PATENT LITIGATION ANALYSIS FOR. SAMPLE REPORT by Los Altos, CA

Transcription

1 PATENT LITIGATION ANALYSIS FOR SAMPLE REPORT by Los Altos, CA 1

2 PATENT LITIGATION ANALYSIS - GOLDEN BRIDGE CASES COMPANY OVERVIEW Golden Bridge Technology develops and licenses 3G W-CDMA technologies for wireless fixed broadband and wideband mobile communication markets. GBT was formed in 1995 by a consortium of telecommunication technology investors, scientists and intellectual property attorneys. GBT's primary business is the creation, licensing and enforcement of Wideband CDMA technology and intellectual property related thereto. 2

3 OVERVIEW OF ANALYSIS This report contains analysis of patent litigation cases involving the company Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. The following analyses were conducted: Patent litigation - filed and closed case details Party involvement Major defendants Year-wise case analysis Court information Judge information Patents in litigation Products in litigation Outcome of cases 3

4 GOLDEN BRIDGE TECHNOLOGY - PATENT LAWSUITS Golden Bridge Patent Lawsuits No. of cases Total patent lawsuits 35 Closed cases 34 Open case 1 Cases appealed in federal circuit 2 Golden Bridge as plaintiff 35 Golden Bridge as defendant 0 4

5 MAJOR DEFENDANTS Major defendants of Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. 5

6 CASE DETAILS Lawsuit Case Number Court Filing Date Closed Date Golden Bridge Technology Inc v. Apple Inc et al 5:12-cv California Northern District Court 9/18/2012 Open Case Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Company et al. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v Amazon.com, Inc. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Sony Electronics Inc. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Research In Motion Limited et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. LG Electronics, Inc. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Lenovo (United States), Inc. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Dell, Inc. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. ZTE (USA) Inc., et al. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Sierra Wireless, Inc., et al. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Pantech Corp., et al. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Motorola Mobility LLC 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Barnes & Noble Inc. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. HTC Corp. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 9/18/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Apple Inc., et. al. 2:12-cv California Central District Court 5/8/2012 9/11/2012 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Motorola Mobility LLC 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. ZTE Corporation et al. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Sony Electronics Inc. et al. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Company 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Research In Motion Limited et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. LG Electronics Inc. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. HTC Corp. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Pantech Corp et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Dell Inc. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Huawei Technologies Co. Ltd. 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /15/2012 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Sierra Wireless Inc. et al 1:12-cv Delaware District Court 4/13/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Amazon.Com Inc. et al 1:11-cv Delaware District Court 2/24/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology Inc. v. Apple Inc., et. al. 1:10-cv Delaware District Court 5/21/ /17/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. AT&T, Inc. et al 2:10-cv California Central District Court 5/20/2010 5/20/2010 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. LG Electronics Mobilecomm USA., Inc., 2:06-cv Texas Eastern District Court 1/11/2006 3/6/2007 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Nokia, Inc. 2:05-cv Texas Eastern District Court 4/15/2005 2/8/2007 Golden Bridge Technology v. Apple Inc Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit 7/5/2013 7/14/2014 Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. v. Lucent Technologies, Inc. et al Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit 3/16/2007 5/21/2008 6

7 CASE COUNTS BY YEAR Year-wise filing and closing trend of Golden Bridge patent cases No. of cases filed No. of cases closed

8 COURT DETAILS Court-wise case distribution of Golden Bridge patent cases. California Northern District Court 3% California Central District Court 5% CAFC (Appeal cases) 6% Court No. of Cases California Central District Court 2 Texas Eastern District Court 6% California Northern District Court 1 CAFC (appeal cases) 2 Delaware District Court 80% Delaware District Court 28 Texas Eastern District Court 2 8

9 JUDGES Judges in Golden Bridge Technology, Inc. patent litigation cases Leonard Manuel L. Otis D Paul Singh Sue L. Davis Real Wright, II Grewal Robinson No. of cases

10 Patents in Litigation PATENT INFORMATION Title Issued Date No. of Litigation Cases US High efficiency spread spectrum system and method US Common packet channel US Common packet channel US Rach ramp-up acknowledgement US Rach ramp-up acknowledgement US US US US US

11 MAJOR PRODUCTS Owner of Product Amazon.com, Inc. Apple, Inc. AT&T, Inc. Barnes & Noble, Inc. Dell, Inc. Panasonic Corp. Hewlett-Packard Company HTC Corp. Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. Lenovo (United States), Inc. LG Electronics, Inc. Lucent Technologies, Inc. Motorola Mobility, LLC Nokia, Inc. Acer, Inc. Research In Motion Limited Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Sierra Wireless, Inc. Sony Electronics, Inc. ZTE Corp. Kindle 3G Wifi device Apple iphone 3G 3G wireless communication network Nook 3G + Wifi device Product Dell LATITUDE, VOSTRO and ALIENWARE M11X Laptops equipped with the Dell WIRELESS G MOBILE BROADBAND MINI-CARD 3G wireless communication networks ipaq Glisten and HP Mini 110 devices, Palm Pre Plus and Pixi Plus devices HTC HD2, HD7, Surround, Aria, Pure and Tilt2 devices Huawei Mediapad 10 FHD Lenovo S10 device LG CF360, Incite, Shine II, Arena, Neon, Xenon, expo, GU295, Quantum, Encore, VU Plus, LG Sentio, dlite and Optimus T devices Wideband Code - Division Multiple access Motorola DROID 4, DROID Bionic, Tundra, Backflip, Karma and CliqXT devices W-CDMA (Wideband Code Division Multiple Access) in Wireless Communications Systems 3G wireless communication networks Mobile Devices Include Lucid, Connect 4G and others Samsung a777, Samsung Captivate, Samsung Captivate Glide and others Mobile Devices Include Aircard 313U, Aircard 320U, Aircard 33U, Aircard 754S Mobile Hotspot And Others Xperia Ion, Sony Tablet P, Daily Edition Prs-900 With 3G Wireless, Sony W518A, Sony Vivaz, Sony Xperia X10 And Sony Xperia Play 4G Devices ZTE F160, ZTE N91, ZTE PF200, ZTE V66, ZTE V96, ZTE V95 and ZTE T98 device 11

12 OUTCOME OF CASES The following graphic represents the outcomes of Golden Bridge Technology patent litigation: CAFC Appeal Affirmed 6% Settlement 8% Judgment on Merits 3% Transferred Out 3% Open Case 3% Case Dismissed 77% Outcomes No. of Cases Transferred Out 1 Settlement 3 Open Case 1 Judgment on Merits 1 Case Dismissed 27 CAFC Appeal Affirmed 2 Note: 27 cases were dismissed in December 2014 by the court since Golden bridge failed to respond to court's order 12

13 DATA SOURCE HIGHLIGHTS MaxVal s Patent Litigation Databank & Analytics: Litigation databank contains patent litigations filed since cases in databank with daily updates Fully searchable databases with information related to patent litigation from ECFs, PACER, ITC, etc. Complaints, docket reports, patent, product details, and patent file histories Watch Case by patent, product, party, inventor Outcome of the closed cases, such as settlements, dismissals, judgments etc. Litigation daily alerts Patent litigation data analytics & research services 13

14 MaxVal Group, Inc Grant Road, Los Altos, CA Phone: Fax: Web: SEE What Else We Can Do For YOU 14