07/2015. Accessible devices for people with a visual impairment

Transcription

1 07/2015 Accessible devices for people with a visual impairment

2 Tested devices The selected devices have been tested by an independent panel of people with a disability, coordinated by the non-profit association Passe-Muraille. This evaluation is based on predefined accessibility criteria taking into account the specific needs of the majority of people belonging to the same disability category. We therefore do not guarantee that these devices can be optimally used by all people recognized as belonging to the disability category concerned. This catalog will be updated regularly.

3 Advantages of the devices We recommend these devices to people with a visual impairment because of their programmable keys, vibrate function, and the possibility to assign a ringtone to a contact (caller identification through the It is important to note that all the devices running Android Ice Cream Sandwich have the following adaptations as standard: An accessibility menu. An advanced voice synthesis and voice command system for calling, texting, etc. Voice synthesis is available in French and English by default. For Dutch, an appropriate module should be downloaded: SVOX LENA DUTCH. However, with Android 5.0, the Dutch version is available by default in most devices. A practical screen reader (Talkback) which can be used directly for calling, texting, etc. but not for reading web pages or with certain incompatible applications. However, with Android 5.1, the screen reader can read websites and most applications. An explore by touch screen system with effective spoken feedback describing all the standard features of the device. The drop-down menu can be blocked: this enables better scrolling control. Tactile navigation requires the use of two fingers for scrolling and a double tap for selecting. 1. Activation of screen reader: Settings Accessibility Activate Talkback 2. Activation of tactile navigation: Settings Accessibility Activate Tactile navigation It should be noted that the most recent, and most complete, versions of Android OS integrate the activation of tactile navigation when the device is switched on for the first time.

4 List of tested devices A ACER Zest+ ACER Z530 Alcatel Shine Lite Apple iphone 5S Apple iphone 6 Apple iphone 6 Plus Apple iphone 7 Plus H Huawei Ascend P7 Huawei P8 Huawei Ascend P9 Huawei Mate 10 Pro Huawei P20 PRO L LG G3 LG G4 LG G4C LG G5 SE LG G6 LG Q6 LG V30 LG X CAM LG X Screen N Nokia 1 Nokia 3 Nokia 5 Nokia 8 S Samsung A3 Samsung A5 Samsung A8 Samsung Galaxy Alpha Samsung Galaxy Note 7 Samsung Galaxy Note 8 Samsung Galaxy S5 Samsung Galaxy S5 mini Samsung Galaxy S8+ Samsung Galaxy Xcover 3 Samsung J7 Sony Xperia M2 Aqua Sony Xpéria M5 Sony Xpéria XZ Premium

5 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation ACER Zest+ Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device, but limited. Mid-range Android device. to use the device. - 5

6 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation ACER Z530 Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. (Limited) possibilities of enlarging the font of the menus. Possibility to adjust brightness and color temperature but not contrast. to operate the device. - 6

7 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Alcatel Shine Lite Quite a complete phone in terms of its accessibility menu but the options are sometimes underdeveloped The shortcut to the accessibility menu is activated via the side button Color correction but only one choice (red-green deuteranopia) Fragile-looking body The largest font size is still small to operate the device

8 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Apple iphone 5S (IOS 7) Fast configuration of the Accessibility mode on initial set-up. Very complete accessibility menu. Effective voice command. Image quality +++ but very narrow screen. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Fast configuration of the Accessibility mode on initial set-up. Very complete accessibility menu. Effective voice command. Voice Over: voice synthesis comes as standard (it not only reads all the menus and apps, but also web content). NB: Voice Over requires the user to have prior knowledge of how it works. Supports braille displays.

9 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Apple iphone 6 (IOS 8) Fast and easy configuration of the Accessibility mode via itunes on a computer. Very complete accessibility menu. Effective voice command. Image quality +++ Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Fast and easy configuration of the Accessibility mode via itunes on a computer. Very complete accessibility menu. Effective voice command. Voice Over: voice synthesis comes as standard (it not only reads all the menus and apps, but also web content). NB: Voice Over requires the user to have prior knowledge of how it works. Supports braille displays. 9

10 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Apple iphone 6 plus (IOS 8) Fast and easy configuration of the Accessibility mode via itunes on a computer. Very complete accessibility menu. Effective voice command. Image quality +++ Large screen. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device Fast and easy configuration of the Accessibility mode via itunes on a computer. Very complete accessibility menu. Effective voice command. Voice Over: voice synthesis comes as standard (it not only reads all the menus and apps, but also web content). NB: Voice Over requires the user to have prior knowledge of how it works. Supports braille displays. 1

11 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation iphone 7 plus (IOS 10) Fast and easy configuration of the Accessibility mode via itunes on a computer. Very complete accessibility menu Magnifier function. Effective voice command. Image quality +++ Large screen. Adjustment of brightness by reducing white points. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via App Store. to operate the device. Fast and easy configuration of the Accessibility mode via itunes on a computer. Very complete accessibility menu. Effective voice command. Voice Over: voice synthesis comes as standard (it not only reads all the menus and apps, but also web content). NB: Voice Over requires the user to have prior knowledge of how it works. Supports braille displays.

12 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Huawei Ascend P7 Limited accessibility menu available on initial setup of the device. (Limited) possibilities of enlarging the font of the menus. Possibility to adjust brightness and color temperature but not contrast. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Limited accessibility menu. Capacitive screen responsive to fingers. Only drawback: the standard screen reader does not yet allow Internet surfing and is not compatible with all Play Store apps. Explore by Touch screen comes as standard with learning module for the interface. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store.

13 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation - Huawei P8 Changes in font size are not applied to the menus. Standard Explore by Touch screen with learning module for the interface, but only in English. The screen reader does not allow you to read all web and other data. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voice-synthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. 13

14 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Huawei Ascend P9 Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. (Limited) possibility to enlarge the menu font. Possibility to adjust brightness and color temperature but not contrast. to use the device. Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. Explore by Touch screen comes as standard with learning module for the interface. 14

15 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation HUAWEI Mate 10 PRO Accessibility menu seems complete but has certain limitations (inexistant or incoherent functions)

16 Assessment Model Comments Possible adaptation HUAWEI P20 PRO Accessibility menu relatively complete, but missing certain options such as font size.

17 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation LG G3 Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial set-up of the device. High-quality capacitive screen. Basic voice commands in English, French, etc. but not in Dutch. Targeted blocking of touch control areas. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial set-up of the device. Capacitive screen responsive to fingers. Only drawback: the standard screen reader does not yet allow Internet surfing and is not compatible with all Play Store apps. Explore by Touch screen comes as standard with learning module for the interface. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. 17

18 Evaluation Model Comments LG G4 Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). TalkBack enabled on all media ( , texting, menu, Internet, etc.) in French and Dutch. Inductive-based charging available as standard. Alternative (Touch assistant) for all commands on the back of the device via a floating button present on all screens: volume adjustment, one-finger zoom, etc. as well as calling, ing and texting directly via a simple gesture on the screen. Possible adapation Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). TalkBack enabled on all media ( , texting, menu, Internet, etc.) in French and Dutch. Inductive-based charging available as standard. Alternative (Touch assistant) for all commands on the back of the device via a floating button present on all screens: volume adjustment, one-finger zoom, etc. as well as calling, ing and texting using a simple gesture on the screen. 18

19 Evaluation Model Comments LG G4C Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). TalkBack enabled on all media ( , texting, menu, Internet, etc.) in French and Dutch. Inductive-based charging available as standard. Alternative (Touch assistant) for all commands on the back of the device via a floating button present on all screens: volume adjustment, one-finger zoom, etc. as well as calling, ing and texting directly via a simple gesture on the screen. Possible adapation Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). TalkBack enabled on all media ( , texting, menu, Internet, etc.) in French and Dutch. Inductive-based charging available as standard. Alternative (Touch assistant) for all commands on the back of the device via a floating button present on all screens: volume adjustment, one-finger zoom, etc. as well as calling, ing and texting using a simple gesture on the screen. 19

20 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation LG G5 SE (Android 6) Very complete, clear, and intuitive accessibility menu, available on initial set-up. Large, very good-quality screen. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via App Store. to operate the device. Very complete, clear, and intuitive accessibility menu, available on initial set-up. 2

21 People with a visual impairment vibra alert function, and the possibility to assign a ringtone to a contact (caller identification through the Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation LG G6 All features of the device can be enlarged, including the apps Possibility of putting text in bold Possibility of downloading and configuring screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via App Store. to operate the device - Talkback did not work in the device tested (to be checked) 21

22 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation LG Q6 Accessibility menu fairly complete for an affordable price Certain accessibility criteria are not optimal The larger font sizes are not very large. For talkback, French and Dutch have to be downloaded

23 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation LG V30 6" screen Double-click to turn phone back on Possibility of putting text in bold Extensive but not complete accessibility menu to operate the device

24 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation LG X CAM (Android 6) Very complete, clear, and intuitive accessibility menu, available on initial set-up. Large, very good-quality screen. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via App Store. to operate the device. Very complete, clear, and intuitive accessibility menu, available on initial set-up. Voice synthesis in English (possibility to download other languages). "Read aloud" option for reading messages and information about the caller or sender of a message. 2

25 Evaluation Model Comments LG X Screen Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). 2 front screens. TalkBack enabled on all media ( , texting, menu, Internet, etc.) in English on set-up but possibility to download other languages for free. Voice notification for messages and calls: read aloud function for information about the caller and messages. Possible adapation to operate the device. Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). 2 front screens. TalkBack enabled on all media ( , texting, menu, Internet, etc.) in English on set-up but possibility to download other languages for free. Voice notification for messages and calls: read aloud function for info about the caller and messages. 25

26 People with a visual impairment We recommend these devices for people with a visual impairment because of their programmable keys, vibra alert function, and the possibility to assign a ringtone to a contact (caller identification through the Assessment Model Comments Possible adaptation Nokia 1 Low-cost device with some interesting accessibility options, to be assessed by the future buyer. Voice synthesis but no screen reader. Rather limited options. Most of the applications have to be downloaded and installed before use.

27 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation - Nokia 3 Talkback available as standard in French and Dutch Easy switching between languages (written and vocal) Relatively complicated menu Lightweight and not very convincing enlargement of characters to operate the device 27

28 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Nokia 5 Relatively complicated menu Lightweight and not very convincing enlargement of characters Lowquality screen to operate the device 2

29 Assessment Model Comments Possible adaptation Nokia 8 The accessibility menu only configures adaptations for visual impairment. The slot for the micro-sim card is not very perceptible.

30 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation SAMSUNG A3 4.5-inch AMOLED screen Magnifying window which enlarges the screen content (3 magnifying sizes and zoom adjustment) Not all accessibility options offered are compatible with each other and require a choice to be made Possibility of configuring direct access to a selection of accessibility options to operate the device

31 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation SAMSUNG A5 Magnifying window which enlarges the screen content (3 magnifying sizes and zoom adjustment) Not all accessibility options offered are compatible with each other and require a choice to be made Possibility of configuring direct access to a selection of accessibility options to operate the device

32 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation SAMSUNG Galaxy A 8 Samsung accessibility menu very complete and well implemented Voice tags: possibility to link recorded voice comments to NFC tags Talkback is sometimes slow to react

33 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Samsung Galaxy Alpha Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. (Limited) possibilities of enlarging the font of the menus. Possibility to adjust brightness and color temperature but not contrast. Simplified mode with large-sized icons. Blocking of touch control areas. Character enlargement also enlarges all menus. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Accessibility menu available from initial set-up of the device. Accessibility can be configured according to category and/or criteria. Possibility to dim the screen for reasons of confidentiality. Voice synthesis available in French and Dutch. Explore by Touch screen comes as standard with learning module for the interface. Blocking of touch control areas. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. 33

34 Evaluation Model Comments Samsung Galaxy Note 7 7-inch phablet. Stylus included, which is stored in the device. Accessibility menu available on initial set-up of the device. High-quality screen. Precise, well-designed contrasts and colors. NB: the accessibility menu is limited. Possible adapation

35 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation SAMSUNG Galaxy Note 8 Samsung accessibility menu 6.3" screen 2 enlargement levels (zoom and font sizes) + magnifying glass Unlocking with face recognition Integrated stylus Arrival of "Bixby" but only in English

36 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation SAMSUNG Galaxy S5 Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). Color control, based on a color perception test. Integrated X5 digital magnifier. X3 screen zoom. Water- and dust-resistant device (NB: see manufacturer s recommendations). Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store.. to use the device. Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial set-up of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). Only drawback: the standard screen reader doesn t allow Internet surfing and is not compatible with all Play Store apps. Explore by Touch screen comes as standard with the learning module for the interface. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store.

37 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation SAMSUNG Galaxy S5 mini Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial setup of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). Color control, based on a color perception test. Integrated X5 digital magnifier. X3 screen zoom. Water- and dust-resistant device (NB: see manufacturer's recommendations). Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voice-synthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial setup of the device. Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions). Only drawback: the standard screen reader does not allow Internet surfing and is not compatible with all Play Store apps. Explore by Touch screen comes as standard with learning module for the interface. Possibility to dim the screen to ensure confidentiality. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voice-synthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store.

38 People with a visual impairment vibra alert function, and the possibility to assign a ringtone to a contact (caller identification through the Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation SAMSUNG Galaxy S8+ Very comprehensive accessibility menu available from first start-up of the device Ergonomic configuration via an interface which classifies the adaptations into special needs categories (sight, hearing, dexterity and interactions) Facial recognition, fingerprint scanner and iris scanner to secure the device No Dutch voice synthesis available as standard on the device tested (to be checked) Simple management of operations by means of head movements (lift head, turn head, etc.) via the camera Possibility of replacing all sliding movements by pressure movements Color control, based on a color perception test Integrated X5 digital magnifier X3 screen zoom Icon enlargement option but not very convincing Water- and dust-resistant device (NB: see manufacturer's recommendations) to operate the device

39 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Samsung Galaxy Xcover 3 Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial set-up of the device. Shortcuts and direct access to selected functions (accessibility, Talkback, negative colors, etc.) via 3 successive taps on the screen. 7 font sizes (from tiny to huge) and 5 different fonts to choose from, including one sans serif. Powerful zoom. Standard Explore by Touch screen with learning module for the interface, available in French and in Dutch as standard. The screen reader can be used on all media ( , texting, menu, Internet, etc.). Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voice-synthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. 3

40 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation SAMSUNG J7 Very high-quality, ultra-large screen The keyboard can be adjusted in size, color and contrast Font enlargement not applicable in all the features of the device Grey scale Button shading to make the buttons stand out from the background Negative colors Effective simplified mode to operate the device

41 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Sony Xperia M2 Aqua Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial set-up of the device. Accessibility can be configured according to category and/or criteria. Voice commands, voice synthesis, screen reader, accessible in French and in Dutch. Targeted blocking of touch control areas. Character enlargement also enlarges the menus. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. to operate the device. Very complete accessibility menu, available on initial set-up of the device. Accessibility can be configured according to category and/or criteria. Voice commands, voice synthesis, screen reader, accessibility in French and in Dutch. Explore by Touch screen comes as standard with learning module for the interface. Targeted blocking of touch control areas. Possibility to download and configure screen-reading, voicesynthesis and voice-command software in Dutch via Play Store. 41

42 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Sony Xpéria M5 Geen toegankelijkheidsmenu bij de start Geen spraakgegevens bij aankoop. Deze moeten gedownload worden. Het toestel kan gemakkelijker bediend worden door middel van een aangepaste stylus. Geen toegankelijkheidsmenu bij de start Geen spraakgegevens bij aankoop. Deze moeten gedownload worden. 4

43 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adapation Sony Xpéria XZ Premium The accessibility menu is limited. High quality large screen Light vibrations to operate the device. Sourd

44 Evaluation Model Comments Possible adaptation Sony Xperia XZ1 Compact Limited accessibility menu Small screen and therefore small fonts and limited enlargement Vibration barely perceptible to operate the device

45 Deaf Motor impairment Mental impairment Accessible fixed-line phones We recommend these phones for their large keys, high-contrast screen, and hands-free function. Visual impairment Hearing impairment Models Comments Maestro / Suitable - Not suitable +/- Can be used with its basic functions or with assistance Large white keys with large black characters or black keys with large white characters. Caller name and number display via the appropriate Proximus services. Hands-free function LED indicator for incoming calls Large backlit touch screen with medium-sized characters Possibility to double the volume of the handset via a button on the front of the phone. Adjustable speaker volume. 3 programmable direct dialling buttons. Directory for up to 10 numbers.

46 Deaf Motor impairment Mental impairment Accessible fixed-line phones We recommend these phones for their large keys, high-contrast screen, and hands-free function. Visual impairment Hearing impairment Models Comments Twist / + + Hands-free function with adjustable volume on the base station. This makes it easier to use the phone's call and answer functions. Moreover, the programmable call keys on the base station (with the possibility to place a photo in the button) make the phone very suitable for people with a mental or motor impairment or for the elderly. Need for training or assistance with the programming of extra functions for the blind and visually or mentally. Switch to the "T" position possible, but not very efficient. However, the adjustable volume via the handset and the amplification function allow you to listen at a comfortable level thanks to the loud, high-quality sound. + Suitable - Not suitable +/- Can be used with its basic functions or with assistance

47 Adapted rate plans If you want to call, text and surf freely, we recommend our Mobilus subscription from 15/month If you want to call, text and surf without exceeding your budget, we recommend our Mobilus Full Control subscription from 15/month If you want to combine your Mobilus or Mobilus Full Control subscription with an Internet, television and fixed telephony subscription, check out our Tuttimus offer Social rate People with a disability may, under certain conditions, be eligible to benefit from the social rate.

48 Customer service Our customer service can be reached: by phone: by If you would like to benefit from an even easier experience, you are welcome to visit our Proximus Centers. You can set up an appointment in order to be helped immediately and avoid having to queue.

49 More information Discover our complete offer on Do you have questions/comments about this catalog? You can send them to