/ 56 9 : " 06..; %4 " " 37 / 4 (; <.7 * )* =(#..; = 91 (",. >+ ) ( ( $% 0 4. " 88 ' 6 ( *(6 9( ( = 6... E" = F 9 ( &( * ( ) * )

Transcription

1 2 1 ( ( )( " '! " # $% & (' ( ( '"! * + + $%',# -. / 56 $ 7 8 )$%4 3 / / 56 9 : " 06..; %4 " " 37 / 4 (; <.7 * )* =(#..; = 91 (",. >+ ) (Build, Operate and Transfer 0 (? =@( *! / 56.' *! $A )BOT) *6 ) 9 ':4 5 # ( ( $% 0 4. " 88 ' 6 6 $% 8. '.. 0 C4 D% ) 0! ( *(6 9( ( = 6... E" = F 9 ( &( * ( ) * ) ( 6 =(6 (.. >:" ) $% " 3 5.D 88 >+ '5. &! "! # $ %. &! "! # $ ( )*

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

3 :$ # A)7,* * ( * (. G# -3,( < < *6 2-3 < * Q BD+ - #*,# * (. $,* -4 " 0-# Q 0 G )=* 1-4 7* L -,( 0* $ QD5 7 "? 2-4 L -,( 0* $ - -L *6 "? 3-4 1$ 1?-L C (BOT,-) "(! 0H* - 5( * (. - * (. :( D -5 (. $ 1-5 D* 5* 05 $ 2-5 DH,-,6* ,( 5* * (. ( 2-6 D* 5* 05 ( :( &R* 3-6 D* S-- * * 5-6.G

4 ,* - * - (. H -2 G1 (.1 A)7,C 5$ 3,- * (. 7+ ( S / E1( -* 48,& 3E*F 7? G,7?,! C OF1* ; UF S* A7 T; 0-3F E*?; ( 1) 1=* * 0 -( (. A)7,* 0 -.(2000 D1.1*#6 $ "-& 7+ * (. 0**$.*#6 + 1? * %L -. FL ** 0&* 3 0 G 1$ 1! 5 V* E*- 0&* 3* ( $ $ * 35* 0 $ ? :; - A)7 G=** B1* $ *6 =! ; ? 4 (. A)7 The W1985 1?) 1-0 $ 8-60 :; - A)7 G=** 3.(World Bank ** 8?= -D $,(. 7X ( * (. B** <D* A* & $ E.* "F F- V* B.* S 3( W.) * G# :; )=* 0, 05* 01 S 3* (.! <L C* - B** M) *,1*6.1* <1*&,65,& 5 -& ( -. *(1?1; B1&* Q=* (. A)7,* F <-- 1C Y M)& 3! $ "-& Z- * :; * <1D 0&1* 3 -D L -- *. ** S1 3=* *87 & -( QD5 0-# 4-X,* A)7 :( 104

5 318-& #D,D& L -,( ; 0*- & 5* 1-? 0&1* 1& T+ 3& 3$ 3 3D 8+ ( 4F$ 3(. A)7,* :(! <D B. 7? L 1-1X + 1- [0&- #- B. $ R* $ L.(Neale 1995; Hillebrandt 1985 W1997 ).1*#6 :1( - 0&- %& * (. $ D* I+ T\$ M) * 1(*.1*# 1 GF "F 3=* E*(D5-5 1Y 1# G$ 3(. A)7 D* B- ]* :( ( #.5.*#6 0 :( * 32 0&- - 0 $ 34( 0 $ (. A)- * $ Austen 1985; The World Bank ) 1*Y * (. B.** :(1984 1* &!,. B. A D L <D C :( QD5 "D.,! & L - 25." $H :( 7* "H.,( ( "?.=F!, ,6Y,^.- * ",5.* _ 07R* <* V

6 ,* - * - (.,# -3 (1. 1$ *,5* D* $ 47 4 `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

7 15.1.* (,87 ; :( - 0,( # )7 31*,( ], DD GF,*6 0(R- 15*-,1# 3,( * 0(R- 5 ]+ (,87 M)& Q1D5 G1 %$* $ 0 **,&,8 A)? (.(F*-) - #*-,( K- -( 2 01?1-L 1 & QD5,& I; :.*- 05 & 37*.* L -,( 0* $ F *1 * ]L -L,( $ R* $ 4F+?-L & M)&.(1990 W1985?) 4F+ QD5 2 QD5 0-# * I Consulting ) 05*1 1*6 %1 C 5 B( (01) 01 < ", 5 2 E- 0 ) (Engineer,.1* 1(; 1* Q.*#6 = ], F**.* Q )=* :( B! ( 4F$ 3#*,*,,1&,1C 3 7 -, C G 3-0 $ :( 7,& A)7,( 3-0 C $ =* (=- A)17 T+ G 3 *6 0(L :( "# 7 D+ V* 1 < *6 T+ 6; 3- D $ 4- &-,# $,C.1* "1-1 15*,* 5* - 0 C $ D* 41 "1,61 M1) :* 3-9 :; *6,.(2000? W2001 -),1N <*& 87 %R* ( < * %R* X 1 <1 * ( - D $ *6 107

8 ,* - * - ( $,,-5 * 3 D- BF 1-1*76 3,1,- ** (*, D* * *,,- 0-* $.(1990?) * :( S *6 3B6a "1( &R- - D $ *6,& <*& ( 5 1DL ( "& :( - *6 <*&,N * 1- "H1.,( $ X M) 3 [0& $ "- *,( L <. :( -L *6 <*&?*,1 :1( <1 1=; ; 5 S 3 "-&. 3-1*6.1?1** :; 7.8 Z-- *6 1.( W '1999?) < 1 1 G* :; B* (, C $ -,& T-** 5,C* 7 3-,C* T+ & 3 *6 1-* 1 (. -5& F- # X) -L 0 $ *- 3D *6 (. * " F DD GF :; :*.(1999 W1990?) (. A)7 :; 5* 05,D ( I 6 3-3,& & [0&- *) "- :( 05 **,# # 3]L ( H. 0 %+- 4-X,65 :1; 1*& 0* 3$ F,65,& R*- - 0 K-,65,& ]+ -( 0,R+ 3(.) QD5,(1 D1D )=* $ -&L < 0*-,+ * ( ) H1. 1( Q1=* - D $ C 30 A)7 $ & * 108

9 <1*&* "* 4D+ 0H* * (#) *,& ( K= 5."-&,- 5 F 34=+ 250 &R- - D $,65,& ( $ 5,* G ) < 5 * F < 41$ *(1 8F(L, * $ 7-4F+,*6 A)7 5* 17X 5* 0 $,C*,*6 $ 0 7 & 34( 1 GF $ 4 0? + T+ & 3a $ 0 W1999 W1985 1?) 1* Q1D# 1$ $ #..( B.1** 3- D $ 5 B.* C 6 )7 1 1! (5 0.L * ( =-,65 Q1=* :1( M) %& 3*,( $ " "\& :( 4- M) %& * *,(?;? R* * B&*.( [0&- - 0 D.*#6 :( - * (.,&1 (D- ) 5& 0L <X+ $ < 5 0 3F,( * 4-X 5* * * # * %1+ :1( *#N,$*8 $,& A)7 G < 5 K- 0 & :(,( ( A)7 $ 5?& 3(Joint Venture) Q 1 1!,1-25 <-- 5* 05 :( 7?&* &+ b-l.(the World Bank 1984 W1999?) 109

10 ,* - * - (. / C5+ # # 4-3 1*6 %1 01 <) 17 7&) T* * BDL M** 1* <1*& G 0 < #* S 3* Q?; $ (05 Q-.,,.* (; ],- 5 2.* < 1-X 1( (! * M) - 3=,=. GF,& < :1; F- 5 ( 5* 3Q )=* 05 G #* $ 0 Q1-* * 4-X 3Q )=* E #* 7+ *- 5 ) 0 < 1D <1.,61 C $ 7 #* *6 $* D <+.2L (K) 1* 1( 45-1 " (5 ( Q-*- &,?** :1( 41+ (5 A)7 * 3Q )=* E 5 G#* * ) 05 1*6, " :( - [0&- %& 3= *6, )17 :( D 3 ** D* $ 5 *6 -X :(.(Traditional) 5* <L #* <L 1&R* C $ #* *6 <+ =* 3 BD 5( R- 5 B.** 3 $* 3 K* 305,?* (& 3M) 0 < 5 ( -* S 1=!,$ R* :; 5 <L )7 3RD 0 < <&* 0 $.0 G# :( (E*) E. $ R* L Q=* ( 05 K*- 0?! 5* 5 G 5*- 5 8 B.** )7 0-# *,( :( B! -* $ "- * M) :; BF <1*& G #* * * 5?&* 3(The World Bank 1984) 0 < 110

11 :; 5* 05.( 07; G,( )=* :( -L,&.(Morgan and Kamil 1982 W1990?) =F 0 " G4 5* (; *.*# 7C * "7C.*#6 7C 7+ I; :05 & 3( ;) $5 :(1999 W W ;) 7-0L %N,5* 05* & "*,6 "?.=* 0., 9*! *6 0* M)& 3 -( *6,6 "?.7(?, "*,& G *6 "1? 1& 1C* "(; V- 0.*#6 $ H*.2 QD M-..*#6,C R* "# (.*.((1999 ) S,N) "*,C 5 *Y <-L :; F, $ "7C * ]? )117 :(The World Bank 2000; Sakbani 1998 W1999 a %*-) :1; DD.*#6 # * *$ *6..*# K= < ) 4(,+- * "* -H..*#6 *? :( 0 8H; &? 0L 05* :( ( ),6.*6 0 $ -& 5* 5* D* ( 4F$ 3*-&? $? DHF - 05**,-.+ * 111

12 ,* - * - (. V*,& G.* & 0 ),,. QD# $.=* 0 $ A)1 1 G# -$ 3- * (. $,* ( C $ 4 7)=* * * "-&,(. (. :7 * (. $ 7C T+ -* 0 ' =# / =, % M) - ],- +-* 3A)=* 0- * Q 15* C $ (.) *6 <*& :* 3* D.*.5 :( Q bd * M) - 3.* 0(R- 5 05* [0&- + 31&* <1L-,(1 )=* A*6? * G 1 *1 )=*.* $ - Q 0 0&- " & B&* 1 15( 41 E1( D + 3(Turnkey) b*= * 5- B.(Engineering, Procurement and Construction EPC) * *6 1D# $ 5( G#* "( + $ * (. $ A*6 )7 C 31& :1; 0.* ; B&*- & *-,( ; Z- * * 7 5( & -C -+ & G#* M)& )=* Q )7 45( &,# 4F *# Q )7 "; 4F+ ")= & :** 3& =&*- 1-D?1H 01* -1,( G#*- M)&,# 3EH*.(MEED 1998) 1$ 1-?1& 3b*= * <R- "( 5( G#* * - $ $ * *6 <+ * ( 4F$ 3,-,.(Olivir 1996) ]L,( 112

13 ..; = " / B1-.1., -D* :; 0 7H& - 0,R 1* 1,6*6 :( <H* * $ " =& G$ *($1?1 1$ S ) -&? <5(+ $. 3 * 1 &1* 1* 01-* 0 K= F* DHF *.(1988 ) ND-* 1 & 32 QD5 :; QD5, & )1=*- 21 Q1D5 # 3.. G : $ ; BF + M1) 345- QD5 & :( ".5,&, 5*,( 01 C,+- #.(1988 )?* 5( -( &*6 *-D <-- 1$ 2 QD5 b R* X - 1 QD5 :( 4& - $,& L - 7)=*,( 0*.(Smith et al. 1997) - 7 L -,( $ 2 QD5 7 "? T+ &)- b1._ M- *5 * V- - (Economic Stabilization).*#6,-* ( F *R* *.*#6 * :; (* *, 7 3(Structural Adjustment) & B&* b1 3 QD5 &,.. :;. (*.*#6 :( 4& - $,& H* 7*,( 0* $ 2 QD5.(+1999 :( W W1999 +) QD5 1* )1 17 3Privatization?1! OD OD E1= OD.1 ]1+ 1-(,$ * &)- 3# A)7 $ E*.(1999 V W1999 W1988 ) C *.*..* 1 113

14 ,* - * - (. <1-7* L -,( 0* $ 2 QD5 7 ** 1* 21 QD5 * - & - (Concession)?* 5(. * :( $* K$ -( 0* "* Q (1 $ *=*,- ;.. V- - 0 C,-* # # 3.. ( $ "-& 4D+,D# - 0 K- ; 0-3 E1$7+ 1+ & (.*#6 b.! V- )=* 4$., ( 1(! E*&7 EC* S QD5 $ C "(; Mohieldin W1998 ( W1998 #) 2 QD5 7 "? M)& E* 97 *.1.,1* *,& ( Z ( :* 3(and Nasr 1996 (1& ). E * &.(1999 ) :1( <1 %. S 1990 (.. V- +- <H $ A ,T* 1996 ( :* D! 1& W1999 V1) ( * 7) -H (1999 1*(6 B )1,N &7 "(; $,+- 5$ %* + 1( 1$ 3( W1988 ( -) 2 QD5 :( * 155 &+?; * 1996 ( :*.. 5 D! GF * *16 V1- -D*- 8?,+- M)& 3(1999 %-().. ( 1* $ M) 5. G =*6-.*#6 (,-*) 1-) (.. %-.. KH 2? ;.(1999 "( 114

15 V1 G1-**,1& 1* - 0 :(.. V- -D*.*5.1. 1, ; 3.*#6 * $ DD.*#6 3 QD5 -& $* 6 *.*# V** * - 0,-1*&.*#6 D 8F - E$ QD5 0 ) L =$ 1?( 4 L &,( ( ) C* )1=* 1L 1&,( (.. - )L 2 QD5 7 "? V- )7 F* 1992 (.*#6 b._ - $ 3(1999 W1988 B ) L -,( )=* $ 1( - 0&* * 5$ 8-15?* 6 QD5 + X Q1D5 "? V -* + 0&- *.. (.* GF 1992.(1999 :() H* *; L - G 07R* $ 2 ( D,+- 5$ 3.. & ( ]R $ - V 0 &*,+1-1* V1 0 : (.. - )L 187,(-,& $ 3(Shaikh 1999 W1999 ) L -..-,1H :* 1994 "*= $ & 17 $.. *& *6 1 0,1(+ 3&+ 6 2 &+.. V-. 1$ 21 QD5 5- *-X ( "* -,!& ]+.(Ghalib 1999) L -,( )=* 0* G1* 1#,+ ; 5* =-.. & * &* $ 2 QD5 < # 5. *6 $ G* * IJ ( 8-57 :; 1980 ( ( W1999 ) QD5 ( * (; 2 QD5,* 115

16 ,* - * - (.,6.1*6 Q1D# 1$,( 0*- 2 QD5 b * # 3(1999. QD5 :( 4& - $,& * *..; = " ; < "71C.1*#6,1* - -L *6- *76 "? * 1R-,*6 A)7? <)* + GD** * 0 :; C 3 1.*# :; F6 IJ.*#6- D-*6 :( "# &L.(Görg and Greenway 2004 W2003 ) -L * $ 0 7 & - 0 *7? # *1 1#.; $ M) :* 3,* "*$ $ 2 0&- - F1** S 3 *6 # 0* B* $ " <8F1 K=* 3-L *6, ; D-* 5 A)7 C *1 M1* :1( F=,& * 5 H; ( 4F$ 3E- D-* G1 1$ *6 $ <L * b + 0.L <L 1& 31 QD5 :( + 2 QD5 :( - $ ".,& <)1 V1* 0&* * ",87 ; 5 A)7,F*.(Alessandrini 2000 W1997 N) -L,*6 V1-1F *R - 0 $ - -L *6 + &)- Q1D5 $ K-.. 4-X F** *.*#6 b._ &*,& :(,& * M) * 3 %40 E*- 0& - -L *6 I; c)d; 3(2001 -D,7) Fujita W1999 ) $..,8(.(

17 1993 1( - 0 $ "- -L,*6,? # ) (Fujita 2001 W2000eDL) %50 75 D L *6 -.? 5$ - 1X ( :; "*= $ 4 6,1( + 6; ( & :;,*6 A)7 2#* Fujita W1997 1N) & Z-* 2000 ( $?*.(2001 (" ( 8(; '! (BOT ) 0? =@ (Build, Operate and (,-) (0* 305) "(! 0H* - C B 1 & AF*5- O* G 0* 0&+ 0& ER- Transfer BOT) 4?1* Q1 &1 :(.,*6 +? "*= 1 E*; EH* E8-- Q & 5* )8( W Q f. 34* EH* Q 0H* 4-+ 5* - B&* **, 1 W1998 1) & :; Q & 05** 3?*6 " $.(2000,(1 01* 1#*,-** ( B* )7,* 9* 01* 8*16 1-3BO 0H* - :0 C )7 $ 7)=* 1* 1#*,-** M) X 3BOO 0H* M*6-3BLT 1L 1-,(1 0* $ 2 QD5 & $ M** W2000 ) QD5 :( - $ ".5,& * H* 7)=*.(

18 ,* - * - (. 1$ 1 45-,&) * 7C G E+ OF* <L )7 B* EH* A)=* Q.*,N 4* 0 $ 3- * (. :( 4& - $,&,(.. 0 & 3" $ E*."- -+,* -( 4-X A)=* * 3 QD5 - - $ L -,( )=* <L )7 * ( L )1=* <1L )7-0 C,-* S 34 "& $,1D )=*,- <+ * *. =$ 3E5$ L -,(,6.1*6 g1,1d D < A 8-& #D * 1$,(1 A)17 K-, # ( ) M) & & (Askar and Gab-Allah 2002 W2000 ) 4 0H* (Butter 1995; MEED 1D,( 0* <L )7 * $ M)& Q * 3,- D $ $ K- )=* 4F+ E* * 31998) R1 1# 3(MEED 1998; Olvier 1996) -,- F $ &_ 18-& 1#D *,( )=*,- <+ * :; M)& L 1,1D! < A-?*,( M)& (+1999 ) M)& <L )7 -D* * 3(MEED 1998) ** -,( 7X 1( 1 1$,^1 K1-1; E* :( L $.(Sommer1999),1# $,+- * - 0 <H %*,& 3- <H $ 0*,- <+ * * # 3 QD5.. V- -D* $ &- D g 8-& #D,D& L - "(,( )=*.(Butter and Kemp 1999; Sommer 1999) 7X 118

19 3L -,( )=* <L )7 :; 7- - V 0,R 1-& 1D )=* * S 30 )7 $ #- 0 (,& S <+ -D* * & 3(Ghalib 1999; Shaikh 1999 W+1999 ),- <R- (Ali 1996; MEED.1 B. A,( $ g $,- )=* 0* "* -,! E** & 31998; Sommer 1999) (Ghalib 1999; Ward 1999; Sommer g1 18-& #D,( <1+ *1-,& $,( D* * 31999).(MEED 1998),-,6.1*,(1 01* 1$ <L )7 * * 5$ $ + 1D 1 05,( $ E* $ & :* 3&.(2004 "?) g M& ' " 1-5 "1*,&1 b "- -L,*6 + 0 O*$ ; 0& 3C (# $ 0 L 0-5 1* 1 1C+ # =**,& *,& 455 4* 1**,1& * QD5,& M) 3-0 C F=* 1 =**,& * 2 QD5,& + 3 $ C-.*6 5* & 01 1C $ * (. 4 4* 0&* + )7,615,&1 *6,& 0? :; N* 3- *,* $ 0* ( E- G*** 0&- 3- L :; "=*6 * L K=* :( (,# 3&*,- L 119

20 ,* - * - (. 7* F * *? :( 48-( 0&* 6 D* S- V-.,? 5* * * + 0 -( 5$L '5 6 =6 " 2-5,1,1* G1 05*6 "? H; $ * 15* 015?1?* $ * + & $ M)- 30-5*,&*-6 -* + 6; 32. E :( - 0 4( 0 $ D* 4 "5=) # A)7 $ F( * * - * (. $,* *1 & 4-X *,.* %& A*6 $ 0* + -* 3(A(+,(1 )1=* ( N * I; c)d; 3D* 5* 05 *# 5&,& :; -L,& "=*6 &; G *,&1 + & 3(1990?) (= L D-) (?& + O- 5* :(?&* 4-X - 0 $ *6- O * 45* 0#L,& 9*\ b 0 M) S1-,D1 :( 5-! 0 M)& 3(2003 V-) 5* 0&1* + 3(1985 E W1986 ) L $ D*.- 0 $ D* 5* * 455 4* 5@. 7 3G5,8 A)7 :( <** 38 G$,8 & :( D* N - -L *6$ 3(2002 +),DH K- $ Q# &; :( E+ 6; 3*6 $ * =F 5 0 "? :; A)17 b-+,8( 9 ( 5.*# 8 :; N # -L ].]+ 0 :; -L,*6 9* ( +,*6 120

21 1$ 0** "- hg$ $ & ; BOT "(! 0H* - C + & 155 $ E+ 6; C )7 -D* * - 0,? ( < B=* 01* 5D $ D5$ 4H* 0.*#6 0* L i- $ L E1\$ I1J 3- $ D :( :5-8 0* <( I; c)d;.1*#6 01 B&* G$ :( D 5* 0* <+ AH& :1L 7 - & &? G$ % =F 5.(UNIDO 1996 W2000 ) 1* (1. $ ( G$ :; C.*# \$ E( j - );. D :( D ( * * B&* < -.- ] $ - *,( )=* $,&,* ' =. -6 E*1 E$ # G# + :( 0* - 6-1,& &! # B=* E$ &,-!??*??* ; & * 08 7L K( *^ $ 3(1999 ) E,& " B=* - * (. $ "=*6 2$ :- * -,( :( "7C A) - *6 1-6 * *,( B&* G$ < :;,( 5* N "1*$ 01* 15* "*$ ** + &R* * (. V* 0* 1 1&R* I1J 3(2002 +) Q ( 0& 0* S- D? 1 &R* 0* * " C * :( -** G$ *.5.*#6 0 :( =&* G A)7 G$?* 121

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

23 01 D* 5* 05 :( - 0.; &R* "F )7 1(, ;, -* M) $ - 3& 08 G- M) 5* :(.D* 5* 05 4D1 -L,& G,#* F* :( &R* 0 )7 $ H- A)7 )=* $ 7 D& 3-0 :; 5* 05 :; B* - +,& G,$*8 $ 0 -( *;,( :1( 1&R* M)& 3(D- ),#*,& )=* -( + )1=* "*$ 0& 0 Dk <* ( $ -L,& 7.(2004? W2000 ) Q,*1-1F, +, =(; 5* + 4F+ - 0 & & 1D* :1(?&* 3(2003 V-) $ 5* D* 05 :( D* *.- 0 BC - $ )R*,( )=*,5* 5 & * & $ 3D* 5* 05 -& * 5 D* S- 31* 1 E. D* S-- *76 5* D* S1-15 1* 1; E* * -1 %1 0&1* 31 $ 4F=,* &+ 7 3D* - 8- "( -?** 6 3(2004?) 0 - :..(2002 V- W1999 *) 5* 0 5=* * 3D* S-- *76 "? - 0 & 6 91*; 1$ *6 -( 3,D A)? 2.* -( M) V-) 4-( $ <*& :; N 5* 4 $.(

24 ,* - * - (. D* S-,D (, :-** + 0 )7 $ - 0 :( 1; 01 M) * + & 3*- G.* -,D A)7 D- D1 S1-?& ; 3D* S-,D (..*. A)7 0* S- 3* - QD# =* G.*,(D# $..* * S- 3*,( $,&-, D- :(?& 15-D* 1 G-1D,) S1- :( &R* D?& A)7 0.(2004 W2003 V-) 5-6 ".L G :( * + M* :(?1?* 1 1- $ IJ (*6.*#6 $ * ( -( ** -* &* -,N :1( 01-6 * -. :( 3(2002 V-),6 G 5 * < *& 85 &* -,N??* 1* 1- (. $ < - 0 & M)& 3< :1; B1* *,6 G $ M) - $,# D- ( :(.* =& *# "? - * - (.??* 124

25 , 1-7 N,&6 -L :.(1999) $* 37-; 3<Y 1= $5 D % 34 *. ( C /-*& ,& & : I $.0 : <.(2000) 3eDL 1* ) 0. 8 '! 4 0..,- 3- ",?& " #7 ".(1998)? 3-- *N <*& -,$*86.(2001) ,1H* 0C $ 0L - *6.2001/9/26,(1 "; 1* 5( $,7*6.(1997) 3."75 3% ( 3 & 3* 3 0H1* - 5( C *6 0&* C -.(2000) 3 3A1*& 3 0 $ L -,( * $ 05."75 3% ( 3 &.0-5* :; " (,-) 05 0H* - C (2001) M'.19-15,1* 01C 1$ - *6 %.(+2001) 3 1-1*6 *N +.*,#*.2001/9/ ,H* 0C $ 0L 125

26 ,* - * - (. 31 1$ * - QD# D* **.(2004) 3 DD* 87 $ * - QD# D* :; 5 0( #. 3" X 3 $ 3(1)?.(1990) = 3 W. 3 W*$ 3.. 3, 1989) <1H 1$.1. ( $a..(1999) 3V 3 ".. #7? $ (1996.,- 3- ",?&.1 L & $..*.(1988) 3B 3 1 :1* 3( " ' $.-C ( *('4 (" (.G@ * ".(1999) 7-; 3." '2 <H $.. -*. 5* -5.(1999) :=D. 3&?1& 3 ".. #7? $.,- 3- ", (" ( N *6.(1999) a -H (*6.*#6.M 3"* L 3.? 65 ( / (5# *6.(+1999) a -H (*6.*#6 3"1* 1L 3(.? (" :+ 0 = " H ' # 5.M <(.7 I%( (...(2003) 1a -H (*6.*#6 ; <.7 O. :.? 65 " ; 126

27 3 ; 7., H.M 3"* L = " <.7 O 6.(1997) *6 F - N."75 37L N 3125.*#6 7L <*& $.L F5 &,.*..*.(1988) 3 31 :* 3 " '.-C D $ * $ S-?&.(1999)? 3* " B D # 3.(1998) 0 3+."75 ( 9(1 ( ( (.(1999) 0 3+.,- 3- ",?& PA; ( ( (6 ".. #7.(2002) 3+.,- 3-= 3 B $ :* 3 1$.1&* 1 G1 5*.(1985).B.B 3,- 0 # & 5#; ".. D(7 0 #7 '! "1,1?1& 3" 6< * 0 *;!,.,- 3- (1*6.1*#6 _ -. 8! "* L V- = (S 4 E 2002 *.? 6.(2002).- 0 #! <*&

28 ,* - * - (. (1*6.1*#6 _ -. 8! "* L V-,( ( # *.? 6.(2003).- 0 #! <*& 3" 1$..*#6,.! $ 8? -*.(1999) -( 3"( -?1& 3( ( ".. #7?.,- 3- ", $ 7 $7+ %* $..* (1988) 3( :* 3 " '.-C ,1-3-1 W.;,- 3* W.?,- 3% W 3%*- 0& :* 34 0 C 4 :.(1999)."75 3 * 7L?& *#6 0&*,F,*.(1999) = 3 * $ &*6, S-L?& 3N' *6 <*& <. - G.(2001) %-( *6 <*& - *,&;,#D - 31,H* 0C $ 0L - *6 *N /9/ C+ 01C $ 0 %+ &* & - D*.(1999).( 3 1$.1(*6.1*#6 E*1& $ *6 G*?1& 3( ( ".. #7?.,- 3- ", 128

29 3<17 1-( D( :* 3?.(1985) D+ 3?.,- 3- ",?&.(.2 ( (. :( (1990) D+ 3? 31- "1,?& ,-?& 3@ *6 6 * I.(1999) D+ 3?.,- 3- ", &( : I $.5* *.(2000) D+ 3? 1* ) 0. 8 '! 4 0..,- 3- ",?& D15 :1( <H** + - 5*,5 & B&.(2004) D+ 3? ",?& 3 =6..7 =F (6 0 (! = (1986) 3.,& 3<Y = $5 D % 3107 $ ( 1- D1 1$ &* **.(1994) " B* + "F $... & b.! $ %* -*.(1999) B. 3%-(?1& 3( ( ".. #7?.,- 3- ", 129

30 ,* - * - (. 1$ Q1D# :.(1999) (?1& 3( ( ".. #7?.,- 3- ", 1.,* 0C $.(1998) ED 3(.() 0-; 20 3"75 3P #7 * ; 1$ 1- $...*#6 b.!.(1999) < 3:(?1& 3( ( ".. #7?.,- 3- ", -H (*6.*#6 0 $...(+1999) < 3:( (.. #7? $ Q*.*#6,) (&!) a.,- 3- ",?& 3 " * + " D G " P #7 T?.(1998) : 3#."75 3"L -*& 3<*&. 8 3 I (,.(1998) * 5 "* L (, ( F( = =" / / 56 "1 31 3"* L 3 / 56.M 3 :1D 1-(,&1 D ( &* 05.(1985).+.9 3E (.. $." <L G 5-5* <L ( ('! 0 # & 5#; " *(; (!,( D7 0 #7.,- 3- ",?& 3" 6< * 0 130

31 ( (#7 :( (.(2001) 7 3-D 0-3,7 % 3273 $ ( 3- -( O$ :* 3* 1.,& 3<Y = $5 D :1; "! G..* Y.(1988) *& 3 *- 37 3( ( " ' $.- -.-C :*. 3 <.7 5.(2004) - $ 05 "? -*& 3<*&. 8 3& < E5.(1999) 3."75 3"L 131

32 ,* - * - (. 2-7 Alessandrini, Sergio (2000). FDI in the MENA Region Third International Development Forum, Cairo, 5-8 March. Ali, P. Mohammed (1996). Case Study: The Muscat Municipal Wastewater Project Developed on a BOOT Basis. in Proceedings of MEIDC Middle East Infrastructure Development Congress, Dubbai, October. Askar, Mohamed M. and Gab-Allah, Ahmed A. (2002). Problems Facing Parties Involved in Build, Operate, and Transfer Projects in Egypt. Journal of Management in Engineering, Vol. 18, No. 4, october, pp Austen, A.D. (1985). Construction in Third World Countries- Developing Appropriate Managing Skills. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers, Part 1, Vol. 78, pp Butter, David (1995). Foreign Finance Fuels Projects. MEED -Middle East Economic Digest, 22 December, pp Butter, David and Kemp, peter (1999). Getting There. MEED -Middle East Economic Digest, 12 March, pp. 2-3 Fujita, Masataka (2001). FDI Flows in the League of Arab States: Some Recent Statistical and Brief Overview of the Current Legal Framework for Investment. The Arab Bank Review, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp Ghalib, Sharif (1999). The Financial and Capital Market Implications of Privatizing the Energy Sector in the Gulf. in Privatization and Deregulation in the Gulf Energy Sector, The Emirates Center for Strategic Studies and Research ECSSR, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. Görg, Holger and Greenway, David (2004). Much Ado about Nothing? Do Domestic Firms Really Benefit from Foreign Direct Investment. The World Bank Research Observer, The World Bank, Oxford University Press, Vol. 19, No. 2, pp Hillebrandt, Patricia M. (1985). Economic Theory and the Construction Industry, Macmillan, Second Edition, London. MEED (1998). MEED Special Report: Construction. MEED -Middle East Economic Digest, 9 January, pp Morgan, Peter R. and Kamil M. H. (1982). Contract arrangements in the Third World. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 132

33 American Society of Civil Engineers ASCE, Vol. 108, No. EI4, October, pp Mohieldin, Mahmoud, and Nasr, Sahar (1996). On Privatization in Egypt with Reference to the Experience of Czech Republic and Mexico. in Privatization in Egypt: The Debate in the People s Assembly, Edited by: Wadouda Badran and Azza Wahby, Center for Political Research and Studies, Cairo University, Cairo. Neale, R. (1995). Managing International Construction Projects: An Overview, International Labour Office, Geneva. Olivier, Charles (1996). Lebanon s Private Capital Crunch Project & Trade Finance, August 1, p. 37. Sakbani, Michael (1998). Pivotal Countries in a Two-Track World: Regionalization and Globalization Cooperation South, United Nations Development Program UNDP, No. 1, pp Shaikh, Abdul Hafeez (1999). Privatization of Energy Sector in the Gulf: Selected Issues and Options. in Privatization and Deregulation in the Gulf Energy Sector, The Emirates Center for Strategic Studies and Research ECSSR, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. Smith, Graham R.; Shafik, Nemat; Guislain, Pierre; and Reichert, James A. (1997). Getting Connected: Private Participation in Infrastructure in the Middle East and North Africa, The World Bank, Washington D.C. Sommer, Dirk (1999). Private Participation in Port Facilities Recent Trends. Public Policy for the private Sector, Note No. 193, The World Bank, September. The World Bank (1984). The Construction Industry: Issues and Strategies in Developing Countries, Washington D.C., USA. The World Bank (2000). Entering the 21st Century-World Development Report 1999/2000, Washington D.C. UNIDO (1996). UNIDO BOT Guidelines Guidelines for Infrastructure Development through Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) Projects, United Nations Industrial Development Organization, Vienna. Ward, Andrew (1999). The Legal Framework for Privatization in the United Arab Emirates. in Privatization and Deregulation in the Gulf Energy Sector, The Emirates Center for Strategic Studies and Research ECSSR, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates..2004/11/9 :; S- `* 133