NoMagic Product Comparison Brief

Transcription

1 1 NoMagic Product Comparison Brief Presented to: SET, AMSEWG Last Updated : September 15 th, 2017 Presented by: David Fields

2 Overview NoMagic offers a variety of UML and SysML tools each with multiple editions and features This brief is designed to help NAVAIR engineers and leadership understand these differences and be able to choose the right NoMagic product for their tasks. Much of this information came from NoMagic s website and from NoMagic s sale representatives:

3 MagicDraw Overview Editions Notable Paid Plugins Notable Free Plugins Cameo System Modeler Overview Editions Contents Cameo Enterprise Architecture Overview Editions NAVAIR Usage

4 MagicDraw File: NAVAIR Brief 4

5 MagicDraw NoMagic s core product Is the base application for all Cameo products! UML Only Can be extended with dozens of plugins SysML, UPDM, Simulation Toolkit, etc. Some plugins are free while others required paid licenses Comprises of several editions with increasing capabilities Reader, Personal, Standard, etc. File: NAVAIR Brief 5

6 MagicDraw Editions Enterprise Professional Architect Standard Edition Plus: Personal, Standard, and all 3 Professional Editions Plus: Reader Free Made for reading/previewing MagicDraw models Has printing and image export capabilities Personal Create, edit, and publish UML 2.5 Models Open API Basic Reporting Image Export Cannot be used with Teamwork Server! Cannot use floating licenses! Cannot use plugins! Standard Personal Edition Plus: Generic Table Wizards User Interface Diagrams Dependency Matrix Additional Diagram Types: Relation Map, Content, Network, Free Form, and Robustness Patterns Model Templates Profile Creation Domain Specific Language customization Standard Edition Plus: Has Programming Language Specific Versions: Java, C++, C# Code Generation and Reverse Engineering for Selected Language Code Generation and Reverse Engineering for DDL and XML Visual Model Differencing Metrics and Metrics Tables Model Validation (including custom created validations) Cameo Data Modeler JDBC Support PIM to PSM Transformations (both directions) WebPortal Reporting File: NAVAIR Brief 6

7 Plugins (Paid) SysML UPDM Cameo Simulation Toolkit Cameo Business Modeler Cameo Requirements Modeler Cameo Concept Modeler ParaMagic Cameo SOA+ Cameo Data Modeler Cameo NIEM Project Merge Adds SysML 1.4 support Adds UPDM 2 or UPDM 3 support for DoDAF, MODAF, NAF, UAF (UPDM 3) Add executing, animating, and debugging SysML Parametric Models Add BPMN support and other business modeling tools Adds the requirement parts of SysML without all of SysML (Includes Import/Export for DOORS and other Requirement Tools ) Allows for concept/ontology modeling using UML 2 notation Adds simulations and trade study capability with SysML Parametrics Adds SoaML and SOA modeling capabilities Adds Entity-relationship, database, and XML Schema modeling National Information Exchange Model (NEIM) information modeling and sharing support Enables copying changes between different project versions File: NAVAIR Brief 7

8 Notable Free Plugins Model-based approach to safety and reliability analysis OMG standardized model transformations Cameo Safety and Reliability Analyzer QVT Modeling automation through easy to build wizards Methodology Wizards Software Process Engineering Metamodel 2.0 support SPEM Import and map elements from CSV files CSV Import Clean imports removing tool-specific extensions/profiles Strict UML Importer Basic SoaML profile SoaML Obfuscate element name and descriptions Model Obfuscator Note: Only SET relevant no-cost plugins listed, additional plugins available File: NAVAIR Brief 8

9 Cameo System Modeler File: NAVAIR Brief 9

10 Cameo System Modeler NoMagic s System Engineering/MBSE Package Still MagicDraw at it s core Includes SysML and Requirements Modeler in all editions Cameo Simulation Toolkit included in Enterprise Edition Other changes are cosmetic: splash screen, GUI colors, etc. Comes is the following editions: Enterprise, Architect, and free Reader Each edition is based on the corresponding MagicDraw edition File: NAVAIR Brief 10

11 Cameo System Modeler Editions Cameo System Modeler Reader Free Made for reading/previewing Cameo System Architect models Cameo System Modeler Architect MagicDraw Architect Plus: SysML Plugin Requirements Modeler Plugin Cameo System Modeler Enterprise MagicDraw Enterprise Plus: SysML Plugin Requirements Modeler Plugin Cameo Simulation Toolkit Plugin Has printing and image export capabilities File: NAVAIR Brief 11

12 Cameo Enterprise Architecture File: NAVAIR Brief 12

13 Cameo Enterprise Architecture Overview NoMagic s Enterprise Architecture Package Focus on DoDAF and other similar frameworks Still MagicDraw at it s core Includes SysML, Requirements Modeler, and UPDM in all editions Very similar, but more robust, to Cameo System Modeler No Cameo Simulation Toolkit (can be added via plugin) Other changes are cosmetic: splash screen, GUI colors, etc. Comes is the following editions: Enterprise, Architect, Standard, and free Reader Each edition is based on the corresponding MagicDraw edition File: NAVAIR Brief 13

14 Cameo Enterprise Architecture Editions Cameo Enterprise Architecture Reader Free Made for reading/previewing Cameo Enterprise Architecture models Has printing and image export capabilities Cameo Enterprise Architecture Standard MagicDraw Standard Plus: UPDM Plugin SysML Plugin Requirements Modeler Plugin Business Modeler Plugin Cameo SOA+ Plugin Cameo Enterprise Architecture Architect MagicDraw Architect Plus: UPDM Plugin SysML Plugin Requirements Modeler Plugin Business Modeler Plugin Cameo SOA+ Plugin Cameo Data Modeler Plugin TOGAF Plugin Cameo Enterprise Architecture Enterprise MagicDraw Enterprise Plus: UPDM Plugin SysML Plugin Requirements Modeler Plugin Business Modeler Plugin Cameo SOA+ Plugin Cameo Data Modeler Plugin TOGAF Plugin Zachman Plugin TOGAF Plugin Zachman Plugin Zachman Plugin File: NAVAIR Brief 14

15 NAVAIR Usage File: NAVAIR Brief 15

16 NAVAIR Client Usage Cameo Enterprise Architect Enterprise Edition v18.5sp1 Fixed licenses for Core Modeler All modelers and likely advanced modelers in 4.0M, 4.5, etc. DADMS Approval in early July 2017 Came System Modeler Architect Edition v18.5sp1 Floating Licenses for system engineers Includes the UPDM2 and Cameo Simulation Toolkit plugins that can be checked out separately DADMS Approval in early July 2017 Free Reader Edition of both CEA EE and CSM AE No license required Can view, print, and export images DADMS Approval pending (~early-mid October) NAVAIR will transition to v19 of CEA, CSM, TWC, etc. in early to mid 2018 File: NAVAIR Brief 16