Pulmonary Emphysema Classification based on an Improved Texton Learning Model by Sparse Representation

Similar documents
Multiple Classifier Systems in Texton-Based Approach for the Classification of CT Images of Lung

Automated Lesion Detection Methods for 2D and 3D Chest X-Ray Images

Extraction and recognition of the thoracic organs based on 3D CT images and its application

Københavns Universitet. Pattern Recognition-Based Analysis of COPD in CT Sørensen, Lauge. Publication date: 2010

Automated segmentations of skin, soft-tissue, and skeleton from torso CT images

Automatic quantification of mammary glands on non-contrast X-ray CT by using a novel segmentation approach

Detection and Identification of Lung Tissue Pattern in Interstitial Lung Diseases using Convolutional Neural Network

Sparse Models in Image Understanding And Computer Vision

A COMPARISON OF WAVELET-BASED AND RIDGELET- BASED TEXTURE CLASSIFICATION OF TISSUES IN COMPUTED TOMOGRAPHY

Image Denoising Using Sparse Representations

Computer-Aided Diagnosis in Abdominal and Cardiac Radiology Using Neural Networks

Hybrid Approach for MRI Human Head Scans Classification using HTT based SFTA Texture Feature Extraction Technique

Patch-Based Color Image Denoising using efficient Pixel-Wise Weighting Techniques

Iterative CT Reconstruction Using Curvelet-Based Regularization

Available Online through

Department of Electronics and Communication KMP College of Engineering, Perumbavoor, Kerala, India 1 2

An Approach for Reduction of Rain Streaks from a Single Image

Image Deblurring Using Adaptive Sparse Domain Selection and Adaptive Regularization

Research Article A Sparse Representation Based Method to Classify Pulmonary Patterns of Diffuse Lung Diseases

Discriminative sparse model and dictionary learning for object category recognition

Volumetric Texture Analysis based on Three- Dimensional Gaussian Markov Random Fields for COPD Detection

An Optimized Pixel-Wise Weighting Approach For Patch-Based Image Denoising

Learning based face hallucination techniques: A survey

Structure-adaptive Image Denoising with 3D Collaborative Filtering

IMAGE DENOISING USING NL-MEANS VIA SMOOTH PATCH ORDERING

The Anatomical Equivalence Class Formulation and its Application to Shape-based Computational Neuroanatomy

A Novel Image Super-resolution Reconstruction Algorithm based on Modified Sparse Representation

Image Restoration and Background Separation Using Sparse Representation Framework

A Comparison of wavelet and curvelet for lung cancer diagnosis with a new Cluster K-Nearest Neighbor classifier

Single Image Interpolation via Adaptive Non-Local Sparsity-Based Modeling

Diffuse Parenchymal Lung Diseases: 3D Automated Detection in MDCT

Skin Infection Recognition using Curvelet

DEVELOPMENT OF THE EFFECTIVE SET OF FEATURES CONSTRUCTION TECHNOLOGY FOR TEXTURE IMAGE CLASSES DISCRIMINATION

Comparison of 2D and 3D Local Binary Pattern in Lung Cancer Diagnosis

Learning Algorithms for Medical Image Analysis. Matteo Santoro slipguru

An Adaptive Threshold LBP Algorithm for Face Recognition

FEATURE DESCRIPTORS FOR NODULE TYPE CLASSIFICATION

Image reconstruction based on back propagation learning in Compressed Sensing theory

Applying Boosting Algorithm for Improving Diagnosis of Interstitial Lung Diseases

Dictionary Learning in Texture Classification

ANALYSIS OF PULMONARY FIBROSIS IN MRI, USING AN ELASTIC REGISTRATION TECHNIQUE IN A MODEL OF FIBROSIS: Scleroderma

Multi Focus Image Fusion Using Joint Sparse Representation

Learning Splines for Sparse Tomographic Reconstruction. Elham Sakhaee and Alireza Entezari University of Florida

Short Communications

Object detection using non-redundant local Binary Patterns

Detecting Burnscar from Hyperspectral Imagery via Sparse Representation with Low-Rank Interference

Similarity Guided Feature Labeling for Lesion Detection

A New Feature Local Binary Patterns (FLBP) Method

IMA Preprint Series # 2281

Enhanced Image Texture Feature Extraction Method Using Local Tetra Patterns for Plant Leaf Classification System

Inverse Problems in Astrophysics

BSIK-SVD: A DICTIONARY-LEARNING ALGORITHM FOR BLOCK-SPARSE REPRESENTATIONS. Yongqin Zhang, Jiaying Liu, Mading Li, Zongming Guo

Unsupervised Discovery of Emphysema Subtypes in a Large Clinical Cohort

Automated 3D Segmentation of the Lung Airway Tree Using Gain-Based Region Growing Approach

Face Recognition via Sparse Representation

Detection & Classification of Lung Nodules Using multi resolution MTANN in Chest Radiography Images

Color Local Texture Features Based Face Recognition

Efficient Implementation of the K-SVD Algorithm and the Batch-OMP Method

Efficient Image Compression of Medical Images Using the Wavelet Transform and Fuzzy c-means Clustering on Regions of Interest.

Feature Based Classifiation Of Lung Tissues For Lung Disease Diagnosis

P257 Transform-domain Sparsity Regularization in Reconstruction of Channelized Facies

Detecting Printed and Handwritten Partial Copies of Line Drawings Embedded in Complex Backgrounds

Cervigram Image Segmentation Based On Reconstructive Sparse Representations

Copyright 2009 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation Engineers. This paper was published in Proceedings of SPIE, vol. 7260, Medical Imaging 2009:

Prostate Detection Using Principal Component Analysis

An Introduction to Content Based Image Retrieval

Journal of Asian Scientific Research FEATURES COMPOSITION FOR PROFICIENT AND REAL TIME RETRIEVAL IN CBIR SYSTEM. Tohid Sedghi

Learning Dictionaries of Discriminative Image Patches

Copyright 2008 Society of Photo Optical Instrumentation Engineers. This paper was published in Proceedings of SPIE, vol. 6915, Medical Imaging 2008:

Efficient Imaging Algorithms on Many-Core Platforms

CHAPTER 6 DETECTION OF MASS USING NOVEL SEGMENTATION, GLCM AND NEURAL NETWORKS

Temporal subtraction system on torso FDG-PET scans based on statistical image analysis

Improving Recognition through Object Sub-categorization

Graph Matching Iris Image Blocks with Local Binary Pattern

Experimentation on the use of Chromaticity Features, Local Binary Pattern and Discrete Cosine Transform in Colour Texture Analysis

DENOISING OF COMPUTER TOMOGRAPHY IMAGES USING CURVELET TRANSFORM

Image Denoising via Group Sparse Eigenvectors of Graph Laplacian

A Simple Centricity-based Region Growing Algorithm for the Extraction of Airways

Modified Iterative Method for Recovery of Sparse Multiple Measurement Problems

SPARSE COMPONENT ANALYSIS FOR BLIND SOURCE SEPARATION WITH LESS SENSORS THAN SOURCES. Yuanqing Li, Andrzej Cichocki and Shun-ichi Amari

MEDICAL IMAGE NOISE REDUCTION AND REGION CONTRAST ENHANCEMENT USING PARTIAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

Image Inpainting Using Sparsity of the Transform Domain

PATCH-DISAGREEMENT AS A WAY TO IMPROVE K-SVD DENOISING

Automatic Shadow Removal by Illuminance in HSV Color Space

MULTI ORIENTATION PERFORMANCE OF FEATURE EXTRACTION FOR HUMAN HEAD RECOGNITION

SEGMENTATION OF IMAGES USING GRADIENT METHODS AND POLYNOMIAL APPROXIMATION

IMAGE SUPER-RESOLUTION BASED ON DICTIONARY LEARNING AND ANCHORED NEIGHBORHOOD REGRESSION WITH MUTUAL INCOHERENCE

A Novel Hand Posture Recognition System Based on Sparse Representation Using Color and Depth Images

Content based Image Retrieval Using Multichannel Feature Extraction Techniques

Computer Aided Diagnosis Based on Medical Image Processing and Artificial Intelligence Methods

Efficient Implementation of the K-SVD Algorithm using Batch Orthogonal Matching Pursuit

2. Methodology. sinθ = const for details see, [5]. ψ ((x 1. ψ a,b,θ

Video shot segmentation using late fusion technique

IMAGE RESTORATION VIA EFFICIENT GAUSSIAN MIXTURE MODEL LEARNING

Illumination-Robust Face Recognition based on Gabor Feature Face Intrinsic Identity PCA Model

Automated segmentation methods for liver analysis in oncology applications

Image Interpolation using Collaborative Filtering

SHIP WAKE DETECTION FOR SAR IMAGES WITH COMPLEX BACKGROUNDS BASED ON MORPHOLOGICAL DICTIONARY LEARNING

Low Light Image Enhancement via Sparse Representations

Texture Segmentation by Windowed Projection

Transcription:

Pulmonary Emphysema Classification based on an Improved Texton Learning Model by Sparse Representation Min Zhang* a, Xiangrong Zhou a, Satoshi Goshima b, Huayue Chen c, Chisako Muramatsu a, Takeshi Hara a, Ryujiro Yokoyama d, Masayuki Kanematsu b,d and Hiroshi Fujita a a Department of Intelligent Image Information, Division of Regeneration and Advanced Medical Sciences, Graduate School of Medicine, Gifu University, Gifu-shi, 501-1194 Japan b Department of Radiology, Gifu University Hospital, Gifu-shi, 501-1194 Japan c Department of Anatomy, Division of Disease Control, Graduate School of Medicine, Gifu University, Gifu-shi,501-1194 Japan d Department of Radiology services, Gifu University Hospital, Gifu-shi, 501-1194 Japan ABSTRACT In this paper, we present a texture classification method based on texton learned via sparse representation (SR) with new feature histogram maps in the classification of emphysema. First, an overcomplete dictionary of textons is learned via K- SVD learning on every class image patches in the training dataset. In this stage, high-pass filter is introduced to exclude patches in smooth area to speed up the dictionary learning process. Second, 3D joint-sr coefficients and intensity histograms of the test images are used for characterizing regions of interest (ROIs) instead of conventional feature histograms constructed from SR coefficients of the test images over the dictionary. Classification is then performed using a classifier with distance as a histogram dissimilarity measure. Four hundreds and seventy annotated ROIs extracted from 14 test subjects, including 6 paraseptal emphysema (PSE) subjects, 5 centrilobular emphysema (CLE) subjects and 3 panlobular emphysema (PLE) subjects, are used to evaluate the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed method. The proposed method is tested on 167 PSE, 240 CLE and 63 PLE ROIs consisting of mild, moderate and severe pulmonary emphysema. The accuracy of the proposed system is around 74%, 88% and 89% for PSE, CLE and PLE, respectively. Keywords: emphysema, computed tomography (CT), texture classification, texton, sparse representation, dictionary learning 1. INTRODUCTION Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a disease of pulmonary system and is a growing health problem worldwide. Coughing up mucus is an early sign of COPD. The term chronic obstructive pulmonary disease or COPD is often used to describe patients who have chronic and largely irreversible airways obstruction, most commonly associated with some combination of emphysema and chronic bronchitis. Emphysema is one of the important kinds of COPD. It is defined histologically as permanent enlargement of the airspace distal to the terminal bronchioles and destruction of the alveolar wall (See Fig.1 for illustration). Areas of the lung that are affected by emphysema have reduced CT attenuation coefficients. Emphysema may be further characterized as centrilobular emphysema (CLE), panlobular emphysema (PLE) and paraseptal emphysema (PSE). CLE affects the lobules around the central respiratory bronchioles and is the most common type of smoking-related emphysemas. CLE is typically found in the upper lung zone. It is depicted on CT images as a low-attenuation area surrounded by normal lung attenuation. CLE predominates in older subjects, whereas PSE predominated in younger subjects. PLE uniformly affects the entire secondary lobules. It appears as a generalized decrease in CT attenuation, predominantly in the lower lobe. The vessels in affected regions of the lung are reduced in number and caliber. Although PLE is typically associated with α1-antitrypsin deficiency, it also may be seen in severe smoking-related emphysemas. *min@fjt.info.gifu-u.ac.jp; zhangmin@mailst.xjtu.edu.cn Medical Imaging 2013: Computer-Aided Diagnosis, edited by Carol L. Novak, Stephen Aylward, Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670, 86700F 2013 SPIE CCC code: 1605-7422/13/$18 doi: 10.1117/12.2007934 Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670 86700F-1

Figure 1. Ilustration of the microscopic view of normal alveoli and alveoli with emphysema [1,2]. Pulmonary function tests (PFTs) are used for the evaluation of patients with suspected COPD. In addition, PFTs are used to determine the severity of the airflow limitation, to assess the response to medications, and to follow up disease progression. Another common measure is the relative area of emphysema (RA), which measures the relative amount of lung parenchyma pixels that have attenuation values below a certain threshold. RA method relies on a single intensity threshold on individual pixels, thus ignoring any interrelations between pixels. RA of emphysema cannot be capable of detecting early stages of emphysema and relies on a hand-picked parameter sometimes [3]. Computerized diagnosis and quantification of emphysema are very important. Clinically, high resolution computed tomography (HRCT) can provide an accurate assessment of lung tissue patterns. Three-dimensional (3D) image of the pulmonary volumes produced by HRCT can avoid the superposition of anatomic structures, and is suitable for the assessment of lung tissue texture. HRCT is a reliable tool for demonstrating the pathology of emphysema, even in subtle changes within secondary pulmonary lobules. Another traditional method is based on the histogram of CT attenuation values. The quantitative measures of the degree of emphysema are derived from this histogram [4]. Another way to objectively characterize the emphysema morphology is to describe the local image structure using texture analysis techniques. An adaptive multiple feature method (AMFM) for examining the lung parenchyma from HRCT scans is proposed [5]. The AMFM is a texture-based method that combines statistical texture measures with a fractal measure. Seventeen measures of texture were used, including the grey level distribution measures, run-length measures, cooccurrence matrix measures, and a geometric fractal dimension (GFD). The optimal feature selection is performed by using the divergence measure along with correlation analysis and the classification is performed by a bayesian approach. Then this method is extended from a 2D texture based tissue classification method (AMFM) to 3D texture based method [6]. In this way, 3D AMFM provides a means of discriminating subtle differences between smokers and nonsmokers both with normal PFTs. Recently, small-sized local operators, such as local binary patterns (LBPs) and patch representation in texton-based approaches are also introduced for classification and quantification of COPD [7,8]. Smallsized local operators are especially desirable in situations where the region of interest (ROI) is rather small, which is often the case in texture analysis in medical imaging, where pathology can be localized in small areas. In our previous work [9], we used a texture classification method based on textons learned via sparse representation in the classification of emphysema. This method is inspired by the great success of l 1 -norm minimization based sparse representation (SR). The dictionary of textons is learned by applying SR to image patches in the training dataset. The SR coefficients of the test images over the dictionary are used to construct the histograms for texture classification. However textons learned in dictionary learning stage are not sensitive to intensity difference. When dealing with CT images, intensity is of a physical property of the tissue which may be related to pathological pattern. Hence, intensity information should be included in the feature histogram. In this paper, 3D joint SR-coefficient-and-intensity histogram maps are proposed as the features used in the classification of emphysema. The joint SR coefficient and intensity histogram map capture information about at which intensity levels the different textons reside to improve discrimination Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670 86700F-2

results. With the proposed method, a texton training dataset is first constructed from descriptors in the training images, and then an over-complete dictionary of textons is computed under the SR framework. A histogram map of joint SRcoefficient-and-intensity can be extracted for texture classification by coding the texture image with the texton dictionary and the image intensity. The test subjects, including mild, moderate and severe emphysema with three different subtypes, are used to evaluate the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed method. Annotated ROIs extracted from 14 test subjects, including 6 PSE subjects, 5 CLE subjects and 3 PLE subjects of different stages, are used to evaluate the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed method. 2. METHOD 2.1 Related work Recently, the theory and algorithms of sparse coding or sparse representation (SR) [10, 11] have been successfully used in image processing and pattern recognition [12-14]. The principle of SR reveals that a given natural signal can be often sparsely represented as the linear combination of an over-complete dictionary. The success of SR largely owes to the fact that natural signals are intrinsically sparse in some domain. Sparseness is one of the reasons for the extensive use of popular transforms such as the discrete fourier transform (DFT), the wavelet transform and the singular value decomposition (SVD). The aim of these transforms is often to reveal certain structures of a signal and to represent these structures in a compact and sparse representation. However, wavelet transform is limited in characterizing the various local structures in natural images. In order to overcome the shortcomings of wavelet transform, more advanced multi-scale transforms such as Curvelet [15], Contourlet [16] and Bandlet [17] are developed. Although these transforms can offer multi-scale and multi-direction representations for natural images, these representations are not adaptive to the image contents. They can only handle some specific classes of images optimally such as piece-wise smooth images, while natural images often have sharp edge structures. If a redundant dictionary of bases can be learned from example images, a good representation of the input signal can be expected by using this redundant dictionary. SR and the associated dictionary learning techniques can be employed to this end. Various dictionary learning methods have been proposed such as the K-SVD [11] and dual Lagrange methods [18]. m With K-SVD, for a given signal x R, we say that x has a sparse approximation over a dictionary [,,..., ] m l D = d1 d2 dl R, if we can find a linear combination of only a few atoms from D that is close enough to the signal x. Under this assumption, the sparsest representation of x over D is the solution of 2 st x D 0 2 min α α.. α ε, (1) where α represents the number of non-zeros in the coding vector α. The process of solving the above optimization 0 problem is commonly referred to as sparse coding. However, the l 0 -norm sparse coding is a non-convex and NP-hard problem, and approximate solutions are often found by algorithms such as matching pursuit (MP) [19] and orthogonal matching pursuit (OMP) [20]. The selection of dictionary D plays an important role in sparse coding. The wavelet, curvelet and contourlet bases can be used as the dictionary to represent signals. However, these analytically designed universal dictionaries are too generic to be effective enough for a specific task, such as texture representation. In many applications of computer vision and pattern classification, we may have training samples, and a more effective dictionary D can be learned from a m n training dataset, denoted by X = [ x1, x2,..., x n ] R. It is expected that each training sample (i.e., each column of X ) can be sparsely and faithfully represented over the dictionary D, i.e., x i Dα i and only a few elements in α i are significant. Sparse representations account for most or all information of a signal with a linear combination of a small number of elementary signals called atoms. Often, the atoms are chosen from a so called over-complete dictionary. Formally, an over-complete dictionary is a collection of atoms such that the number of atoms exceeds the dimension of the signal space, so that any signal can be represented by more than one combination of different atoms. Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670 86700F-3

2.2 The proposed method The motivation of the proposed work is from the following aspects. First, from above analysis, HRCT can provide an accurate assessment of lung tissue patterns. And based upon the previous work, texture features are quite useful in the classification and quantification of emphysema in CT images. Second, recently, there is a growing interest in the use of sparse representations for signals. Texture classification inspired by dictionary learning and sparse representation has achieved great success. It shows impressive performance in the natural texture image classification. Sparsity in an overcomplete dictionary is the basis for all kinds of highly effective signal and image presentations. It is based on the suggestion that natural signals can be efficiently represented as linear combinations of prespecified atom signals with linear sparse coefficients. The proposed method mainly includes four stages: 1) ROI image pre-processing; 2) construction of a dictionary of textons via sparse representation; 3) texton histogram learning with the training set; and 4) ROI image classification. The details of the proposed method are as follows. 1. ROI preprocessing The test images were obtained from 14 subjects, including 6 PSE subjects, 5 CLE subjects and 3 PLE subjects of different stages. Totally 470 ROIs with 40 40 pixels were extracted from these subjects. 2. Texton learning by K-SVD a) Before texton learning, all training ROI images are normalized to have zero mean and unit standard deviation. The normalization offers certain amount of invariance to the illumination changes. A square neighborhood around each pixel in the image is cropped and is stretched to a vector. For each type of ROIs, a training dataset m n X = [ x1, x2,..., x n ] R is constructed, where x i, i = 1,2, L, n, is the patch vector at a position in a training sample image of this type. The dictionary of textons, denoted by [,,..., ] m l D = d1 d2 dl R, can be learned from the constructed training dataset X, where d j, j = 1,2, L, k is one of the k textons. In this stage, a high-pass filter is applied to exclude the patches reside in smooth regions. b) Then an overcomplete dictionary of textons is learned by optimizing D and d j, j = 1,2, L, k of the function below by using K-SVD [11] 2 st x D 0 2 min α α.. α ε, (1) where the coding vector α is the SR objective function. In this stage, orthogonal matching pursuit (OMP) is used to update the dictionary. Figure 2 (a) shows the flowchart for the training stage. 3. Feature extraction Dictionary learning is not sensitive to intensity difference due to the normalization process in the dictionary learning stage. When dealing with CT images, intensity is of a physical property of the tissue may be related to pathological pattern. Hence, intensity information should be included in the feature histogram by forming the joint histogram between the SR coefficient and the intensity in the center pixels. So in this work, new 3D joint SR coefficient and intensity histogram maps are used as the extracted feature for the classification of emphysema. The joint SR coefficient and intensity histogram captures information about at which intensity levels the different textons reside to improve discrimination results. Figure 2 (b) illustrates the extraction of the proposed histogram map. 4. ROI classification Finally, the ROI image can be classified into the corresponding class by the selected classifier using the proposed feature histogram maps. Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670 86700F-4

DrcFrou; D loruf ExFLsc[64 : (a) (b) Figure 2. (a) The illustration of the dictionary learning using K-SVD and (b) the generation of 3D histogram map. 3. EXPERIMENTS AND RESULTS 3.1 Data preparation The dictionary of texton is learned via applying SR to image patches in the training dataset. The SR coefficients of the test images over the dictionary are used to construct the histograms for texture classification. The proposed scheme was applied to 14 patient cases of non-contrast CT images. Each CT image covers the whole torso region with an isotopic spatial resolution of 0.63 [mm] and a 12 [bits] density resolution. The test images were obtained from 14 subjects with three subtypes of pulmonary emphysema. Totally 470 40 40 region of interests (ROIs) are extracted. Table 1 shows details of the test dataset with different emphysema. Table 1. Details of test dataset. ROI Numbers ROI Size Texton Size PSE CLE PLE 167 (6 subjects) 240 (5 subjects) 63 (3 subjects) 40 40 8 8 3.2 Experimental results and comparison In this section, we present the results of the proposed method. In the experiments, training set was constructed only by 47 ROIs, which account for 10% of total ROIs. This training set was used for the texton learning by sparse representation to build 128 textons separately. Patch size of 8 8 are used in the experiments. Preliminary results are shown in Table 2 and Table 3 along with the result obtained based on the proposed classification framework. The confusion matrix in Table 3 shows that the result of proposed method generally agrees with the class labels in most cases. The classification accuracy for PSE is relatively low. The discrimination between PSE and CLE needs further improvement. Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670 86700F-5

Table 2. The average performance for different types of emphysema classification. PSE CLE PLE Average accuracy (%) 73.6 87.5 88.9 Table 3. Confusion matrix showing the true label vs. label assigned by the classifier for the proposed method. Estimated labels True labels PSE CLE PLE PSE 123 25 2 CLE 38 210 5 PLE 6 5 56 4. CONCLUSION This paper presents to use 3D joint SR coefficient and intensity histogram maps in pulmonary emphysema classification based on texton learning via sparse representation. The dictionary of texton is learned via applying K-SVD to image patches in the training dataset. The SR coefficients of the test images over the dictionary joint intensities are used to construct the 3D histogram maps for texture classification. The dataset, including 470 annotated ROIs consisting of PSE, CLE and PLE emphysema of mild, moderate and severe, is used. The performance of the proposed system obtained an accuracy of around 74%, 88% and 89% for PSE, CLE and PLE, respectively. ACKNOWLEGEMENT Authors thank to the members of Fujita Lab. This research was granted in part by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Reasearch on Innovative Areas (21103004), MEXT, Japan. Authors also gratefully acknowledge the Venture Business Laboratory (VBL) of Gifu University for the support of this research work. REFERENCES [1] http://depositphotos.com/2627823/stock-photo-lung-infection.html. [2] http://www.modernmedicalguide.com/emphysema/. [3] N. L. Müller, C. A. Staples, R. R. Miller, and R. T. Abboud, "Density mask. An objective method to quantitate emphysema using computed tomography, " Chest, vol.94, no.4, pp. 782 787 (1988) [4] Shaker, et al., "Identification of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) by measurement of plasma biomarkers," The Clinical Respiratory Journal 2(1), 17 25 (2008) [5] R Uppaluri, G McLennan, P Enright, and E A Hoffman, "Adaptive multiple feature method (AMFM) for the early detection of parenchymal pathology in smoking population," in Proc. SPIE Conf. Medical Imaging, vol. 3337, pp. 8-13 (1998). [6] Y. Xu, M. Sonka, G. McLennan, J. Guo, and E. A. Hoffman, MDCT based 3-D texture classification of emphysema and early smoking related lung pathologies, IEEE Trans. Med. Imag., vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 464 475, (2006). [7] Sørensen, L., Shaker, S.B., de Bruijne, M., Quantitative Analysis of Pulmonary Emphysema Using Local Binary Patterns. IEEE Trans. Med. Imag. 29(2), 559 569, (2010). Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670 86700F-6

[8] Gangeh, M.J., Sørensen, L., Shaker, S.B., Kamel, M.S., de Bruijne, M., Loog, M., "A Texton-Based Approach for the Classification of Lung Parenchyma in CT Images." In MICCAI 2010, LNCS, vol. 6363, pp. 596--603. Springer, Heidelberg (2010). [9] M. Zhang, X. Zhou, S. Goshima, H. Chen, C. Muramatsu, T. Hara, R. Yokoyama, M. Kanematsu and H. Fujita, "An application to pulmonary emphysema classification based on model of texton learning by sparse representation", SPIE medical imaging conference (2012) [10] A. Bruckstein, D. Donoho, and M. Elad, From sparse solutions of systems of equations to sparse modeling of signals and images, SIAM. Review, vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 34 81(2009). [11] M. Aharon, M. Elad, and A. Bruckstein, The K-SVD: an algorithm for designing of overcomplete dictionaries for sparse representation, IEEE Trans. Signal Processing, vol. 54, no. 12, pp. 4311 4322(2006). [12] J. Yang, K. Yu, and T. Huang, Efficient highly over-complete sparse coding using a mixture model, in ECCV, (2010). [13] J. Wright, A. Yang, A. Ganesh, S. Sastry, and Y. Ma, Robust face recognition via sparse representation, IEEE Trans. PAMI, vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 210 227, 2009. E. Candes, and D. Donoho, Continuous curvelet transform: I. Resolution of the wavefront set, Applied and Computational Harmonic Analysis, vol. 19, no. 5, pp. 162 197 (2003). [14] Xie, J., Zhang, L., You, J., Zhang, D., "Texture Classification via Patch-Based Sparse Texton Learning," In: Int l Conf. on Image Processing (ICIP), Hong Kong, pp. 2737 2740 (2010) [15] E. Candes, and D. Donoho, Continuous curvelet transform: II. Discretization and frames, Applied and Computational Harmonic Analysis, vol. 19, no. 5, pp. 198 222 (2003). [16] M. N. Do, and M. Vetterli, The contourlet transform: an efficient directional multiresolution image representation, IEEE Trans. IP, vol. 14, no. 12, pp. 2091-2106 (2005). [17] E. Lepennec, and S. Mallat, Discrete bandelets with geometric orthogonal filters, in ICIP, (2005). [18] H. Lee, A. Battle, R. Raina, and A. Ng, Efficient sparse coding algorithms, in NIPS, pp. 801-808 (2006). [19] S. Mallat, and S. Zhang, Matching pursuits with time-frequency dictionaries, IEEE Trans.SP, vol. 41, no. 12, pp. 3397 3415(1993). [20] J. Tropp, Greed is good: algorithmic results for sparse approximation, IEEE Trans. Information Theory, vol. 50, no. 10, pp. 2231 2242(2004). Proc. of SPIE Vol. 8670 86700F-7