RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

Transcription

1 CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES The number of houses being built varies with time.

2 The number of houses that are under construction in any town varies over time. Sometimes there are more homes being built, and at other times there are fewer. Statistical tools can help builders see trends and patterns so they can make good decisions. In This Chapter In this chapter, you will learn how to identify and describe the correlation between two variables. You will also learn two methods for finding linear models for two-dimensional data and will see the usefulness and limitations of any model. Topic List Chapter Introduction Scatter Plots Association The Correlation Coefficient Fitting a Line to Data Least Squares Regression Regression Analysis Cautions in Statistics Chapter Wrap-Up RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

3 Chapter Introduction Graphing two data sets can show trends and enable us to make predictions. Determining the Association Between Two Data Sets Sometimes two data sets can be paired to determine whether there is a relationship between two variables. Consider these two variables: single family housing starts and time. A housing start is the beginning of construction on a new house on privately owned property. According to the National Association of Home Builders, construction began on about,99,000 single family homes during 00. Data from 00 to 00 are shown in the table. Year Housing Starts (thousands) 99 0 We can look at each pair of data as an ordered pair. So the ordered pair (00, 99) represents the number of housing starts (in thousands) for 00 and can be plotted on the coordinate plane. A scatter plot results when all pairs of data are plotted in a graph. 000 U.S. Housing Starts Housing starts (thousands) Year CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

4 Chapter Introduction The points on the graph tell us that although the number of housing starts increased for the first couple of years, housing starts generally decreased during this time period. There could be a relationship between the year and the number of new housing starts for this time period. Using a Line to Describe Data When the pattern of the points on a graph appears to follow a line, a line (called a model) can be drawn to represent the pattern. Though there are many different models that can be used, a straight line has been used to represent the data here. A line is useful for making predictions and estimates. For example, someone in 00 might want to predict the number of housing starts for the next year based on the line. The line indicates that there should be about 00,000 housing starts in 0, but this prediction could be inaccurate due to unforeseen circumstances. Keep in mind that estimates based on data and statistics are subject to error. For example, no one can be 00% certain about how many housing starts there will be from one year to the next. Nevertheless the use of models to represent data continues to play a significant role in fields such as economics and the social sciences. Applying It Housing starts (thousands) U.S. Housing Starts Year In this chapter, you will learn how to graph two sets of data on a scatter plot and determine the level of association between the data sets. You will learn how to fi t a line to data and determine the linear regression line. You will then learn how to determine whether a line is the appropriate way to model the data. And you will learn how to decide whether a graph or statistical claim is incorrect or misleading. CHAPTER INTRODUCTION

5 Preparing for the Chapter Review the following skills to prepare for the concepts in Chapter. Determine the slope of a line from its graph. Find the equation of a line through two points. Find the vertical distance between two points on a coordinate plane. Find the slope of a line, given the equation of the line. Given the equation of a line, find the value of one variable when the other is unknown. Problem Set Match the line with its slope, m. A. m = _ B. m = _ C. m = D. m = y a c d b x. line a. line b. line c. line d Find the equation of the line that contains the two points.. (, ) and (0, ). (0, ) and (, ). (, ) and (, ) 9. (, ) and (0, ). (9, 9) and (9, ) 0. (00, ) and (99, ) CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

6 Chapter Introduction Find the distance between the two points.. (, ) and (, ). (9.,.) and (9.,.) Find the slope of the line with the given equation.. y = x +. y + 0.x = Find the value of y for the given value of x. 9. y =.x + 0; x = 0. y =.x; x = 0.. (00, ) and (00, ). (9, 0.0) and (9, 9.). y =.x. y.x =. y =.x + 0; x = 0.. y =.x; x =. Find the value of x for the given value of y.. y =.x ; y = 9. y = 0.x + ; y =.. y =.x ; y =. y = 0.x + ; y =. The graphs show the results of two different surveys in which people were asked in what type of setting they prefer to live. Rural % Survey A Suburban % Urban 0% Percent Survey B 0 Urban Suburban setting Rural. According to Survey A, what is the most popular setting? According to Survey B, what is the most popular setting?. If 00 people participated in Survey A and 0 in Survey B, how many actual individuals in each survey chose a rural setting? 9. Create a circle graph that shows the combined results of both surveys. CHAPTER INTRODUCTION

7 Scatter Plots A scatter plot reveals patterns in a set of bivariate data. Bivariate Data States collect income for services through taxes. Two kinds of taxes that states use are sales tax and income tax. Many states have both, while others have one but not the other. Tax Rates (00) Income tax (%) Sales tax (%) CA 0.. TX 0. IN. MA.. IL. PA.0 OH.9. MD. GA VA. FL 0 THINK ABOUT IT Bivariate data is sometimes called paired data. The table represents a set of bivariate data consisting of variables and represented by a set of ordered pairs. These ordered pairs show sales tax rates and highest income tax rates (in 00) for a sample of populous states (more than million residents). For example, Georgia is represented by the ordered pair (, ), which means that in 00, the highest income tax rate in that state was % while the sales tax rate was %. Though a table is an effective way to organize a data set, there are also graphical ways to display data. CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

8 Displaying Bivariate Data A scatter plot is a graph that displays a set of bivariate data. Look at this scatter plot that represents the data set in the table. The scatter plot makes it easier to identify patterns that the table alone can t reveal. For example, we can see that Texas and Florida have close to the same sales tax rate, but no income tax (as of the tax year 00). We can also see that California is an outlier, with greater sales tax and highest income tax rates than any other state in the sample for 00. Sales tax rate (%) 9 TX FL 00 Tax Rates for High Population States In the scatter plot, there is a grouping of six states (Illinois, Massachusetts, Maryland, Ohio, Virginia, and Georgia) where sales tax rates and highest income tax rates are similar. Such a grouping is called a cluster and is revealed clearly in the scatter plot. IN PA IL MA MD VA OH GA CA 9 0 Highest income tax rate (%) THINK ABOUT IT Clusters are where data points have many neighbors. Outliers are where data points have no neighbors. Creating a Scatter Plot Creating a scatter plot is really just a matter of plotting points on the coordinate plane. However, it is important to consider appropriate scales for the horizontal and vertical axes. Let s create a scatter plot for a similar set of bivariate data. How do populous states compare to lower population states in terms of sales and income tax rates? A scatter plot is a good way to compare. The table shows sales tax rates and highest income tax rates (in 00) for a sample of low population states (fewer than million residents). Sales tax rates range from 0% to 9.9%, while highest income tax rates range from 0% to %. So, it makes sense to have a range of 0 to for the vertical axis, and 0 to for the horizontal axis. Sales tax rate (%) 00 Tax Rates for Low Population States WY and SD AK NH The scatter plot reveals that this sample of lower population states has more states with either no sales tax, no income tax, or both. Also there are no clusters of data. ND DE MT ME VT 9 0 Highest income tax rate (%) RI Tax Rates (00) Income tax (%) Sales tax (%) SD 0 VT 9. ND. AK 0 0 WY 0 DE. 0 MT.9 0 RI 9.9 NH 0 ME. SCATTER PLOTS 9

9 Problem Set The scatter plot shows the number of chin-ups and push-ups completed by a sample of fourth grade students. Push-ups 0 9 Number of Chin-ups and Push-ups J B H L D F K E A C I G 9 0 Chin-ups Student Name Jared Tonya Alex Rishab Gao Riki Label A B C D E F Student Name Anne Amira Samuel Lily Abdu Mike Label G H I J K L. How many push-ups did Rishab do?. How many chin-ups did Samuel, Gao, Mike, and Alex do together?. What is the difference between the number of push-ups Amira and Jared did?. Which students did more push-ups than chin-ups?. What is the range of the number of push-ups for all students?. What is the median number of chin-ups for all students?. What is the mean number of push-ups for all students? 0 CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

10 The scatter plot shows temperatures, taken at the same time but at different elevations on a mountain. Temperatures are measured to the nearest degree Fahrenheit, and elevation is measured to the nearest 0 meters. 0 Mountain Temperatures 0 0 Temperature ( F) Elevation (m) What temperature was measured at 0 meters? 9. At what elevations was a temperature of 0 F taken? 0. What is the mean temperature at 0 meters?. What is the mean temperature at elevations above 00 meters?. What is the median temperature for all temperatures?. At what elevation do you find a possible outlier? What is the temperature at this elevation? Why is it an outlier?. At what range of elevations do you find clusters? What is the approximate range of temperatures at these elevations? Create a scatter plot for the set of data. Determine whether there are any clusters or outliers.. protein and fat grams for nuts (Use the Nutrition data set on p. A-.). number of mobile phones per 00 people in Guyana and Ecuador (Use the Mobile Phone data set on p. A-9.) SCATTER PLOTS

11 Association The points on a scatter plot often display noticeable patterns. Direction of Association The price of gasoline is subject to many fluctuations due to many factors ranging from the time of year to political developments around the world. The top scatter plot shows the average price for a gallon of gasoline in nine different states in mid-may 00 and mid-may 0. Looking at the scatter plot, you can see a trend between these two variables: The greater the average prices of gas in mid-may 00, the greater the average price of gas in mid-may 0. This is an example of a positive association, where the points in a scatter plot increase from left to right. May 0 (dollars) Average Gas Prices per Gallon THINK ABOUT IT If the points in a scatter plot go up to the right, then there is a positive association between the variables May 00 (dollars) The bottom scatter plot shows average gas price per gallon and average number of miles driven per day. This scatter plot shows another trend: As average gas prices increase, the average number of miles driven per day decreases. This is an example of a negative association, where points in a scatter plot decrease from left to right. Daily driving distance (miles) Average Gas Price and Driving Distance THINK ABOUT IT If the points in a scatter plot go down to the right, then there is a negative association between the variables Price per gallon (dollars) CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

12 Strength of Association Some scatter plots show a stronger association between two variables than others. In general, the more closely the data points fit a straight line pattern, the stronger is the association between the two variables. Moderate Positive Association REMEMBER Variable Y Variable Y Strong Negative Association Scatter plots make it easy to describe how two variables are associated. Variable X Variable X Figure Figure Weak or No Association Perfect Positive Association Variable Y Variable Y Variable X Variable X Figure Figure Determining the strength of association is often a matter of judgment. For example, the variables in Figure are positively associated but do not show as strong of an association as the do the variables in Figure. For this reason, Figure shows a moderate positive association, and Figure shows a strong negative association. Because there is no apparent pattern in Figure, the variables have no association. Because all of the data points in Figure fall on the same line, there is a perfect positive association between the variables. These following phrases, along with the direction (positive or negative), are typically used to describe the strength of association between two variables in a scatter plot: No association Weak association Moderate association Strong association Perfect association ASSOCIATION

13 Problem Set Determine whether there is a positive association, negative association, or no association between variable X and variable Y. If there is an association, then describe it as weak, moderate, strong, or perfect..... Variable Y Variable Y Variable Y Variable Y Variable X 9 0 Variable X 9 0 Variable X 9 0 Variable X.... Variable Y Variable Y Variable Y Variable Y Variable X 9 0 Variable X 9 0 Variable X 9 0 Variable X CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

14 Determine whether there is a positive association or negative association between variable X and variable Y. 9. Variable X: minutes of exercise; Variable Y: heart rate 0. Variable X: hours worked; Variable Y: dollars earned. Variable X: family size; Variable Y: amount of recycling produced. Variable X: age of car; Variable Y: resale value. Variable X: number of sleep hours; Variable Y: number of awake hours. Variable X: time studying; Variable Y: time watching TV Create a scatter plot for the set of data. Determine whether there is a positive association, negative association, or no association between the variables. If there is an association, then describe it as weak, moderate, or strong.. number of calories and grams of fat for cereals (Use the Nutrition data set on p. A-.). sugar consumption from 9 to 00 in Turkey and the United Kingdom (Use the Sugar Consumption data set on p. A-0.) The table shows scores that eight students earned on four different quizzes. Use scatter plots to solve. Daniel Tori Ela Jordan Eun Mi Kenneth Barry Amelia Quiz 0 9 Quiz 9 Quiz Quiz 9. Describe the association between scores on Quiz and scores on Quiz.. Describe the association between scores on Quiz and scores on Quiz. 9. On which quizzes are scores negatively associated with scores on Quiz? 0. On which two quizzes are scores perfectly associated? ASSOCIATION

15 The Correlation Coefficient A single number is used to describe the association between two variables. Understanding the Correlation Coefficient The direction and strength of the association between two variables can be represented by a single number r called the correlation coefficient. THE CORRELATION COEFFICIENT The correlation coefficient, written as r, describes the strength and direction of the association between two variables. Values of r range from (perfect positive correlation) to 0 (no correlation) to (perfect negative correlation). Calculating r can take a long time; however, most graphing calculators and spreadsheets can be used for quick calculations of r. REMEMBER When data points in a scatter plot increase from left to right, this trend indicates a positive association. When the data points decrease from left to right, this trend indicates a negative association. Interpreting the Correlation Coefficient The scatter plot shows the relationship in Argentina between the number of personal computers owned per 00 residents and the number of mobile phones owned per 00 residents from 99 to 00. Number of PCs (per 00) Mobile Phones and PCs in Argentina (99 00) 0 Mobile Phones Number of mobile phones (per 00) PCs 9 REMEMBER The more closely the data points fit a straight line pattern, the stronger the association is between the two variables. CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

16 The correlation coefficient is about r = 0., which can be verified using technology. The correlation coefficient has a value close to and is positive, indicating a strong positive association. The scatter plot also confirms a strong positive association between the variables. This scatter plot shows the average number of grams of sugar consumed per person each day in Finland and Portugal from 9 to 00. Portugal (grams per day) Average Sugar Consumption (per person) 00 Finland Portugal Finland (grams per day) The correlation coefficient is about r = 0., which can be verified using technology. The correlation coefficient is negative and has a value between and 0, indicating a moderate negative association, which can also be confirmed by looking at the scatter plot The value of r alone does not always give an accurate description of the true strength of association between two variables. For example, consider a correlation coefficient of r = 0.. This value might reflect a moderate association for one set of paired data but could reflect a strong association for another set of paired data. It depends on the situation under study. However, a rule of thumb can be used to describe the strength of association between two variables, based on the value of r. The association between two variables is Weak if 0 < r < 0. Moderate if 0. r < 0. Strong if 0. r < For example, consider a scatter plot that has a correlation coefficient of 0.. Because 0. is between 0 and 0., then the association between the two variables in the scatter plot would be considered weak. THINK ABOUT IT A correlation coefficient of 0. indicates the same strength of association between two variables as a coefficient of 0.. THE CORRELATION COEFFICIENT

17 Problem Set Use estimation to match the correlation coefficient with the scatter plot. A. 0 Variable Y Variable X C. 0 Variable Y Variable X E. Variable Y Variable X B. 0 Variable Y 9 D. Variable Y 9 0 Variable X F. Variable Y 9 0 Variable X 9 0 Variable X. r = 0. r = 0.. r = 0.. r = 0.. r = 0.9. r = Draw a scatter plot (with 0 data points) that approximates the correlation coefficient. Describe the strength and direction of the association between the variables.. r = 0.9. r = r = r = In a certain region, the amount of recycling produced by a household and the number of members in the household are correlated with r = 0... According to the correlation coefficient, how is the amount of recycling expected to change as the number of members in the household increases?. Is it correct to say that the amount of recycling produced by a household is caused by the number of members in the household? Explain.. Suppose r = 0.. Describe how the amount of recycling is expected to change as the number of members in the household increases. CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

18 Use technology to determine the correlation coefficient between the variables. Use the correlation coefficient to describe the strength of the relationship between the variables.. grams of protein and fat for cheeses (Use the Nutrition data set on p. A-.). grams of carbohydrates and fat for cheeses (Use the Nutrition data set on p. A-.). sugar consumption from 9 to 00 in Turkey and the United Kingdom (Use the Sugar Consumption data set on p. A-0.). sugar consumption from 9 to 00 in Spain and Belgium (Use the Sugar Consumption data set on p. A-0.) The data show the number of home runs and walks for players on the Oakland Athletics who had more than 0 at bats and fewer than 0 at bats during the 00 baseball season. The data are presented as ordered pairs: (home runs, walks). More than 0 at bats: (, ), (0, 0), (, 0), (, 0), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, 0), (, 9) Fewer than 0 at bats: (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (, ), (0, ), (, ), (, ), (0, ). Use technology to determine the correlation coefficient of home runs and walks for players who had more than 0 at bats. Use the correlation coefficient to describe the relationship between the number of home runs and walks for players who had more than 0 at bats. 9. Use technology to determine the coefficient of home runs and walks for players who had fewer than 0 at bats. Use the correlation coefficient to describe the relationship between the number of home runs and walks for players who had fewer than 0 at bats. 0. Challenge Are home runs and walks more strongly correlated for players with more at bats? Why would this be so? THE CORRELATION COEFFICIENT 9

19 Fitting a Line to Data A line can be used to summarize a linear trend in a scatter plot. Drawing a Regression Line When it appears that the points in a scatter plot reasonably fit a straight line pattern, then a regression line can be drawn through the points to summarize the pattern. The scatter plot shows the 00 median weekly earnings of U.S. citizens with various levels of education, as reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Since the points appear to follow a straight line pattern, a regression line has been drawn through the points, summarizing the pattern. Median weekly income (dollars) Education and Median Weekly Income 00 THINK ABOUT IT Education (years) Using a line to represent data in this way can be useful for estimating values of the response variable based on values of the explanatory variable. Using the regression line, the response variable (median weekly income) can be estimated based on values of the explanatory variable (years of education). According to the regression line drawn, what is the approximate median weekly income for a person with years of education? Finding the Equation of a Regression Line Once a regression line has been drawn, we can find the equation of the line using algebra. Values of the explanatory variable can then be substituted into the equation to make predictions. 0 CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

20 FINDING THE EQUATION OF A REGRESSION LINE When a regression line has been drawn to summarize data in a scatter plot, the following steps can be used to find its equation. Step Choose two points that appear to be closest to the line drawn. Step Determine the equation of the line through the two points using algebra. Let s find the equation of the regression line for the scatter plot. You can choose the points (, 00) and (0, 00), since they appear to be closest to the line. The slope of the line is m = = 000 =. y y = m(x x ) Point slope formula y 00 = (x 0) Substitute slope and one point on the line y x = 900 Equation in y = ax + b form We will now use the notation ŷ (read y hat ) in the equation of the regression line to remind us that ŷ is a predicted value of y, based on a certain value of x. So the equation of the regression line would be written as ŷ = x 900. TIP The equation of the regression line is sometimes called a model. The model tells us how the response variable changes as the explanatory variable changes. Making Predictions The equation of the regression line can be used to estimate, or predict, values of the response variable based on values of the explanatory variable. Suppose we want to estimate the median weekly income for a person with years of education. For a person with years of education, the value of the explanatory variable is x =. The predicted value is ŷ = () 900 =. So a person with years of education would have a predicted median weekly income of about $. THINK ABOUT IT The model can only predict for a certain range of values of the explanatory variable. For example, why doesn t the predicted median weekly income for someone with years of education make sense? The Slope of a Regression Line The equation of the regression line, ŷ = x 900, describes the trend of the data in the scatter plot. The slope gives the change in the response variable for each unit increase in the explanatory variable. The slope of means that a person can expect to earn an additional $ per week for each additional year of education achieved. In general, the slope of a regression line specifies the amount of change in the response variable that accompanies one unit of change in the explanatory variable. FITTING A LINE TO DATA

21 Problem Set Determine whether Scatter Plot A or Scatter Plot B is described. Scatter Plot A Scatter Plot B The line of best fit has a negative slope.. The line of best fit has a positive y-intercept The line of best fit has a negative y-intercept.. The line of best fit has a positive slope. The data in the scatter plot represent carbon dioxide emissions from a sample of vehicles built in 0. Carbon dioxide emissions (tons) 0 9 Carbon Dioxide Emissions Miles per gallon (city) mpg (city) CO emissions What are the explanatory and response variables shown in the scatter plot? Explain.. Use the two data points closest to the line to write an equation for the regression line. Write the equation in the form ŷ = ax + b. Give the slope and y-intercept.. For each additional mile per gallon in the city that a car gets, what, according to the equation obtained in Problem, would be the effect on carbon dioxide emissions in a year?. If a car tested at city miles per gallon, what, according to the equation obtained in Problem, would be the estimated number of tons of carbon dioxide emissions in a year? CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

22 Explain why a line would not be used to represent the data shown in the scatter plot The scatter plot represents the Sugar Consumption data set on p. A-0. Grams of sugar (day) Sugar Consumption in Portugal Year. What are the explanatory and response variables shown in the scatter plot? Explain.. Suppose a regression line is drawn through the data points. The data points for 90 and 00 appear to be closest to the line. Write an equation for the regression line. Write the equation in the form ŷ = ax + b. Give the values of a and b to two decimal places.. For each additional year, what is the change in the number of grams of sugar consumed? Use the equation obtained in Problem.. In 0, what would be the average daily number of grams of sugar consumed per person in Portugal? Use the equation obtained in Problem.. Suppose another regression line is drawn through the data points. The data for 9 and 00 appear to be closest to this line. Write an equation for the regression line. What would be the average daily number of grams of sugar consumed per person in Portugal in 0, according to the equation? Compare this to the estimate obtained in Problem.. Challenge For each additional month, how does the number of grams of sugar consumed change? Use the equation obtained in Problem. FITTING A LINE TO DATA

23 Least Squares Regression The least squares regression equation is called the line of best fit. Least Squares Regression Line Drawing a regression line to fit a scatter plot does not always give consistent results. In fact, it is possible that two slightly different regression lines could be drawn on the same scatter plot yielding vastly different predictions for the same value. A method for finding a regression line that does not depend on guessing is called least squares regression. The least squares regression line is the line that makes the sum of the squares of the vertical distances from each data d point to the line as small as possible. d For this scatter plot with six data d d d points, the goal would be to find the line that minimizes S the sum of the d squared distances to the line. Once this is achieved, a least squares regression line has been found and represents what Explanatory variable statisticians call the line of best fit. Response variable Least Squares Regression Line S = d + d + d + d + d + d Finding the Least Squares Regression Equation Without the aid of technology, finding the equation of the least squares regression equation for a data set can be time consuming. Fortunately, most graphing calculators and spreadsheets allow you to calculate the least squares regression equation once the paired data has been entered. Here is an example. As digital music became more popular after 000, sales of music CDs in the United States declined. The table represents annual CD sales (in millions) from 000 to 009. Year CD Sales (millions) CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

24 To find the equation of the least squares regression line using technology, data from each variable should be entered as lists into spreadsheet or graphing calculator. Here is what typical input/output will look like when using a graphing calculator. Input: Input data into two list. Output: Calculate the linear regression equation. L L L LinReg y = ax + b a =. b =.9 r =.9 r =.909 Using the values of a and b from the output, the least squares regression equation for these data is ŷ =.x + (rounded). The correlation coefficient of r = 0.9 (rounded) indicates a strong negative association between the variables, which is verified by the scatter plot. Sales (millions) U.S. Sales of CDs ŷ =.x + Q & A Q A What would be the model estimate for CD sales in 999? The model predicts approximately,,00,000 CD sales in Year Coefficient of Determination The coefficient of determination is the square of the correlation coefficient, and is written r. When r is written as a percent, it represents the percent of variance (or change) of the response variable that is due to changes in the explanatory variable. In general, variance is a measure of variability of a data set relative to its mean. For the U.S. Sales of CDs scatter plot, the coefficient of determination is r = 0.9 (rounded). This means that about 9% of the variance in CD sales is associated with changes in the year. The other % of variability is due to other factors. REMEMBER The correlation coefficient describes the strength and direction of association of two data sets. The coefficient of determination describes the percent of variation in y associated with changes in x. LEAST SQUARES REGRESSION

25 Problem Set Identify the equation of the least squares regression line that most closely matches the data set. A. ŷ = 0.x. B. ŷ =.x + C. ŷ =.x 9. D. ŷ =.x +.. x y. x y. x y x y Use the correlation coefficient to find the coefficient of determination. What percent of variation in the response variable can be explained by changes in the explanatory variable? Explain.. r = 0.. r = 0.. r =. r = 0. The data in the table represent the fuel economy (miles per gallon) for a car at different speeds (miles per hour). 9. Make a scatter plot of the data and determine the equation of the least squares regression line using technology. Draw the graph of the least squares regression line on the scatter plot. 0. According to the least square regression equation found in Problem 9, what would be the effect on fuel economy for each additional mile per hour?. Find the value of the coefficient of determination. What percent of the variation in speed is associated with differences in fuel economy?. According to the least squares regression equation, what is the fuel economy for this vehicle at miles per hour? Fuel Economy mph mpg CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

26 The winning times for the Olympic 00-meter women s butterfly are given in the table.. Make a scatter plot of the data and determine the equation of the least squares regression line using technology. Draw the graph of the least squares regression line on the scatter plot.. According to the least squares regression equation, what would be the effect on record times for this event for each additional year?. Find the value of the coefficient of determination. What percent of the variation in winning times is associated with differences in the year?. Use the least squares regression equation to predict the winning time for the Olympic 00-meter women s butterfly event in the year 0.. According to the least squares regression equation, during which Olympic year will the winning time break 0 seconds?. According to the least squares regression equation, predict the winning time for the Olympic 00-meter women s butterfly event in the year. Is this prediction reasonable? Explain. Olympic Year Winning Time (seconds) Use the Sugar Consumption data set on p. A Find the equation of the least squares regression line for each: Albania, France, Italy, and the United Kingdom. Use the year as the explanatory variable. 0. Find the coefficient of determination for each equation. Order the four countries of Albania, France, Italy, and the United Kingdom from the least coefficient of determination to the greatest.. Use the coefficient of determination to determine whether a linear regression model is appropriate for describing sugar consumption for Albania, France, Italy, or the United Kingdom from 9 through 00. Explain your answer.. Which country Albania, France, Italy, or the United Kingdom would you predict to have the highest sugar consumption in 0? Explain. LEAST SQUARES REGRESSION

27 Regression Analysis Residuals show how well a line summarizes data. Finding Residuals The points on a scatter plot usually do not fall on the regression line, which creates an error between observed and predicted values. This error, called a residual, is the vertical distance between a point on the scatter plot and the point on the regression line directly above or below the point. RESIDUALS A residual is the difference between an observed value and the predicted value from the regression line: residual (e) = observed (y) predicted (ŷ). REMEMBER e = y ŷ In the top scatter plot, when x =, the observed value is y = 0, the predicted value according to the regression line is ŷ =, and the residual is e =. When a point is below the regression line, the residual is negative. For example, when x =, the residual is e =. 0 y x A residual plot is a graph that shows the residual for each value of the explanatory variable. The bottom scatter plot shows a residual plot for the data. Residual Plot THINK ABOUT IT The sum of all of the residuals will always equal 0. Residual (e) 0 x CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

28 Interpreting Residual Plots If the points in a residual plot show a pattern, then a straight line may not be an appropriate way to summarize the data. However, if the points have a random pattern that is scattered above and below the horizontal axis, then a line is probably an appropriate model. Curved pattern: A straight line is not a good fit. Random pattern: A straight line is a good fit. Residual (e) Residual (e) x x For example, looking at the scatter plot showing the amount of public debt in the United States from 000 to 00, it appears that a straight line might be a good way to summarize the data. Debt (trillions of dollars) 0 U.S. Debt Scatter Plot ŷ = 0.x Year The residual plot shown below, however, tells a different story. The curved pattern indicates that a straight line is not the best fit for these data. Residual (e) U.S. Debt Residual Plot Year When a linear model is not the best fit, quadratic models, exponential models, and others can be used. In this lesson, however, we will focus only on whether a linear model is a good fit. REGRESSION ANALYSIS 9

29 Problem Set Using the scatter plot with the least squares regression line, estimate the value to the nearest half unit.. the observed value at x =. the predicted value at x =. the residual at x =. the observed value at x =. the predicted value at x =. the residual at x =. Show that the sum of the estimated residuals is equal to 0.. Create a residual plot for the data set. Response variable 0 9 Explanatory variable The table shows values of the explanatory variable (x) and corresponding observed values of the response variable (y). Residuals (e) for the x-value are also given. 9. What is the observed value at x =? 0. What is the residual at x =?. What is the predicted value at x =?. How many observed values are below the regression equation?. Show that the sum of the residuals is equal to 0.. Create a residual plot for the data set. x y e CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

30 For the given residual plot, determine whether a linear model is appropriate for the data set. Explain.. e. e x x 0 0 Alicia started her own business after graduating from college in 99. She immediately started paying off her student loan when she started her business. The spreadsheet shows her annual reported income from her business as well as her student loan balance at the end of the year. Year Income (thousands of dollars) Student loan balance (thousands of dollars) Create a scatter plot that displays Alicia s income for each year, and find the correlation coefficient.. Find the least squares regression equation. What is Alicia s predicted income for 00? How does it compare to the observed value during this year? 9. According to the least square regression equation, what is the effect on Alicia s annual income for each additional year? 0. Find the value of the coefficient of determination. What percent of the variation in Alicia s income is associated with the year?. Create a residual plot to determine whether a linear regression model is a good model to use to represent Alicia s annual income from 99 to 00.. Create a scatter plot that displays Alicia s student loan balance for each year.. Find the least squares regression equation. What is Alicia s predicted student loan balance for 00? How does it compare to the observed value during this year?. According to the least squares regression equation, what is the effect on Alicia s student loan balance for each additional year?. Find the value of the coefficient of determination. What percent of the variation in Alicia s student loan balance is associated with the year?. Create a residual plot to determine whether a linear regression model is a good model to use to represent her student loan balance from 99 to 00. REGRESSION ANALYSIS

31 Cautions in Statistics Graphs and statements using statistics can sometimes be false or misleading. Analyzing Misleading or Incorrect Graphs This graph shows the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for entertainment from 00 to 009. CPI 0 Consumer Price Index for Entertainment BY THE WAY The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is a measure used to monitor costs for consumers over time. The CPI covers many different household costs including food, housing, and other categories Year You can see that the CPI for 00 is just more than, and the CPI for 00 is just more than. The graph is misleading because the height of the bar for 00 is almost twice as high as the bar for 00. Someone looking at this graph might think that entertainment costs the consumer twice as much in 00 as in 00 when in fact, entertainment costs from 00 to 00 only rose.%. This kind of graph is fairly common and results when the numbering on the vertical axis does not start at 0. This is one example of how a statistical graph, whether it is accidental or intentional, can be misleading. Use caution when reading such graphs so that you can make sound judgments about the information contained in the graphs. WHY GRAPHS COULD BE INCORRECT OR MISLEADING Here are ways that could lead to statistical graphs with false or misleading conclusions: Numbering on the vertical axis does not start at 0. Axis scales are not evenly spaced. Numbering on one or both of the axes is in reverse order. The graph does not make sense or is difficult to read. CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

32 Flawed Statistical Claims and Lurking Variables Sometimes we read or hear statistical claims that are flawed, and it is important to be able to identify such flaws when they exist. Consider the following statistical claim: A survey about street parking indicates baseball fans who attended games regularly during the season are in favor of street parking. Though it is probably true that regular game attendees are in favor of street parking, local residents who live near the stadium may not be in favor of street parking. This is a situation where the sample is biased. In such a study, everyone who might be affected by allowing street parking should be included in the survey in order to make it valid. Consider another statistical claim: The decrease in attendance at the baseball games from 00 to 00 was due to an increase in the price of admission during that time. Though it may be true that an increase in ticket prices had an effect on game attendance during this time period, there could be other causes. A lurking variable is a hidden variable that was not considered during the study, or has been left out intentionally so that certain outcomes are favored. In this particular situation, possible lurking variables that could have also contributed to the decrease in attendance include The win-loss record of the team The availability of HDTV and Internet broadcasts The safety of the game location REMEMBER A high correlation between two variables does not necessarily mean that there is a causal relationship between them. WHY STATISTICAL CLAIMS COULD BE INCORRECT OR MISLEADING Here are ways that could lead to statistical claims that could be false or misleading: Lurking variables may also contribute to the outcomes. The sample is biased toward a particular outcome. The claim does not make sense or contains errors. CAUTIONS IN STATISTICS

33 Problem Set Explain why the graph is misleading or incorrect.. Candidate Preferences. Game Attendance No % Male % Year Yes % Female % 00,000,00,00,00,00,000,00,00 Attendance.. Team Record Number of respondents Should increase Public Funding for the Arts Should stay the same Should decrease Number of wins Year Explain why the statistical claim is flawed.. A poll found that % of the voters were in favor of the proposed amendment, % were not in favor, and the remaining 0% were undecided.. A study of hotel guests, conducted by a consortium of hotel owners, determined that travel is beneficial for marriages.. A study determined that watching too much television causes poor performance on math tests.. A survey of employed people showed they did not favor the tax increase proposal. 9. In a traffic flow study that took place at the corner of Pine and Main streets on the weekend of December and, it was determined that a traffic signal is not needed at this corner. 0. In a study of a group of -year-olds, it was determined that a new medicine reduced acne by 0%.. It was determined that lack of regular sleep is the reason for the common cold.. More people are unemployed today than 00 years ago. CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

34 For each research conclusion, identify the explanatory and response variables. Identify a lurking variable and how it could affect the research conclusion.. A vehicle s fuel economy improves as the speed of the vehicle increases.. Sunscreen sales increase as ice cream sales increase.. People who make their own salad dressing with olive oil have lower cholesterol than most people.. Higher usage of a cell phone leads to less sleep at night. A study of 0 apple trees in Orchard X and Orchard Y showed that % more trees in Orchard X contained undersized apples than in Orchard Y. The researcher claimed that this is because Orchard X gets less sunlight per day than Orchard Y.. What reason might justify the claim made by the researcher?. How many more trees in Orchard X contained undersized apples than in Orchard Y? 9. Which of the following could be lurking variables for this situation: age of trees, variety of apples, money spent on the trees, or use of fertilizer? Explain. Eighty adult learners were given a memory task and then separated into two equal groups. In Group A, the learners were given the memory technique of creating pictures. In Group B, the learners were given the memory technique of recite and repeat. When the memory task was repeated, % of the learners in Group A made improvements, while only.% of the learners in Group B made improvements. The researcher claimed that creating pictures was a better memory technique than recite and repeat. 0. What reason might justify the claim made by the researcher?. How many actual learners in Group A improved their score? How many in Group B improved their score?. Which of the following could be lurking variables for this situation: age of learners, time of day for the experiment, content of what was memorized, head size of the learners, or how the techniques were taught? Explain.. Challenge Name another lurking variable not included in Problem. CAUTIONS IN STATISTICS

35 Chapter Wrap-Up Determining the Association Between Two Data Sets The data from the National Association of Home Builders show that from 00 to 00, there was an overall drop in the number of housing starts during this time. Housing Starts (thousands) U.S. Housing Starts Year There is a strong negative association between the year and the number of single family housing starts with a correlation coefficient of approximately 0.9. The equation of the least squares regression line ŷ 99.x + 00,. can be used to represent the data set and to make predictions and estimations. The coefficient of determination is r 0., meaning that about % of the change in the number of single family housing starts is due to changes in the year. These data were collected during a time of economic decline. Data from a different -year period might show a very different pattern. Nevertheless, there are many other variables that can explain the decrease in the number of single family housing starts during this time period. These lurking variables include a rise in the cost of housing materials or a lack of available labor. CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

36 Regression Analysis Is a straight line a good fit for these data? A residual plot is a good way to find out Residual (e) Year The points in the residual plot show a curved pattern, which indicates that a line may not be the best fit. In Summary Two sets of data can be graphed on a scatter plot. The direction and strength of association between the data sets can be determined by the correlation coefficient, r. A linear regression line is a special line of best fit that minimizes the squares of the vertical distances from the points on the scatter plot to the line. A residual plot helps determine whether a line is the appropriate way to model the data. Finally all your statistical knowledge about the situation being studied can help you judge whether a graph or statistical claim is incorrect or misleading. CHAPTER WRAP-UP

37 Practice Problems Relationships Between Variables The scatter plot shows the instrumentation of small musical bands at a band competition.. How many woodwinds were in the band that had the fewest brass instruments? How many brass instruments were in the band that had the fewest woodwinds?. What is the mean number of woodwind instruments at the competition?. What is the median number of brass instruments for bands that have woodwind instruments?. Describe the strength and direction of the association between these variables.. Suppose a regression line is drawn, and it is determined that the points (, ) and (9, 0) are closest to the line. What is the equation of this line?. Use the equation of the regression line found in Problem to predict the number of woodwinds in a band with brass instruments.. Use the equation of the regression line found in Problem to predict the number of brass instruments in a band with woodwinds. Woodwind 0 9 Band Instrumentation 9 0 Brass The table shows the average ticket prices for movies from 9 to 00.. Create a scatter plot that displays the average price for movies each year. Describe the strength and direction of the association between these variables, and then determine the correlation coefficient. 9. Determine the least squares regression equation. 0. Use the least squares regression equation to predict the average price for a movie in 9. How does it compare to the observed value during this year? What is the value of the residual for this year?. Use the least squares regression equation to predict the year that average ticket prices will exceed $.00.. According to the least square regression equation, what would be the effect on the average prices of movie tickets for each additional year?. Find the value of the coefficient of determination. What percent of the variation in the differences in average ticket prices is associated with the year?. Create a residual plot to determine whether a linear regression model is a good model to use to represent average movie ticket prices from 9 to 00. Year Average Price (dollars) CHAPTER RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN VARIABLES

38 Chapter Wrap-Up The table shows the winning times for the Olympic men s 000-meter run.. Create a scatter plot that displays the winning time for each Olympics. Describe the strength and direction of the association between these variables, and then determine the correlation coefficient.. Determine the least squares regression equation.. Use the least squares regression equation to predict the winning time for the 99 Olympic Games. How does it compare to the observed value during this year? What is the value of the residual for this year?. Use the least squares regression equation to estimate the Olympic year in which the winning time will be less than 0 seconds. 9. According to the least square regression equation, what is the effect on winning times for each additional year? 0. Find the value of the coefficient of determination. What percent of the variation in winning times is associated with the year?. Create a residual plot to determine whether a linear regression model is a good model to use to represent winning times from 9 to 00. A study of 0 franchise restaurants in each of two Metropolitan Areas, A and B, showed that sales were, on average, % higher in Metropolitan Area A. The researcher claimed that this was due to Metropolitan Area A having less crime than Metropolitan Area B.. What reason might justify the claim made by the researcher?. If sales in Metropolitan Area A were, on average, $. million, what were sales in Metropolitan Area B?. List two lurking variables that could also explain the difference in sales between the metropolitan areas. The cost of a -star, -star, and -star hotel (per night) in a selected foreign city is $9, $0, and $. When these figures were typed into a spreadsheet program, the display shown here was created.. What information is being conveyed by this display?. Why would this display be considered misleading?. According to the data, how much more does a -star hotel cost compared to a -star hotel? What is the percentage increase in cost from a -star hotel to a -star hotel?. Create a bar graph that is more appropriate for these data. U.S. Dollars Year of Olympic Games Winning Time (seconds) Foreign City Hotel Costs -star -star -star CHAPTER WRAP-UP 9