FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/05/ :02 PM INDEX NO /2016 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 68 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/05/2018

Transcription

1

2 JOHNSON LIEBMAN, LLP ATTORNEYS AT LAW 305 BROADWAYSUITE 801 ROBERT E. JOHNSON NEW YORK, NEW YORK NICOLE SlBBLE CHARLES D. LIEBMAN* rel (212) PARALEGAL *LICENSEDIN NY ANDNJ FAX: ( 212) EWELINA SIERZPUTOWSKA LAW CLERK Via First Class Mail. NYSCEF and ( James.Catterson(alkaveschoicr.com) January 31, 2018 James A. Catterson, Esq. Kaye Scholer, LLP 250 West 55"' Street New York, NY Re: Ruben Elberg et al. v. Crabapple Corp. et al. New York County Supreme Court Index No.: /2016 Subpoena directed to Charles Liebman Subpoena directed to Tamara Pewzner Dear Mr. Catterson: Kindly accept this letter as a formal demand, pursuant to CPLR 2304, to request that the Subpoena Ad Testificandum directed to myself be withdrawn and that all documentary requests in this subpoena be modified to be considered as requests made directly to the defendants in this action. As the subpoena process is not meant as a substitute for normal discovery processes between the parties, we ask that your requests be limited to the issues pending before the Court in the upcoming hearing. The hearing before the Court is limited to a determination of Ruben Elberg's fitness to serve as comanager or comanaging member of the defendants. Instead your subpoenas seek information far beyond the scope of this hearing and therefore we ask that be modified to designate documents actually related to matters currently before the Court. they Please provide your response to this request no later than 5 p.m., February 2, 2018, or we will deem this request as rejected and denied. Very truly yours, 7 ( CHARLES D. LIEBMAN CDL/ea cc: Andrew R. Tulloch, Esq. (via )

3 ,:; ' "~~ NYSCEF New York County Supreme Court 94 C n> Confirmation Notice This is an automated response for Supreme Court cases. The NYSCEF site has received your electronically filed documents for the following case /2016 RUBEN ELBERG v. CRABAPPLE CORP. et al Assigned Judge: Charles Edward Ramos Documents Received on 01/31/ :23 PM Doc # Document Type Motion # 64 LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE TOJUDGE Does not contain an SSN or CPI as defined in 202.5(e) or 206.5(e) Filing User Name: Charles David Liebman Phone #: (212) Address: chaslieb@yahoo.com Fax #: (212) Work Address: 305 BROADWAY NEW YORK, NY Notifications An notification regarding this filing has been sent to the following address(es) on 01/31/ :23 PM: CATTERSON, JAMES MICHAEL James.Catterson@kayescholer.com JENSEN, PETER TORBEN ptjensen@jensenlaw.com LIEBMAN, CHARLES DAVID chaslieb@yahoo.com ROGERS, MARGARET ANNE margaret.rogers@kayescholer.com TULLOCH, ANDREW ROGER tullochlaw@aol.com NOTE: If submitting a working copy of this filing to the court, you must include as a notification page firmly affixed thereto a copy of this Confirmation Notice. Hon. Milton A. Tingling, New York County Clerk and Clerk of the Supreme Court Phone: Website: NYSCEF Resource Center EFile@nycourts.gov Phone: (646) Fax: (212) Website: Page 1 of 1

4 Network Solutions NYSCEF Notification New York Commercial... https.//webmail.networksciüticñs eem/appsuite/v= We'v»lail.networksVlllllc":3=::1=..:! 1/31/2018 4:23 PM NYSCEF Notification: New York Commercial Division <LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE> /2016 (RUBEN ELBERG CRABAPPLE CORP. et al) v. To e!!sebeth.:::": ±n::: sts;n.com tullochlaw@aol.com n.:!bb!: j±r cr!!±com efile@nycourts.gov ' mergeret.rogers@kayescholer.com chas isb@yâhgg.com ' e.sierzpstew5k..'..."....com n.com n.:n ::::: ':. com * james.catterson@kayescholer.com maonystatecourt@kayescholer.com //' n I, i~tl,~ 'I,,) New York County Supreme Court Notification 01/31/2018 Please retain this notification for your records. The NYSCEF web site has received documents from the filing user, CHARLES LIEBMAN, for the following case/claim. Case Information Index #: /2016 Short Caption: RUBEN ELBERG v. CRABAPPLE CORP. et al Assigned Case Judge: Charles Edward Ramos Filing User Information User Name: CHARLES LIEBMAN Phone Number: (212) Fax Number: (212) Service Address: chaslieb ho.co Work Address: 305 BROADWAY, NEW YORK, NY, Documents Filed (To view a document, click the document type link) Doc # Document Type Additional Doc Info Special Instructions Filed Date 64 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE Letter to Mr. Catterson 01/31/2018 The judge assigned to this case requires working copies. Print out a Confirmation Notice and attach it to the back facing out of an exact copy of the efiled document. Working copies should include tabs and motion sequence number. 1) If the application is brought on by notice of motion, all working copies are to be submitted in Room 130 on the final return date. 2) If the application is brought on by order to show cause, deliver working copies of the proposed order to show cause and its supporting documents to the Commercial Division Support Office, Room 119A at 60 Centre Street. Working copies on all subsequent documents related to an order to show cause must be submitted directly to the Part as directed by the judge. See the EFiling Website for more information. Service Notifications Sent 1 of 2 2/5/2018, 4:14 PM

5 Network Solutions NYSCEF Notification New York Commercial... Name Emall Address CHARLES LIEBMAN JAMES CATTERSON MARGARET ROGERS PETER JENSEN ANDREW TULLOCH No Service Notifications Sent (NYSCEF has no record of opt out or participation recorded for the parties listed below) Uniform Rules 202.5b and 202.5bb require hard copy service upon optedout and nonparticipating parties. Party Name Role ZHU QING FENG LI MENGSHA CHEN RUIZHEN WANG HONG GE,QIN, SI YANG ZHANG ZHE FANG XU NING ' THIS IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE USE OF THE NAMED ADDRESSEE(S) AND FOR THE PURPOSES OF THE NEW YORK STATE COURTS ELECTRONIC FILING SYSTEM. IF YOU ARE NEITHER THE INTENDED RECIPIENT NOR A PERSON DESIGNATED TO RECEIVE MESSAGES ON BEHALF OF THE INTENDED RECIPIENT PLEASE NOTIFY THE SENDER IMMEDIATELY THANK YOU. ol N Hon. MIIton A. Tingling, New York County Clerk and Clerk of the Supreme Court Phone: Website: clerk operations.shtml 2of2 2/5/2018, 4:14 PM