British Columbia Utilities Commission Reliability Standards with Effective Dates adopted in British Columbia

Transcription

1 Page 1 of 15 British Columbia Utilities Reliability Standards with s adopted in British Columbia BAL Standard Real Power Balancing Control Performance R July 1, 2016 BAL Disturbance Control Performance R December 12, 2013 BAL Disturbance Control Standard Contingency Reserve for Recovery from a Balancing Contingency Event January 1, 2018 BAL-002-WECC-2 1 Contingency Reserve R October 1, 2014 BAL-002-WECC-2a Contingency Reserve July 26, 2017 BAL Frequency Response and Frequency Bias Setting R October 1, 2016 BAL Time Error Correction BAL-004-WECC-2 Automatic Time Error Correction R October 1, 2014 BAL b Automatic Generation Control R BAL Inadvertent Interchange R-1-13 April 15, 2013 CIP CIP CIP , 3, 4 CIP CIP Cyber Security Critical Cyber Asset Identification G July 1, 2012 December 12, 2013 R2: Retired January 21, Cyber Security BES Cyber System Categorization R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security Security Management Controls G July 1, 2012 R1.2, R3, R3.1, R3.2, R3.3, and R4.2: Retired January 21, Cyber Security Security Management Controls R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security Security Management Controls CIP-004-3a 1 Cyber Security - Personnel & Training R August 1, 2014 CIP n/a Adoption held in abeyance at this time 5 Cyber Security Personnel & Training R October 1, Reliability standard is superseded by the revised/replacement reliability standard listed immediately below it as of the effective date(s) of the revised/replacement reliability standard. On November 21, 2013, FERC Order 788 (referred to as Paragraph 81) approved the retiring of the reliability standard requirements. Reliability standard is superseded by CIP as of the CIP effective date. Reliability standard is superseded by CIP as of the CIP effective date. BC Hydro recommends that the CIP reliability standard be held in abeyance and be of no force or effect in BC due to technical suitability issues that will not improve reliability and instead place undue burden on responsible entities. When adopted by FERC, the NERC approved CIP-003-7(i) reliability standard will retire CIP CIP-003-7(i) is anticipated to be assessed in the next MRS Assessment Report.

2 CIP CIP-005-3a 1, 3 CIP CIP-006-3c 1 CIP CIP Standard Cyber 1, 3, 4 CIP-007-3a CIP CIP CIP CIP CIP CIP CIP CIP CIP CIP CIP Cyber Security Personnel & Training Cyber Security Electronic Security Perimeter(s) R-1-13 ATTACHMENT B Page 2 of 15 October 1, 2018 See BC CIP Version 5 Revisions July 15, 2013 R2.6: Retired January 21, Cyber Security Electronic Security Perimeter(s) R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security Physical Security of Critical Cyber Assets G July 1, 2012 Cyber Security Physical Security of BES Cyber Systems R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security Physical Security of BES Cyber Systems Security - Systems Security Management R October 1, 2018 See BC CIP Version 5 Revisions August 1, 2014 R7.3: Retired January 21, Cyber Security System Security Management R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security System Security Management Cyber Security Incident Reporting and Response Planning G July 1, 2012 October 1, 2018 See BC CIP Version 5 Revisions Cyber Security Incident Reporting and Response Planning R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security Recovery Plans for Critical Cyber Assets G July 1, 2012 Cyber Security Recovery Plans for BES Cyber Systems R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security Recovery Plans for BES Cyber Systems Cyber Security Configuration Change Management and Vulnerability Assessments Cyber Security Configuration Change Management and Vulnerability Assessments October 1, 2018 See BC CIP Version 5 Revisions R October 1, 2018 October 1, 2018 See BC CIP Version 5 Revisions Cyber Security Information Protection R October 1, 2018 Cyber Security Information Protection CIP Physical Security R October 1, 2018 See BC CIP Version 5 Revisions October 1, 2017 and as per BCspecific

3 Standard COM , 6 Telecommunications G January 1, 2011 COM Communications R October 1, 2017 ATTACHMENT B Page 3 of 15 COM Communications R1, R2: October 1, 2017 R3 R13: October 1, 2018 Operating Personnel COM Communications Protocols R April 1, 2017 EOP b 7 Emergency Operations Planning R August 1, 2014 EOP Capacity and Energy Emergencies R August 1, 2014 EOP Load Shedding Plans EOP Load Shedding Plans Adoption held in abeyance at this time 10 EOP Event Reporting R August 1, 2015 EOP Event Reporting October 1, 2017 EOP System Restoration and Blackstart Resources R EOP System Restoration Coordination R August 1, 2014 EOP Loss of Control Center Functionality R August 1, 2015 EOP Geomagnetic Disturbance Operations R August 1, 2015 R3.1: Retired January 21, EOP Emergency Operations October 1, 2018 R1, R3: October 1, 2016 R2: At retirement of IRO aR3 FAC Facility Interconnection Requirements R October 1, 2016 FAC Facility Interconnection Studies R October 1, 2015 FAC FAC Transmission Vegetation Management R August 1, 2015 Transmission Vegetation Management October 1, 2017 FAC-501-WECC-1 Transmission Maintenance R-1-13 April 15, Requirement 4 of the reliability standard is superseded by COM as of the COM effective date. Reliability standard is superseded by EOP as of the EOP effective date. Reliability standard would be superseded by EOP if adopted in BC. Adoption of EOP pending reassessment. Reliability standard is superseded by EOP as of the EOP effective date in conjunction with PRC Requirement 1 if adopted in BC. Adoption of PRC pending reassessment. Unable to assess based on undefined Planning Coordinator/Planning Authority footprints and entities responsible. The Reasons for Decision for Order No. R (page 20), indicated that a separate process would be established to consider this matter as it pertains to BC. Requirement 2 of the reliability standard will be effective upon the retirement of IRO a Requirement 3 which follows the effective date of.

4 Standard FAC Facility Ratings R FAC FAC FAC FAC FAC FAC FAC System Operating Limits Methodology for the Planning Horizon System Operating Limits Methodology for the Planning Horizon System Operating Limits Methodology for the Operations Horizon System Operating Limits Methodology for the Operations Horizon G G ATTACHMENT B Page 4 of 15 August 1, 2015 R4 and R5: Retired January 21, October 30, 2011 R5: Retired January 21, R1 R4: October 1, 2017 R5: Retired January 1, 2011 R5: Retired January 21, October 1, 2017 Establish and Communicate Transfer Capability Assessment of Transfer Capability for the Near-Term Transmission Planning Horizon Establish and Communicate System Operating Limits G January 1, 2011 Adoption held in abeyance at this time 10 INT Dynamic Transfers R R1, R2: October 1, 2015 R3: January 1, 2016 Evaluation of Interchange INT Transactions R October 1, 2015 INT Implementation of Interchange R October 1, 2015 INT INT IRO IRO Interchange Initiation and Modification for Reliability R October 1, 2015 Intra-Balancing Authority Transaction Identification R October 1, 2015 Reliability Coordination Responsibilities and Authorities G January 1, 2011 Reliability Coordination Responsibilities October 1, 2017 IRO Reliability Coordination Facilities R-1-13 April 15, 2013 IRO Reliability Coordination Monitoring and Analysis October 1, 2017 Reliability Coordination Wide Area View Reliability standard would be superseded by the FAC if adopted in B.C. Adoption of FAC pending reassessment. See IRO and TOP Reliability Standards Supersession Mapping section below.

5 IRO Standard IRO a 13, 14 IRO IRO-006-WECC-2 IRO IRO IRO IRO-010-1a 13 IRO IRO IRO Reliability Coordination Operations planning R-1-13 April 15, 2013 Reliability Coordination - Current Day Operations R August 1, 2014 Reliability Coordination Transmission Loading Relief R-1-13 April 15, 2013 Qualified Transfer Path Unscheduled Flow (USF) Relief R October 1, 2015 Reliability Coordinator Operational Analyses and Real-time Assessments R-1-13 April 15, 2013 Reliability Coordinator Operational Analyses and Real-time Assessments October 1, 2017 Reliability Coordinator Actions to Operate Within IROLs R-1-13 April 15, 2013 Reliability Coordinator Actions to Operate Within IROLs October 1, 2017 Reliability Coordinator Data Specification and Collection R-1-13 April 15, 2013 Reliability Coordinator Data Specification and Collection April 1, 2019 Procedures, Processes, or Plans to Support Coordination Between Reliability coordinators Coordination Among Reliability Coordinators October 1, 2017 Notification and Information Exchange IRO Coordination of Real-Time Activities G ATTACHMENT B Page 5 of 15 November 1, 2010 R2: Retired January 21, IRO Outage Coordination October 1, 2020 IRO MOD-001-1a Reliability Coordinator Real-time Reliability Monitoring and Analysis Capabilities April 1, 2018 Available Transmission System Capability G November 30, 2011 MOD Capacity Benefit Margin G November 30, 2011 MOD Transmission Reliability Margin Calculation Methodology G November 30, Requirement 3 of the reliability standard is superseded by EOP Requirement 2 as of the effective date.

6 MOD MOD MOD MOD MOD MOD Standard Steady-State Data for Modeling and Simulation for the Interconnected Transmission System Dynamics Data for Modeling and Simulation of the Interconnected Transmission System Providing Interruptible Demands and Direct Control Load management Data to System Operators and Reliability Coordinators Verification and Data Reporting of Generator Real and Reactive Power Capability and Synchronous Condenser Reactive Power Capability Verification of Models and Data for Generator Excitation Control System or Plant Volt/Var Control Functions Verification of Models and Data for Turbine/Governor and Load Control or Active Power/Frequency Control Functions R R R ATTACHMENT B Page 6 of 15 40% by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, 2020 R1: October 1, 2016 R2: 30% by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, 2025 R3-R6: October 1, 2015 R1: October 1, 2016 R2: 30% by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, 2025 R3-R5: October 1, 2015 MOD Area Interchange Methodology R August 1, 2014 MOD-029-1a 1 Rated System Path Methodology G November 30, 2011 MOD-029-2a Rated System Path Methodology October 1, 2017 MOD Flowgate Methodology G November 30, 2011 MOD Flowgate Methodology October 1, 2017 MOD Demand and Energy Data R October 1, 2016 MOD Demand and Energy Data April 1, 2018 MOD MOD Data for Power System Modeling and Analysis R Effective date held in abeyance 10 Steady-State and Dynamic System Model Validation R Effective date held in abeyance 10 NUC Nuclear Plant Interface Coordination R January 1, 2016 PER Operating Personnel Responsibility and Authority R December 12, 2013 PER Operating Personnel Training 15 Reliability standard will be superseded by MOD and MOD if adopted in BC. Adoption of MOD and MOD pending reassessment.

7 Standard PER Operating Personnel Credentials R January 1, 2015 PER Reliability Coordination Staffing R-1-13 January 15, 2013 PER Operations Personnel Training R ATTACHMENT B Page 7 of 15 R1-R4, R6: October 1, 2016 R5: October 1, 2017 PRC (ii) System Protection Coordination R October 1, 2016 PRC PRC a 1 PRC-004-5(i) PRC-004-WECC-1 1 PRC-004-WECC-2 PRC b 1,18 Disturbance Monitoring and Reporting Requirements Analysis and Mitigation of Transmission and Generation Protection System Misoperations R R August 1, 2014 R1, R5: April 1, 2017 R2-R4, R6-R11: staged as per BCspecific R12: July 1, 2017 Protection System Misoperation Identification and Correction R October 1, 2017 Protection System and Remedial Action Scheme Misoperation R-1-13 July 15, 2013 Protection System and Remedial Action Scheme Misoperation October 1, 2017 Transmission and Generation Protection System Maintenance and Testing PRC Protection System Maintenance R PRC-005-2(i) 1 Protection System Maintenance R PRC PRC PRC PRC Protection System, Automatic Reclosing, and Sudden Pressure Relaying Maintenance Automatic Underfrequency Load Shedding Assuring consistency of entity Underfrequency Load Shedding Program Requirements Implementation and Documentation of Underfrequency Load Shedding Equipment Maintenance Program R January 1, 2015 R1, R2, R5: October 1, 2017 R3, R4: staged as per BC-specific R1, R2, R5: October 1, 2017 R3, R4: staged as per BC-specific R1, R2, R5: October 1, 2019 R3, R4: See Adoption held in abeyance at this time Reliability standard supersedes PRC which has been held in abeyance due to the undefined Planning Coordinator/Planning Authority footprints and entities responsible. Reliability standard will be superseded by PRC if adopted in BC. Adoption of PRC pending reassessment. Reliability standard is superseded by PRC as per the PRC BC specific.

8 PRC PRC Standard Analysis and Documentation of Underfrequency Load Shedding Performance Following an Underfrequency Event Technical Assessment of the Design and Effectiveness of Undervoltage Load Shedding Program G ATTACHMENT B Page 8 of 15 November 1, 2010 R2: Retired January 21, PRC Under Voltage Load Shedding Adoption held in abeyance at this time 10 Undervoltage Load Shedding system PRC Maintenance and Testing PRC PRC PRC PRC PRC ,18 PRC PRC PRC PRC PRC Special Protection System Data and Documentation Remedial Action Scheme Data and Documentation October 1, 2017 Special Protection System Misoperations G January 1, 2011 Remedial Action Scheme Misoperations October 1, 2017 Special Protection System Maintenance and Testing Remedial Action Scheme Maintenance and Testing October 1, 2017 Disturbance Monitoring Equipment Installation and Data Reporting Coordination of Generating Unit or Plant Capabilities, Voltage Regulating Controls, and Protection R % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, 2020 Under Voltage Load Shedding Program Data Under Voltage Load Shedding Program Performance G PRC , 21 Transmission Relay Loadability R November 1, 2010 R2: Retired January 21, R1-R5: For circuits identified by sections and : January 1, 2016 For circuits identified by sections , , , and : To be determined 10 R6: To be determined Reliability standard is superseded by PRC as of the PRC effective date. Reliability standard is superseded by PRC if adopted in B.C. Adoption of PRC pending reassessment. PRC Requirement 1, Criterion 6 only is superseded by PRC as of PRC s 100 per cent.

9 Page 9 of 15 Standard PRC Transmission Relay Loadability R PRC Transmission Relay Loadability R1-R5: regarding circuits and January 1, 2016 R1-R5: Circuits , , and : To be determined 7 R6: To be determined 10 R1-R5 Circuits , : October 1, 2017 with the exception of Criterion 6 of R1 which will not become effective until PRC R1 is completely effective in BC. Until then, PRC R1, Criterion 6 will remain in effect. PRC Generator Frequency and Voltage Protective Relay Settings R PRC Generator Relay Loadability R PRC TOP-001-1a 13 Relay Performance During Stable Power Swings Reliability Responsibilities and Authorities R-1-13 January 15, 2013 Transmission Operations October 1, 2020 n/a R1-R5 Circuits , , , and R6: To be determined 40% by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, % by October 1, 2020 Adoption held in abeyance at this time 10 TOP b 13 Normal Operations Planning R December 12, 2013 TOP Operations Planning October 1, 2020 TOP Planned Outage Coordination R-1-13 April 15, 2013 Operational Reliability Data April 1, 2019 TOP Transmission Operations G January 1, 2011 TOP-005-2a 13 Operational Reliability Information R-1-13 April 15, 2013 TOP Monitoring System Conditions R-1-13 April 15, 2013 TOP Reporting System Operating Unit (SOL) and Interconnection Reliability Operating Limit (IROL) Violations TOP-007-WECC-1a System Operating Limits R October 1, 2015 TOP Response to Transmission Limit Violations

10 Page 10 of 15 Standard TOP TPL TPL TPL-002-0b 22 TPL-003-0b 22 TPL-004-0a 22 TPL Real-time Reliability Monitoring and Analysis Capabilities October 1, 2020 System Performance Under Normal (No Contingency) Conditions (Category A) Transmission System Planning Performance Requirements System Performance Following Loss of a Single Bulk Electric System Element (Category B) System Performance Following Loss of Two or More Bulk Electric System Elements (Category C) System Performance Following Extreme Events Resulting in the Loss of Two or More Bulk Electric System Elements (Category D) Transmission System Planned Performance for Geomagnetic Disturbance Events G January 1, 2011 Adoption pending reassessment To be determined R-1-13 January 15, 2013 R August 1, 2014 R August 1, 2014 n/a Adoption held in abeyance at this time 10 VAR Voltage and Reactive Control R October 1, 2016 VAR Generator Operation for Maintaining Network Voltage Schedules R October 1, 2016 VAR-002-WECC-2 Automatic Voltage Regulators (AVR) R October 1, 2016 VAR-501-WECC-2 Power System Stabilizer (PSS) R October 1, Reliability standard will be superseded by TPL Requirements 2-6, and 8 if adopted in BC as of their effective dates. Adoption of TPL pending reassessment.

11 Page 11 of 15 British Columbia Utilities IRO and TOP Reliability Standards Supersession Mapping This following mapping shows the supersession of Requirements for the following IRO, TOP, and PER reliability standards by the revised/replacement IRO and TOP reliability standards adopted or yet to be adopted in BC as of the effective date in the BC Reliability Standards section above: IRO Reliability Coordination - Responsibilities and Authorities IRO Reliability Coordination - Facilities IRO Reliability Coordination - Wide-Area View IRO Reliability Coordination - Operations Planning IRO a Reliability Coordination - Current Day Operations IRO Reliability Coordinator Operational Analyses and Real-time Assessments IRO-010-1a Reliability Coordinator Data Specification and Collection IRO Procedures, Processes, or Plans to Support Coordination Between Reliability Coordinators IRO Notifications and Information Exchange Between Reliability Coordinators IRO Coordination of Real-time Activities Between Reliability Coordinators PER Operating Personnel Responsibility and Authority TOP-001-1a Reliability Responsibilities and Authorities TOP b Normal Operations Planning TOP Planned Outage Coordination TOP Transmission Operations TOP-005-2a Operational Reliability Information TOP Monitoring System Conditions TOP Reporting System Operating Limit (SOL) and Interconnection Reliability Operating Limit (IROL) Violations TOP Response to Transmission Limit Violations Standard IRO Reliability Coordination - Responsibilities and Authorities Requirements R1-R6, R8, R9 IRO Requirement R7 IRO Standard IRO Reliability Coordination Facilities Requirements R1, R3-R5, R7, and R8 Requirement R2 Requirement R6 Standard IRO Reliability Coordination - Wide-Area View All Requirements

12 Page 12 of 15 Standard IRO Reliability Coordination - Operations Planning All Requirements IRO Standard IRO a Reliability Coordination - Current Day Operations Requirements R1-R3 Requirement R4 Requirements R5 and R8 Requirements R6 and R7 Requirement R8 Requirement R9 Requirement R10 Requirement R11 Requirement R12 IRO IRO IRO IRO MOD-001-2, Requirement R2 (pending FERC adoption in the US and subsequent assessment and adoption in BC.) Standard IRO Reliability Coordination - Current Day Operations All Requirements Standard IRO-010-1a Reliability Coordinator Data Specification and Collection All Requirements Standard IRO Procedures, Processes, or Plans to Support Coordination Between Reliability Coordinators Requirement R1 Requirements R2-R4 IRO IRO Standard IRO Notifications and Information Exchange Between Reliability Coordinators Requirements R1 and R2 IRO Requirement R3

13 Page 13 of 15 Standard IRO Coordination of Real-time Activities Between Reliability Coordinators All Requirements IRO Standard PER Operating Personnel Responsibility and Authority All Requirements Standard TOP-001-1a Reliability Responsibilities and Authorities Requirements R1, R2, R4, R5, R6 Requirement R3 Requirement R7 Requirement R8 IRO EOP-003-2, Requirement 1 (adoption held in abeyance in BC due to PA/PC dependencies) IRO Requirement R1 Requirements R2, R5-R9, R12 Requirement R3 Requirement R4 Requirement R10 Requirement R11 Requirement R13 Requirements R14, R15, and R19 Requirements R16, R17, and R18 Standard TOP b Normal Operations Planning TOP TOP IRO IRO IRO TOP TOP-002-4

14 Page 14 of 15 Requirement R1 Requirement R2 Requirement R3 Requirement R4 Standard TOP Planned Outage Coordination IRO IRO Requirement R1 Requirement R2 Requirements R3 and R4 Requirement R5 Requirement R6 Standard TOP Transmission Operations TOP Retired IRO Requirement R1 Requirement R2 Requirement R3 Standard TOP-005-2a Operational Reliability Information Retired Requirement R1 Requirement R2 Requirement R3 Requirement R4 Requirement R5 Requirement R6 Requirement R7 Standard TOP Monitoring System Conditions

15 Page 15 of 15 Standard TOP Reporting System Operating Limit (SOL) and Interconnection Reliability Operating Limit (IROL) Violations Requirement R1 Requirement R2 Requirement R3 Requirement R4 IRO EOP-003-2, Requirement 1 (adoption held in abeyance in BC due to PA/PC dependencies) IRO Requirements R1 Requirements R2 and R3 Requirement R4 Standard TOP Response to Transmission Limit Violations EOP-003-2, Requirement 1 (adoption held in abeyance in BC due to PA/PC dependencies) TOP-002-4