Mobiles beyond voice: identifying the conditions for use Ayesha Zainudeen, Senior Research Manager, LIRNEasia Dimuthu Ratnadiwakara, former Researcher, LIRNEasia CPRsouth5, Xi an, China This work was carried out with the aid of a grant from the International Development Research Centre, Canada and UKaid from the Department for International Development, UK, with contributions from Telenor Research & Development Centre Sdn. Bhd., Malaysia.
Key takeaways Beyond-voice services offer new revenue sources for operators Social influence a key factor in beyond-voice service adoption Leveraging on this can help bring less educated and recently connected segments of BOP into market Innovations in pricing of services for affordability needed Other conditions (e.g., payment services, delivery services, etc) need to be satisfied also
Study data: Teleuse@BOP3 Representative survey of ICT use among 15-60 year old BOP teleusers in Bangladesh, Pakistan, India, Sri Lanka, Philippines & Thailand BOP defined as SEC groups D + E* 10,000+ individuals surveyed in 2008; 200+ studied in depth via FGDs, mini-ethnographies and home visits in 2009 What this means in emerging Asia 579 million** * SEC E only in Philippines ** 15-60 age groups only
Beyond voice awareness and use are low, esp in BD, PK and IN Use of Mobile2.0 services (% of BOP aware of the services) Bangladesh Pakistan India Sri Lanka Philippines Thailand Not regularly Regularly Not regularly Regularly Not regularly Regularly Not regularly Regularly Not regularly Regularly Not regularly Regularly Banking and financial services 1 2 1 3 Payment services 3 2 3 1 4 Government services 2 2 Health services 1 1 8 1 2 Voting, competitions, reality shows, etc 1 1 1 5 7 1 8 General information services 1 1 3 2 5 11 Agricultural or fisheries information 1 Use of mobile Internet services (% of BOP teleusers aware of the Internet) Mobile internet 0 1 0 2 12 6 Among BOP teleusers who are aware of services
Understanding of factors influencing probability of beyond-voice mobile use can inform business strategies to better target BOP Factors influencing probability of beyond-voice use modeled using logistical regression Factors investigated: Demographics, education, income, distance from nearest town, mobile ownership, duration of mobile ownership, social influence perceived usefulness, Internet use via computer
Coefficient Odds Ratio Significance Age squared -0.001 0.999 0.09 Gender -0.153 0.858 0.04 Secondary education 0.242 1.274 0.00 Tertiary education 0.391 1.478 0.00 Duration of mobile ownership 0.013 1.013 0.02 Walk time to nearest town -0.012 0.988 0.19 % of phone-owning contacts 0.820 2.270 0.00 Sum of perceived benefits (uselfulness) 0.078 1.081 0.00 Use Internet through computer 1.958 7.085 0.00 Philippines -1.789 0.167 0.00 Thailand -1.160 0.313 0.00 Constant -6.340 0.000 0.00 n = 2524; Nagelkerke R Square: 0.354
Social influence a key predictor of probability of beyond-voice services Other significant factors: Internet use via computer Education perceived benefits (usefulness) duration of mobile ownership
Key barriers to uptake include lack of knowledge and relative cost Don t know how Not applicable to me 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% Reason for not using payments (% of those that are aware but don't use) 0% Don't know how Not applicable to me Don't own a phone/computer Too expensive Not trustworthy My service provider/handset doesn't allow it Language I need a bank account for this Happy with current methods Bangladesh Pakistan India Sri Lanka Philippines Thailand
Too expensive, when they're available free or cheaper via other modes Dinn Automobile mechanic 15 years Jae Hom, Thailand Previously subscribed to sports news on his mobile, until he felt that the service was not worth spending on, since the same information is available for free on the TV and Internet. Tried using the Internet on his mobile, but he lost all his credit (THB50) in less than 5 minutes. He no longer uses it on his mobile. Instead, he goes to a cyber café and downloads ringtones, wallpapers and themes for his mobile and uploads his mobile photos to his Hi5 page. A two hour visit only costs him THB20.
Other conditions need to be satisfied also Dispute resolution Feedback mechanism Delivery Payment Order Search CellBazaar stages included (basic functionality) stages included (full functionality) Dispute resolution Feedback mechanism Delivery Payment Order Search Amazon Marketplace stages not included
Why is this important? Total BOP phone ownership: 2006 vs 2008 (% of BOP teleusers) ICT use and ownership (% of BOP) 91% 77% Use a mobile Own 131% a mobile Use the Internet Own a computer 73% 95 90 63% increase 76 54% 74 69 43% 36% 41% 59 45% 52 41% 41 * 50 37 34 32 19% * 16 18 1 0 2 3 1 1 3 4 1 Bangladesh Pakistan India Sri Lanka Philippines Thailand 2008 2006 2008 2006 2008 2006 2008 2006 2008 2006 2008 Bangladesh Pakistan India Sri Lanka Philippines Thailand 12 Even at the BOP non-owners have access * Excludes CDMA fixed wireless phones in Sri Lanka Among BOP teleusers
Cost of ownership is declining (below USD5 in several emerging economies) Four S Asian countries in less-than-usd 5 TCO club among 77 emerging economies (average TCO = USD10.88) Includes services, taxes and cheapest handset
Operators finding it harder and harder to make money from basic services ARPU (INR/SIM/month) 200 150 100 50 0 GSM CDMA 185 164 144 131 122 92 89 82 76 74 Q2 2009 Q3 2009 Q4 2009 Q1 2010 Q2 2010 Source: TRAI, 2010; USD= INR (June 2010)
Concluding thoughts Developing world is connecting to the Internet via mobiles Mobile access/ownership growing; affordability increasing Mobile2.0 and mobile Internet (data) services seen as a way to boost revenues and reduce churn AND provide access to an array of important services to BOP at lower transaction costs Operators need to target older mobile owners, more educated, and current Internet users at the BOP Leveraging on social networks can push services out Innovations in pricing of services for affordability needed Other conditions (e.g., payment services, delivery services, etc) need to be satisfied also
www.lirneasia.net ayesha@lirneasia.net