DEERE AFFIDAVIT Attachment FF

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "DEERE AFFIDAVIT Attachment FF"

Miranda Bridget Horn
6 years ago
Views:

1 DEERE AFFIDAVIT Attachment FF Attachment FF consists of a Report and three Attachments. The Report and Attachments 1 and 2 to the Report are Public, Attachment 3 to the Report is Pacific Bell Proprietary Information and will only be provided to parties who have Signed a Nondisclosure Agreement

2 Deere Attachment FF April 13, 1999 Mr. Jack Leutza Director, Telecommunications Division California Public Utilities Commission 505 Van Ness Avenue, Room 3210 San Francisco, California Re: Results of 2PIC Customized Routing Trial for Lucent Switches Dear Mr. Leutza: Ordering Paragraph ( O.P. )12 of Decision requires that within 30 days of the technical workshop, Pacific must conduct any necessary technical trials of switching Options B and C, including the 2PIC element of Option C, and provide the results of the trials with the Director of the Telecommunications Division no later than 30 days after conclusion of the technical trials. After the conclusion of the technical workshops in February 1999, Administrative Law Judge Jacqueline A. Reed issued a ruling ( Ruling ) dated March 2, In the Ruling, she acknowledged that the parties at the workshop had discussed a test plan for the trial of 2PIC customized routing for Lucent switches. She noted that the plan was satisfactory to all parties and that the plan had been modified to include changes suggested by the parties. Ruling, p.4. The Ruling adopted the test plan and required that it be conducted within the timeframe of O.P Pacific completed the trial as defined in the test plan within the timeframe required by O.P. 12. The results of the trial consist of three attachments: Attachment 1 is a summary of the results, Attachment 2 is the completed test scripts, and Attachment 3 consists of the switch outputs. Attachment 3 is proprietary to Pacific and is submitted to you and Ms. Jones pursuant to General Order 66-C and to Mr. Stover and Ms. Rogers under the terms of the nondisclosure agreement which has been executed between the parties. Although the trial demonstrated 2PIC customized routing is feasible in Lucent switches, it is important to understand the potential effect of the use of this type of customized routing on access charges. CLECs can use unbundled loops, switching (including customized routing), and transport to provide local service to their end users. If the CLEC is providing local service to an end user using unbundled switching and transport and that end user originates an intralata call, the CLEC will pay UNE rates, instead of access rates, for the originating end of the call. CLECs must still pay originating access charges to Pacific when they do not provide local service to the end user originating the intralata call. If an intralata call terminates to an end user served by the same CLEC providing local service to the originating end user, then the CLEC will pay UNE rates instead of access rates for the terminating end of the call. If the call terminates to a facilitiesbased CLEC, then charges as agreed to by the two CLECs will apply. If a CLEC end user, who is served with unbundled elements, originates a call terminating to another CLEC end user, who is also served using unbundled elements, then Pacific will bill the first CLEC UNE rates for the originating end of the call and will bill the second CLEC UNE rates for the terminating end of the call. Finally, the CLEC will pay Pacific terminating switched access charges for the transport and termination of intralata calls to a Pacific end user or to a Pacific resold line. It is appropriate that terminating access charges continue to apply because the call terminates on Pacific s network and Pacific s intrastate access charges are its Commission-authorized wholesale charges to transport and terminate interexchange calls. 1 The Ruling actually stated the filing must be made in accordance with O.P. 2. Pacific believes this is a clerical error because O.P. 2 deals with CPNI and the timeframes for technical trials are set forth in O.P. 12. WD Attachment FF-1

3 The key to understanding assessment of UNE and access charges is that the correct rates must be applied to the originating and terminating portions of each call. The FCC s First Report and Order and the Shared Transport Order indicate that Pacific should assess switched access charges for the originating and/or terminating portion of the call depending on whether the CLEC is serving the originating and/or terminating end user. See First Report and Order, 363, fn. 772, and Shared Transport Order, 52. The use of UNEs by CLECs to carry intralata toll calls for their end users will allow CLECs to pay UNE rates instead of access rates for specific local portions of intralata calls depending on whether the CLECs serve the originating and terminating end users. Pacific is providing this information to you so that there is no misunderstanding concerning its views on the appropriate pricing, subject to future Commission determinations in pending proceedings. Also, under a recent Supreme Court decision, AT&T Corporation v. Iowa Utilities Board, 119 S. Ct. 721 (1999), there will necessarily have to be further determinations as to UNEs Pacific might be required to provide to CLECs and the appropriate pricing for any such UNEs. Pacific hereby reserves its rights with regard to these matters as they apply to 2PIC customized routing and unbundled transport. If you have any questions, please contact me at the number listed above. Sincerely, L. Nelsonya Causby Senior Counsel Attachments cc: Kathleen Rogers Glenn Stover Karen Jones WD Attachment FF-2

4 ATTACHMENT 1 Summary Of Results WD Attachment FF-3

5 5ESS INTRALATA TOLL PIC2 CUSTOM ROUTING TECHNICAL TESTING Scope of Test Executed To validate translation configurations designed to support custom routing of direct dialed intralata toll calls in a post-pic2 environment. The translation configurations tested were based on an assessment of PIC2 technology capabilities for custom routing provided by Lucent, the supplier of the 5ESS switch. SUMMARY TABLE 1 GENERAL TEST EXECUTION INFORMATION Specific Testers Test Site(s) & Test Process Test Dates Routing Function Tested & Outcome Billie Otis, Pacific Bell 3/26/1999 & Olet Diaz, Pacific Bell 3/29/1999 See Summary Table 2 Testing was completed at Pacific Bell s facilities in San Ramon, California. Test calls were originated using a test line, test trunk groups, and software translation configurations established in the originating test switch to support the specific test call placed. Test Switches-Pacific Bell: DAVLCA13DS0 (5ESS-Originating Test Switch) MRTZCA11DS0 (DMS100-Terminating Test Switch) PLALCA02DS0 (5ESS Terminating Test Switch) OKLDCA0349T (Tandem) WD Attachment FF-4

6 5ESS INTRALATA TOLL PIC2 CUSTOM ROUTING TECHNICAL TESTING SUMMARY TABLE 2 TEST CALL AND RESULTS SUMMARY Test # 1 Test Case(s) Test Results AMA Record Results Originating End Office 2 1 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via dedicated CLEC end office to end office direct trunk group. CLEC trunk group does not overflow to Pacific Bell shared network. CLEC end user originates call. 2 2 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via a dedicated CLEC end office to end office direct trunk group. Call overflows and is completed via Pacific Bell shared end office to tandem trunk group. CLEC end user originates call. 2 3 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via a dedicated CLEC end office to access tandem trunk group. CLEC trunk group does not overflow to Pacific Bell shared network. CLEC end user originates call. 2 4 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via a dedicated CLEC end office to access tandem trunk group. CLEC trunk group overflows to Pacific Bell shared end office to tandem trunk group. CLEC end user originates call. 2 5 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via Pacific Bell shared network. CLEC end user originates call. 2 Test call completed between two Pacific Bell switches via dedicated CLEC end office to end office direct trunk group Test call completed between two Pacific Bell switches via Pacific Bell end office to tandem overflow trunk group. Test call completed between two Pacific Bell switches via dedicated CLEC end office to access tandem trunk group. Test call completed between two Pacific Bell switches via Pacific Bell end office to tandem overflow trunk group. Test call completed between two Pacific Bell switches via Pacific Bell shared network. AMA record anomaly noted: CC110 FGD AMA record created; routing indicator field indicated tandem -completed call which is not an accurate reflection of how the call was routed. No AMA anomalies noted: Call Code 110 FGD AMA record created. No AMA anomalies noted: Call Code 110 FGD AMA record created. No AMA anomalies noted: Call Code 110 FGD AMA record created. No AMA anomalies noted: Call Code 110 FGD AMA record created. 1 Test # refers to the actual test(s) performed as documented in the CPUC Workshop Technical Trial IntraLATA Toll NPA NXX custom routing Using 2PIC Technology 5ESS SwitchTtest Plan and scripts attached to the March 2, 1999, ruling issued by Administrative Law Judge Reed. 2 CLEC refers to the test trunk groups or test end users established to represent a CLEC network and CLEC end users for the test calls. WD Attachment FF-5

7 ATTACHMENT 2 Completed Test Scripts CPUC Workshop Technical Trial Test Results IntraLATA Toll NPA NXX Custom Routing Using 2PIC Technology 5ESS Switch WD Attachment FF-6

8 Author: Billie Otis Technology Consultant Pacific Bell WD Attachment FF-7

9 CPUC Workshop Technical Trial IntraLATA Toll NPA NXX Custom Routing Using 2PIC Technology - 5ESS Table of Contents Page Test Scripts with Results NPA NXX IntraLATA Toll Custom Routing via End Office Direct 3 Trunk Group (no overflow to Pacific Bell shared network) NPA NXX IntraLATA Toll Custom Routing via End Office Direct 4 Trunk Group (with overflow to shared network) NPA NXX IntraLATA Toll Custom Routing via Access Tandem 5 Trunk Group (no overflow to shared network) NPA NXX IntraLATA Toll Custom Routing via Access Tandem 6 Trunk Group (with overflow to Pacific Bell shared network) IntraLATA Toll Call Routing via Pacific Bell Shared Network with 7 NPA NXX Custom Routing in Effect WD Attachment FF-8

10 Test #1 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed and completed via a dedicated CLEC end office to end office direct trunk group. CLEC trunk group does not overflow to Pacific Bell shared network. CLEC end user originates call. Originating Local Switch: DAVLCA13DS0 Access Tandem Switch: N/A Originating Switch Type: 5ESS Test Date: 3/26/1999 P*B Tester(s) Name(s): B. Otis, O. Diaz Originating Test Line #: Test Line LCC/LTG: XAH Test Line Class-of-Service: Basic Test Line PIC1: 333 Test Line PIC2: 372 Test Call Dialed Digits: Test Steps: # Action: Desired Result: 1 Dial (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX. Called number is reached. 2 Hang up and release the trunk. Call is completed between two Pacific Bell switches via dedicated CLEC end office to end office direct trunk group. Accurate CC110 AMA record is created at P*B originating end office. Test Data: Start Time: End Time: Answer Status: Originating End Office AMA Record: Terminating Office AMA Record: TGN(S) Used in Call: Comments: 1111am 1111am (Answered, Recording, etc.) Answered CC110 Not Applicable 294 ( CLEC dedicated TGN between DAVL13 & PLAL02) CC110 record ROUTING INDICATOR field indicated tandem. This does not accurately reflect how the call was routed. All other fields populated correctly. WD Attachment FF-9

11 Test #2 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via a dedicated CLEC end office to end office direct trunk group. Call overflows and is completed via Pacific Bell shared end office to tandem trunk group. CLEC end user originates call. Originating Local Switch: DAVLCA13DS0 Access Tandem Switch: OKLDCA0349T Originating Switch Type: 5ESS Test Date: 3/29/1999 P*B Tester(s) Name(s): B. Otis, O. Diaz Originating Test Line #: Test Line LCC/LTG: XAH Test Line Class-of-Service: Basic Test Line PIC1: 333 Test Line PIC2: 372 Test Call Dialed Digits: Test Steps: # Action: Desired Result: 1 Dial (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX. Called number is reached. 2 Hang up and release the trunk. Call is completed between two Pacific Bell switches via Pacific Bell end office to tandem overflow trunk group. Accurate CC110 AMA record is created at P*B originating end office. Test Data: Start Time: End Time: Answer Status: Originating End Office AMA Record: Terminating Office AMA Record: TGN(S) Used in Call: Comments: 1047am 1047am (Answered, Recording, etc.) Answered CC110 Not Applicable 274 (P*B shared TGN between DAVL13 & OKLD0349T) No test call/ama anomalies noted WD Attachment FF-10

12 Test #3 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call custom routed via a dedicated CLEC end office to access tandem trunk group. CLEC trunk group does not overflow to Pacific Bell shared network. CLEC end user originates call. Originating Local Switch: DAVLCA13DS0 Access Tandem Switch: OKLDCA0349T Originating Switch Type: 5ESS Test Date: 3/29/1999 P*B Tester(s) Name(s): B. Otis, O. Diaz Originating Test Line #: Test Line LCC/LTG: XAH Test Line Class-of-Service: Basic Test Line PIC1: 333 Test Line PIC2: 372 Test Call Dialed Digits: Test Steps: # Action: Desired Result: 1 Dial (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX Called number is reached 2 Hang up and release the trunk Call is completed between two Pacific Bell switches via dedicated CLEC end office to access tandem trunk group. Accurate CC110 AMA record is created at P*B originating end office. Test Data: Start Time: End Time: Answer Status: Originating End Office AMA Record: Terminating Office AMA Record: TGN(S) Used in Call: Comments: 1101am 1101am (Answered, Recording, etc.) Answered CC110 Not Applicable 295 ( CLEC dedicated TGN between DAVL13 & OKLD0349T) No test call/ama anomalies noted WD Attachment FF-11

13 Test #4 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via a dedicated CLEC end office to access tandem trunk group. CLEC trunk group overflows to Pacific Bell shared end office to tandem trunk group. CLEC end user originates call. Originating Local Switch: DAVLCA13DS0 Access Tandem Switch: OKLDCA0349T Originating Switch Type: 5ESS Test Date: 3/29/1999 P*B Tester(s) Name(s): B. Otis, O. Diaz Originating Test Line #: Test Line LCC/LTG: XAH Test Line Class-of-Service: Basic Test Line PIC1: 333 Test Line PIC2: 372 Test Call Dialed Digits: Test Steps: # Action: Desired Result: 1 Dial (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX Called number is reached 2 Hang up and release the trunk Call is completed between two Pacific Bell switches via Pacific Bell end office to tandem overflow trunk group. Accurate CC110 AMA record is created at P*B originating end office. Test Data: Start Time: End Time: Answer Status: Originating End Office AMA Record: Terminating Office AMA Record: TGN(S) Used in Call: Comments: 1107am 1107am (Answered, Recording, etc.) Answered CC110 Not Applicable 274 (P*B shared TGN between DAVL13 & OKLD0349T) No test call/ama anomalies noted WD Attachment FF-12

14 Test #5 (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX intralata toll call is custom routed via Pacific Bell shared network. CLEC end user originates call. Originating Local Switch: DAVLCA13DS0 Access Tandem Switch: OKLDCA0349T Originating Switch Type: 5ESS Test Date: 3/29/99 P*B Tester(s) Name(s): B. Otis, O. Diaz Originating Test Line #: Test Line LCC/LTG: XAH Test Line Class-of-Service: Basic Test Line PIC1: 333 Test Line PIC2: 372 Test Call Dialed Digits: Test Steps: # Action: Desired Result: 1 Dial (1+) (NPA) NXX-XXXX Called number is reached 2 Hang up and release the trunk Call is completed between two Pacific Bell switches via Pacific Bell shared network. Accurate CC110 AMA record is created at P*B originating end office. Test Data: Start Time: End Time: Answer Status: Originating End Office AMA Record: Terminating Office AMA Record: TGN(S) Used in Call: Comments: 1122am 1122am (Answered, Recording, etc.) Answered CC110 Not Applicable 274 (P*B shared TGN between DAVL13 & OKLD0349T) No test call/ama anomalies noted WD Attachment FF-13

15 ATTACHMENT 3 Switch Outputs Proprietary PROPRIETARY NOT FOR USE OR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE SBC FAMILY OF COMPANIES EXCEPT BY PRIOR WRITTEN AGREEMENT WD Attachment FF-14

Table of Contents. AT&T Texas. April 08, Informational Notice Access Service Tariff - IntraLATA Primary Interexchange Carrier (LPIC) Page

Table of Contents. AT&T Texas. April 08, Informational Notice Access Service Tariff - IntraLATA Primary Interexchange Carrier (LPIC) Page AT&T Texas April 08, 2011 Table of Contents Informational Notice Access Service Tariff - IntraLATA Primary Interexchange Carrier (LPIC) Page I. Cover Letter 2 II. Informational Notice 3 III. Attachment