T E C H N I C A L E V A L U A T I O N R E P O R T (Date: )

Transcription

1 Tender for purchase of tools, tests, and repair and calibration equipment for Bio Medical workshops Lahore, Multan and Sargodha T E C H N I C A L E V A L U A T I O N R E P O R T (Date: ) GOVERNMENT OF THE PUNJAB PRIMARY & SECONDARY HEALTHCARE DEPARTMENT

2 BID EVALUATION SHEET Name: Tender for the Procurement of Tools, Test, Repair and calibration Equipment for BIOMEDICAL WORKSHOP Lahore, Multan & Sargodha Commercial Evaluation (All evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance) Sr. No. Firm Evaluation Parameters Meditech SAKUF Trading Crystal Healthcare Coral ORBLYNX 1 Registered / IT/ ST Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 2 Tender Purchase reciept / Earnest 2 % Yes Yes Yes Yes No Earnest Money 3 Relevant Business Experience, min 3 yrs. Yes Yes Not for test equipment Not for test equipment Not for test equipment Financial Strength, Rs 5 Mil plus Turnover Cover letter / Authorization- Annex D & E Undertaking / Integrity pact - Annex B &C Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 7 Affidavit / Blacklisting Yes Yes Yes Yes Not provided

3 Manufacturer (Package 2 & 3) International repute / quality standards Manufacturer / local agent, Authorization Provision of Warranty & maintenance services, undertaking Fluke Biomedical, USA Rigel Medical, UK BC Group International Inc., IBP, IMTmedical and Maxtech BC Biomedical group, IMT medical, maxtech and IBP. Datrend system Inc, Canada Yes Yes Yes Not avaiable Not available Yes Yes Only IBP and BC Group authorization letter given. IMTmedical and Maxtech are missing. M/S Coral also claiming for authorization of these manufacturers. Not from the manufacturer/s Crystal Healthcare also claiming for authorization of these manufacturers. Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 11 Compliance of tender document Yes Yes Yes Yes Remarks Responsive Responsive Non- Responsive Non- Responsive Yes The bidder has mentioned the price in its Technical Offer which is against the PPRA rule 38(2)(a). Non-responsive

4 TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION COMPARITIVE STATEMENT PACKAGE 2 Set of Test & Quality Assurance Equipment for Electro medical items Specifications M/S Sakuf M/S Medi Tech 1- Electric Safety Analyzer Yes, Rigel Medical, UK Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA Rigel 288+ ESA620 Microprocessor based electrical safety - Externally replaceable ground - Main voltage range: V and analyzer. Compact size to hold and operate. fuse, LED status indicators, 180 to 264v AC rms and Operation from 85 to /60 Hz, source receptacle wiring accessible voltage is 0-300v ac with Load Currents up to at least 16 Amps. integrity monitor. Automatic rms instead of 85 to 265 volts. Should test open ground, reverse polarity, load reversal delay, Full 20A - Externally replaceable ground Earth/ground lead resistance/leakage current. rating, Touch control keys and fuse, Open ground, reverse Line voltage readout. Externally replaceable Audio feedback is not found in polarity, external resistance, ground fuse. LED status indicators. its brochure. Source receptacle wiring External resistance. External leakage integrity monitor, Automatic load current. Point-to-Point Testing True RMS measurements. Source receptacle wiring integrity monitor. Automatic load reversal reversal delay, Touch control key and audio feedback are not mentioned in brochure. delay. AAMI ES or IEC 601 Selectable. Full 20 amp rating. Touch control keys. Audio feedback 2- ECG / Patient Simulator Yes, Rigel Medical, UK Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA Pat Sim 200 PS410 Patient Stimulator Generating various BPM s and frequency - Four waveforms display and for - Four waveforms, NSR and waves. All lead connections. Four 6-lead ECG/PVC simulator is performance are not mentioned in waveforms. NSR and performance. missing in brochure. brochure of test equipment. Compact and easy to use. 10 lead wire hook - 10 lead wire hook-up for up for diagnostic 12 lead ECG machines. Lead Test. For 6-lead ECG/PVC simulator. diagnostic 12 Lead ECG machine is mentioned in offer but not in brochure. 3- Defib Analyzer Yes, Rigel Medical, UK Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA

5 Microprocessor-based instrument used in the testing of defibrillators. Measuring the energy output and providing information about the pulse. High and low ranges. For use with manual, semi-automatic and automatic defibrillators with monophasic or biphasic outputs. Feature for viewing and selecting the desired waveforms with quick and intuitive data test. Operational information visible in graphic display for easy navigation through parameters and scrolling through available options. Built in 50 ohm human body simulation load as well as 12 leads ECG with arrhythmias and performance waveforms. Capability to test AEDs. Battery or line power. With an easyto-use menu V, min 500 Joule Capacity. Have internal paddle adapters. Should be flash programmable for upgrades. Should have printer output capability. Rigel Uni-Pulse Impulse 7000DP Defib & pacemaker Analyzer - Nothing mentioned about - Use with manual, semi-automatic arrhythmias and performance and automatic defibrillators with waveforms, External paddle monophasic or biphasic outputs adaptor provided as compare to and Operational information internal paddles. visible in graphic display information not available in brochure. - Internal paddle adaptors are mentioned in offer not in brochure. 4- Electro Surgical Analyzer Yes, Rigel Medical, UK Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA Rigel Uni-therm QA-ES Mark-III Electrosurgical Device Analyzer Comprehensive and accurate analyzer. Test modes should include RF output power, current and leakage, measurements. Should have different color codes for each range at the input connector and on the meter, making measurements quick & easy. Built in 0 to 1000 ohm variable resistance with 1 ohm - Load bank ohm with Resolution 5 ohm instead of 1 ohm. - Only monitor CQM not REM, ARM and PSS testing mA but not mentioned for 200 ohm load ohm Variable resistance but not mentioned about 1 ohm resolution. For ohm (by 25 ohm) - Only monitor CQM not REM, ARM and PSS testing mA but not mentioned for

6 digital resolution for return contact monitor - Display size is not given but 200 ohm load. (CQM, REM, ARM, PSS) testing. The unit from picture it does not seems - Display size is not given but from should have RF leakage test: 500 ma 4.5 picture it does not seems 4.5 maximum into 200 ohm load, Min display: 4.5 analog meter; accuracy of at least ± - Analog meter not mentioned in offer. - Analog meter not mentioned in offer. 2.0% of full scalecolor-coded scales in watts and milliamps, esu output current range: ma for all loads. Min 6 selectable load - Current range not mentioned for ESU. - ESU output current range: ma for all loads not mentioned in brochure. ranges from 50 to 500 ohms. 5- Oximeter / pulse tester Yes, Rigel Medical, UK Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA SP-SIM Index 2XLFE SpO2 Analyzer Should test SpO2 systems the way they are designed to work. Should allow to check SpO2 sensor by passing light source thru the simulator with the absorbance being read by the photocell on the other portion of the - No mention to check SpO2 sensor by passing light source thru the simulator with the absorbance being read by the photocell - Three percentages of saturation levels and pulse synchronization is not mentioned. sensor. Should work with any style Pulse Oximetry Finger Sensor simulating the digit. - It is not mentioned that it will work with any style Pulse Should be able to push on the device to Oximetry Finger Sensor generate a pulse or generate a calibrated simulating the digit. pulse rate with the pulse oximetry module. At least three percentages of saturation levels. Pulse synchronized. Accurate and - No description of ability able to push on the device to generate a pulse or generate a calibrated easy to use SpO2 simulator. Quick testing of pulse rate with the pulse pulse oximetry systems including sensors. oximetry module. - Three percentages of saturation levels and pulse synchronization is not mentioned. 6 Pressure and Vacum Meter No Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA DPM4-2G parameter tester Microprocessor based with positive & - Not mentioned about the pressure

7 negative pressure sensing of compatible liquids & gases. Should also measure temperature compensated pressure measurement. Should also have PSI 700 temperature probe interface minimum and maximum. Programmable digital filter. Built in LCD display. Having digital calibration with no pots to turn. With and accuracy of.1% of full scale accuracy. Should have a range of at least to PSI. Digital adjustment of zero (digital calibration & zero adjust). Should have a male luer connector. With at least four pressure scales namely; PSI, inh2o, cmh2o and mmhg. measurement of both liquid and gases. - Programmable digital filter and digital calibration with no pots to turn, not mentioned. - Accuracy given is +-2% (For temp reading) and 0.3% (For pressure range) - Digital adjustment of zero not given. 7 Gas Flow Analyzer Yes, Rigel Medical, UK Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA Model: Ven Test 800 VT Pulse HF with AccLung Robust and simple operation. Easy to use. Bi-directional flow measurement. Should be able to measure respiratory parameter, real time graphs and multiple gas standards and gas types. Should have a built-in memory function with multiple interfaces. Measurement of temperature and pressure compensated flow. High, differential, flow channel and barometric pressure measurement. Should display all units of flow and pressure measurements. Pressure compensated oxygen measurement. Measurement of gas temperature, type and standard, time (ti and te) ratio, volume (Vti, Vte), minute volume(vi, Ve), peak - No built-in memory functions with multiple interfaces. - Not all units of measurement. - No adjustable test lungs which simulate adult and infant lungs with widely adjustable resistance, compliance and leakage. - No built-in memory functions with multiple interfaces. - No display all units of flow and pressure measurements given. - No adjustable test lungs which simulate adult and infant lungs with widely adjustable resistance, compliance and leakage. - Not able to check and calibrate other types of gas flow and pressure-producing devices. - Not mentioned to be integrated with data management software.

8 flow(insp. / Exp), pressure(ppeak, Pmean, PEEP, Pplateau), compliance(cstat), volume trigger (Adult, Pediatric, HFO, flow or pressure at preset and at adjustable levels) breath rate. With adjustable test lungs which simulate adult and infant lungs with widely adjustable resistance, compliance and leakage. In addition should also be able to check and calibrate other types of gas flow and pressure-producing devices. Should integrate with data management software. 8 Infusion Pump Analyzer Yes, Rigel Medical, UK Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA Infusion Pump Analyzer to test the flow rates of intravenous infusion pumps to ensure their correct operation. Design should be tough, simple, portable, easy to clean & very user friendly. Should be able to test up to two pumps/chambers (chamber sizes 3.5 & 35 ml), simultaneously by the volumetric method in milliliters per hour. Testing should be microprocessor controlled. Fluid path should be unobstructed and easy to clean. Tubes should be made of rugged plastic and the cables and chambers should be interchangeable. The analyzer should auto identify each chamber when it is plugged in. Digital calibration. Should have software adjustable contrast, replaceable tubes. Programmable end of test audio and programmable auto or manual test start. The chamber calibration should be electronically Model: Rigel Multi Flo - Multichannel configuration is mentioned instead of multi chamber. - Microprocessor based is not mentioned. - Calibration method is not specified. - Graphic display not cursor based. - No fluid path. - Software adjustable contrast, replaceable tubes are not mentioned. - No chamber calibration Model: IDA-5Infusion Device Analyzer - Dual Channel but not chamber based. - No mention of Programmable end of test audio and programmable auto or manual test start. - No large graphics display with cursor based selection of options & setup of parameters along with sealed level sensors. - No mention of out of sequence sensing.

9 stored in each chamber. Should have large graphics display with cursor based selection of options & setup of parameters along with sealed level sensors. Should have out of sequence sensing. Ranges 0 to ml/hr & 0 to9999 ml/hr with at least ±1% of reading flow accuracy. 9 Oxygen Analyzer No Yes, Fluke Biomedical, USA MaxO2+AE oxygen Analyzer Easy to use, low-maintenance analyzer - No mention of backlight LCD, monitor with a 0 to 100% oxygen alarms, measurement range. The sensor should have a long life. Should have a backlit LCD. The - Sensor life is of >900,000 O 2 % hours. alarms should be smart. Unit should also have built-in alarms for high and low values. The unit should have a DC power port with a protective overmold or a bumper to protect from extreme environment and shock. The sensor operating life should be > 1,500,000 oxygen percent hours. The unit should have a - No built-in stand. built-in stand, and dovetail. An extended battery life is essential for remote and reliable operation. 10 Dialysis Refernce Meter No No

10 Measure of Pressure, Temperature, Conductivity, Flow and ph for Hemodialysis Machines. Should have a touch Screen. The test device should display measuring values, statistical measuring data. The device should be able to perform data acquisition and data export to Microsoft excel. Produce test reports. Should have multiple sensor ports. Should have min 7" diagonal HD WXGA IPS multi touch screen, 30 GB Flash Memory, 1 GB DDR3L SDRAM, 30 GB Flash Memory Card. Unit should be able to work on ac and battery. Device should be protected with a robust housing. The test device should be scalable and upgradable. The test device should also be able to measure: Pressure in: Ophtamological lasers, Blood pressure meters, Automatic tourniquets, Drainage devices, IV pumps, Diagnostic, surgical suction, Ventilators, Pressure gauges, RO-Water Systems. Temperature in: Temperature monitors, Electronic thermometers, Humidifiers/nebulizers, Blood warmers, Hypo/hyperthermia machines, Infant incubator, and Radiant warmers. Conductivity in: RO-Systems, Water Treatment Flow in: RO-Water Systems, Water Treatment. Remarks Non-Compliant Non-Compliant