/Plug/Setting: 1600 / 1600 Main WLL 1600A 1600 Amp 800A FEEDER WLL 800A 800 Amp.5 1 10 100 1000 10000 Current in Amperes X 100 480 Volt Phase Time-Current Characteristic Curves TCC 1 03-31-2010 11:42:04 480 Volt Phase Time-Current Characteristic Curves TCC 2 03-31-2010 09:34:42 C:\EDSA2005\Projects\SAFETYSWITCHGEARWHITEPAPER.PDC C:\EDSA2005\Projects\SAFETYSWITCHGEARWHITEPAPER.PDC
White Paper Best practices for making switchgear safer 5 Remote operation and monitoring J Remote Monitoring for temperature, metering and maintenance data. J Remote Control via communications with or without interposing relays. J Remote Racking feature. J Remote Operation for opening and closing via local hand held pendant station. Remote Monitoring is an effective way to maintain separation between personnel and energized electrical equipment. With the latest equipment from Siemens, this is now easier and more cost effective than ever. Maintenance personnel and engineers can now view real-time electrical parameters, operating conditions (like temperature in the breaker and number of operations), and open and close breakers remotely. The WinPM.Net software with its Web Enabled interface allows multiple users to access only the information they are interested in from the convenience of their desks. Accountants can access cost allocation and utility billing information to enforce accountability for electrical resources and verify utility bills. Trip settings and other parameters for the LV power breakers can be modified and monitored remotely as well. In addition, WL breakers with appropriate electrical controls and communication components, can be opened and closed through communications directly or with the use of interposing relays. Unit sub #5 elevation Real-time data from WL breakers with remote open/close capability
White Paper Best practices for making switchgear safer 6 Remote Racking Device Although it is always preferable to work on equipment that has been de-energized, in some cases it may not be practical. Siemens now offers the Remote Breaker Racking Device. This product uses an integral torque overload sensing mechanism and allows users to safely rack our WL breakers into the Connect, Test and Disconnect position from up to 30 feet away. This allows the operator to be outside the arc flash boundary thereby providing additional personnel protection and reducing the PPE requirements. This system can be retrofitted to existing Siemens WL switchgear lineups. Remote Racking Device Remote Operator Pendant This hand held pendant allows a user to remotely operate (open/close) a WL breaker without being in front of the switchgear. Standard cable lengths are 30 feet with other lengths available. This pendant, along with the Remote Racking device, can be used to improve personnel safety by putting operators outside the arc flash boundary. Maintenance personnel can remotely open breakers and close breakers, without being in front of the equipment. The Remote Operator Pendant can be used in combination with the Remote Racking Device for added personnel safety. Remote Operator Pendant Control port on WL Switchgear
White Paper Best practices for making switchgear safer 7 Other protection options J Infrared Viewing ports J Zone Selective Interlocking J High Resistance Grounding Infrared viewing ports allow maintenance personnel to monitor temperatures of the cable and bus connection points in the rear of the gear while it is energized and under load. Excessive temperatures can be an indication of a problem with a connection. Infrared viewing ports Zone Selective Interlocking eliminates any intentional time delay in the event a fault occurs between two breakers in adjacent zones. In the schematic to the right, representative time delay values are shown for the breakers in each zone. If a fault occurs on the load side of the downstream breaker, the ZSI system enables the upstream breaker s delay and allows the downstream device more time to independently clear the fault. If the fault occurs on the line side of the downstream breaker (between two zones), the delay in the upstream breaker will not occur. This allows the fastest tripping time for faults and will reduce the amount of arc energy which may be released. The ZSI function is available for short time delays and ground fault delays. Research has shown that a high percentage of arc faults start as a phase to ground fault. High resistance grounding systems minimize the available phase to ground arcing current. Zone Selective Interlocking A high resistance grounding system reduces the magnitude of phase to ground faults. This will reduce the mechanical stress on equipment for the most common of faults and will reduce the magnitude of energy released. PH1 PH2 PH3 PH1 PH2 NEUT 3-CLF 2-CLF ROD TEST PULSE TEST PULSE TEST ISTOR METER SYSTEM SWITCH SYSTEM SWITCH AM W NORMAL TEST ISTOR METER W NORMAL WIRE LOOP FOR PORTABLE DETECTOR R FAULT AM R FAULT G PULSE WIRE LOOP FOR PORTABLE DETECTOR G PULSE CONTROL CIRCUIT PULSE SW CONTROL CIRCUIT PULSE SW
White Paper Best practices for making switchgear safer 8 In summary, it is strongly recommended that work is performed only on de-energized equipment. Arc resistant switchgear provides added design features which reduce the danger of injury in the event of an arc flash within the gear. Remote monitoring can provide every day data to the facility personnel without ever having to be in the room with the gear. It allows for remote operation as well. When operating conditions do not allow equipment to be de-energized, the use of the Siemens Remote Operator Pendant and Remote Breaker Racking Device can allow the operator to be located outside the arc flash boundary. Always wear the proper personnel protective equipment (PPE). Infrared View Ports offer improved methods for maintaining the equipment, while Zone Selective Interlocking can reduce breaker clearing times reducing the amount of arc flash energy available. In addition, High Resistance Grounding (HRG) can be employed to limit the magnitude of phase to ground currents. These HRG Systems are typically seen in industrial facilities with continuous processes. www.usa.siemens.com/switchgear All rights reserved. All trademarks use are owned by Siemens or their respective owners. 2010 Siemens Industry, Inc. Siemens Industry, Inc. Building Technologies Division 5400 Triangle Parkway Norcross, GA 30092 1-800-964-4114 LVWP-SAFER-0610 Printed in USA