of Leaving Court Judgment(s) Intact, By Judge 1 2 3 Ambrose, Donetta W. DJ WDPA 49 95.92 5 34 94.12 10 Andrews, Richard G. DJ DDEL 10 90.00 29 27 92.59 15 Bartle, III, Harvey DJ EDPA 55 89.09 32 68 94.12 10 Baxter, Susan Paradise MJ WDPA 20 90.00 29 14 92.86 14 Baylson, Michael M. DJ EDPA 63 84.13 50 58 87.93 30 Bissoon, Cathy MJ/DJ WDPA 17 94.12 11 28 96.43 4 Bloch, Alan N. DJ WDPA 36 86.11 41 28 85.71 41 Brann, Matthew W. DJ MDPA 1 -- 4 -- 16 68.75 72 Brody, Anita B. DJ EDPA 34 61.76 77 35 65.71 73 Brown, Jr., Garrett E. DJ DNJ 64 68.75 75 37 59.46 75 Buckwalter, Ronald L. DJ EDPA 27 77.78 66 23 86.96 33 Bumb, Renee Marie DJ DNJ 49 93.88 12 43 86.05 40 Caldwell, William W. DJ MDPA 86 95.35 7 85 95.29 5 1 The number of appeals from the judge s orders or judgments across the three-year period. are defined on the basis of a unique COA docket number. A single COA opinion can dispose of multiple appeals (e.g., where cross appeals were filed, consolidated appeals). 2 The percentage of appeals in which the judgment or order was affirmed or in which the appeal was dismissed. 3 Based on the percent reported in table. Ties got the same ranking. s are reported for 93 judges for FY 2011, 2012, 2013 and for a different set of 93 judges for FY 2012, 2013, 2014. s ranged from 1 (high) to 78 (low) for FY 2011, 2012, 2013 and from 1 (high) to 75 (low) for FY 2012, 2013, 2014. 4 Information on percent is omitted if the data from available Court of opinions and orders showed fewer than 10 appeals over the three-year period. Several judges are not listed in this table because they had fewer than 10 appeals in each of the two periods. 1
of Leaving Court Judgment(s) Intact, By Judge 1 2 3 Caputo, A. Richard DJ MDPA 116 82.76 56 103 88.35 28 Cavanaugh, Dennis M. DJ DNJ 71 77.46 67 60 73.33 65 Cercone, David Stewart DJ WDPA 45 84.44 48 37 75.67 62 Chesler, Stanley R. DJ DNJ 72 86.11 41 65 86.15 39 Cohill, Jr., Maurice B. DJ WDPA 28 82.14 58 26 76.92 59 Conaboy, Richard P. DJ MDPA 53 86.79 39 38 89.47 24 Conner, Christopher C. DJ MDPA 108 93.52 15 92 92.39 16 Conti, Joy Flowers DJ WDPA 50 82.00 59 47 85.11 45 Cooper, Mary L. DJ DNJ 35 94.29 10 29 96.55 2 Dalzell, Stewart DJ EDPA 61 98.36 2 54 92.59 15 Davis, Legrome D. DJ EDPA 54 90.74 28 53 94.34 8 Debevoise, Dickinson R. DJ DNJ 31 93.55 14 26 84.61 48 Diamond, Gustave DJ WDPA 28 96.43 4 21 100.00 1 Diamond, Paul S. DJ EDPA 59 93.22 16 51 94.12 10 Ditter, Jr., J. William DJ EDPA 11 90.91 27 14 85.71 41 DuBois, Jan E. DJ EDPA 39 79.49 64 27 74.07 63 Farnan, Jr., Joseph J. DJ DDEL 18 66.67 76 6 -- Finch, Raymond L. DJ DVI 20 95.00 8 17 100.00 1 2
of Leaving Court Judgment(s) Intact, By Judge 1 2 3 Fischer, Nora Barry DJ WDPA 42 92.86 18 32 93.75 12 Fullam, John P. DJ EDPA 23 56.52 78 11 63.64 74 Gardner, James Knoll DJ EDPA 45 86.67 40 41 85.36 43 Gibson, Kim R. DJ WDPA 116 83.62 52 90 86.67 35 Goldberg, Mitchell S. DJ EDPA 36 88.89 33 40 85.00 46 Gomez, Curtis V. DJ DVI 52 73.08 73 56 73.21 67 Hayden, Katharine S. DJ DNJ 47 76.60 69 34 76.47 61 Hillman, Noel L. DJ DNJ 66 83.33 54 52 94.23 9 Hochberg, Faith S. DJ DNJ 32 84.37 49 39 82.05 53 Hornak, Mark R. DJ WDPA 4 -- 15 100.00 1 Irenas, Joseph E. DJ DNJ 48 85.42 44 44 86.36 37 Jones, II, C. Darnell DJ EDPA 29 89.66 31 32 87.50 32 Jones, III, John E. DJ MDPA 115 77.39 68 82 86.58 36 Joyner, J. Curtis DJ EDPA 59 81.36 61 50 82.00 54 Kane, Yvette DJ MDPA 90 91.11 24 75 90.67 19 Kelly, Maureen MJ WDPA 12 100.00 1 16 100.00 1 Kelly, Robert F. DJ EDPA 26 88.46 34 19 84.21 49 Kosik, Edwin M. DJ MDPA 39 92.31 21 33 90.91 18 3
of Leaving Court Judgment(s) Intact, By Judge 1 2 3 Kugler, Robert B. DJ DNJ 79 92.41 20 59 93.22 13 Lancaster, Gary L. DJ WDPA 52 82.69 57 34 73.53 64 Lenihan, Lisa P. MJ WDPA 11 81.82 60 12 100.00 1 Linares, Jose L. DJ DNJ 79 89.87 30 61 85.24 44 Ludwig, Edmund V. DJ EDPA 18 88.89 33 18 72.22 69 Mannion, Malachy E. MJ/DJ MDPA 5 -- 14 100.00 1 Mariani, Robert D. DJ MDPA 20 80.00 63 36 83.33 52 Martini, William J. DJ DNJ 50 82.00 59 49 81.63 56 McClure, Jr., James F. DJ MDPA 16 93.75 13 0 -- McLaughlin, Mary A. DJ EDPA 73 94.52 9 66 93.94 11 McLaughlin, Sean J. DJ WDPA 55 92.73 19 49 89.79 22 McNulty, Kevin DJ DNJ 3 -- 10 90.00 21 McVerry, Terrence F. DJ WDPA 56 87.50 37 58 89.65 23 Mitchell, Robert C. MJ WDPA 14 85.71 43 10 70.00 71 Muir, Malcolm DJ MDPA 20 85.00 45 9 -- Munley, James M. DJ MDPA 66 84.85 46 55 83.64 50 Nealon, Jr., William J. DJ MDPA 31 87.10 38 26 84.61 48 O Neill, Jr., Thomas N. DJ EDPA 16 93.75 13 20 95.00 6 4
of Leaving Court Judgment(s) Intact, By Judge 1 2 3 Padova, John R. DJ EDPA 32 93.75 13 29 89.65 23 Pisano, Joel A. DJ DNJ 66 74.24 71 56 71.43 70 Pollak, Louis H. DJ EDPA 12 75.00 70 5 -- Pratter, Gene E.K. DJ EDPA 47 82.98 55 49 87.75 31 Rambo, Sylvia H. DJ MDPA 100 92.00 22 85 83.53 51 Robinson, Sue L. DJ DDEL 64 85.94 42 54 81.48 57 Robreno, Eduardo C. DJ EDPA 89 87.64 36 86 88.37 27 Rodriguez, Joseph H. DJ DNJ 33 81.82 60 29 86.21 38 Rufe, Cynthia M. DJ EDPA 46 91.30 23 47 89.36 25 Salas, Esther DJ DNJ 9 -- 16 93.75 12 Sánchez, Juan R. DJ EDPA 102 73.53 72 101 73.27 66 Savage, Timothy J. DJ EDPA 45 77.78 66 37 89.19 26 Schiller, Berle M. DJ EDPA 45 88.89 33 41 85.36 43 Schwab, Arthur J. DJ WDPA 57 70.18 74 63 73.01 68 Shapiro, Norma L. DJ EDPA 13 84.62 47 10 100.00 1 Sheridan, Peter G. DJ DNJ 60 86.67 40 53 90.57 20 Shipp, Michael A. MJ/DJ DNJ 6 -- 12 83.33 52 Simandle, Jerome B. DJ DNJ 67 91.04 26 51 88.23 29 5
of Leaving Court Judgment(s) Intact, By Judge 1 2 3 Sleet, Gregory M. DJ DDEL 55 83.64 51 33 84.85 47 Slomsky, Joel H. DJ EDPA 29 89.66 31 38 86.84 34 Standish, William L. DJ WDPA 10 90.00 29 6 -- Stark, Leonard P. DJ DDEL 42 97.62 3 57 96.49 3 Stengel, Lawrence F. DJ EDPA 65 87.69 35 66 86.36 37 Surrick, R. Barclay DJ EDPA 50 78.00 65 47 76.59 60 Thompson, Anne E. DJ DNJ 66 80.30 62 49 81.63 56 Tucker, Petrese B. DJ EDPA 61 83.61 53 51 80.39 58 Vanaskie, Thomas I. DJ MDPA 36 88.89 33 11 81.82 55 Walls, William H. DJ DNJ 26 88.46 34 19 94.74 7 Wigenton, Susan D. DJ DNJ 56 91.07 25 62 85.48 42 Wolfson, Freda L. DJ DNJ 57 92.98 17 49 91.84 17 Yohn, Jr., William H. DJ EDPA 23 95.65 6 19 94.74 7 6