GPP-C00-00007-00R Page Title: APPROVED SUMMARY OF GPP TSG-C MEETING for 8 December 00 conference call. 7 8 9 0 7 8 9 0 7 Source: Clifton J. Barber SECRETARY Tantivy Communications 0 S. Babcock Street Melbourne, FL 90 www.tantivy.com (0) 08-977 Fax () 9-99 cbarber@tantivy.com Abstract: This document is a summary of the GPP TSG-C meetings that was held by conference call on 8 December 00. Recommendation: Review and adopt. Notice: 00 GPP The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to GPP and its partner organizations to incorporate text contained in this contribution and any modifications thereof in the creation of a GPP standards publication; to copyright in the name of GPP or its partner organizations any standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution; and, at GPP's sole discretion, to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting GPP standards publication. 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page 7 8 9 0 7 8 9 0 7 8 On 8 December 00, a meeting of GPP TSG-C was held by conference call. This document is intended to summarize those proceedings. The call in info for this meeting is summarized below: Date: 8 December 00 Time: :00 PM EST Telephone: 0-7- Access #: 8. CALL TO ORDER AND OPENING REMARKS: The meeting was called to order at :0 PM US east coast time on 8 December 00 by TSG-C Chair, Jean Alphonse (Lucent). The Chair noted the primary purpose of this meeting as consideration of the Sync Channel AdHoc Report.. ATTENDANCE REGISTRATION AND ROLL CALL: A roll call of companies indicated that companies included on the list of active members were present and thus quorum was established (% participation). In addition, the following four () proxies were noted for this meeting: COMPANY ETRI HYUNDAI PRAIRIECOMM SEROME TECHNOLOGY PROXY ASSIGNEE SAMSUNG LGE SAMSUNG SAMSUNG. INTRODUCTION AND NUMBERING OF CONTRIBUTIONS: Contributions were loaded onto the GPP network server and listed in the document register (C00-008- 000).. AGENDA APPROVAL: The proposed agenda (C00-008-00R) was presented. DECISION: This agenda was approved without objection as submitted.. ASSIGNMENTS OF CONTRIBUTIONS TO AGENDA ITEMS: Contributions were assigned to agenda items on the agenda.. LIAISON REPORTS: C.S00 Recommended Minimum Performance Standards for cdma000 High Rate Packet Data Access Networks (C00-000-08) was presented by WG. DECISION: This contribution was approved without objection for publication. C.S00 Recommended Minimum Performance Standards for cdma000 High Rate Packet Data Access Terminals (C00-000-09) was presented by WG. DECISION: This contribution was approved without objection for publication. 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page 7 8 9 0 7 8 9 0 7 8 9 0 7 8 The Sync Channel AdHoc Report (C00-008-00) was presented by the Sync Channel AdHoc Chair, Rick Ross (Sprint PCS). This report indicated that testing had confirmed that there were indeed problems with running Release 0 mobiles on the new software with the Sync Channel fix. However, Motorola recommended solutions that would mitigate those problems but there was insufficient time to test those recommendations. The AdHoc also reported that LGE and Samsung indicated that no test criteria was acceptable to them so that no consensus had been reached on the resolution of the Sync Channel issue. The Sync Channel AdHoc report noted that the Sync Channel fix is optional to all carriers for both cdma000 Revision A and Revision B. Therefore, this fix should not be deployed in Korea if known problems exist. The Korean carriers indicated that they would consider the Sync Channel fix to be mandatory if it is included in the next releases of cdma000. Based on the results of the Sync Channel AdHoc report, the Chair recommended that both cdma000 Revision A and Revision B be released without the Sync Channel fix. This recommendation was supported by LGE. However, this recommendation was not acceptable to Sprint PCS and Alltel. LGE made a motion that TSG-C immediately release cdma000 Revision A and Revision B without any changes for resolution of the Sync Channel issue. The motion was seconded by LG Telecom. Based on a request by Lucent, quorum was reconfirmed and the Secretary noted that votes (including proxies) were available to be cast. The results of the vote were as summarized below: YES 9 NO ABSTAIN 8 The vote was valid (the number of votes for and against exceeded 0% of the votes available to be cast) but the motion did not achieve the necessary 7% level. Therefore, the motion failed. VOTE-08-0 The Chair then declared a deadlock on this issue and closed on discussion on this subject until the Vancouver meeting. However, he subsequently allowed the discussion to continue. Lucent made the motion that TSG-C immediately release cdma000 Revision A and Revision B with the Sync Channel fix included. The motion was seconded by Sprint PCS. Based on the opposition by LGE, LG Telecom, and Samsung, a roll call vote was held. The results of the vote were as summarized below: YES 8 NO 9 ABSTAIN 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page 7 8 9 0 The vote was valid (the number of votes for and against exceeded 0% of the votes available to be cast) but the motion did not achieve the necessary 7% level. Therefore, the motion failed. VOTE-08-0 The Chair again deferred all discussions until the January 00 meeting in Vancouver, BC. 7. NEW BUSINESS: A series of e-mail correspondences related to a TIA disapproval of C.S000 v.0 and C.S000 v.0 during the -day SC review period based on a procedural issue related to the SMV Algorithm Description copyright (C00-008-00) was presented as FYI. 8. ASSIGNMENTS: There were no outstanding assignments from this meeting. 9. ADJOURNMENT: The Plenary was adjourned on 8 December 00 at : PM US east coast time.. 7- January 00-8 February 00 - March 00 Fairmont Hotel Vancouver in Vancouver, BC Four Seasons Hotel Seattle in Seattle, WA Portopia Hotel in Kobe, Japan 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page A listing of the contributions that were distributed is itemized below: NUMBER GPP-C00-008- 000 00 00 00 DOCUMENT REGISTER AGENDA E-mail correspondences regarding TIA NO vote on publication of C.S000 v.0 and C.S000 v.0 SMV Algorithm Description Sync Channel AdHoc Report SUBJECT SOURCE SECRETARY CHAIR GPP/TIA SYNC CHANNEL ADHOC 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page STATUS OF SPECIFICATIONS AND REPORTS BEING DEVELOPED BY TSG-C REFERENCE GPP TIA TITLE STATUS C.S000-A v.0 cdma000 Introduction Release A Addendum Resolution of SDO C.S000-A v.0 cdma000 Physical Layer Release A Addendum Resolution of SDO C.S000-A v.0 cdma000 MAC Release A Addendum Resolution of SDO C.S000-A v.0 cdma000 LAC Release A Addendum Resolution of SDO C.S000-A v.0 cdma000 Layer Signaling Release A Addendum Resolution of SDO C.S000-A v.0 cdma000 Analog Release A Addendum Resolution of SDO C.P000-B cdma000 Introduction Release B C.P000-B cdma000 Physical Layer Release B C.P000-B cdma000 MAC Release B C.P000-B cdma000 LAC Release B C.P000-B cdma000 Layer Signaling Release B C.P000-B cdma000 Analog Release B C.P9007 Video Streaming Service C.P9008 Video Conferencing Service In development C.P90 Test Application Specification for xev-do C.P90 Video Conference - circuit based C.P907 PDE Simulator Messages Specification Canceled C.S00-A IS-7-B SMS SDO review and comment. C.S00-0 v.0 IS-80- Position Determination Services Addendum v Published. C.S00-0 v.0 IS-80- R-UIM Published C.S00-0 v.0 xev-do v.0 Published. C.S008 TTY Minimum Performance Specification. Published. C.S009 Test Application Specification for xev-do v.0 SDO ballot resolution. C.S000 IS-89 SMV (Selectable Mode Vocoder) Algorithm Description SDO ballot resolution. C.S00 IS-898 Signaling Conformance Test v.0 Published. C.S00 Access Network Minimum Performance for xev-do Published. C.S00 Access Terminal Minimum Performance for xev-do Published. C.S00-0 v0. SMV Minimum Performance Specification SDO review and comment. 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page 7 GPP QUORUM ROLL CALL TSG-C (CDMA000) December 8, 00 COMPANY Attendance Consecutive Quorum Status /8/00 Mtgs Missed at Mtg Start ADVANTEST 0 AGILENT TECHNOLOGIES 0 0 AIRVANA 0 ALLTEL 0 ARRAYCOMM 0 BELL MOBILITY 0 CAMBIA NETWORKS 0 COMMWORKS 0 COMVERSE 0 DENSO 0 DOCOMO US LABORATORIES 0 ERICSSON 0 ETRI P FRANCE TELECOM 0 FUJITSU 0 GEMPLUS 0 HITACHI 0 HYUNDAI P 0 KDDI 0 KT FREETEL 0 KYOCERA 0 LEAP WIRELESS LG ELECTRONICS 0 LG TELECOM 0 LINKAIR 0 LSI LOGIC 0 LUCENT 0 MATSUSHITA/PANASONIC 0 MOTOROLA 0 NEC 0 NEXTEL NOKIA 0 NORTEL NETWORKS 0 PHILIPS 0 PRAIRIECOMM P 0 QUALCOMM 0 QUICKSILVER 0 QWEST WIRELESS 0 SAMSUNG 0 SCHLUMBERGERSEMA 0 SEROME TECHNOLOGY P SIEMENS 0 SIERRA WIRELESS 0 SIRF TECHNOLOGY 0 SK TELECOM 0 SORRENTO TELECOM 0 SPIRENT COMMUNICATIONS 0 SPRINT PCS 0 TANTIVY COMMUNICATIONS 0 TEXAS INSTRUMENTS 0 TOSHIBA 0 VERIZON WIRELESS 0 ZTE 0 TOTALS QUORUM CALCULATION % ADDITIONS OBSERVERS AND GUESTS QUORUM STATUS NOTES: - HIGHLIGHTED ZERO = Must attend consecutive mtgs to be added to quorum list - NON-HIGHLIGHTED ZERO = Will be added to quorum list if they attend the next mtg 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page 8 VOTE-08-0 "TSG-C immediately release cdma000 Revision A and Revision B without any changes for resolution of the Sync Channel issue." TSG-C (CDMA000) December 8, 00 COMPANY Attendance Quorum VOTE Consecutive Quorum Status /8/00 Validation #08- Mtgs Missed at Mtg Start ADVANTEST 0 AGILENT TECHNOLOGIES 0 0 AIRVANA 0 ALLTEL N 0 ARRAYCOMM 0 BELL MOBILITY N 0 CAMBIA NETWORKS N 0 COMMWORKS 0 COMVERSE 0 DENSO A 0 DOCOMO US LABORATORIES 0 ERICSSON N 0 ETRI P P Y FRANCE TELECOM 0 FUJITSU 0 GEMPLUS 0 HITACHI 0 HYUNDAI P P Y 0 KDDI A 0 KT FREETEL Y 0 KYOCERA N 0 LEAP WIRELESS A LG ELECTRONICS Y 0 LG TELECOM Y 0 LINKAIR A 0 LSI LOGIC 0 LUCENT N 0 MATSUSHITA/PANASONIC A 0 MOTOROLA N 0 NEC A 0 NEXTEL N NOKIA N 0 NORTEL NETWORKS N 0 PHILIPS 0 PRAIRIECOMM P P Y 0 QUALCOMM A 0 QUICKSILVER 0 QWEST WIRELESS 0 SAMSUNG Y 0 SCHLUMBERGERSEMA 0 SEROME TECHNOLOGY P P Y SIEMENS 0 SIERRA WIRELESS 0 SIRF TECHNOLOGY N 0 SK TELECOM Y 0 SORRENTO TELECOM 0 SPIRENT COMMUNICATIONS 0 SPRINT PCS N 0 TANTIVY COMMUNICATIONS A 0 TEXAS INSTRUMENTS N 0 TOSHIBA N 0 VERIZON WIRELESS N 0 ZTE 0 TOTALS 8 QUORUM CALCULATION % % ADDITIONS OBSERVERS AND GUESTS QUORUM STATUS NOTES: - HIGHLIGHTED ZERO = Must attend consecutive mtgs to be added to quorum list - NON-HIGHLIGHTED ZERO = Will be added to quorum list if they attend the next mtg 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08
GPP-C00-00007-00R Page 9 VOTE-08-0 "TSG-C immediately release cdma000 Revision A and Revision B with the Sync Channel fix included." GPP QUORUM ROLL CALL TSG-C (CDMA000) December 8, 00 COMPANY Attendance Quorum VOTE Consecutive Quorum Status /8/00 Validation #08- Mtgs Missed at Mtg Start ADVANTEST 0 AGILENT TECHNOLOGIES 0 0 AIRVANA 0 ALLTEL Y 0 ARRAYCOMM 0 BELL MOBILITY Y 0 CAMBIA NETWORKS Y 0 COMMWORKS 0 COMVERSE 0 DENSO Y 0 DOCOMO US LABORATORIES 0 ERICSSON Y 0 ETRI P P N FRANCE TELECOM 0 FUJITSU 0 GEMPLUS 0 HITACHI 0 HYUNDAI P P N 0 KDDI A 0 KT FREETEL N 0 KYOCERA Y 0 LEAP WIRELESS Y LG ELECTRONICS N 0 LG TELECOM N 0 LINKAIR A 0 LSI LOGIC 0 LUCENT Y 0 MATSUSHITA/PANASONIC A 0 MOTOROLA Y 0 NEC A 0 NEXTEL Y NOKIA Y 0 NORTEL NETWORKS Y 0 PHILIPS 0 PRAIRIECOMM P P N 0 QUALCOMM Y 0 QUICKSILVER 0 QWEST WIRELESS 0 SAMSUNG N 0 SCHLUMBERGERSEMA 0 SEROME TECHNOLOGY P P N SIEMENS 0 SIERRA WIRELESS 0 SIRF TECHNOLOGY Y 0 SK TELECOM N 0 SORRENTO TELECOM 0 SPIRENT COMMUNICATIONS 0 SPRINT PCS Y 0 TANTIVY COMMUNICATIONS A 0 TEXAS INSTRUMENTS Y 0 TOSHIBA Y 0 VERIZON WIRELESS Y 0 ZTE 0 TOTALS 8 QUORUM CALCULATION % % ADDITIONS OBSERVERS AND GUESTS QUORUM STATUS NOTES: - HIGHLIGHTED ZERO = Must attend consecutive mtgs to be added to quorum list - NON-HIGHLIGHTED ZERO = Will be added to quorum list if they attend the next mtg 00 GPP TSG-C_MtgSum-08