IADIS International e-society 2011 1 The Potential of ICT for Creative Learning & Innovative Teaching IADIS International e-society 2011 Romina Cachia, Anusca Ferrari &Yves Punie Joint Research Centre (JRC) Institute for Prospective Technological Studies The European Commission s Research-Based Policy Support Organisation
Institute for Prospective Technological Studies IADIS International e-society 2011 2 Part of Joint Research Centre of the EC IPTS: Research Institute supporting EU policy-making on socio-economic, scientific and/or technological issues
ICEAC study IADIS International e-society 2011 3 If you look for creativity in schools in Europe, will you find it?
Phase Objective Method Timing ICEAC Plan How are creativity and innovation conceptualized in the educational context? IADIS International e-society 2011 4 1 To understand the implications of creativity and innovation in education Literature review Dec 08 April 09 2 To validate methodological framework, focus and operation of the study Scoping workshop 23 24 Feb 09 How creativity and innovation are explicitly dealt with in the Member States' learning objectives? 3 To assess the role and relevance of creativity and innovation in the national learning objectives (curricula) of Member States Analysis of the Curricula Jul 09 Aug 10 What is the level of creative learning and innovative teaching taking place in school? What is the link between educational policies on creativity and innovation and the practices? 4 To assess teachers opinions and practices on creativity and innovation in each country at school level 5 To assess the relevance of creativity and innovation in education at national level Teachers survey Jul 09 Jul 10 Stakeholders interviews Nov 09 Jul 10 What are good practices of creative learning and innovative teaching in Europe? 6 To identify good practices of creativity and innovation in education in Europe Good practices (Case Studies) Nov 09 Jul 10 What are the main results and policy options? 7 To validate the results of the study Validation workshop 1 2 Jun 10 8 To synthesize the main results of the study and develop policy options Final report Jun 10 Oct 10
Final Report IADIS International e-society 2011 5 Project page: http://is.jrc.ec.europa.eu/pages/eap/iceac.html
Aim of paper IADIS International e-society 2011 6 The potential role of ICT as a driver which can enable educational change in public policy in developing a creative & innovative school environment PERCEPTIONS CREATIVITY ICT PERCEPTIONS PRACTICES POLICY SUGGESTIONS
Respondents & Instrument IADIS International e-society 2011 7 Respondents: 7,650 from EU 27 Obligatory schooling: (ISCED levels 1 and 2) Other biases Instrument: Collaboration with EUN Schoolnet & Ministries Online questionnairë: 22 languages etwinning: from mid Sept to mid Oct 2009 Italy Greece Spain Poland Bulgaria Estonia Hungary Finland Lithuania France Slovakia Portugal Czech Republic Latvia Sweden Germany Romania Belgium Slovenia United Cyprus Malta Ireland Denmark Netherlands Austria Luxembourg 0 200 400 600 800 1.000 1.200 1.400 1.600 358 311 310 279 233 202 189 188 178 164 154 149 139 115 107 98 91 54 34 27 25 22 4 656 891 1.203 1.478 28 close ended questions
Teacher Survey: Perceptions IADIS International e-society 2011 Do teachers perceive creativity as an important characteristic of education? 8
Everyone can be creative but less agreement on statement related to arts IADIS International e-society 2011 9 Almost nine out of ten teachers endorse a democratic view of creativity sustaining that everyone can be creative (88%). Creativity can be applied to every domain of knowledge (98%) and to every school subject (96%) Less agreement to the statement: creativity is not restricted to visual arts, music, drama and artistic performance (86%).
Teachers perception on creativity are positive but some ambivalence may be observed IADIS International e-society 2011 10 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Creativity is a skill that can be applied to every domain of knowledge Creativity is a skill that can be applied to every school subject Everyone can be creative Creativity is an inborn talent Creativity is only relevant to visual arts, music, drama and artistic performance Creativity is a characteristic of eminent people only Strongly Agree & Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree & Strongly Disagree
Training enables better understanding of creativity IADIS International e-society 2011 11 Most teachers have received ITT training Only 23% of respondents deem to have learnt how to teach during initial teacher training Positive correlation between teachers who have received training and their opinions and practices of creativity training.
Teacher Survey: Perceptions ICT 12 IADIS International e-society 2011 Do teachers perceive ICT as an enabler of creativity?
ICT can be used to enhance creativity and can improve teaching IADIS International e-society 2011 13 The vast majority of European teachers (85%) claim that technology has improved their teaching. An impressive high agreement (91%) amongst teachers that ICT can be used to enhance creativity.
Technologies important for learning IADIS International e-society 2011 14 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% High expectations classical ICT solutions Lower awareness of the potential of web 2.0 for learning Computers Educational software Videos Online collaborative tools Virtual learning environments Interactive whiteboards Online free material Online courses Music/photo/video/slide sharing sites Blogs Social networking sites Podcasts Bookmarking and tagging sites Digital games RSS feeds Mobile phones Strongly agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly Disagree Note: For the online collaborative tool item Wikipedia was given as an example
Scepticism in relation to the benefits of mobile phone IADIS International e-society 2011 15 More than half of European teachers (54%) disagree and strongly disagree that mobile phones could be important for learning. EU27 40,0% 35,0% 30,0% 25,0% 20,0% 15,0% 10,0% 5,0% 0,0% Strongly Agree Agree Neither agree nor disagree Disagree Strongly Disagree EU27
Teacher Survey: ICT Practices IADIS International e-society 2011 How is ICT used in schools in Europe? 16
Internet has become an important source of information 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% I use a computer to prepare handouts and material IADIS International e-society 2011 17 I use the Internet to access information to update my own knowledge for use in my lessons I use the Internet to search for teaching material I use the Internet to develop my teaching skills by being in contact with other teachers I use teaching software for which the school has a license I let my students use a wide range of technologies to learn (videos, mobiles, cameras, educational software, etc.) I use software which is freely available online I use the computer to access students' results and keep track of their progress Using a computer in class to present or demonstrate Using the computer room Asking pupils to use computers for their homework / outside school time I use the computer to send assignments to students and to receive their completed assignments I use digital games (including video games, online games, games that run on consoles, computers or mobile phones) in class always often sometimes rarely never
Divergent Opinions on the Benefit of Digital Games IADIS International e-society 2011 18 Less than half of the respondents (47%) agree that digital games are important for learning. However, only 17% of the respondents use them as resources in their teaching. Primary teachers use digital games as a teaching resource much more than secondary school
More resources & technical support needed IADIS International e-society 2011 19 Above half of the teachers lament a lack of resources (57%) Teachers (78%) claim to need more technical support (78%). More than half the respondents (59%) maintain to have found relevant support and examples to combine Information Communication Technology (ICT) and creativity through contact with other teachers/colleagues.
IADIS International e-society 2011 20 Major conclusions & policy suggestions
Perceptions stronger than practices IADIS International e-society 2011 21 Teachers believe that everyone can be creative but are less convinced on statement related that creative is not restricted to art Teachers are in agreement that ICT can be used to enhance creativity and to improve teaching and learning. Teachers' opinions on creativity in education are much stronger than their practices.
Potential of Web2.0 remains untapped IADIS International e-society 2011 22 The Internet is mainly used as a resource tool for teachers own profession and in some cases, for collaboration with other teachers Teachers lack of ICT proficiency is a major issue Although ICT may be used as an extension of other teaching tools, it also has the potential to develop new ways of doing things, thus developing creative attitudes in learning
Access to technology is just the first step IADIS International e-society 2011 23 Major policies related to ICT focused more on access to technology Notwithstanding access only a quarter of respondents believe that the quality of ICT in their schools was excellent. Good quality ICT, continuous maintenance and technical support are extremely important Research to assess the status and level of technology use by teachers and whether it is used for creative learning and innovative teaching
Teacher training makes a difference in teacher s claims on creativity and their practices IADIS International e-society 2011 24 Training is needed focusing on enabling teachers to: eradicate recurrent myths about creativity to get familiar with new technologies to equip young generations with new skills to encourage students to engage in more exploratory & creative interaction with ICT to reflect and discern which activities which take place in the classroom are more likely to encourage creativity and how to assess them adequately
Major Areas for Improvement IADIS International e-society 2011 25 Creative Learning Curriculum Assessment & Pedagogy Teachers Skills Development ICT & Digital Media Culture and Leadership Innovative Teaching
IADIS International e-society 2011 26 Questions? Thank you for your attention romina.cachia@ec.europa.eu