324Mbps WLAN Equipment with MAC Frame Aggregation for High MAC-SAP Throughput

Similar documents
standard. Acknowledgement: Slides borrowed from Richard Y. Yale

4.3 IEEE Physical Layer IEEE IEEE b IEEE a IEEE g IEEE n IEEE 802.

IEEE MAC Sublayer (Based on IEEE )

3.1. Introduction to WLAN IEEE

Local Area Networks NETW 901

CSC344 Wireless and Mobile Computing. Department of Computer Science COMSATS Institute of Information Technology

Chapter 3.1 Acknowledgment:

Wireless LANs. ITS 413 Internet Technologies and Applications

A Modified Medium Access Control Algorithm for Systems with Iterative Decoding

Software Defined Radio Prototype (II) Implementation and Evaluation of IEEE Wireless LAN

Topics for Today. More on Ethernet. Wireless LANs Readings. Topology and Wiring Switched Ethernet Fast Ethernet Gigabit Ethernet. 4.3 to 4.

Hands-On Exercises: IEEE Standard

WNC-0300USB. 11g Wireless USB Adapter USER MANUAL

Wireless LAN A competing method to wired LAN. Course: Wireline Communication Instructor: Prof. Werner Henkel Student: Chin Yung Lu

Ubiquitous Network. Hotspot Network. ad-hoc & RF-ID

Mobile & Wireless Networking. Lecture 7: Wireless LAN

Vehicle Networks. Wireless Local Area Network (WLAN) Univ.-Prof. Dr. Thomas Strang, Dipl.-Inform. Matthias Röckl

A Frame Aggregation Scheduler for IEEE n

High-Throughput and Enhanced-QoS Technologies in Wireless LAN

Investigation of WLAN

Multimedia Communication Services Traffic Modeling and Streaming

IEEE Romel Rudyard J. Lucentales, ECE 5

PROPOSAL OF MULTI-HOP WIRELESS LAN SYSTEM FOR QOS GUARANTEED TRANSMISSION

Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) Part I

Medium Access Control. MAC protocols: design goals, challenges, contention-based and contention-free protocols

HIPERLAN/2 and a: A Comparative Study

A New Full Duplex MAC Protocol to Solve the Asymmetric Transmission Time

Interactions Between the Physical Layer and Upper Layers in Wireless Networks: The devil is in the details

ICE 1332/0715 Mobile Computing (Summer, 2008)

Performance anomaly of b

Chapter 6 Wireless and Mobile Networks. Csci 4211 David H.C. Du

02/21/08 TDC Branch Offices. Headquarters SOHO. Hot Spots. Home. Wireless LAN. Customer Sites. Convention Centers. Hotel

Data and Computer Communications. Chapter 13 Wireless LANs

EVALUATION OF EDCF MECHANISM FOR QoS IN IEEE WIRELESS NETWORKS

IEEE C802.16h-07/017. IEEE Broadband Wireless Access Working Group <

Mobile Communications Chapter 7: Wireless LANs

Computer Networks. Wireless LANs

CS 348: Computer Networks. - WiFi (contd.); 16 th Aug Instructor: Sridhar Iyer IIT Bombay

MC-CDMA Based IEEE Wireless LAN

Expanding the use of CTS-to-Self mechanism to improving broadcasting on IEEE networks

Development of Dependable Wireless System and Device

IEEE ah. sub 1GHz WLAN for IoT. What lies beneath Wi-Fi HaLow. Eduard Garcia-Villegas, Elena López-Aguilera Dept. of Network Engineering

Mobile Communications Chapter 7: Wireless LANs

Adaptive Two-Level Frame Aggregation in IEEE n WLAN

DCF/USDMA: Enhanced DCF for Uplink SDMA Transmissions in WLANs

IEEE Ad Hoc Networks: Performance Measurements

Radio Networks. Riccardo Cavallari. Radio Networks Office: 3 rd floor, Main Building

Wireless Communication and Networking CMPT 371

A new MAC protocol for reducing effect of needless transmission deferment induced by missed RTS/CTS handshake

ECE442 Communications Lecture 3. Wireless Local Area Networks

Announcements : Wireless Networks Lecture 11: * Outline. Power Management. Page 1

WiFi / IEEE WLAN

Strategies and Guidelines for Improving Wireless Local Area Network Performance

CSC344 Wireless and Mobile Computing. Department of Computer Science COMSATS Institute of Information Technology

MAC level Throughput comparison: ax vs ac

Wireless LAN -Architecture

Throughput Analysis of IEEE802.11n using OPNET

Wireless# Guide to Wireless Communications. Objectives

Lesson 2-3: The IEEE x MAC Layer

Laboratory of Nomadic Communication. Quick introduction to IEEE

WiFi Networks: IEEE b Wireless LANs. Carey Williamson Department of Computer Science University of Calgary Winter 2018

Analysis of IEEE e for QoS Support in Wireless LANs

A Novel Contention Window Control Scheme Based on a Markov Chain Model in Dense WLAN Environment

SEN366 (SEN374) (Introduction to) Computer Networks

Mohammad Hossein Manshaei 1393

04/11/2011. Wireless LANs. CSE 3213 Fall November Overview

Samsung Smart WLAN Solution

November 1998 doc.: IEEE /378 IEEE P Wireless LANs Extension of Bluetooth and Direct Sequence Interference Model.

Overview : Computer Networking. Spectrum Use Comments. Spectrum Allocation in US Link layer challenges and WiFi WiFi

CS698T Wireless Networks: Principles and Practice

Mohammad Hossein Manshaei 1393

Performance analysis of Internet applications over an adaptive IEEE MAC architecture

EE 597: Wireless Networks (Spring 12)

Throughput Enhancement of IEEE WLAN for Multimedia Communications.

Lecture 16: QoS and "

Wireless Local Area Network (IEEE )

AN ANALYSIS OF THE MODIFIED BACKOFF MECHANISM FOR IEEE NETWORKS

Advanced Computer Networks WLAN

Delivering Voice over IEEE WLAN Networks

Wireless Technologies: Wi-Fi

Intelligent Transportation Systems. Wireless Access for Vehicular Environments (WAVE) Engin Karabulut Kocaeli Üniversitesi,2014

Collision Probability in Saturated IEEE Networks

Wireless Communication

CHAPTER 7 MAC LAYER PROTOCOLS. Dr. Bhargavi Goswami Associate Professor & Head Department of Computer Science Garden City College

Data Communications. Data Link Layer Protocols Wireless LANs

Day 1: Wi-Fi Technology Overview

Mohamed Khedr.

Page 1. Outline : Wireless Networks Lecture 11: MAC. Standardization of Wireless Networks. History. Frequency Bands

Mohammad Hossein Manshaei 1393

Impact of IEEE n Operation on IEEE Operation

Scheduling strategies and throughput optimization for the Uplink for IEEE ax and IEEE ac based networks

IEEE Wireless LAN draft Standard

Alternate PHYs

Wireless Local Area Part 2

Medium Access Control Sublayer

IEEE Wireless LANs Part I: Basics

WiMAX Capacity Enhancement: Capacity Improvement of WiMAX Networks by Dynamic Allocation of Subframes

Mobile Communications Chapter 7: Wireless LANs

Evaluations and Enhancements in n WLANs Error-Sensitive Adaptive Frame Aggregation

IEEE 1901 HD-PLC (High Definition Power Line Communication) Abstract

Transcription:

JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 1 324Mbps WLAN Equipment with MAC Frame Aggregation for High MAC-SAP Throughput Yukimasa Nagai, Akinori Fujimura, Yoshihiko Shirokura, Yoji Isota, Fumio Ishizu Mitsubishi Electric Corporation/Information Technology R & D Center, Kamakura, Japan Email: Nagai.Yukimasa@ds.MitsubishiElectric.co.jp Hiroyuki Nakase, Suguru Kameda, Hiroshi Oguma, Kazuo Tsubouchi Tohoku University/Research Institute of Electric Communication, Sendai, Japan Email: Nakase@riec.tohoku.ac.jp Abstract We developed a high speed wireless LAN prototype in the 5GHz band. Maximum transmission rate of the developed WLAN equipment was 324Mbit/sec using 6 multi-channels of 82.11a. We proposed a novel frame aggregation scheme to improve MAC efficiency. The proposed frame aggregation scheme had a feature of an adaptive aggregation size selection depending on the wireless channel conditions and application requirements. Throughput performance was obtained from simulation using a multiple station system with the proposed frame aggregation. A throughput of more than 15Mbit/sec was achieved with an evaluated system of 1 STAs. We also found that the measured throughput of more than 17Mbit/sec was achieved using the proposed frame aggregation. Index Terms Wireless Networks, IEEE82.11, Frame Aggregation, performance evaluation I. INTRODUCTION High reliability and data rate are required for multimedia access at home and at office using wireless local area network. The reliability is indispensable to maintain a constant bandwidth to serve broadband data such as HDTV (High Definition Television) and Video-on- Demand traffic. A data rate of more than 1Mbit/sec throughput is necessary in order to allow several users to gain access to the same access point (AP) of WLAN (Wireless LAN) simultaneously In legacy WLAN [1], CSMA/CA (Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Collision Avoidance) was used for multiple accesses. However, QoS (Quality of Service) was not supported. Enhancing the QoS at the MAC (Medium Access Control) layer for supporting diversification of applications became the standard of Task Group e (TGe) [2] in Sept 5. Based on Implementation of 324Mbps WLAN equipment with MAC frame aggregation for high MAC-SAP throughput, by Yukimasa Nagai, H. Nakase, A. Fujimura, Y. Shirokura, Y. Isota, F. Ishizu, S. Kameda, H. Oguma, K. Tsubouchi which appeared in the Proceedings of the IEEE Consumer Communications and Networking Conference 6, Las Vegas, U.S.A., January 6. 6 IEEE. Throughput at the MAC service access point (SAP) was less than 3Mbit/sec even with 15byte UDP data in legacy IEEE82.11a [3], although the PHY data rate was 54Mbit/sec. The low efficiency was due to the high MAC overhead using CSMA/CA. Increasing the throughput to more than 1Mbit/sec at the MAC-SAP has been discussed for the standard at Task Group n (TGn) [4-6]. For the enhancement of the PHY data rate, MIMO (Multiple Input Multiple Output) and channel bundling have been proposed in TGn. It was well known that the conventional IEEE82.11 MAC protocol was not enough to achieve improvement of throughput in accordance with increasing PHY data rate. Moreover, legacy IEEE82.11a systems limited the maximum length to 15byte, because 15byte was maximum length at Wired LAN. The limitation of MAC throughput with legacy MAC protocol was evaluated by computer simulations. Table.1 shows the parameters of the simulation, which was defined in the IEEE82.11a standard. Figure.1 shows simulation results of the MAC-SAP throughput as a function of the PHY data rate. The horizontal axis is the PHY data rate. The vertical axis is the throughput at the MAC-SAP. Packet size of 5, 1, and 15 byte/packet were used. There was a limitation of throughput of Mbit/sec using the conventional MAC protocol, although the PHY data rate was increased. TABLE 1. IEEE82.11a parameters Parameter Value SIFS 16usec DIFS 34usec Slot time 9usec PLCP preamble 16usec 4usec CWmin 15 CWmax 123 MAC 28byte rate 6Mbit/sec

2 JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 Throughput (Mbit/sec) zzz 5 3 1 5byte 1byte 15byte knowledge of boundaries. A delimiter for marking the start point of each was placed before the s. Except when it was the last, padding octets were appended to make each section a multiple of 4 octets in length, if needed. The delimiter is 4 octets in length and consists of length, CRC, unique pattern. 5 1 15 25 3 PHY data rate (Mbit/sec) Figure 1. IEEE82.11 CSMA/CA Throughput Limit Delimiter Pad octets Delimiter PSDU Pad octets Delimiter In this paper, we present our development of the 324Mbit/sec WLAN equipment to alleviate these efficiency problems. We present both the implementation of the WLAN equipment and the construction of MAC layer architecture including the proposed frame aggregation. Instead of MIMO technology as proposed in IEEE82.11n, we use 6 channels bundling of IEEE82.11a. While channel bundling decreases the spectral efficiency, the developed equipment has the advantage of backward compatibility with IEEE82.11a. Furthermore, the developed MAC algorithms can also be used in a MIMO context. The developed WLAN equipment has the functions of adaptive modulation per channel, adaptive coding per channel, link adaptation, adaptive channel selection, and frame aggregation. We proposed a novel frame aggregation scheme for over 1Mbit/sec throughput at MAC-SAP. The optimal frame aggregation size for the PHY data rate was evaluated by computer simulation. It was shown quantitative results for the improvement of MAC-SAP throughput due to the proposed frame aggregation, as obtained from measurement result using the WLAN equipment. II. FRAME AGGREGATION In this section, a comparison of 3 types of frame aggregation was described. Figure 2 shows an example of frame format of PPDU aggregation method. The PPDU aggregation should be implemented in the PHY layer. A PHY SYNC header was placed before a field of the first. Subsequent PPDUs without PHY SYNC were continuously transmitted after RIFS (Reduce Inter frame Space) timing that is < RIFS << SIFS. Data rate of each was independently defined in the field. PHY SYNC RIFS RIFS Figure 2. PPDU aggregation format Figure 3 shows a frame format of aggregation method [5, 6]. The aggregation should be implemented between PHY and MAC layer. PHY has no Figure 3. aggregation format Figure 4 shows a format of MSDU aggregation method. The MSDU aggregation should be implemented in the MAC layer. MAC header and FCS (Frame Check Sequence) were attached for the whole frame. A Subframe header was placed in front of each MSDU in order to detect the starting points of the MSDUs. The QoS Control Field of MAC header included one bit to indicate using MSDU aggregation. Processing and implementation was relatively easy because MAC and PHY could operate on a single frame body. MAC Subframe Subframe Subframe MSDU MSDU MSDU Figure 4. MSDU aggregation format The summary of the comparison among 3 types of frame aggregation was listed in Table 2. The PPDU aggregation and the aggregation had an advantage for implementation for multiple destination addresses. The PPDU aggregation and the aggregation were robust to transmission errors because a FCS was attached. Furthermore, the PPDU aggregation had an advantage for rate changes for each PPDU. On the other hand, in order to implement and PPDU aggregation, MAC function should be changed itself for the addition of the aggregation function. An access procedure to receive Acknowledge packets from each destination should be redesigned for the frame aggregation with multiple destinations using the or the PPDU aggregation. Efficiency of the MAC was the most important factor to design high speed WLAN equipment, because the processing speed of a MAC layer using CSMA/CA was a bottleneck for the data rate. Furthermore, complexity from legacy was important factor to ensure interoperability between proposed high speed WLAN equipment and legacy equipment. The MSDU aggregation had the highest efficiency because of its small overhead. In order to implement MSDU aggregation, a convergence function was added in addition to the conventional MAC function. It meant that FCS

JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 3 it was easy to maintain compatibility with legacy IEEE82.11 MAC functions. TABLE 2. Aggregation Comparison PPDU MSDU Multiple DA Yes Yes No Rate change for every DA Yes No No Efficiency Low Middle High Robust for Error High High Low Complexity from Legacy High High Low From the summary of features of each aggregation methods as described above, it was confirmed that the MSDU aggregation was the most suitable for the realization of high throughput WLAN equipment. III. SIMULATION FOR FRAME AGGREGATION The MAC throughput as a function of the aggregation size was simulated using the Network Simulator 2 (NS2). The PHY and MAC parameters for the simulation are listed in Table 3. The offered load for the simulation was Mbit/sec. Constant UDP data was used. The UDP data sent from AP from a STA. Figure 5 shows the throughput performances of frame aggregation compared with the performances without frame aggregation. The horizontal axis is the packet length. The vertical axis is the throughput at the MAC- SAP. TABLE 3. Simulation parameters Simulation Unit Access DCF --- Data frame rate Mbit/sec/ 54 per channel Channel Control frame rate Mbit/sec/ 24 per channel Channel Slot Time 9 usec DIFS 48 usec SIFS 3 usec CW min 15 --- CW max 511 --- Transmission Rate 324 Mbit/sec Channel Number 6 Channels Frame Aggregation 6 Packets Packet Error Rate Error Free --- Throughput (Mbit/sec) 18 1 1 1 1 8 without frame aggregation with frame aggregation 1 3 5 7 8 9 byte Figure 5. The throughput of frame aggregation A maximum simulated throughput of more than 17Mbit/sec was obtained for the case of an aggregated frame size of 9byte. The throughput of a multiple STAs was evaluated using a computer simulation. Figure 6 shows the throughput at MAC as a function of station number. The PHY and MAC parameters for the simulation are listed in Table 3. The traffic parameter was constant for both uplink and down link UDP data. The evaluated system throughput of more than 15Mbit/sec was achieved for the case of 1 stations. AP and STA use same procedure to obtain the transmission opportunity. The transmission opportunity of the total STA was relatively increased due to the randomization of CW (contention window). However the transmission opportunity of AP was relatively reduced due to the traffic of other STAs. Consequently, uplink traffic becomes the dominant traffic when the STA numbers is increased. Throughput (Mbit/sec) 18 1 1 1 1 8 Down Link Up Link Up Link(each STA) System (Both) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 Station Numbers Figure 6. The throughput of multiple STAs The optimal frame aggregation size for the PHY data rate was evaluated. MAC throughput as a function of aggregation size is shown in Figure 7. Table 4 lists parameters for throughput simulation. The horizontal axis is the number of frame aggregation at the Adaptive Frame Aggregation sub-layer. The vertical axis is the throughput at the MAC-SAP. TABLE 4.Simulation parameters Parameter Value SIFS 16usec DIFS 34usec Slot time 9usec PLCP preamble 16usec 4usec CWmin 15 CWmax 123 MAC 28byte Channel Number 2 channels Data Rate 54Mbit/sec per channel rate 6Mbit/sec PER Error Free

4 JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 1 9 Throughput (Mbit/sec) aaaa 8 7 5 3 1 15byte 1byte 5byte 1byte 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Frame Aggregation Size Figure 7. The throughput saturation Throughput Increasing Rate (%) aaa 1 9 8 7 5 3 1 1byte 5byte 1byte 15byte 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Frame Aggregation Size Figure 8. The throughput increasing rate The PHY data rate was 18Mbit/sec, i.e., bundling two IEEE82.11a channels. Maximum throughput was evaluated to be more than 9Mbit/sec at the frame aggregation size of 1 with a 15byte packet length from the LLC layer. Saturation of throughput was evaluated in the case of any packet frame size. Figure 8 shows the increase of throughput as a function of aggregation size. The increasing rate at 15byte packet size was over % at a frame aggregation size of less than 3. Frame aggregation was thus highly effective in improving MAC efficiency. On the other hand, the throughput increasing rate at 15byte was less than 1% at an aggregation number of more than 4. The efficiency of frame aggregation showed no additional improvements for frame aggregation sizes of more than 4. Based on the above result, we have defined the optimal frame aggregation size depending on packet length at the 1% throughput increasing point. IV. HIGH SPEED WIRELESS LAN PROTOTYPE We developed high speed WLAN equipment using 5GHz frequency band as shown in Figure 9 [7-13]. The maximum transmission rate of the prototype is 324Mbit/sec. The developed equipment is backward compatible with legacy IEEE82.11a. The channel structure of the PHY was designed by IEEE82.11a channel binding to achieve the bandwidth of 1MHz, corresponding to 6 channels. Figure 9. The developed high speed Wireless LAN Unit A. Dynamic Channel Assign and Link Adaptation Figure 1 shows the channel structure with the features of Dynamic Channel Assign and Link Adaptation. The transmission rates of each channel were independently selected to be up to 54Mbit/sec, based on the propagation and interference conditions of each channel. Furthermore duplicate frames were transmitted at every used channel with same transmission rate to adjust to the same transmission time. Originator acknowledged when received one of frames from recipient. At the time of T, the transmitter sent Data frame using Channel (CH) 1 with the transmission rate of 54Mbit/sec, CH2 with 54Mbit/sec, CH3 with 24Mbit/sec, CH4 with 36Mbit/sec, and CH6 with 54Mbit/sec. CH5 was not used due to interference conditions from others. At the time of T1, the receiver send frame using the CH1, CH2, CH3, CH4, CH6 with same data rate. At the time of T2, the transmitter send Data frame using every channel with updating data rate based on Link Adaptation (CH2, CH3). CH1 CH2 CH3 CH4 CH5 CH6 T T1 T2 24Mbps 24Mbps Figure 1. Dynamic Channel Assign and Link Adaptation Figure 11 shows the implemented Link Adaptation that uses a closed loop. We extended Feedback field for every frame data and control frame to convey feedback information. The Field included one bit to

JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 5 indicate using closed loop link adaptation and frame extension. In addition to 2 sub-layers, the designed MAC layer has the frame aggregation control and the frame distribution control at the MAC layer. Store the Feedback rate for next TX Reception of Data frame Using Feedback rate that is embedded in Data frame (Feedback rate was 24Mbps) Measure reception condition (S/N etc) No Link Adaptation Rate determination Next DA? Yes Feedback rate is embedded into next frame t1 STA 2 t2 FB (24Mbps) Frame (24Mbps) Data Frame ( 36 Mbps) FB () Using Feedback rate that is embedded in frame (Feedback rate was ) FB (18Mbps) Time Data Frame ( 54 Mbps) STA 1 t t3 Waiting for frame Link Adaptation (18Mbps) Figure 11. Implemented link adaptation sequence using one channel (image) At the time of t, STA1 transmitted Data frame using 36Mbit/sec which included Feedback (FB) rate of 24Mbit/sec. At the time of t1, STA2 received Data frame and estimated optimal transmission rate from STA1 to STA2 using received Data frame. At the time of t2, STA2 transmitted frame using 24Mbit/sec that was informed by STA1 in previous Data frame. The estimated feedback rate of 54Mbit/sec was embedded in the feedback field of frame. At the time of t3, STA1 received frame and started to estimate the optimal transmission rate from STA2 to STA1 using received frame. At the time of t4, the embedded feedback rate in the previous frame was used for Data frame transmission from STA1 to STA2. The transmission rates of each channel were independently selected to be up to 54Mbit/sec, based on the propagation and interference conditions of each channel. B. The designed MAC layer structure Figure 12 shows a block diagram of the designed MAC layer structure. The designed MAC layer has adaptive frame aggregation on the sub-layer for the MSDU frame aggregation. In the sub-layer, frames from the LLC layer are aggregated to a single frame for the same destination address. The designed MAC layer has an adaptive frame distribution sub-layer at the bottom of the MAC layer. In this sub-layer, the aggregated frame is distributed to each PHY channel module. The frames, distributed to each PHY module, are adjusted to the same length of OFDM symbols for individual PHY data rate. Time 82.2 LLC Legacy 82.11 MAC PHY 82.2 LLC proposed MAC Adaptive Frame Aggregation Legacy 82.11 MAC + Frame Aggregation Control + Frame Distribution Control Adaptive Frame Distribution Multi-CH PHY PHY PHY PHY PHY PHY PHY Figure 12. The designed MAC layer structure C. The Proposed Adaptive Frame Aggregation Sub-layer Figure 13 shows block diagram of the proposed adaptive frame aggregation sub-layer. The sub-layer includes a frame aggregation unit for transmission and frame de-aggregation unit for reception. Several memories are placed in the frame aggregation unit to allow individual destination addresses in the aggregation frames simultaneously. The maximum aggregation length is limited by the summation of symbol lengths of each channel as determined from the individual data rates. The aggregation length is controlled depending on the PHY data rate determined by link adaptation, and the application requirement is determined by the acceptable delay. 82.11 MAC Aggregate Information Frame De-Aggregate Unit Aggregation memory#1 Aggregation memory#2 Aggregation memory#3 Frame Aggregate Unit 82.2 LLC Figure 13. The Adaptive Frame Aggregation Sub Layer (Image) Figure 14 shows the procedure of the proposed adaptive frame aggregation and the adaptive frame distribution. For example, the adaptive frame aggregation sub-layer aggregates 2 frames into one. The adaptive frame distribution sub-layer distributes a to a 3 PHY-channels module with the same OFDM symbol length. In this case, the PHY data rate is 54Mbit/sec at CH #1, 48Mbit/sec at CH #2 and 24Mbit/sec at CH #3. The number of bytes in the symbol of CH#1, CH#2 and CH#3 are 27, 24 and 12, respectively. The is distributed to each PHY channel depending on the number of bytes in the symbol. In order to adjust the number of OFDM symbols, appropriate pad bytes are inserted to the end of each PHY frame.

6 JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 Aggregate multiple MSDUs into one Hdr MAC 1OFDM symbol CH#1 64QAM 3/4 Preamble () CH#2 64QAM 2/3 (48Mbps) CH#3 16QAM 1/2 (24Mbps) Ethernet Frame FrameBody Ethernet Frame Distribute one frame to multiple channels with Same OFDM symbols Signal Data Data Data Data Service Preamble Signal Data Data Data Data Service Tail+Pad 3 6 Preamble Signal Data Data Data Data Service 1 2 4 5 7 Hdr Transmission Time Tail+Pad Tail+Pad Figure 14. Adaptive Frame Distribution Sub Layer FCS t t t TABLE 5. Prototype Parameters Prototype Unit Access DCF --- Measurement time Sec Data frame rate Mbit/sec/ 54 per channel Channel Control frame rate Mbit/sec/ 24 per channel Channel Slot Time 9 usec DIFS 48 usec SIFS 3 usec CW min 15 --- CW max 511 --- Application (Downlink) Constant UDP Mbps --- Transmission Rate 324 Mbit/sec Channel Number 6 Channels Frame Aggregation 6 Packets Packet Error Rate Error Free --- D. Measurement Results The MAC throughput as a function of the aggregation size was measured. We measured the throughput at the MAC-SAP using Smart Bit. The prototypes were connected through an attenuator with an RF cable as shown in Figure 15. The received power of 6 multi channels at sub-rack #2 was -37.1dBm with the attenuator level at 42dB. The PHY and MAC parameters for the measurement are listed in Table 5. Figure 16 shows the throughput performances of frame aggregation compared with the performances without frame aggregation. The horizontal axis is the packet length. The vertical axis is the throughput at the MAC-SAP. SubRack#2 MAC BB RF HPA ATT 42dB Smart Bits HPA RF Figure 15. Test System SubRack#1 BB MAC Constant UDP Mbps As shown in Figure16, the maximum throughput was measured to be more than 17Mbit/sec in the case of frame aggregation size of 9byte. The measurement results were similar to the simulation results with and without frame aggregation, respectively. The result without frame aggregation was less than Mbit/sec although the PHY data rate was 324Mbit/sec. It was confirmed that the legacy MAC procedure was a bottleneck to increase the MAC-SAP throughput and that the proposed frame aggregation scheme had a good performance to increase the throughput of high speed wireless LAN equipments. Throughput (Mbit/sec) i 18 1 1 1 1 8 without frame aggregation with frame aggregation 1 3 5 7 8 9 byte Figure 16. Frame Aggregation measurements result V. CONCLUSION We have developed a high speed WLAN equipment in the 5GHz spectrum. The developed WLAN equipment has a data rate of 324Mbit/sec using 6 PHY channels of IEEE82.11a. We have proposed an adaptive frame aggregation to improve the MAC efficiency. Throughput performance was simulated in a multiple station scenario with the proposed frame aggregation. A system throughput of 15Mbit/sec was achieved using an evaluation system of 1 stations. The MAC throughput as a function of aggregation size was both simulated and measured. It was found that a measured throughput of more than 17Mbit/sec was successfully achieved using the proposed frame aggregation in our equipment. It was proven that the proposed frame aggregation provides an effective alternative to achieve high throughput in a situation of high PHY data rates. NOWLEDGMENT The work was partly supported by RR2 (IT program) of MEXT, Japan.

JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 7 REFERENCES [1] IEEE82.11-1999, Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specification, Standard, IEEE, 1999. [2] IEEE82.11e-5, Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specification, Amendment8: Medium Access Control (MAC) Quality of Service Enhancements, IEEE, 5. [3] IEEE82.11a-1999, Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specification, High-speed Physical layer in the 5GHz Band, Standard, IEEE, 1999. [4] IEEE82.11-3/813r12, 82.11 TGn Functional Requirements, documentation, IEEE82.11, 4. [5] IEEE82.11-5/195r5, Joint Proposal: High throughput extension to the 82.11 Standard: MAC, IEEE82.11, 6. [6] IEEE82.11n Draft1., Wireless LAN Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY) specifications: Enhancements for Higher Throughput, documentation, IEEE82.11, 6. [7] Isota, et al., 324Mbps Ultra High Speed Wireless LAN prototype (1): Overview of the Equipments, B-5-6, IEICE General Conference, 5. [8] Hayashi, et al., 324Mbps Ultra High Speed Wireless LAN prototype (2): RF section and High Speed AGC Circuits, B-5-7, IEICE General Conference, 5. [9] Fujimura, et al., 324Mbps Ultra High Speed Wireless LAN Prototype (3): PHY Layer, B-5-8, IEICE General Conference, 5. [1] Nakase, et al., 324Mbps Ultra High Speed Wireless LAN prototype (4): High Speed MAC Implementation, B-5-9, IEICE General Conference, 5. [11] Nagai, et al., 324Mbps Ultra High Speed Wireless LAN Prototype (5): Frame Aggregation, B-5-21, IEICE General Conference, 5. [12] Oguma, et al., 324Mbps Ultra High Speed Wireless LAN Prototype (6): HDTV transmission system, B-5-211, IEICE General Conference, 5. [13] Nagai, et al., Implementation of 324Mbps WLAN equipment with MAC frame aggregation for high MAC- SAP throughput, IEEE Consumer Communications and Networking Conference (CCNC), 6. of satellite communications and digital modulation and demodulation schemes for mobile communications. He is now a head engineer in the Wireless IP Access Department of the Information Technology R & D Center. He is a member of the Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers (IEICE). Yoshihiko SHIROKURA graduated from the Department of Electronic Engineering, the University of Electro- Communications in 1986, and joined Mitsubishi Electric. Since then, he has been engaged in research and development related to broadband communication systems and wireless communication systems. He is a manager of Wireless IP Access Communication Control Team in the Wireless IP Access Technology Department of the Information Technology R & D Center. Yoji ISOTA received the B.S. and M.S. degrees in communication engineering from Osaka University, Osaka, Japan in 1976 and 1979, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree in electrical engineering from Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan, in 3. In 1979, he joined the Mitsubishi Electric Corporation, where he has been engaged in the research and development of microwave and millimeter-wave circuit for antenna feed systems, MMICs, and SSPAs. During 2-4, he was Professor with the Research Institute of Electrical Communication of Tohoku University. Currently, he is the manager of Electro-Optics & Microwave Electronics Technology Department of Information Technology R & D Center, Mitsubishi Electric Corporation. Dr. Isota is a senior member of the IEEE. Fumio ISHIZU graduated from the Department of Electronic and Communications Engineering, Waseda University, in 1983, completed the M.S program in 1985, and joined Mitsubishi Electric. Since then, he has been engaged in research and development in the fields of satellite communications and digital modulation and demodulation schemes for mobile communications. He is now a manager in the Wireless IP Access Department of the Information Technology R & D Center. Yukimasa NAGAI was born in Kanagawa, Japan, on August 14, 1975. He graduated from the Department of Communications and Systems, the University of Electro- Communications, in 1998, completed the M.S program in, and joined Mitsubishi Electric. Since then, he has been engaged in research and development related to broadband mobile communications systems. He is now affiliated with the Wireless IP Access Technology Department of the Information Technology R & D Center. He is a member of the Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers (IEICE). Akinori FUJIMURA graduated from the Department of Electronic and Communications Engineering, Waseda University, in 1989, and joined Mitsubishi Electric. Since then, he has been engaged in research and development in the fields Hiroyuki NAKASE was born in Tokyo, Japan, on March 16, 1967. He received the B.S., M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in Electronics Engineering from Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan in 1989, 1992 and 1995, respectively. He joined Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corporation in 1995. He was working on evaluation of CDMA packet network, measurement of transmission of CDMA equipment, and design of software defined radio equipment. He joined Research Institute of Electrical Communication, Tohoku University in 1999, as Research Associate. He is currently the Associate Professor of the Research Institute of Electrical Communication, Tohoku University. He is currently interested in mobile broadband wireless access, CDMA technology, OFDM technology for mobile communication networks, and RF 3D packaging. Dr. Nakase received the Student Paper Award of PIMRC1994 in 1994, the TELECOM System Technology Award in 1996, the

8 JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATIONS, VOL. 1, NO. 5, AUGUST 6 special prize selected by judge of EDS-Fair 5 in 5. He is a member of the IEICE and the IEEE. system. He is a member of the Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers (IEICE) Suguru KAMEDA was born in Fukushima, Japan, on October 25, 1974. He received the B.S., M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in Electronics Engineering from Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan in 1997, 1999 and 1, respectively. He is currently the Research Associate of the Research Institute of Electrical Communication, Tohoku University. His current interests are in wireless IP networking, CDMA technology and OFDM technology for mobile communication networks. Dr Kameda received the TELECOM System Technology Award for Student in 1. He is a member of the Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers (IEICE), and the IEEE. Hiroshi OGUMA was born in TOYAMA, Japan, on November 3, 1972. He received the B.S. and M.S. degrees in electronics engineering from Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan in 1996 and 1998, respectively. In, he joined the Industrial Technology Miyagi Prefecture Government, where he has been engaged in the research and design of using FPGA. In 2, he joined the IT21-project of the Research Institute of Electrical Communication of Tohoku University. Currently he is engaged in development and the field test of the wireless communication Kazuo TSUBOUCHI was born in Kyoto, Japan, on February 6, 1947. He received the B.S., M.S. and Ph.D. degrees in Electronics Engineering from Nagoya University, Nagoya, Japan, in 1969, 1971 and 1974, respectively. Since 1974, he has been with the Research Institute of Electrical Communication, Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan. In 1982, he spent at Purdue University as a Visiting Associate Professor. He is currently the Professor of Wireless Info Tech Division and the director of Research Center for 21st-Century Information Technology (IT- 21 Center). His current interests are highly reliable GHz CDMA wireless communication system, GHz surface acoustic wave devices and materials, low-power RF signal processing integration circuits, high speed Si CMOS circuit/device/process technology, and system in package (SiP) technology. Prof. Tsubouchi received the Hattori-Hoko Award in 1983, the 26th Ichimura Award in 1994, the TELECOM System Technology Award in 1996, the 22nd Inoue Harushige Award in 1997, and the 5 Achievement Award from the Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers (IEICE). He is a member of the IEICE, the Physical Society of Japan, the Japan Society of Applied Physics, the Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan, the Japan Institute of Electronics Packaging, and the IEEE.