ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 N 2340

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 N 2340"

Karen Matthews
5 years ago
Views:

1 ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 N 2340 Da: REPLACES: ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Data Management and Inrchange Secretariat: Unit Stas of America (ANSI) Adminisr by Farance Inc. on behalf of ANSI DOCUMENT TYPE TITLE SOURCE Summary of Voting/Table of Replies Summary of Voting on 32N2301 ISO/IEC CD Information chnology - Metamodel framework for inroperability (MFI) Part 10: Core model and basic mapping SC32 Secretariat PROJECT NUMBER STATUS REFERENCES ACTION ID. REQUESTED ACTION DUE DATE The document did not obtain substantial support. WG2 is request to address the comments and revise the draft xt accordingly. ACT Number of Pages 13 LANGUAGE USED DISTRIBUTION English P & L Members SC Chair WG Conveners and Secretaries Dr. Timothy Schoechle, Secretary, ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Farance Inc *, 3066 Sixth Street, Boulder, CO, Unit Stas of America Telephone: ; Timothy@Schoechle.org available from the JTC 1/SC 32 WebSi *Farance Inc. adminisrs the ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Secretariat on behalf of ANSI

2 ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 N2340 Summary of Voting on Document SC 32 N 2301 Title: ISO/IEC CD Information chnology - Metamodel framework for inroperability (MFI) Part 10: Core model and basic mapping Project: P Member Approval Approval with Comments Disapproval with Comments Canada 1 China 1 Czech Republic 1 Egypt 1 Absntion with Comments Finland 1 Germany 1 India 1 Japan 1 Korea, Republic of 1 Portugal 1 Russian Feration 1 Unit Kingdom 1 Unit Stas 1 Austria Belgium Total P O Member France 1 Ghana Hungary Indonesia Italy Kazakhstan Netherlands, The Norway Romania Poland Swen Switzerland Total O Dr. Timothy Schoechle, Secretary, ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Farance Inc *, 3066 Sixth Street, Boulder, CO, Unit Stas of America Telephone: ; Timothy@Schoechle.org available from the JTC 1/SC 32 WebSi *Farance Inc. adminisrs the ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Secretariat on behalf of ANSI

3 COMMENTS: Canada NO. See comments below: Finland ABSTAIN. Lack of expertise and inrest. Germany YES. See comments below: India ABSTAIN. Lack of expertise and inrest. Japan NO. See comments below: Portugal ABSTAIN. Lack of expertise and inrest. Unit Kingdom NO. See comments below: Unit Stas YES. See comments below:

4 Canadian Comments on 32N2301 CD Da: Document: N2301 Project: CD All All - ge Canada disapproves of the draft for the reasons below. All All - ge Since the new mpla allows for xt to be referenc using line s, we generat a line version of the xt which is attach at the bottom of this document, and we have referenc those line s in our comments Introduction Para 2, line Scope Para 3, line 1 Comments Propos change Observations of the Ed repeat 'for regisring' Remove the duplica. Ed 'memodel' should be 'metamodel' Make the correction Scope Figure 1 Ed Three instances of 'specifie' should be 'specifies'. Make the corrections Figure 3 Te Association Model to Model_Element nes at least 1 cardinality of a Model_Element. Otherwise we do not have a model. All All All ge If any further problems are discover before or during the Comment Resolution Meeting, and a consensus can be reach on a solution, then they should be correct. Canada will change its vo to Approval if the comments below are satisfactorily address. Canada asks that future ballot xts include line s so that all NBs can reference them. Make the correction. To be dermin at the CRM as requir. END 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 1 of 1

5 Comments on CD ISO/IEC CD Da: Document: ISO/JTC 1/SC 32N (3) 4 5 (6) (7) MB 1 Clause No./ No./ Annex No Type of comment 2 Comment (justification for change) by the MB Propos change by the MB Secretariat observations on each comment submitt DE 1 2 ge The view on ontologies and their relationship to models is unclear, maybe imprecise. If we deno statistical classifications (e.g. ICD-10) and rminologies (e.g. SNOMED) as ontologies we have to distinguish at least three levels. Firstly, there is an ontology like ICD-10-GM It is, as it is. It is not a representation of something. Consequently, it is not a model. Secondly, we have a family of ontologies, the ICD or the ICD-10, sharing a common structure, common rules, the domain and the area of application. That could be call a model, but the model does not exist explicitly, because it summarizes different instances like ICD-9 WHO 1996, ICD-10 WHO 2006, ICD-10-, ICD-10-CM 2012, Thirdly, something like ClaML exists; ClaML is a language able to represent statistical classifications. So, if one is looking for a model of ontologies, ClaML is the most obvious option. Avoid the phrase model of ontologies. Replace that sennce with.. a metamodel for a registry that can regisr ontologies and models of a specific type such as process models or.... DE 1 3 memodel misspell Replace with metamodel. DE 1 Figure 1 MFI Core and mapping misspell Wri consisntly mapping or Mapping in MFI Core and Mapping throughout the document. DE 1 Figure 1 Missing s in specifie. Correct three times. DE 1 Figure 1 Abbreviation E/R model uncommon. I suggest E-R model. DE Missing that in a basic mapping model allows. Replace with basic mapping model that allows. DE 5.2 Figure 3 The xt introduces a self-referencing association for model_element without visualizing that association. DE ge This description should be rephras according to the first comment on ontologies. Add the association to figure 3. Alrnatively, dele the respective paragraph here ( Each model element uses zero... ). Model is a metaclass each instance of which represents an ontology or a model that is us to represent information requirements MB = Member body (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial NOTE Columns 1, 2, 4, 5 are compulsory. ISO electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 1 of 1

6 ISO/IEC CD Core model and basic mapping Da: 2013/4/12 Document: 32N2301T Project:MFI-10 Comments Propos change Observations of the model element 5.2 Overview of the Core_Model pacakge 5.2 Overview of the Core_Model pacakge 5.2 Overview of the Core_Model pacakge NOTE Bas on their definitions, an event and a service operation do not exist in a process model and in a service model. Figure 3 Model should be a subclass of Model_Element. Rationale: It cannot not explicitly defin how a Model differs from a Model_Element. It is a kind of Model_Element and depends on the recognition of a Model by its modeller Also see 04. Figure 3 Model_Element should be able to be decompos recursively. Rationale: It is very natural that everything can be decompos recursively. This recursive decomposition can be us in most of subordina parts, in addition to Part 5. Also see 05, 06. Figure Figure 4 is overlapp with xt. Only in 32N2301T-xt_for_ballot-CD2_ *** doc *** Model Superclass None "None" should be chang to "Model_Element" Also see Model Reference contains This reference should be mov to Model_Element Also see 03, Model_Elem ent Reference contain_b 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC/CEN/CENELEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version Class(domain or range) should be chang from Model to Model_Element. page 1 of 6

7 ISO/IEC CD Core model and basic mapping Da: 2013/4/12 Document: 32N2301T Project:MFI-10 Comments Propos change Observations of the y Also see 03, (descript ion) 8.4 Model_Elem ent_set_ma pping It nes to be clearly defin in this part or in the subordina part what it means that a subject set is mapp from an object set by a Model_Element_Set_Mapping. If a subject set and an object set consist of ontology_atomic_constructs, intuitively, they should be inrpret disjunctively. If they consist of ontology_component, intuitively, they should be inrpret conjunctively. If they consist of entity_types, how they should be inrpret? If they consist of processes without dependencies, how they should be inrpret, they are in parallel or in any order? Unless all these kind of things are defin, Model_Element_Set_Mapping makes little sense. 09 (descript ion) 8.5 Model_Elem ent_set_ma pping_type It is too ambiguous. Nes more specific description Model_Elem ent_set_ma pping_degr ee The meaning of each value nes to be clearly specifi Annex B Figure B-1 It should be Figure B.1 to be consisnt with ISO_IEC_Directives Part_2. Annex B Figure B-3 Object1101 Similar comments are applicable to all figures and tables in Annex. "(name)" should be "name" because it is defin in this part. Annex B Figure B-3 "express_model" should be "describes". 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC/CEN/CENELEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 2 of 6

8 ISO/IEC CD Core model and basic mapping Da: 2013/4/12 Document: 32N2301T Project:MFI-10 Comments Propos change Observations of the Object Annex B Figure B-3 Object1102 defin in this part. 15 Annex B Figure B-3 Object1102 The value of "identifier" has to be globally unique. "Product Supplier Model A" is hardly globally unique. 16 Annex B Figure B-3 Object1102 "describing_language" should be "describ_by". 17 Annex B Figure B-3 Object1103 "containing_model" should be "contain_by". 18 Object1201 "(name)" should be "name" because it is defin in this part. 19 Object1201 "express_model" should be "describes". 20 Object1202 defin in this part. 21 Object1202 The value of "identifier" has to be globally unique. "Product Supplier Model B" is hardly globally unique. 22 Object1202 "describing_language" should be "describ_by". 23 Object1203 "containing_model" should be "contain_by". 24 Object1304 "(label)l" and their values should be remov. 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC/CEN/CENELEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 3 of 6

9 ISO/IEC CD Core model and basic mapping Da: 2013/4/12 Document: 32N2301T Project:MFI-10 Comments Propos change Observations of the Object Annex B Figure B-8 Object2101 "(name)" should be "name" because it is defin in this part. 26 Annex B Figure B-8 Object2101 "express_model" should be "describes". 27 Annex B Figure B-8 Object2102 defin in this part. 28 Annex B Figure B-8 Objec2102 The value of "identifier" has to be globally unique. "Order Placement Model C" is hardly globally unique. 29 Annex B Figure B-8 Object2102 "describing_language" should be "describ_by". 30 Annex B Figure B-8 Object2103 "containing_model" should be "contain_by". 31 Annex B Figure B-9 Object2201 "(name)" should be "name" because it is defin in this part. 32 Annex B Figure B-9 Object2201 "express_model" should be "describes". 33 Annex B Figure B-9 Object2202 defin in this part. 34 Annex B Figure B-9 Objec2202 The value of "identifier" has to be globally unique. "Order Placement Model D" is hardly globally unique. 35 Annex B Figure B-9 Object2202 "describing_language" should be "describ_by". 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC/CEN/CENELEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 4 of 6

10 ISO/IEC CD Core model and basic mapping Da: 2013/4/12 Document: 32N2301T Project:MFI-10 Comments Propos change Observations of the 36 Annex B Figure B-9 Object2203 "containing_model" should be "contain_by". 37 Annex B Figure B-13 Object3101 "(name)" should be "name" because it is defin in this part. 38 Annex B Figure B-13 Object3101 "express_model" should be "describes". 39 Annex B Figure B-13 Object3102 defin in this part. 40 Annex B Figure B-13 Objec3102 The value of "identifier" has to be globally unique. "Handle Order Model E" is hardly globally unique. 41 Annex B Figure B-13 Object3102 "describing_language" should be "describ_by". 42 Annex B Figure B-13 Object3103 "containing_model" should be "contain_by". 43 Annex B Figure B-23 Object4101 "(name)" should be "name" because it is defin in this part. 44 Annex B Figure B-23 Object4101 "express_model" should be "describes". 45 Annex B Figure B-23 Object4102 defin in this part. 46 Annex B Figure B-23 Object4102 "describing_language" should be "describ_by". 47 Annex B Figure B-23 It should be not that the values of "model_element" are not exhaustive. 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC/CEN/CENELEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 5 of 6

11 ISO/IEC CD Core model and basic mapping Da: 2013/4/12 Document: 32N2301T Project:MFI-10 Comments Propos change Observations of the Object Annex B Figure B-23 Object4103 "containing_model" should be "contain_by". 49 Annex B Figure B-24 Object4201 defin in this part. 50 Annex B Figure B-24 Object4201 "describing_language" should be "describ_by". 51 Annex B Figure B-24 Object4101 It should be not that the values of "model_element" are not exhaustive. 52 Annex B Figure B-24 Object4202 "containing_model" should be "contain_by". 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC/CEN/CENELEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 6 of 6

12 Templa for comments and observations Da: 2 April 2013 Document: ISO/IEC CD (3) 4 5 (6) (7) MB 1 Clause No./ No./ Annex No (e.g. Table 1) Type of comment 2 Comment (justification for change) by the MB Propos change by the MB Secretariat observations on each comment submitt GB 01 Introduction Para 2, line 3 " for regisring for regisring " - duplication Remove one of the instances of " for regisring " GB 02 1 Para 3 " memodel " incorrect spelling Amend to read " metamodel " GB Para 2, line 3 GB Penultima para " basic mapping model allows the registration " missing word "Each model element uses zero, one or more other model elements. Each model element is us by zero, one or more other model elements." This implies a recursive association on Model_Element which is not shown in Fig 3. GB 05 Annex A Last para "Instances of Model_Element_Set_Mapping_Type are examples of instances which may not instances of Identifi_Im." missing word GB 06 Annex B Examples 1 and 2 are not consisnt with CD no objects corresponding to the Diagram metaclass are includ. Amend to read " basic mapping model which allows the registration " Add recursive association to Fig 3. Amend to read "Instances of Model_Element_Set_Mapping_Type are examples of instances which may not be instances of Identifi_Im." Add Diagram objects to Examples 1 and 2 1 MB = Member body (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial NOTE Columns 1, 2, 4, 5 are compulsory. ISO electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 1 of 1

13 Templa for comments and observations Da: Document: 32N2301T Project: CD Comments Propos change Observations of the US- 01 US- 02 US- 03 US- 04 US- 05 US- 06 Introduction 2 The phrase "for regisring" occurs twice. Remove one occurrence. 1 Scope 3 The word "memodel" is misspell. Change to "Metamodel." 1 Scope Figure 1 "specifie" occurs repeatly. Change to "specifies." 5.1 Para 2 Last sennce ungrammatical. Replace "allows" with "to allow." B.1 Para 5, Sennce 3 "reference" should be plural. Replace with"references." Throughout Use of rm meta-class is confusing and not consisnt with UML. The part specifies a model represent in UML. UML describes classes. Use class insad. 1 MB = Member body / NC = National Commite (enr the ISO 3166 two-letr country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS iting unit are identifi by **) 2 comment: ge = general = chnical = itorial ISO/IEC/CEN/CENELEC electronic balloting commenting mpla/version page 1 of 1

ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 N 2406

ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 N 2406 Da: 2013-07-13 REPLACES: ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 Data Management and Inrchange Secretariat: Unid Stas of America (ANSI) Adminisr by Farance Inc. on behalf of ANSI DOCUMENT TYPE Disposition