Implementation Of Lame Delegation Policy. Ray Plzak ARIN

Transcription

1 Implementation Of Lame Delegation Policy Ray Plzak ARIN

2 Background MAR 2002 Policy Formally Proposed APR 2002 ARIN IX JUN 2002 Scripts Developed & Tested Further Discussion on Lists OCT 2002 ARIN X NOV 2002 Policy Adopted DEC 2002 Implementation Activity Begins

3

4

5

6

7 Attempt Contact

8 Attempt Contact the in-addr.arpa POC

9 Attempt Contact the in-addr.arpa POC If No Contact Proceed to Next Step

10 Attempt Contact the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC

11 Attempt Contact the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC If No Contact Proceed to Next Step

12 Attempt Contact the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC

13 Attempt Contact If No Contact Proceed to Next Step the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC

14 Attempt Contact the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Postal Mail the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC

15 Attempt Contact the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC If No Contact Proceed to Next Step Postal Mail the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC

16 Attempt Contact Evaluate the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Postal Mail the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC

17 Attempt Contact Evaluate the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Postal Mail the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Wait 30 Days

18 Attempt Contact Evaluate the in-addr.arpa POC the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Postal Mail the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Wait 30 Days Delegation Declared Lame

19 the in-addr.arpa POC Attempt Contact Evaluate Remove Delegation the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Postal Mail the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Wait 30 Days Delegation Declared Lame

20 the in-addr.arpa POC Attempt Contact Evaluate Remove Delegation the ASN POC Telephone the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Remove NS Delegations Postal Mail the in-addr.arpa or ASN POC Update WHOIS Record Wait 30 Days Delegation Determined to be Lame Delegation Declared Lame Evaluation Date of the Lame Delegation Contact has been Attempted Unsuccessfully Update Record Date Record Updated

21 Lame Delegation Test For: 1. No AA bit set 2. AA bit set, but nothing in the answer section 3. AA bit set, but answer is not an SOA record Not Tested 1. No IP address for name server - forward look up errors 2. No connection to name server 3. No answer - SERVFAIL, NX-DOMAIN error codes Operational Servers Removed from Subsequent Testing.

22 Timeline Test 1 st Notification Test 2 nd Notification Test 15 Feb 4-6 Mar 13 Mar Mar 27 Mar

23 Zones Servers No AA Bit Set 88, Feb 2003 Results Tested Tested 198, ,555 Bad Server Summary AA Bit Set Nothing in Answer 17,599 At Least One Bad Server 55,281 Bad 106,322 AA Bit Set No SOA Record 1

24 4 6 March 2003 Notification Results 1 st Week 2 nd Week Total Telephone Calls

25 Help Desk Actions Define the problem/exact question. Use the lame tool to see what the answers look like. Use dig to obtain further information. Review results with customer Define what the expected results should look like. Walk through the steps needed to correct information at ARIN. Provide Reconfiguration Help Sources by Referring to SA Vendor Bind documentation

26 Observations 1. People Are Interested Want to Correct Problem Want Know What This is About 2. This Will be a Deliberate Process

27 Next Steps Continue Notification Phases Update Information Continue Testing for Lamness

28