Summary of the ATN/OSI Doc Security Validation Report
|
|
- Phebe Lang
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 International Civil Aviation Organization WORKING PAPER ACP-WGM16/WP May 2010 AERONAUTICAL COMMUNICATIONS PANEL (ACP) 16h MEETING OF WORKING GROUP M Paris, France May 2010 Agenda Item 3a: ATN/OSI Document 9880 Update Status Security Updates Summary of the ATN/OSI Doc Security Validation Report (Presented by Michael Olive, Honeywell International Inc., United States) SUMMARY This working paper provides a summary overview of the analysis, results, and recommendations presented in the ATN/OSI Doc Security Validation Report. The detailed validation report is included as an appendix to ACP-WGM16-WP08. ACTION The working group is invited to review the ATN/OSI Security Validation results and consider recommended improvements to Part IV-B. (28 pages) WG-M WP ATN-OSI Security Validation Report Summary_ pdf
2 Background Under the terms of the FAA DataComm Avionics Contract, Honeywell was tasked to perform validation of ATN security provisions Task 1 ICAO Doc Requirements Validation Analyze and document similarities between ICAO Doc and ARINC 823, ACARS Message Security (AMS) Identify validation objectives Leverage Honeywell Secure ACARS to establish that ICAO Doc security provisions have been validated in a representative environment Deliverable: Doc Security Validation Report Task 2 ICAO ACP WG-M Meeting Participation Participate in WG-M meetings Present results of the security validation task Purpose of this working paper. 2
3 Validation Report Table of Contents 1. Introduction 4. Validation Analysis & Results 1.1. Purpose Analysis format and example 1.2. Scope 4.1. Chapter 2 ATN Security Services 1.3. Document Overview 4.2. Chapter 4 ATN PKI 1.4. Terminology 4.3. Chapter 5 ATN Crypto 1.5. Reference Documents 4.4. Chapter 6 ATN SSO 2. Validation Objectives 2.1. High-level Validation Objectives 2.2. ATN Security Validation Scope 2.3. Validation Means 2.4. ATN Security Validation Matrix 5. Conclusions 5.1. Summary Results 5.2. Recommendations 3. Validation Approach Validation report topics highlighted in RED are summarized in this working paper presentation Overall Approach Provision Alignment Implementation Verification Means 3
4 1.1 Purpose 1. Introduction The purpose of the report is to present results of validation analysis of the security provisions proposed for Part IV-B, ATN Security Services, of ICAO Doc. 9880, Manual of Technical Provisions for the Aeronautical Telecommunications Network (ATN) using ISO/OSI Protocols. Part IV-B of ICAO Doc is intended to update and supersede the ATN/OSI security provisions specified in Sub-volume VIII of ICAO Doc Edition 3, Manual of Technical Provisions for the Aeronautical Telecommunications Network (ATN). The proposed Part IV-B security provisions were presented by the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) as information paper IP1405 during the 14 th meeting of Working Group M (WG-M) of the ICAO Aeronautical Communications Panel (ACP). Honeywell was tasked by the FAA to perform this validation as part of the FAA Data Communications (DataComm) Avionics contract. 4
5 2. Validation Objectives [1/5] 2.1 High-Level Validation Objectives Re-use high-level objectives applied previously to validate ICAO Doc Ed. 3, SV-III References to SV-VIII changed to Part IV-B Focus is on the highlighted objectives SVO 1 SVO 2 SVO 3 FVO 1 FVO 2 FVO 3 FVO 4 FVO 5 FVO 6 FVO 7 TVO 1 TVO 2 TVO 3 TVO 4 TVO 5 TVO 6 TVO 7 TVO 8 Determine which system level requirements are satisfied by Part IV-B requirements. Validate that the Part IV-B requirements trace to other sub-volumes, where applicable. Validate that Part IV-B includes provision for backward compatibility with prior versions of peer ATN implementations that do not incorporate security services. Validate that Part IV-B supports implementation of local security policies and practices, within the boundaries of SARPs, as determined by States/Organizations. Validate that Part IV-B requirements are complete. Validate that Part IV-B requirements are unambiguous. Validate that Part IV-B requirements are consistent. Determine if there are any Part IV-B requirements that would have no effect if removed. Determine if provision has been made to ensure that Part IV-B is implementation independent. Determine if Part IV-B includes provision for security services necessary for all security users. Validate that Part IV-B includes provisions for both mobile and fixed ATN users. Validate that Part IV-B minimizes air-ground security related protocol overhead. Validate that Part IV-B supports the security provisions of the ATN Upper Layer Communications Service (ULCS). Validate that Part IV-B supports the security provisions of the ATN IDRP. Validate that independent implementations built in accordance to Part IV-B will be able to interoperate. To determine if the ATN security solution has any unacceptable behavior. To determine if provision for future migration has been addressed. To determine if the functionality described in Part IV-B is implementable. 5
6 2.2 ATN Security Validation Scope Indentifies the Part IV-B chapters that are included in the scope of the validation effort 2. Validation Objectives [2/5] 6
7 2. Validation Objectives [3/5] 2.3. Validation Means Re-use validation means (and notation) applied previously to validate ICAO Doc. 9705, Sub-Volume VIII The means applicable to this validation activity is analysis and inspection. However, the analysis leverages and references the Secure ACARS flight demonstration, which is a representative implementation validated by one organization in a relevant operational communications environment. 7
8 2. Validation Objectives [4/5] 2.4. Validation Matrix Cross-reference security provisions included in the scope of the validation to high-level validation objectives and validation means. 8
9 2. Validation Objectives [5/5] 2.4. Validation Matrix (continued) 9
10 3. Validation Approach [1/7] 3.1. Overall Approach Leverage ARINC Standard 823, ACARS Message Security (AMS), which is based on ATN/OSI security provisions in Doc SV-VIII (plus the enhancements included in Doc Part IV-B) Honeywell Secure ACARS, which is an existing ARINC 823- compliant implementation of AMS To show, by analysis and inspection that 1. There is substantial alignment between the AMS provisions in ARINC 823 and ATN/OSI security provisions specified in Part IV-B. 2. Secure ACARS is a representative implementation of the technical security solution specified in Part IV-B. Given that alignment 3. Successful system-level testing and flight demonstration of the Secure ACARS implementation in a representative, operational communications environment satisfies high-level ATN security validation objectives and provides confidence in the technical security solution specified in Part IV-B. Consequently 10
11 3. Validation Approach [2/7] 3.1. Overall Approach (continued) Why is this validation approach feasible? The ATN/OSI technical security solution i.e., the security framework, security services, cryptographic algorithms, and public key infrastructure is independent of the upper layer applications that use the security services and the underlying sub-network(s) over which the security protocol is communicated. In other words, the technical security solution is suitable for protecting bit-oriented ATN application messages communicated over the ATN network as well as protecting character-oriented ACARS messages communicated over the ACARS network» Recognizing that some minor adaptation is necessary to accommodate differences in network addressing. Consequently, an ACARS security implementation that is based on ATN/OSI security can serve as a suitable platform for validation of ATN/OSI technical security provisions. 11
12 3. Validation Approach [3/7] 3.2. Analysis Component 1 Provision Alignment Qualitative assessment of provision alignment between AMS provisions in ARINC 823 and ATN/OSI security provisions in Part IV-B» Focus on technical equivalence, recognizing that technically equivalent provisions may be worded differently in their respective specifications ICAO Doc SV-VIII ATN/OSI 2. Provisions transferred to ICAO Doc Part IV-B ATN/OSI 4. Provision Alignment ARINC 823 ACARS Message Security 3. ARINC 823 influenced enhancements incorporated in Part IV-B 1. ARINC 823 is based directly on ATN/OSI security 12
13 3. Validation Approach [4/7] Background: What were the primary drivers for selecting ATN/OSI security as the basis for ACARS security? 1. In developing the ATN/OSI security solution, the ICAO ATN Panel Security Sub-group considered the unique challenges of the mobile aeronautical communications environment, including RF bandwidth constraints and avionics resource limitations, which are shared by both ATN and ACARS. 2. The ATN Panel Security Sub-group specified a security solution that is based on internationally recognized cryptographic and public key infrastructure standards. This ensures a high degree of confidence in the cryptographic strength of the solution, and it also facilitates use of commercially available security tool-kits, which reduces development time and minimizes life cycle cost, including non-recurring, procurement, maintenance, and support costs. 3. Finally, a common datalink security solution for both ATN/OSI and ACARS is consistent with ARINC Report 811, which recommends use of common security controls and a common security infrastructure (e.g., PKI) in order to minimize airline investment. 13
14 3. Validation Approach [5/7] 3.3. Analysis Component 2 Implementation Honeywell Secure ACARS implementation of ARINC 823 employs a two-part System Security Object (SSO)» The ATN SSO, which supports authentication, data integrity, and key/certificate management services as specified in Sub-volume VIII of ICAO Doc (and Part IV-B of Doc. 9880), and,» AMS-specific SSO extensions that support confidentiality services as well as initialization and self-test functions (these functions are not included in ATN provisions since they are not required for interoperability) Software ported to Honeywell MK-II CMU 14
15 3. Validation Approach [6/7] 3.4. Analysis Component 3 Verification Secure ACARS Unit-level test Secure ACARS System-level bench test (end-to-end)» Simulated network environment, non-operational ground system,» Simulated network environment, operational ground system,» Virtual network environment, operational ground system,» Over-the-air network environment, operational ground system. 15
16 3. Validation Approach [7/7] 3.4. Analysis Component 3 Verification (continued) Secure ACARS over-the-air flight demonstration» Verification of datalink security operation (nominal & error modes)» Conducted in accordance with a formal test plan» Using operational VHF frequency, DSP, and ground system» Witnessed by USAF representatives Avionics test pallet Demonstration Environment 16
17 4. Validation Analysis and Results [1/3] 4. Validation Analysis and Results This section is organized by Chapter and Section of Part IV-B Validation analysis of provisions within a Chapter/Section is presented in the following tabular format Paragraph number of each specific ATN security provision Reference to corresponding AMS security provision(s) in ARINC 823 and/or ATA Spec 42 Commentary explaining any exceptions Validation analysis in terms of: A Assessment (Yes/No) of the alignment between the ATN and AMS security provisions I Indication (Yes/No) as to whether the provision was implemented in Secure ACARS V Indication as to whether the provision was verified and the verification means: I Inspection S System-level bench test U Unit-level test D Over-the-air flight demonstration 17
18 4. Validation Analysis and Results [2/3] 4. Validation Analysis and Results (continued) Validation results are presented in the following tabular format Applicable validation objective(s) per the validation matrix in Section 2.4. Summary of the validation analysis (i.e., alignment, implementation, and verification) with respect to each applicable validation objective, including identification of any defects uncovered during the analysis. 18
19 4. Validation Analysis and Results [3/3] Example 19
20 5. Conclusions [1/7] 5.1. Summary Results Validation Objectives FVO2, FVO3, FVO4, FVO5 Overall, the validation analysis shows alignment between ATN and AMS provisions for security services, PKI, cryptographic infrastructure, and SSO functions. This provides a high degree of confidence that the Part IV-B provisions are complete (FVO 2), unambiguous (FVO 3), consistent (FVO 4), and necessary (FVO 5). Validation Objective FVO6 Overall, successful adaptation of the aligned ATN provisions to the ACARS communications environment provides a high degree of confidence that the provisions in Part IV-B are implementation independent. Validation Objective FVO7 Overall, inspection of the ARINC 823 (AMS) provisions and the successful implementation and flight demonstration of the aligned AMS provisions provide a high degree of confidence that Part IV-B includes provisions necessary for all security users, including those users that may desire confidentiality services in the future. Validation Objective TVO1 Overall, inspection of the ARINC 823 (AMS) provisions and the successful implementation and flight demonstration of the aligned AMS provisions provide a high degree of confidence that Part IV-B includes provisions necessary for both mobile and fixed communicating entities. 20
21 5. Conclusions [2/7] 5.1. Summary Results (continued) Validation Objective TVO8 Overall, successful implementation and flight demonstration of the aligned AMS provisions provides a high degree of confidence that the Part IV-B provisions for SSO functions are implementable. Defects Identified DEFECT TYPE: FVO3 = Editorial FVO4 = Not consistent FVO5 = No effect if removed 21
22 5. Conclusions [3/7] Defects Identified (continued) DEFECT TYPE: FVO3 = Editorial FVO4 = Not consistent FVO5 = No effect if removed 22
23 5. Conclusions [4/7] 5.2. Recommendations Recommendation 1: Certificate and CRL Profile Specifications Improvement Opportunity AMS and Secure ACARS Experience Detailed certificate and CRL profiles transferred from Doc SV-VIII were developed in the late 1990 s and do not necessarily reflect current industry standards (commercial or aero) AMS certificate/crl requirements, based on ATN/OSI, were coordinated with the ATA Digital Security Working Group (DSWG) ATA Spec 42 specifies certificate policy and certificate/crl profiles suitable for aero applications including AMS and ATN and for interoperability with an aero bridge. Recommendation Replace Sections with wording consistent with ICAO Doc. 9896: X.509 certificate/crl profiles per IETF RFC 5280 Certificate policy and practices framework per IETF RFC 3647 Note indicating that ATA Spec 42 is available for use by the aero community Potential Pros Harmonization with ATA Spec 42 and industry standard practice Harmonization between text in Doc Part IV-B and Doc Significant simplification of text in Doc Part IV-B Potential Cons None identified. 23
24 5. Conclusions [5/7] 5.2. Recommendations (continued) Recommendation 2: Compressed Certificates Improvement Opportunity AMS and Secure ACARS Experience ATN compressed certificates are a non-standard, ATN-unique format. The constraints imposed on uncompressed certificates may be difficult to achieve since they do not reflect industry standard practice for PKI (the subject of Recommendation #1). AMS considered and rejected the non-standard, ATN-unique format. To minimize air-ground security overhead, the AMS protocol includes coordination logic between the aircraft and ground entities such that ground certificates are sent over-the-air only when necessary. Recommendation At a minimum, remove provisions for compressed certificates in Section and of Part IV-B. Consider air-ground coordination logic employed by AMS to minimize air-ground security overhead associated with certificate delivery. Potential Pros Eliminate non-standard, ATN-unique format. Eliminate constraints imposed by compressed certificate format and ensure harmonization with industry standard PKI practices ( minimize life cycle costs). Potential Cons Without air-ground coordination logic (or similar), elimination of compressed certificates may increase air-ground security overhead. However, the implementation of Recommendation #4 offsets the increase in security overhead. 24
25 5. Conclusions [6/7] 5.2. Recommendations (continued) Recommendation 3: Compressed Elliptic Curve Points Improvement Opportunity AMS and Secure ACARS Experience ATN/OSI provisions specify use of compressed elliptic curve points, which offers some bandwidth efficiency, but at the expense of additional computation by the aircraft entity. Implementation of EC point compression my infringe 3 rd party intellectual property, and therefore may not be widely supported by crypto toolkits and certificate suppliers. AMS considered and rejected the non-standard, ATN-unique format due to the impact on the aircraft entity and potential for limiting crypto toolkit and certificate suppliers. Recommendation Re-consider specification of EC point compression. Potential Pros Eliminate impact on aircraft computational requirements (important for legacy). Maximize support by crypto tool-kit and certificate suppliers (i.e., minimize costs). Potential Cons Use of un-compressed EC points does increase slightly the air-ground security overhead. But, this needs to be evaluated against the potential drawbacks associated with using compressed EC points. In addition, the implementation of Recommendation #4 offsets the increase in security overhead. 25
26 5. Conclusions [7/7] 5.2. Recommendations (continued) Recommendation 4: Number of Required Key Pairs Improvement Opportunity AMS and Secure ACARS Experience ATN/OSI provisions specify use of two public/private elliptic curve key pairs: one for key agreement and a separate one for digital signature. This approach increases the numbers and types of security items that an airline must manage, which may increase maintenance actions and life-cycle costs. During development of the AMS standard, airlines including the US Air Force recommended that AMS specify a single key pair that is used for both key agreement and digital signature. Recommendation Revise ATN/OSI provisions to specify a single public/private key pair for key agreement and digital signature. Potential Pros Addresses airline-identified need to minimize the numbers and types of aircraft keys/certificate to be procured and managed. Reduces air-ground security overhead since a single ground entity certificate, rather than two certificates, is delivered to the aircraft entity over the air-ground datalink; this offsets the potential increase in security overhead resulting from implementation of Recommendations 2 and 3 Potential Cons None identified. 26
27 Action by the Meeting The ACP WG-M is invited to: Review the detailed ATN/OSI Security Validation results, and Consider recommended improvements to ICAO Doc Part IV-B Note: The ICAO Doc Part IV-B Security Validation Report contains the complete security validation results and recommended improvements. The validation report is included as Appendix A to working paper ACP WGM16/WP
28 Point of Contact Honeywell Aerospace Advanced Technology Michael Olive Sr. Principal Systems Engineer Tel: + 1 (410) Questions? 28
AERONAUTICAL COMMUNICATION PANEL WORKING GROUP N. PM-CPDLC Validation Report
ACP WGN/5 WP19 AERONAUTICAL COMMUNICATION PANEL WORKING GROUP N PM-CPDLC Validation Report SUMMARY This paper gives the results of the PM-CPDLC ATN Application (version 1) validation effort. Version: 0.1
More informationICAO Air-Ground Security Standards Strategy ICAO ACP WG M #21. Date: July 17 th 18 th Federal Aviation Administration
ICAO Air-Ground Security Standards Strategy Administration ICAO ACP WG M #21 Presenter: Vic Patel, FAA Date: July 17 th 18 th 2014 SENSITIVE SECURITY INFORMATION 0 Administration 0 Agenda Goals and objectives
More informationTERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 214 Standards for Air Traffic Data Communication Services Revision 11
RTCA Paper No. 009-19/PMC-1844 TERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 214 Standards for Air Traffic Data Communication Services Revision 11 REQUESTORS: Organization FAA ATC Communications Services Jim
More informationAviation Cyber Security Efforts
Aviation Cyber Security Efforts Airlines Electronic Engineering Committee (AEEC) Rev version H: May 2018 Paul J. Prisaznuk AEEC Executive Secretary and Program Director This document summarizes the efforts
More informationTERMS OF REFERENCE. Special Committee (SC) 223
REQUESTOR: TERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 223 Internet Protocol Suite (IPS) and Aeronautical Mobile Airport Communication System (AeroMACS) (Version 3) FAA ANG-B Organization Person ANG-B/Michelle
More informationTERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 214 Standards for Air Traffic Data Communication Services Revision 10
TERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 214 Standards for Air Traffic Data Communication Services Revision 10 REQUESTORS: Organization FAA ATC Communications Services Jim Eck Person SC LEADERSHIP: Position
More informationAeronautical Communication Panel. Application Level Security Considerations
ACP SGN4 WP0306 ACP WGN04 WP18 Aeronautical Communication Panel Working Group N Networking Subgroup N4 - November 2004 New Orleans, LA, USA Application Level Considerations Prepared By: Tom McParland,
More informationSecuring Your Data ATA Spec 42. Regan Brossard - The Boeing Company June 2017
Securing Your Data ATA Spec 42 Regan Brossard - The Boeing Company June 2017 Agenda PKI - Use in the Aviation Industry and why is it necessary Guidance for Transitioning to Connected Airplanes Choosing
More informationCLARIFICATION OF DOC 9896 INTERNET PROTOCOL SUITE IPv6. (Presented by USA)
International Civil Aviation Organization ATNICG WG/8-WP/13 28/09/10 AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK IMPLEMENTATION COORDINATION GROUP EIGHTH WORKING GROUP MEETING (ATNICG WG/8) Christchurch New
More informationAMCP/4-WP/70. b) requirements and recommendations together with their rationale; and
Appendix A to the Report on Agenda Item 3 3A-1 APPENDIX A VHF DIGITAL LINK (VDL) DESIGN GUIDELINES 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 In the absence of a comprehensive and detailed set of operational requirements, the
More informationTechnical Developments Roundup. Tony Whyman Helios IS
Technical Developments Roundup Tony Whyman Helios IS Highlights ATN Technical Manual 4 th Edition PM-CPDLC IP SNDCF Consolidate editorial and minor technical revisions TCP/IP Report Start of Voice over
More informationInternational Civil Aviation Organization. AIDC Review Task Force Meeting. Brisbane, Australia, March 2003
AIDC/R TF/IP/3 International Civil Aviation Organization AIDC Review Task Force Meeting Brisbane, Australia, 27-28 March 2003 Agenda Item 2: Agenda Item 4: Review of experience gained and lessons learned
More informationATNP WG2 Utrecht, Netherlands 29 June 1 July IDRP Security. Prepared by Ron Jones. Summary
ATNP WG2/WP 450 8 June 1998 ATNP WG2 Utrecht, Netherlands 29 June 1 July 1998 IDRP Security Prepared by Ron Jones Summary This working paper presents a review of ISO/IEC 10747 and Sub-Volume 5 as regards
More informationSafety Services Using the Internet Protocol Suite
ACSICG/3 IP/6 Agenda Item 7 03/05/16 Engineering, Operations & Technology Boeing Research & Technology Airspace & Operational Efficiency Safety Services Using the Internet Protocol Suite Greg Saccone,
More informationInternational Civil Aviation Organization. COM Co-ordination Meeting. 6 7 March 2013, Kunming, China
CCM-WP/5 Agenda Item 5 06/03/13 International Civil Aviation Organization COM Co-ordination Meeting 6 7 March 2013, Kunming, China Agenda Item 5: Letter of agreement for technical and operational trial
More informationETSI TR V1.1.1 ( )
TR 119 400 V1.1.1 (2016-03) TECHNICAL REPORT Electronic Signatures and Infrastructures (ESI); Guidance on the use of standards for trust service providers supporting digital signatures and related services
More informationDraft ICAO IPv6 Addressing Plan
International Civil Aviation Organization ACP-WG I-07/WP-02 01/06/08 WORKING PAPER AERONAUTICAL COMMUNICATIONS PANEL (ACP) SEVENTH MEETING OF THE WORKING GROUP I (IPS) Montreal, Canada 2 6 June 2008 Agenda
More informationTWELFTH AIR NAVIGATION CONFERENCE
International Civil Aviation Organization 7/5/12 WORKING PAPER ANConf.12.WP.007.en.docx TWELFTH AIR NAVIGATION CONFERENCE Montréal, 19 to 30 November 2012 Agenda Item 3: Interoperability and data through
More informationProposed Modifications to CNS/ATM-1 Applications To Support Package-2 Security Services
ATNP/WG3/WP 15-31 AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK PANEL Working Group 3 (Applications and Upper Layers) Honolulu (U.S.A), 19 22 January 1999 Proposed Modifications to CNS/ATM-1 Applications To
More informationASIA/PACIFIC REGIONAL AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK (ATN) AIR TRAFFIC SERVICE (ATS) MESSAGE HANDLING SYSTEM (AMHS) DESCRIPTION
INTERNATIONAL CIVIL AVIATION ORGANIZATIONA ASIA AND PACIFIC OFFICE ASIA/PACIFIC REGIONAL AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK () AIR TRAFFIC SERVICE (ATS) MESSAGE HANDLING SYSTEM (AMHS) DESCRIPTION First
More informationICAS Workshop 3rd October 2005 Single European Sky Implementation Plan - SESAME
ICAS Workshop 3rd October 2005 Single European Sky Implementation Plan - SESAME Jan Van Doorn EUROCONTROL Experimental Centre, France Director European 1 Organisation for the Safety of Air Navigation Demand
More informationManual on Detailed Technical Specifications for the Aeronautical Telecommunication Network (ATN) using ISO/OSI Standards and Protocols
Doc 9880 AN/466 Manual on Detailed Technical Specifications for the Aeronautical Telecommunication Network (ATN) using ISO/OSI Standards and Protocols Part IV Directory Services, Security and Systems ManagementIdentifier
More informationICAO S COOPERATIVE NETWORK OF TRAINING CENTRES
ICAO S COOPERATIVE NETWORK OF TRAINING CENTRES MEMBERSHIP PROGRAMME Associate Full RTCE Corporate 1 Programme ICAO s cooperative network of training centres ICAO s TRAINAIR PLUS Programme promotes training
More informationValidation Tool Descriptions for ATN Applications
ATNP/WG3/IP EUROCONTROL 12 April 1996 AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK PANEL WORKING GROUP 3 (APPLICATIONS AND UPPER LAYERS) Brussels, 15-26 April, 1996 Validation Tool Descriptions for ATN Applications
More informationThe outline of the CONOPS
The outline of the CONOPS CS#9 - Data Communication Services (DCS) Philippe Renaud CS9 Project Manager 25 Oct 2013 CS9 Context A/G datalink mandated by EC No 29/2009 More ANSPs to be connected More ATN/VDL
More informationBoeing Communications Strategy
Boeing Communications Strategy Presentation to ATN2004 Rob Mead Date: September 15, 2004 Phone: 253-951-8447 Email: rob.mead@boeing.com Topics Data link in Boeing ATM concepts Boeing communications strategy
More informationSpace for safe skies. ESA Iris Program. Satellite Communications for Air Traffic Management (ATM)
Space for safe skies ESA Iris Program Satellite Communications for Air Traffic Management (ATM) 23rd Ka-Band Broadband and 35th AIAA ICSSC Conference 18/10/2017 Slide 1 Satellite Communications for the
More informationATSMHS SARPs Validation Report
ATNP/WG3 WP/9-4a 05/03/97 ATSMHS SARPs Validation Report Presented by Jean-Yves Piram (SG1 Chairman) Prepared by Jean-Marc Vacher Version 2.0a Appendix G: ATSMHS SARPs Validation report Appendix G: ATSMHS
More informationValidating ATN with VDL
ATNP WG-2 WP 346 bis AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK PANEL (ATNP) Validating ATN with VDL Prepared by Nicholas Xenocostas and David Leahy Presented by H. Thulin SUMMARY This Working paper presents
More informationAeroMACS Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) Users Overview
AeroMACS Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) Users Overview WiMAX Forum Proprietary Copyright 2019 WiMAX Forum. All Rights Reserved. WiMAX, Mobile WiMAX, Fixed WiMAX, WiMAX Forum, WiMAX Certified, WiMAX Forum
More informationReview of the ATN CAR/SAM Planning/Implementation Activities. (Presented by the Coordinator) SUMMARY
WP/2 5/05/10 International Civil Aviation Organization CAR/SAM Regional Planning Implementation Group (GREPECAS) CNS/ATM Subgroup Coordination meeting of the ATN ground-ground and ground-air applications
More information5/4/2016 ht.ttlms.com
Order Template Screen 1 Free Form Lesson Overview 2 Free Form Performance Based CNS Requirements 3 Free Form Performance Based CNS Requirements 4 Single Answer Knowledge Check 5 Free Form Related ICAO
More informationAMHS Implementation Issues. Julio C. Siu Regional Officer/ Communication, Navigation and Surveillance
AMHS Implementation Issues Julio C. Siu Regional Officer/ Communication, Navigation and Surveillance III Workshop/Meeting on the Follow up to the Implementation of the ATS Message Handling System (AMHS)
More informationTel.: +1 (514) ext Ref.: AN 7/ /39 22 June 2007
International Civil Aviation Organization Organisation de l aviation civile internationale Organización de Aviación Civil Internacional Ìåæäóíàðîäíàÿ îðãàíèçàöèÿ ãðàæäàíñêîé àâèàöèè Tel.: +1 (514) 954-8219
More informationRoadmap for Implementation of New Specifications for MRTDs
for MRTDs For Publication on the ICAO Website Roadmap for Implementation of New Specifications for MRTDs DISCLAIMER: All reasonable precautions have been taken by the International Civil Aviation Organization
More informationNEWSKY Project. SAI Subcommittee Meeting, August 2008, Vienna
NEWSKY Project Mobile aeronautical communication network Based on Internet technologies For cockpit and cabin services Integrating satellite and terrestrial data links SAI Subcommittee Meeting, August
More informationASIA/PACIFIC REGIONAL AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK (ATN) GROUND-GROUND ROUTER DESCRIPTION
INTENATIONAL CIVIL AVIATION OGANIZATION ASIA AND PACIFIC OFFICE ASIA/PACIFIC EGIONAL AEONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWOK (ATN) GOUND-GOUND OUTE DESCIPTION Edition 1.2 May 2004 ISSUE 1.2- MAY 2004 Table
More informationS1000D - An Overview. Background, Benefits, and Overview of S1000D Data Module Structures
S1000D - An Overview Background, Benefits, and Overview of S1000D Data Module Structures What is S1000D? S1000D is an international specification for technical publications, utilizing a Common Source Database.
More informationMANUAL ON DETAILED TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR THE AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK (ATN) using ISO/OSI standards and protocols
Doc 9880-AN/466 PART IIA MANUAL ON DETAILED TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR THE AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK (ATN) using ISO/OSI standards and protocols PART IIA GROUND-GROUND APPLICATIONS ATS INTERFACILITY
More informationData-link Services (DLS) implementation 2017 CEF Transport Calls for proposals
Data-link Services (DLS) implementation 2017 CEF Transport Calls for proposals Brussels, 17 th November 2017 EC Workshop on DLS Agenda Overview SDM activities for Path I and Path II Path I - implementation
More informationEU Passport Specification
Biometrics Deployment of EU-Passports EU Passport Specification (EN) 28/06/2006 (As the United Kingdom and Ireland have not taken part in the adoption of this measure, an authentic English version of the
More informationAir Navigation Service Providers
Air Navigation Service Providers ATN and FANS Data Link Solutions www.airtel-atn.com European Commission Data Link Mandate The implementation of Data Link is key to increasing Air Traffic Control efficiency,
More informationFunctional areas of the communications domain. List of example constituents and standards for the air-ground applications functional area
Air-ground communication applications Air-ground communication networks Air-ground datalink communication Air-ground voice communications Ground-ground communication applications Ground-ground communication
More informationATNP Configuration Control Board (CCB) Configuration Management (CM) Procedures
AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK PANEL Working Group 2 ATNP Configuration Control Board (CCB) Presented by CCB Chair SUMMARY This paper contains detailed procedures for the configuration management
More informationARINC Project Initiation/Modification (APIM)
Project Initiation/Modification proposal for the AEEC Date Proposed: August 31, 2017 ARINC Project Initiation/Modification (APIM) 1.0 Name of Proposed Project APIM 17-015 ARINC Specification 8xx: Aircraft
More informationAERONAUTICAL FIXED SERVICES GROUP (AFSG) of the European Air Navigation Planning Group (EANPG)
AFSG/16 WP/16 04/04/2012 AERONAUTICAL FIXED SERVICES GROUP (AFSG) of the European Air Navigation Planning Group (EANPG) SIXTEENTH MEETING (Paris, 23-27 April 2012) Agenda Item 4: AMHS Technical/Documentation
More informationEUR AMHS Manual, Appendix G
EUR AMHS Manual EUR Doc 020 EUR AMHS Manual Appendix G European Directory Service Document Reference: Author: EUR AMHS Manual, Appendix G EUROCONTROL, Revision Number: Version 12.0 Date: 28/04/17 Filename:
More informationLINK Programme. Generic Interop Test Plan for Avionics - Part 1 Upper Layers and CM/CPDLC applications. Cooperative Network Design
Edition 2.3 Author: LINK Test Facility Edition date: 15.06.2010 Reference nr: LINK2000+/LIT/Avionics Test Plan LINK 2000+ Programme Generic Interop Test Plan for Avionics - Part 1 Upper Layers and CM/CPDLC
More informationEUROCAE ED-122 / RTCA DO-306 Oceanic SPR Standard
Oceanic SPR Standard ICAO NAT PBCS Workshop, Feb 2013 Presented by Jerome CONDIS RTCA SC-214 / EUROCAE WG-78 Co-chair 1 History SC189 / WG53 1 2 3 4 ED100 / DO 258 : Interoperability Requirements for ATS
More informationATNP Configuration Control Board (CCB) Procedures Document
-WP/66 15 March 1996 AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK PANEL CCB Standing Document ATNP Configuration Control Board (CCB) Edited by CCB Chair SUMMARY This document contains detailed procedures to
More informationEurocontrol ATN Trials End System - Status Update
ATNP/WG3/WP 15-18 17 January 1999 EUROCONTROL AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK PANEL WORKING GROUP 3 (APPLICATIONS AND UPPER LAYERS) Honolulu, USA, 19-22 January 1999 (Information paper) Eurocontrol
More informationREGULATORY APPROACH FOR
EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR THE SAFETY OF AIR NAVIGATION EUROCONTROL SINGLE EUROPEAN SKY (SES) REGULATIONS REGULATORY APPROACH FOR DATA LINK SERVICES May 2006 Edition 1.1 DOCUMENT CONTROL DOCUMENT CHANGE
More informationMEVA III NETWORK IMPLEMENTATION. (Presented by Secretariat) SUMMARY
GREPECAS/17 - WP/24 International Civil Aviation Organization 19/06/14 CAR/SAM Regional Planning and Implementation Group (GREPECAS) Seventeenth Meeting of the CAR/SAM Regional Planning and Implementation
More informationInformation technology Security techniques Telebiometric authentication framework using biometric hardware security module
INTERNATIONAL STANDARD ISO/IEC 17922 First edition 2017-09 Information technology Security techniques Telebiometric authentication framework using biometric hardware security module Technologies de l information
More informationU. S. Department of Transportation. Federal Aviation Administration. Interface Requirements Document
U. S. Department of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration Interface Requirements Document NAS-IC-XXXXXXXX DRAFT February 29, 2012 Communications Service Provider (CSP) To Tower Data Link Service
More informationISO/IEC INTERNATIONAL STANDARD
INTERNATIONAL STANDARD ISO/IEC 9594-8 Sixth edition 2008-12-15 Information technology Open Systems Interconnection The Directory: Publickey and attribute certificate frameworks Technologies de l'information
More informationCommon Understanding 10/2014 Implementation of Article 6(5) of the Commission Regulation (EU) 73/2010
Common Understanding 10/2014 Implementation of Article 6(5) of the Commission Regulation (EU) 73/2010 Edition: 1.2 Date: 20 October 2016 Reference: ARWG CU 10/2014 1/6 1. INTRODUCTION This document describes
More informationPresentation of Iris. ART-Workshop 'CNS and Infrastructure 13 th March 2018
Presentation of Iris ART-Workshop 'CNS and Infrastructure 13 th March 2018 1. Inmarsat Eco system 2. Aviation 3. SwiftBroadband - Safety (SB-S) 4. Iris 2 1. Inmarsat Eco system 2. Aviation 3. SwiftBroadband
More informationSmart Meters Programme Schedule 2.1
Smart Meters Programme Schedule 2.1 (DCC Requirements) (SMKI version) V1.2 1 Schedule 2.1 (DCC Requirements) This Schedule 2.1 (DCC Requirements) is formed of the following parts: Part A Introduction...3
More informationIMPLEMENTATION ISSUES, CHALLENGES, LESSONS LEARNED FOR DATA LINK MONITORING
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES, CHALLENGES, LESSONS LEARNED FOR DATA LINK MONITORING OPERATIONAL DATA LINK WORKSHOP 8-12 August Accra Josiah BACKOBI Regional Manager Safety & Flight Operations Operational Data
More informationTERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 222 AMS(R)S Systems Revision 10
13, 2018 REQUESTORS: TERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 222 AMS(R)S Systems Revision 10 Inmarsat Iridium Organization Person Alan Schuster-Bruce Alan_schuster-bruce@inmarsat.com Michael W. Hooper
More informationINTERNATIONAL CIVIL AVIATION ORGANIZATION ASIA and PACIFIC OFFICE ASIA/PAC RECOMMENDED SECURITY CHECKLIST
INTERNATIONAL CIVIL AVIATION ORGANIZATION ASIA and PACIFIC OFFICE Aeronautical Telecommunication Network Implementation Coordination Group (ATNICG) ASIA/PAC RECOMMENDED SECURITY CHECKLIST September 2009
More informationTERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 222 AMS(R)S Systems Revision 9
REQUESTORS: TERMS OF REFERENCE Special Committee (SC) 222 AMS(R)S Systems Revision 9 Inmarsat Iridium Organization SC LEADERSHIP: Position Name Affiliatio n Chairmen RTCA SC-222 EUROCAE WG- 82 Government
More informationIT Security Evaluation and Certification Scheme Document
IT Security Evaluation and Certification Scheme Document June 2015 CCS-01 Information-technology Promotion Agency, Japan (IPA) IT Security Evaluation and Certification Scheme (CCS-01) i / ii Table of Contents
More informationThe Many Faces of Air-Ground Data Link
The Many Faces of Air-Ground Data Link It is widely recognized that data link or digital communication for air-ground communications is the cornerstone of the 21 st century aviation system. What is less
More informationAvionics / Avionics Test Specialists
Innovative High Tech Solutions for Leading Edge Aerospace Companies www.icsaero.com Avionics / Avionics Test Specialists Design, Manufacture, and Production of Avionics and Avionics Test & Simulation Instruments
More informationCIVIL AVIATION REQUIREMENT SECTION 2 - AIRWORTHINESS SERIES E PART XII EFFECTIVE : FORTHWITH
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF CIVIL AVIATION TECHNICAL CENTRE, OPP SAFDURJUNG AIRPORT, New Delhi CIVIL AVIATION REQUIREMENT SECTION 2 - AIRWORTHINESS SERIES E PART XII, 2017 EFFECTIVE
More informationDatabase Integrity Policy for Aeronautical Data
Database Integrity Policy for Aeronautical Data Presented to: By: Date: 2008 Software and Airborne Electronic Hardware Standardization Conference Denver, Colorado Brad Miller, AIR-130 Background Prior
More informationFrequently Asked Questions
December 2001 Introduction International Standard ISO/IEC 17799:2000 Information Security Management, Code of Practice for Information Security Management Frequently Asked Questions The National Institute
More informationEUR AMHS Manual, Appendix E
EUR AMHS Manual EUR Doc 020 EUR AMHS Manual Appendix E AMHS Interoperability s Document Reference: Author: EUR AMHS Manual, Appendix E Revision Number: Version 6.0c Date: 28/04/11 Filename: EUR_AMHS_Manual-Appx_E-v6_0c.doc
More informationRID IETF Draft Update
RID IETF Draft Update Kathleen M. Moriarty INCH Working Group 5 August 2004 This work was sponsored by the Air Force under Air Force Contract Number F19628-00-C-0002. "Opinions, interpretations, conclusions,
More informationInternet Engineering Task Force (IETF) Request for Comments: 6403 Category: Informational ISSN: M. Peck November 2011
Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) Request for Comments: 6403 Category: Informational ISSN: 2070-1721 L. Zieglar NSA S. Turner IECA M. Peck November 2011 Suite B Profile of Certificate Management over
More informationAsia/Pacific Regional AMHS MTA Routing Policy
International Civil Aviation Organization Asia and Pacific Office Asia/Pacific Regional AMHS Routing Policy First Edition SEPTEMBER 2008 ASIA/PAC AMHS Routing Policy Table of Contents 1.0 INTRODUCTION...3
More informationETSI TS V7.1.0 ( )
TS 102 266 V7.1.0 (2006-01) Technical Specification Smart Cards; USSM: UICC Security Service Module; Stage 1 2 TS 102 266 V7.1.0 (2006-01) Reference RTS/SCP-R0002r1 Keywords smart card, security 650 Route
More informationETSI ESI Electronic Signature Activities
ETSI ESI Electronic Signature Activities Cornerstone for interoperability of Digital Documents in Europe Riccardo Genghini TB ESI Chairperson ETSI 2008. All rights reserved 4th ETSI Security Workshop ETSI
More informationThe ATN Routing Concept
ATNP/WP/ ATNP/WG2-WP/ 10 October 1994 AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK PANEL Working Group Two San Diego 17.10.94-28.10.94 The ATN Routing Concept Presented By Eike Meyenberg and Henk Hof Prepared
More informationIEEE Conformity Assessment Program (ICAP) June12, 2013
IEEE Conformity Assessment Program (ICAP) June12, 2013 Understanding Conformity Assessment Understanding Conformity Assessment What is Conformity Assessment? Conformity Assessment is defined as the process
More informationARINC Project Initiation/Modification (APIM)
Project Initiation/Modification proposal for the AEEC Proposed: October 11, 2016 ARINC Project Initiation/Modification (APIM) 1.0 Name of Proposed Project APIM 17-001 Internet Protocol version 6 (IPv6)
More informationLDS2 Concept and Overview: Exploring Possibilities in Travel Border Clearance
LDS2 Concept and Overview: Exploring Possibilities in Travel Border Clearance Overview Current generation of epassports Benefits and Limits of an epassport Overview of the next generation epassport Applications
More informationAdvisory Circular (AC)
Advisory Circular (AC) Certification Plans File No. 5009-6-500 AC No. 500-015 RDIMS No. 528332-V4 Issue No. 01 Issuing Branch Aircraft Certification Effective Date 2004-12-01 1.0 INTRODUCTION... 2 1.1
More informationFinal Project Report. Abstract. Document information
Final Project Report Document information Project Title SWIM security solutions Project Number 14.02.02 Project Manager THALES Deliverable Name Final Project Report Deliverable ID D01 Edition 00.01.00
More informationEuropean Sky ATM Research (SESAR) [5][6] in Europe both consider the implementation of SWIM as a fundamental element for future ATM systems.
(FIXM) and the weather information exchange model 1. INTRODUCTION With the rapid increase in local and global air traffic, the system-wide operational information exchange and life-cycle management technologies
More informationRequirements for Design Make/Design Only Suppliers RRES 90009
Notice to Suppliers Requirements for Design Make/Design Only Suppliers RRES 90009 Originator: Laura Hill Job Title: Chief of Engineering Quality Operations Business Unit: Central Engineering Quality NTS
More informationOpen Geospatial Consortium
Open Geospatial Consortium Date: 28-March-2011 Reference number of this document: 10-195 Editors: OGC Aviation Domain Working Group Requirements for Aviation Metadata Copyright 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium.
More informationGlobal Reference Architecture: Overview of National Standards. Michael Jacobson, SEARCH Diane Graski, NCSC Oct. 3, 2013 Arizona ewarrants
Global Reference Architecture: Overview of National Standards Michael Jacobson, SEARCH Diane Graski, NCSC Oct. 3, 2013 Arizona ewarrants Goals for this Presentation Define the Global Reference Architecture
More informationISO/IEC INTERNATIONAL STANDARD
INTERNATIONAL STANDARD ISO/IEC 9594-8 Fifth edition 2005-12-15 Information technology Open Systems Interconnection The Directory: Publickey and attribute certificate frameworks Technologies de l'information
More informationTC32 presentation to ECMA General Assembly, Edinburgh, 22nd June 2000
TC32 presentation to ECMA General Assembly, Edinburgh, 22nd June 2000 John Elwell, Chairman ECMA TC32 Siemens Communications (International) Limited john.elwell@siemenscomms.co.uk ECMA/TC32/2000/103 ECMA/GA/2000/69
More informationACCREDITATION: A BRIEFING FOR GOVERNMENTS AND REGULATORS
ACCREDITATION: A BRIEFING FOR GOVERNMENTS AND REGULATORS Accreditation is continuously gaining recognition as an important technical tool in the delivery of objectives across an increasing range of policy
More informationINFORMATION NOTE. United Nations/Germany International Conference
INFORMATION NOTE United Nations/Germany International Conference Earth Observation: Global solutions for the challenges of sustainable development in societies at risk Organized by The United Nations Office
More informationFurther Guidance Material on the Scaleability of the ATN Routing Architecture
WP429 AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS NETWORK PANEL ATN Internet Working Group (WG2) 13th Meeting 27th - 30th October 1997 Redondo Beach, USA Further Guidance Material on the Scaleability of the ATN Routing
More informationINTERNATIONAL STANDARD
INTERNATIONAL STANDARD This is a preview - click here to buy the full publication ISO/IEC 9594-8 Eighth edition 2017-05 Information technology Open Systems Interconnection The Directory Part 8: frameworks
More informationDraft ETSI EN V ( )
Draft EN 319 412-2 V2.0.15 (2015-06) EUROPEAN STANDARD Electronic Signatures and Infrastructures (ESI); Certificate Profiles; Part 2: Certificate profile for certificates issued to natural persons 2 Draft
More informationJARUS RECOMMENDATIONS ON THE USE OF CONTROLLER PILOT DATA LINK COMMUNICATIONS (CPDLC) IN THE RPAS COMMUNICATIONS CONTEXT
Joint Authorities for Rulemaking of Unmanned Systems JARUS RECOMMENDATIONS ON THE USE OF CONTROLLER PILOT DATA LINK COMMUNICATIONS (CPDLC) IN THE RPAS COMMUNICATIONS CONTEXT DOCUMENT IDENTIFIER : JAR_DEL_WG5_D.04
More informationREPORT ON AGENDA ITEM 4
15/2/00 AERONAUTICAL TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORK PANEL (ATNP) THIRD MEETING Montreal, 7 to 18 February 2000 Agenda Item 4: Review of existing technical and procedural provisions relating to the aeronautical
More informationInternational Civil Aviation Organization
CNS/MET SG/14-WP/55 International Civil Aviation Organization FOURTEENTH MEETING OF THE COMMUNICATIONS/NAVIGATION/SURVEILL ANCE AND METEOROLOGY SUB-GROUP OF APANPIRG (CNS/MET SG/14) Jakarta, Indonesia,
More informationCABIN MAINTENANCE. PANEL DISCUSSION WITH Michael Sattler, SR Technics Alex Laybros, Honeywell Ron van Baaren, CEO, ADSE.
CABIN MAINTENANCE PANEL DISCUSSION WITH Michael Sattler, SR Technics Alex Laybros, Honeywell Ron van Baaren, CEO, ADSE Introduction Impressive technology upgrades and higher quality of cabin interiors
More informationISO/IEC INTERNATIONAL STANDARD
INTERNATIONAL STANDARD ISO/IEC 15945 First edition 2002-02-01 Information technology Security techniques Specification of TTP services to support the application of digital signatures Technologies de l'information
More informationIntroduction of the Seventh Edition of Doc 9303
Introduction of the Seventh Edition of Doc 9303 Sjef Broekhaar Advisor ICAO TRIP IRAN SEMINAR Kish Island 17/05/2016 Footer 1 July 2015: ICAO publishes the 7th edition of Doc 9303 Part 1 Part 2 Part 3
More informationINTERNATIONAL CIVIL AVIATION ORGANIZATION ASIA AND PACIFIC OFFICE
INTERNATIONAL CIVIL AVIATION ORGANIZATION ASIA AND PACIFIC OFFICE GUIDANCE MATERIAL FOR END-TO-END SAFETY AND PERFORMANCE MONITORING OF AIR TRAFFIC SERVICE (ATS) DATA LINK SYSTEMS IN THE ASIA/PACIFIC REGION
More informationPublic Key Infrastructure
Public Key Infrastructure Ed Crowley Summer 11 1 Topics Public Key Infrastructure Defined PKI Overview PKI Architecture Trust Models Components X.509 Certificates X.500 LDAP 2 Public Key Infrastructure
More information