University of St Andrews Cardiff Business School!!! # % # &! (!#! ) +!!!,#!,! %,!! # 6!! 7.! % %788! 7 9 8! 8! (:0; <= (

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "University of St Andrews Cardiff Business School!!! # % # &! (!#! ) +!!!,#!,! %,!! # 6!! 7.! % %788! 7 9 8! 8! (:0; <= ("

Kory Price
5 years ago
Views:

Reid, Gavin C. and Smith, Julia A. (2005) Venture capital investor behaviour in the backing of UK high technology firms : financial reporting and the level of investment. Discussion paper.

1 Reid, Gavin C. and Smith, Julia A. (2005) Venture capital investor behaviour in the backing of UK high technology firms : financial reporting and the level of investment. Discussion paper. Centre for Research into Industry, Enterprise, Finance and the Firm (CRIEFF), St Andrews, UK., This version is available at Strathprints is designed to allow users to access the research output of the University of Strathclyde. Unless otherwise explicitly stated on the manuscript, Copyright and Moral Rights for the papers on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. Please check the manuscript for details of any other licences that may have been applied. You may not engage in further distribution of the material for any profitmaking activities or any commercial gain. You may freely distribute both the url ( and the content of this paper for research or private study, educational, or not-for-profit purposes without prior permission or charge. Any correspondence concerning this service should be sent to the Strathprints administrator: strathprints@strath.ac.uk The Strathprints institutional repository ( is a digital archive of University of Strathclyde research outputs. It has been developed to disseminate open access research outputs, expose data about those outputs, and enable the management and persistent access to Strathclyde's intellectual output.

2 ! University of St Andrews Cardiff Business School!!! # % # &! (!#! ) +!!!,#!,! %,!! &! # #!./0./ !! 7.! % %788! 7 9 8! 8! (:0; <= ( >+?> Α 03322;1230, Α 03322; ))> )ΒΧ!!)%788 = 9 8!! D!! # D.!!8037 >+Ε?! Α 0111/Φ;;Ε1. =, 22 Α 0111/Φ;;Ε Α 0111/Φ220< + +))! )#)!))

3 ! %&!! ( D1ΑΑ1,4=0<<Ε,440<</!! &!# 1ΑΑ3,## 0<</! %!!! D!!1ΑΑΕ!! (1ΑΑ3! # D!!1ΑΑΕ,DΓ! 1ΑΑ1,4 1ΑΑΑ!!!!! +!!D 0<</,Η1ΑΑ3! ( #,#! 0<<<!!! >! 7 0<</,!!#! %,! D Η0<<<,D!!1ΑΑΕ,8 1ΑΑΑ! & Η #! #! #! & %! 1

4 ! 1ΑΑΑ #! > 6 1ΑΑ0 #! Ι# ϑ Ι #!! # D &! # #!!%%!! 81ΑΑΕ, 1ΑΑΕ,( 1ΑΑΑ,## 0<</, Η # Η # 1ΑΑ3! 0<<< 7 Η# 1ΑΑ3 # >1ΑΑ3, # 1ΑΑΑ,Κ1ΑΑ1,Κ1ΑΑ0,4 1ΑΑ2 > #0<<Α!!! 4.9 Λ 4 1ΑΑΑ!!! # > 5!! #!>!# Κ 1ΑΑΕ # # & D! # & ># ( >!,!!,! ( 1ΑΑ3, 3

5 ! 7 1ΑΑ1,81ΑΑΕ, 1ΑΑΕ!! 8! >!#! +! 4 1ΑΑ3,,! #0<<Α!% # + &,!!,) D!!!+!!!!!!!!!! # #! >!! #!! & ( 4 # # >!!!! 6 6!# 6 1ΑΑ1 # 1ΑΑΑ, 4 1ΑΑ1,! 8 2

6 Μ021 #!! (! & 2.1 Sample! # +! #! DΝ DΝ,! ( # Ν Ν!! # > #!!002!!! 1ΦΟ &!! )% 8 0! %!!! >!!!!! 0ΠΕΠ Θ03! Θ 8 07 # #!! #!. # #!!Ρ # #!! ( +# )!! 5!! # Ε

7 !!! ϑ #!! )!! #! 8 18 >!! > 4D5 Θ02 Θ! ΑΠ,0ΠΕΠ %! > > #! ( ϑ!!! 4D5 4D%!! & # #! # Κ! ( # ϑ >! & > #! 5!! 4D5, # #! (! Η!!!! 0 # # Κ # >! ;

8 ! #! ΡΡ! & #! &! # % ##!>! #! Η #! viz.>! ( ϑ# >!!!!! ) (! # #&! 8! Θ00Θ %!!!!!! #! >!!!!#!! ( & %! # Ε1;Ο #! # # ( #!# Γ# ( &! 1Φ2Ο!! 7! Φ

9 2.2 Questionnaire!! # #! Ν # >!! > & D! & + #!,!!#,! 4& &!! etc! = %!>!>! & #! ## > #! ( > ),% # 0 #! 8!! #! Σ/ΕΦ Σ22Ε< 5! Σ1;<0Ο! #!# ;2Ο # #! #Γ Η #!!! 0/Ο! /

10 Η! 5! # (!DDD (8# ΦΕΟ # 1ΕΟ!!#!! = = 1ΑΑΕ # # #!! # & #!! & #! # # ), # 1! & + #!Ρ!,#! # 1ΑΑΑ,Κ1ΑΑ1,4 1ΑΑ2, # 0<<Α,! Η 1ΑΑ2, 4 0<<Ε 8 0<<Ε, :0<<0, 0<<< 8 & &! attitudes!! utility!! preference!!# %!! &! #! # D <

11 ! # &! & % # #! & # #! # Κ # #!! ( %#! 2 # #!! 3.1 Financial Reporting 8!!! Θ10! Ρ ϑ 2ϑ! FinAcUse#!!!! # # #! # 8 2! #!!!! 02# ϑ! )!# ϑ!! 1ΑΑ3,Η1ΑΑ3!! 0Α

12 ! Κ!!!! &! #! # # &! %! #!!!!!! #> > =!!!! #!! 7 # # 3.2 Risk Reporting and Disclosure 8 Ε & # Θ10Α! # #! 8 Ε &!!!! &!.! #!! 3Α! #ϑ!!!!! Risk1 Π1<Ε ϑ & #!! Risk3 Π 300!!!! Κ! #!!Risk2Π100 #!!! Risk5 Π 1ΑΑ! 00

13 Risk6Π1ΑΑ Τ%! % # Υ 8 ϑ # Risk4Π2ΑΕ 5! #!!! #! # # #! &!! # # # &! 2# + # # ς ). 3.3 Benefit from Required Publishing of Financial Accounts!8 Ε &!! do #!! & #ςη 8 ; & Θ1<!! ReqFinR ReqPeopR) ReqTechR ReqMktR!# ReqIntR!! > 4 ( 0<<3 &!!! 8 Ε#! 3 # Ρ 8 ; 01

14 !! # #!!! #! # # & )/! viz.! #!!! D Η 0<<< #! 6 #!! # # #!!!7!! # # &! #!!!8 ; # &! viz!! #! #! # & 7 8 ; Τ% Ι # Η D! ) #! #!! Υ &!!!! & +Τ% # 03

15 ! # Ι # > ς%!υ&!! >! % #! #! +Τ% #! Υ +&,0 8 8 Φ!& Θ11 # Κ1ΑΑ1, 4 1ΑΑ3,4 1ΑΑ2,!# 1ΑΑΑ # #!! +!!! # &!! 8 ΦΚ 1ΑΑΕ! &! Ρ!!! & #!8 Φ# #! Ρ )1 02

16 !! %! &! # #!!! Γ!!!# % &! &!8 Φ#! 8 Ε!! 8 ;! # #!8 Φ! public! # #!!! ## >! # #!! 1 & 2 0!! 13! % 8 # +!!!!!,! #! 9!,! #! 4 0<<Φ,Η## 0<<; etc 0<<Φ, 0<<< 0Ε

17 !!!D!!Γ ϑ! ϑ!! #!! # #! D!!1ΑΑΕ 8 1ΑΑΑ Η1ΑΑ3! 4.1 Statistical Analysis Η!! # # #!!! #Γ # 57! 6!!!!!!! #!!! Usefulness of Financial Accounts # 3 6!!! Ρ Μ a priori > #!!!FinAcUse) #! # 0;

18 !! Staged, ROSF ROCE ),+ Staged!! Π0 ΠΑ Staged!!! 8!Staged!!#!!>!!!!!ROSF!,ROCE DROSFROCE!!! Η! # 3 +!! #!! ΕΟ ROCE ROSF Staged%# #!#!! #!! #! #! ##! Technopoles: Investment Stage and Risk Disclosure! # 2 # Technopole Θ01 Π0 ΠΑ! #0/Ο!!! 5 0Φ

19 !! &!# 2 8! Indus07!! # 6#Ν ΠΑΑΑ/ %!! # # Stage11 ΡΡ! Stage13! 6#Ν ΠΑΑ3ΑΑΑ3Α!!! ), 8# 2! &! viz. &! TechFin PeopFin MarkFin!FinQual 9! HnSFin!!!!!! 6# Ν Π ΑΑΑ2 6# Ν Π ΑΑΑΑ 6# Ν Π ΑΑ22 9! 6# Ν ΠΑΑΑ2 quantitative!!! qualitative FinQual!! was! 6#Ν ΠΑΑ0/! &! #!! # &!!!&! 0/

20 4.1.3 Influence over Internal Management! # # Ε!! #!!InflInfo # &!! Θ30!! #!! ΠΑ ΠΕ ),. %#!#! Indus12,6#Ν ΠΑΑ3Φ Indus19,6#Ν ΠΑΑΑ0 # 5!!!! 8 4D5 Stage9, 6# Ν Π ΑΑΑΕ 4D% Stage10, 6# Ν Π ΑΑ1Ε =D5 Stage12, 6# Ν Π ΑΑ2/ # Stage14, 6# Ν ΠΑΑ13!!! #! 5! Π ΑΕ<Α,6#Ν ΠΑΑ03!#!! & ## MarkSens # Ε 8 Π Α;Ε;! 6# Ν Π ΑΑΑ1 #! Risk4 0<

21 !!! 31Risk Reporting and Disclosure &!8 ΕRisk Reporting in Financial Accounts & Τ Υ!! # Π >ΑΕ0;! 6# Ν Π ΑΑ12 #!! Risk6 %! Risk4 # % # #! 8 Ε # #& Τ%! % Υ!!>!! #!! &!! 8 # Ε! #!! %!!!!! #! %!! InflMgt1,6#Ν ΠΑΑΑ2 > InflDec, 6# Ν Π ΑΑΑ;!!! InflStaff, 6# Ν Π ΑΑ31! InflMgt2, 6# Ν Π ΑΑΑ2 InflProd,6#Ν ΠΑΑ23!!!!4D54D%!! # 1Α

22 4.2 Econometric Analysis!20# # # #!!!! % #!!!! #!!, #!! # Κ #!! # 5 # # &!! +!,! 5 ϑ Γ =! 1ΑΑ0! #! Γ # D = 0<<< # Κ 0<<Φ!& Η!!8 Ε! Θ10Α %8 Ε! #! Η # # Risk1Risk6 per se!! 10

23 # #!!> ># # Average Min Θ0Ε # Risk1 Risk # ;!! AverageMinimum! 7! + Level of investment funds allocated = f(investor attitude to risk) + ε 3%4 ε! &0 # & >! # ; ),/ Η #!#!!!!! 7!8!2Α</6#Ν ΠΑΑ0/ 2/3Α6# Ν ΠΑΑ0Α! Π;> Π01!! # ;!! > 6# Ν Μ Ρ!!!! Ρ!! 7! 4!!! # Risk6% #!Risk5#! #! ## not! # Μ 11

24 !!8 Ε viz.!! Risk5!! Risk6 5! #!Risk2ϑ! # Risk4ϑ & ## 6 #! 4 1! Risk4! #! (!!! # #!! 8 # Risk 1ϑ!!! & Risk3 ϑ! # ## #! # Risk3!! %! #! #! # # # Risk1# #! Risk3# # #! >!! #! # 13

25 5!!!! #! # #! #.&!! (!&! ( >!!!! Η!+ %!! 8!!!!# % not Γ!!! ># # # 12

26 Η!!! # Η!!!! # ( #!!#! DD Κ >Η 4 1ΑΑΕ #!! 0! Venture Capital Report 1! #!> # >!! 1Ε

27 D Μ = 0<</ ϑκ! Ρ # Management AccountingΝ/ΑΜ212>3Α D Η Η 0<<< ϑ% + ( The Journal of Real Estate ResearchΝ0/Μ11<0>301 D = 0<<< ϑ & # The Review of Financial StudiesΝ01Μ32;0>Φ< DΗ4!!1ΑΑΕ ϑ% The Journal of BusinessΝΦ/Μ12ΑΕ>22Α DΓ! 7 =4Κ : 4Μ D 7 Κ 1ΑΑ1 ϑ%# + Ρ Brookings Papers on Economic ActivityΝ003Φ></ D=1ΑΑ1 ϑ Ν! European Venture Capital Journal40Ε # (1ΑΑ3 Smarter Ventures: a survivor s guide to venture capital through the new cycle=+86 Κ >Κ W > ( Κ 4% 1ΑΑ3 ϑd>! # +! >! Review of Quantitative Finance and AccountingΝ10Μ23Α3> (. 0<</ ϑ > + Issues in Accounting Education Ν03 Μ3Ε<Ε>;01 7Η#1ΑΑ3 ϑ5!!! # # Journal of Evolutionary Economics Ν 03 ΜΕ;ΑΦ> Κ 1ΑΑ1 ϑ!!! Journal of Accounting ResearchΝ2ΑΜ12/Ε>Ε0/ 8 50<<Ε ϑ Journal of Management StudiesΝ31ΕΕ0>ΕΦ2 8 (= 4 1ΑΑΑ ϑ% Financial Analysts JournalΝΕ;Μ10;>13 81ΑΑΕ ϑ.!!! #4D5+! Journal of Business Finance & AccountingΝ31Μ3>2 ;/3><Α >41ΑΑ3 ϑ8!!!# Accounting, Auditing & Accountability JournalΝ0;Μ0ΕΦ>;< #.6 1ΑΑΑ ϑ%# Review of Quantitative Finance and AccountingΝ0ΕΜ23ΑΦ>313 ΚDΚ!! 4Γ # 1ΑΑΕ ϑ4 The Rand Journal of EconomicsΝ3;Μ00;>3/ 1

28 Κ 4 1ΑΑ1 ϑ%# + The Accounting ReviewΝΦΦΜ3;<;>Φ Κ.(60<<Φ ϑ!& + Expert SystemsΝ02Μ012>3; Κ 1ΑΑ0 ϑ8 # Accounting, Auditing & Accountability JournalΝ02Μ22<Φ>Ε1< D5(1ΑΑΑ ϑ.!!!%65!ς Journal of Business Finance & Accounting Ν 1ΦΜ<>0Α003<>00/3 D4Η1ΑΑΕ ϑ6!! #4D5+! Journal of Business Finance & AccountingΝ31 Μ3>2;23>/1 (( 1ΑΑ3 ϑ6 & + Γ Journal of Accounting and Public PolicyΝ11Μ;Ε0Φ>3/ ( 1ΑΑΑ ϑ.!!!%65!ς Journal of Business Finance & AccountingΝ1ΦΜ<> 0Α00ΦΦ>/3 = 77Η=0<<< ϑν Journal of Legal EconomicsΝ<Μ030>2/ 4 64( 0<<3 ϑ!# # & The American Economic ReviewΝ/3Μ11;Ε 4..1ΑΑ1 ϑ Small Business Economics Ν0<Μ Μ 0<<Ε ϑ6>!!# Accounting and Business Research Ν1ΕΜ<<0/;><; 4 4 1ΑΑ2 ϑρ! # Journal of AccountancyΝ0</Μ;Φ2>/ 6 4 1ΑΑ1 ϑ%# Journal of Evolutionary EconomicsΝ01Μ0>10ΑΦ>32 6 1ΑΑ0 ϑ # # Information World Review 5! 2<>ΕΑ Μ 0<<; ϑ &! (! Η # 6 Innovation and the Intellectual Property System=+( =% 13>2Ε ## 4(0<</ ϑν &+ Journal of Business Finance & AccountingΝ1ΕΜΕ>;Ε10>ΦΑ =Ν0<<< ϑ!!# Behavioural Research in AccountingΝ000;0><0 7:0<<0 ϑ # Journal of Business VenturingΝ;00Ε>33 3

29 Μ#0<<Α ϑ #! Accounting HorizonsΝ2Μ2Φ/>/Φ 7 0<<< ϑ! Γ The International Journal of Project Management Ν0Φ Μ3 0;0>< Η # 4Η #1ΑΑ3 ϑ.! ς 7! #!! Journal of Accounting ResearchΝ20Μ2;/0>Φ1Α Η Θ 1ΑΑ3 ϑ% American Business ReviewΝ10Μ00Φ>1Α Η4= 64Κ Ρ6. #Ξ Κ 1ΑΑ2 ϑν!+ 7 Journal of International Entrepreneurship Ν1Μ23ΑΕ Η4(## 0<<; ϑν & &!! Accounting and Business ResearchΝ1;Μ10Ε3>ΦΦ 2

30 , 2 %& Η! ς6! #!0Ε 0Ε 7 8 3%.9:% 4 = Μ % 7 %.! ς : Μ %!!+ 6!#!!!!0Ε 0Ε 3% 4 D 4 ) 7 # 8 % %9 4! 4 %!! % 7 = 5

31 Ε 6!#!!!0Ε 0 2 (3%.4 > 5 7 D!!# # ) & ) 4 #>4D5 4 #>4D% %#>%D5 = #>=D 4 ΡΡ! 6# 6!& Η Ρ! ς 4 4 Σ Σ Σ.!! #! ς Ψ # # Ζ = # & 0 Κ>!! #! > ϑ# #!!# > 10!! >! ς ; 1

32 # # %!!!!ς,0 [Please tick one box for each case below] ; < :, 6 D = 8 Θ!!! > &!!! ς On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is insufficient and 5 is full and complete information, please tick the relevant box for each item. %!! [[[[[[[[8) % = 6 Η!# >! ς[tick one] Η! Η! 3

33 1Ε Κ!!! >! On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is insignificant and 5 is highly significant information, please tick the relevant box for each item. %![[[Κ! % +. 7!!! [please give examples] 1; 1Φ Κ &!! ς On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is not at all and 5 is very extensive, please tick the relevant box for each item. Μ[[[[[[[[[[Ν 7 % Κ 9! %! &! & & #ς [Please tick all that apply] # [[tick all that apply] = 3 = 3> = 4 9:,, Κ 9! 2

34 1/. > ς : Μ %!!! ς On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is not at all important and 5 is crucial, please tick the relevant box for each item. Μ[[[[[[[[[ % D! 4 8 %! Κ!! 5 [please specify] Ε

35 1< 10Α %! # < #! ς On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is not at all important and 5 is crucial, please tick the relevant box for each item. Μ[[[[[[[[[ % Ν!#! # > ς On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is completely disagree and 5 is completely agree, please tick the relevant box for each item.!!!!! 4!# & #! 5 # >!!!! [[ % +. ;

36 &( 0 8 Κ! # ς On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is little influence and 5 is complete control, please tick the relevant box for each item. =! [[[ % +. %! 4 8. >!!!! 6 4 5! #! ςψ #!!ϑ ϑ! # Ζ <!:8 8. Η 4 Θ ;> Κ &!!! ς : < %! 4 8. >!!!! 6 4 Φ

37 32 6 #! #! > Many thanks for your cooperation in completing this questionnaire. If you are interested in receiving summary results from our project, in due course, please tick the box. Dr Julia A Smith Cardiff Business School Tel: Professor Gavin C Reid University of St Andrews Tel: & + Dr Julia A Smith Cardiff Business School Aberconway Building Colum Drive Cardiff CF10 3EU Office use only:χχχχχχχχ /

38 %8,! Α0 D Α1 4 ) Α3 Α2 7 ΑΕ # Α; 8 ΑΦ % Α/ %9 Α< 4! 0Α %! 02! 0Ε % 0; 7 0Φ = 0/ 5 0< <

39 8,2! 8 2 Α0 Α1 > Α3 5 Α2 7 ΑΕ D! Α;!# # ΑΦ ) & Α/ ) Α< 4 #>4D5 0Α 4 #>4D% 00 %#>%D5 01 = #>=D 03 4 ΡΡ! 02 6# 0Ε 6!& 0Α

40 +8,( 5 00

41 0?! #%&% ()%)) +, () (% 01

42 . 0 &, % 0, (&,0% &, %.)0,.)/.)/.)/.)/.)/.)/, 2 Risk1 Risk2 Risk3 Risk4 Risk5 Risk6!!!!! 4!# & #! 5 # >!!!! 03

43 ,(!.0% / (&,0%.#,&0&, ReqFinR ReqPeopR ReqTechR ReqMktR ReqIntR,< %# 02

44 1< , Patent Copyrig Brand License Franch Quota CustList TradMark < 6 D = 8 Θ 0Ε

45 ,%2 2 4 Σ ΕΑΑΑ 0ΑΑΑΑΑΑΑ /Ε;/0/ 4 % Σ 0ΑΑΑΑΑ ΕΑΑΑΑΑΑΑ 22Ε<Α<0 Σ /ΑΑΑΑ 3ΑΑΑΑΑΑΑ 1Ε;ΕΦ02 6 0/Ο 6 ;2Ο 6! <0Ο 6 # 1ΕΟ 6 # ΦΕΟ 0;

46 , Α8 = 1. Background! 6! 4 Ρ! 6!!> 2. High Technology and Financial Accounting!! &! # &!!!!#!! 7! &! Θ &!! >! Μ! &!.! 3. Management Accounting and Performance 7!!! 7!!! &! &! % 6#! 0Φ

47 ,+ : 0 FinAcUse Staged ROSF ROCE 6 >Α22< ΑΕΑ< ΑΕΕ3 6#Ν ΑΑ20 ΑΑ22 ΑΑ1/ Μ 10 0; 0;! ΑΑΕ 1> 0/

48 , : Techpole Indus07 Stage11 Stage13 TechFin 6 ΑΕ2Φ Α2;3 Α2;3 Α2<2 6#Ν ΑΑΑ/ ΑΑ3Α ΑΑ3Α ΑΑ22 Μ Φ Techpole PeopFin MarkFin FinQual HnSFin 6 ΑΦ/< Α2<2 ΑΕ;; Α;Ε/ 6#Ν ΑΑΑΑ ΑΑ22 ΑΑ0/ ΑΑΑ2 Μ 0Φ 0Φ 0Φ 02! ΑΑ0 1>! ΑΑΕ 1> 0<

49 ,. :( 0 InflInfo Indus12 Indus19 Stage09 Stage10 6 >Α22Φ >Α;;Φ >ΑΕΦΦ >Α2Φ/ 1> ΑΑ3Φ ΑΑΑ0 ΑΑΑΕ ΑΑ1Ε Μ InflInfo Stage12 Stage14 MarkSens Risk4 6 >Α21; >Α2/0 ΑΕ<Α Α;Ε; 1> ΑΑ2/ ΑΑ13 ΑΑ03 ΑΑΑ1 Μ Φ 0< InflInfo Risk6 InflMgt1 InflDec InflStaff 6 >ΑΕ0; ΑΕ<3 ΑΕ;Φ Α2Ε/ 1> ΑΑ12 ΑΑΑ2 ΑΑΑ; ΑΑ31 Μ 0< InflInfo Inflmgt2 InflProd 6 ΑΕ<3 Α23; 1> ΑΑΑ2 ΑΑ23 Μ 11 11! ΑΑ0 1>! ΑΑΕ 1> 1Α

50 ,/5! ( % (, Average Investment Minimum Investment,? 38,& 4? 38,& 4 Risk1 0ΕΑ;0Α 3 0/ΦΕ ΑΑ/Ε Ε;3Φ0Α 1 10;3 ΑΑΕ0 Risk2 01Α00Α 3 0Ε</ Α03; 2Α1Α0Α 1 0;2; Α01; Risk3 1Ε;;0Α 3 1;3Ε ΑΑ11 <1;<0Α 1 1<31 ΑΑ03 Risk4 >1;ΕΦ0Α 3 >0;Ε1 Α012 ><;Ε;0Α 1 >0/2< ΑΑ/< Risk5 21/10Α 1 Α0Φ0 Α/;Φ ;03/0Α 1 ΑΦΕΕ Α2;Ε Risk6 33Φ10Α 1 Α01Ε Α<Α3 >23Φ30Α 1 >Α2<< Α;1Φ Constant 1<Ε10Α 3 >Α3<< Α;<Φ ><Α<10Α 1 >Α3Φ/ ΑΦ01 Adjusted R 2 ΑΕΑ/ ΑΕ;0 FΙStatistic 2Α</ 2/3Α Prob. Value ΑΑ0/ ΑΑ0Α, 2 Risk1!!!!! Risk2 4!# Risk3 & #! Risk4 5 # > Risk5!! Risk6!! 10

Tracing Lineage Beyond Relational Operators

Tracing Lineage Beyond Relational Operators Mingwu Zhang 1 Xiangyu Zhang 1 Xiang Zhang 2 Sunil Prabhakar 1 1 Computer Science 2 Bindley Bioscience Center Purdue University Introduction Lineage (Data Provenance)