Proceedings of 173 rd Meeting (Emergent) of ERC-NCTE held on 26 th June, 2014

Transcription

1 PROCEEDINGS OF 173 rd MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE HELD ON 26 th JUNE, 2014 The 173 rd Meeting of the Eastern Regional Committee (ERC), National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) was convened on 26 th June, 2014 at Conference Hall, ERC, NCTE, 15, Neelakantha Nagar, Nayapalli, Bhubaneswar. The Chairperson, Members and Convener as listed below were present at the time of the 173 rd ERC Meeting. Prof.(Dr.) P.C. Mahapatra Prof. Brajanath Kundu Dr. Tilottama Senapati Shri Chandrapida Neelap - Chairperson - Member - State representative of Odisha - Regional Director, ERC & Convener. At the outset, the Regional Director welcomed all the members of Committee and apprised them about the provisions of the NCTE Act, Rules, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time. With the permission of Chairperson, Shri Chandrapida Neelap (Convener) presented the Agenda before the Committee for its due consideration and appropriate decision. Sl. No. ER Item No. Content Confirmation of the Proceedings of 172 nd ERC meeting, 17 th June, 2014 at Bhubaneswar. Confirmed The committee unanimously decided that the institution may reply in response to the decision of the committee uploaded on the ERC website without waiting formal letters from the office of ERC. The replies so received will also be considered by the committee. ER-173.2(ii) Court Case: Inspection conducted by the NCTE Hqrs. U/S 13 on the basis of direction given by the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand (ii).1 The Graduate School College for Women, Jamshedpur, Sakchi, Jamshedpur, Jharkhand (Course:B.Ed.) (Constituent Unit) (Kolhan University) (Code No.:APE00355) A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-30/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86677 dated In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification vide letter dated to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply dated submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under: 1. The following deficiencies are still exist : (i) The B.Ed. Department is located in a part of the building with a covered area of 443 sq.ft. which is less than the required 1500 sq,m. (ii) Laboratories like Psychology, ICT, Art & Craft Resource Centre etc are not available. (iii) No separate provision has been made for Health and Physical Education. (iv) The Library has a stock of 800 books which is less than the required 3000 books as per norms. 1

2 (v) The University has recruited eight lecturers on contractual basis for 11 months for the year and posted them in this college on The services of the staff are terminated after 11 months and fresh appointments are made in the beginning of a session. As per norms the teaching faculty must be appointed on regular basis. Show Cause notice be issued to the institution as to why the recognition to the institution be not withdrawn on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides an opportunity under section 17(1) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee takes final decision. A copy may also be sent to the Registrar of the concerned university and State Govt. ER Appeal Case Loyola College of Education, Plot No. 5373, Street No. Ward No. 17, Vill- Hurlung, Po- Telco, Tehsil/Taluka-Golmuri Cum Jugsulai, Town/City- Jamshedpur, Dist.- Purba Singhbhum, Jharkhand (B.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Private) (Kolhan University) (Code No.:ERCAPP1357) The Appeal Committee vide its order F.No /2013-Appeal/6 th Meeting-2013 dated confirmed the rejection order of the ERC. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee Malatipur B.Ed. College: Plot No.-3260/3559, Vill.-Sadiknagar, P.O.-Chaita, Tehsil/Taluka-Sadiknagar, Dist.-North 24 Parganas, West Bengal (Course - B.Ed.) (Code No.:ERCAPP1625) The Appeal Committee vide its order F.No /2014-Appeal/6 th confirmed the rejection order of the ERC. Meeting-201-A88345 dated The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee Gen School Of Education: Plot No.-455/764, 413/462/463, St. No.-10, Vill.-Heingang, P.O.-Heingang, Tehsil/Taluka-Porompat, Town / City / Dist.- Imphal East, Manipur Bearing (Course B.Ed.) (Code No.:ERCAPP1707) The Appeal Committee vide its order F.No /2013-Appeal/5 th Meeting-2014-A88737 dated confirmed the rejection order of the ERC. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee Salar College of Education and Research, Plot No. 1000, 1001, 1007, Vill/PO. - Salar, Dist. - Murshidabad, West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Kalyani)(Code No.:ERCAPP1282) The Appeal Committee vide its order F.No /2013-Appeal/6 th Meeting-2014-A88381 dated confirmed the rejection order of the ERC. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee. 2

3 Chuyapara Shree Ramakrishna Teachers Training College and Research, Plot No.-102,764, Vill.-Chuyapara, P.O.-Fulpur, Tehsil/Taluka-Bhagwangola- II, Town/City-Murshidabad, Dist.-Murshidabad, West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Kalyani) (Code No:ERCAPP1563) The Appeal Committee vide its order F.No /2014-Appeal/6 th Meeting-2014-A88405 dated confirmed the rejection order of the ERC. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee Aina E Hind B.Ed. College, Plot No.-01, Vill.-Kutub Shahar, P.O.-Malda, Tehsil/Taluka-Gazole, Town/City-Pandua, Dist.-Malda, West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (Affiliating body not mentioned) (Code No:ERCAPP1698) The Appeal Committee vide its order F.No /2014-Appeal/6 th confirmed the rejection order of the ERC. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee. Meeting-2014-A88509 dated ER (i) (i).1 Misc. Cases- (I) Daulatabad Primary Teachers Training College, Plot No. 44, 2027, Vill.-Daulatabad, P.O.-Daulatabad, Tehsil/ Taluka/ Town/ City-Daulatabad, Dist.-Murshidabad West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (WBBPE) (Code No.ERCAPP1776) A complaint dated forwarded by NCTE Hqrs on received from Mrinmoy Mandal stating that Dr. Sarepalli Radha Teacher Training College, Daultabad, Dist- Murshidabad and Daulatabad Primary Teachers Training College, Daultabad, Murshidabad are running in the same campus and same land. The committee considered the complaint and decided as under: 1. The institution be asked to submit the certified copy of land documents of both the institutions along with building plan duly approved by any Government Engineer. 2. A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to the District Magistrate of the concerned District with a request to direct the concerned officers to make an inquiry whether both the institution are running in the same campus or has separate land and building and submit the report within 30 days (i).2 R.T.C. B.Ed. College, Vill-P.H.E.D., Buti, Po: Bariyatu, Dist-Ranchi, Jharkhand (B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No.APE00780) A complaint dated 02/06/2014 & received from Renu, Chet Narayan Sahu & Kumari Nagpal against the institution of RTC B.Ed College regarding removal from the teaching faculty by the management of the institution. The committee considered the complaint and decided as under: A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to the Registrar of the concerned university as well RTC B.Ed college for comments. 3

4 (i).3 Magadh Teacher s Training College, West Church Road, Near D.M. Residence, Dist Gaya, Bihar (B.Ed.) (Private) (Magadh University) (Code No.APE00422) A complaint dated 19/02/2014 received from Anant Kumar and another complaint dated received from Bipin Kumar, Gaya against the institution. The committee considered the complaint and observed as under: Mr. Brij Mohan Singh, Mr. Vijay Kumar Pandey and Mr. Ishwar Singh who were shown as lecturers in the approved faculty of Magadh Teacher Training College, Gaya also shown as lecturers in A.M. College, B.Ed Course, Kotari Hill Road. Gaya. A clarification letter be issued to the both the institutions to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee takes final decision (i).4 S.M. Zaheer Alam Teacher Training College, Bahera, Darbhanga, Bihar (B.Ed.) (Private) (L.N. Mithila University) (Code No.APE00506) The complaints dated , , , , , 03,03,2014, , and received from the different complainants regarding illegal admission made by the S.M. Zaheer Alam Teacher Training college and collecting huge amount from the students. The Registrar of the Lalit Narayan Mithila University has also sought a clarification vide its letter No. 6372/14 dated regarding total intake of 200 students, which was granted by the ERC in two installments i.e vide order No. BR-S/E-9/96/6268 dated granted recognition with intake of 150 and vide order No. ERC/BR-S/E-9/96/14533 dated granted additional intake of 50 for making the total intake of 200 students. As per NCTE Regulation 2009, the institution has to accredited by NAAC with a Grade B certificate on or before 1 st April 2010 failing which the additional intake granted shall stand withdrawn with effect from the academic session The institution has failed to accredited by NAAC till date. Hence, committee decided to withdraw the additional intake of 50 granted vide order No. ERC/BR-S/E- 9/96/14533 dated with effect from the session The institution henceforth will make admission for intake of 150 only order No. BR-S/E-9/96/6268 dated (i).5 Sova Rani College Of Education, Vill-Gobindapur, Tehsil/Taluka-Birahimpur, City-Malda, P.O-Birampur, Dist-Malda, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Code No.:ERCAPP1272) A complaint dated , , received from Sukdeb Biswas, Bijon Poddar and other local people of Najarpur, Malda stating that the Malpractice and fraudulent activities is being done by the President of Sova Rani College of Education (D.El.Ed.). The institution building is not constructed in the same land and plot No. 143 & 145 which was submitted in the ERC office. Moreover, the said trust authority in order to commit malpractice laid down the signboard and have changed the colour of Sova Rani College of Education (D.El.Ed) to show that the name of college as Janardan College of Education (B.Ed). 1. A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to the District Magistrate, Malda, West Bengal with a request to direct the concerned officers to inquire the matter and submit the report to RD, ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar within 30 days. 2. The institution be asked to submit the certified copy of land documents from both of the institutions along with building plan. 4

5 ER (ii) (ii).1 Misc. Cases - (II) Central University of Bihar, BIT Campus, Po-B.V. College, Patna , Bihar (Govt.) (Course: 4 year Integrated B.A. B.Ed. and B.Sc.Ed.) The Registrar, Central University of Bihar had submitted an application for grant of recognition for innovative course viz. four 4-year Integrated B.A.B.Ed and B.Sc.B.Ed on and same was forwarded to the NCTE Hqrs for examination if its innovativeness. The NCTE Hqrs vide letter No. 61-1/2013/NCTE/Acad/A85909 dated has advised to the Registrar of the Central University, Bihar as follows: to stop admitting students in the said teacher education courses not recognized by NCTE and also inform that the degrees of the students already passed/admitted in the said teacher education courses shall be treated as invalid for employment purposes as per section 17(4) of the NCTE Act. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal Committee (ii).2 Central University of Jharkhand, Vill- Cheri/Manatu, Po- Bukru, Tehsil-Kanke (Gonda), Town/City-Ranchi, Dist.-Ranchi, Jharkhand (Govt.) (Course: 4 year Integrated B.A. B.Ed. and B.Sc. B.Ed.) Previously the Central University of Jharkhand had submitted an application for grant of recognition for innovative course viz. four 4-year Integrated B.A.B.Ed and B.Sc.B.Ed on and same was forwarded to the NCTE Hqrs for examination if its innovativeness. The said application had already been refused/dropped by the NCTE Hqrs vide letter No. 61-1/2013/NCTE/Acad/A83093 dated Further the Central University of Jharkhand has submitted a proposal of 4-year B.A. B.Ed and B.Sc.B.Ed. programme vide letter No. CUJ/CE/3/808/2014 dated to the Member Secretary, NCTE, New Delhi. A copy of the proposal of Central University of Jharkhand may be forwarded to the Member Secretary, NCTE, New Delhi for further necessary action in the matter. Volume-II Sl. No. ER-173.2(ii) Item No (ii).2 Content Court Case: Inspection conducted by the NCTE Hqrs. U/S 13 on the basis of direction given by the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand. S.S.L.N.T. Mahila Mahavidyalaya, Luby Circular Road, Hirapur, Dhanbad, Jharkhand (Course:B.Ed.) (Constituent Unit) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00443) A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda - Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-62/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86383 dated In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification vide letter dated to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the 5

6 NCTE Hqrs as well as reply dated submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under: The following deficiencies are still exist : (i) The land and building is not demarcated for the B.Ed. programme. (ii) Multipurpose hall is not available in the institution. (iii) There are no Psychology lab, Language learning lab. Art & work experience room, playground and the staff room, Principal room and common room, play ground and staff room for B.Ed course. (iv) Books in the Library are only 1006 which is less than the required 3000 books. Seating arrangement in the library is not available. (v) Computers in the ET room are not available. (vi) The HOD is not appointed for B.Ed. programme. (vii) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list appointing the faculty on regular basis and duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university alongwith their educational/professional certificates. (viii) Original FDRs of Rs lakh and Rs lakh are not submitted towards endowment fund and reserve fund respectively into joint account in the name of institution and RD, ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. Show Cause notice be issued to the institution as to why the recognition to the institution be not withdrawn on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides an opportunity under section 17(1) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee takes final decision. A copy may also be sent to the concerned University and State Govt (ii).3 Indra Singh B.Ed. Teacher s Training College, Vill- Bshunpur, Po- Garhwa, Plot No. 66, City Garhwa, Dist- Garhwa, Jharkhand (Course:B.Ed.) (Private)(Ranchi University) (Code No.APE00911) A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-67/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86412 dated In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification vide letter dated to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply dated submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under: (i) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university alongwith their educational/professional certificates. A clarification letter be issued to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee takes final decision. A copy may be sent to the Registrar of the concerned university for information. 6

7 (ii).4 Tata College, Chaibasa, Singhbhum (West), Jharkhand (Course: B.Ed.) (Constituent College) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00292) A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda - Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-65/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86417 dated In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification vide letter dated to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply dated submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under: (i) During granting recognition, the institution vide letter dated committed that the college has earmarked a separate complete building for the Department of Education of the College of B.Ed and separate psychology, Science lab, lecturers room and Library would be constructed in due course of time. (ii) As per recognition order, the B.Ed deptt shall be shift to its own building having separate campus within a period of 3 years. (iii) As per VT report, the new building for the Department of education is under construction and the B.Ed college is still functioning in the existing building of General college whereas the 08 years have already been elapsed. (iv) Laboratories and Library is not available in the B.Ed department. (v) All teaching faculty have been appointed on contractual basis for a period of less than one year. (vi) No regular HOD has been appointed to supervise the work of the faculty. (vii) Separate supporting staff for the B.Ed department has not been appointed. (viii) Original FDRs of Rs lakh and Rs lakh are not submitted towards endowment fund and reserve fund respectively into joint account in the name of institution and RD, ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. Show Cause notice be issued to the institution as to why the recognition to the institution be not withdrawn on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides an opportunity under section 17(1) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee takes final decision. A copy may also be sent to the concerned university and State Govt (ii).5 Jaspuria B.Ed. College, Plot No. 155, Vill.-Bisa, Po.- Getalsud, Tehsil/Taluka - Angara, Town/City - Ranchi, Dist. - Ranchi, Jharkhand (Course:B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No.ERCAPP990) A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No.327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda - Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-77/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86678 dated In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification vide letter dated to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of NCTE Hqrs as well as representation submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and decided as under: Recognition of the institution be continued. 7

8 ER Appeal Case The committee in its 171 st meeting decided as under: Proceedings of 173 rd Meeting (Emergent) of ERC-NCTE held on 26 th June, 2014 Jogendra Rajkrishna College of Teachers Education, Plot No-335, 335, 335/718,334, Vill-Amberia, Tehsil/Taluka-Hingalganj, P.O-Amberia, Dist-North 24 Parganas, West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal State University) (Code No.ERCAPP1022) As per the court order, the committee authorized the Regional Director to call the petitioner for hearing their case and thereafter a reasoned order communicate to the petitioner. Accordingly, a letter to the institution informing the date & time u.e at A.M. at ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar for hearing was issued on The committee noted the action taken by the Regional Director of ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. ER (i) (i).6 Misc. Cases-(I) (File linked to Code No.APP1272 : Volume-1) Janardan College of Education, Plot No , Vill - Gobindapur, PO Birampur, Tehsil/ Taluka Birahimpur, Town/City - Malda , West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Code No. ERCAPP122/2012) A complaint dated 7 th June 2014 against corruption in respect of Janardan College of Education applied for B.Ed. course. The construction work of the said college building have not stated so far and the trust had changed the colour of the college building of Sovarani College of Education (D.El.Ed) purposefully to show the same building to the inspecting team of NCTE. 1. A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to the District Magistrate, Malda, West Bengal with a request to direct the concerned officer to inquire the matter and submit the report to RD, ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar within 30 days. 2. The institution be asked to submit the certified copy of land documents both of the institutions along with building plan (i).7 B.N. Saha DAV Teacher s Training College, At- Sirsia, Near Giridih Block, Giridih Madhupur Road, Dist.- Giridih, Jharkhand (Private) (B.Ed.) (Vinoba Bhave University) (Code No.APE00581) A complaint dated received from Shri Manoj Kumar regarding non availability of land and building in the name of the institution and also running a public school in the same campus. 1. A copy of the complaint be forwarded to the Registrar of the concerned university with a request to inquire the matter and submit the report within 30 days. 2. A copy of the complaint may also be forwarded to the District Magistrate of the concerned district with a request to direct the concerned officer to inquire the matter and submit the report within 30 days. 8

9 Volume-III Sl. No. ER-173.2(ii) Item No (ii).6 Content Proceedings of 173 rd Meeting (Emergent) of ERC-NCTE held on 26 th June, 2014 Court Case: Inspection conducted by the NCTE Hqrs. U/S 13 on the basis of direction given by the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand. Patel B.Ed. College, Plot No. 49, Vill- Katamkuku, Po- Lodhma, Tehsil/Taluka-Karra, Town/City- Khunti, Dist.- Ranchi, Jharkhand (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University) (Code No.ERCAPP705) A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-72/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86391 dated In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution submitted its clarification vide letter dated to the ERC, NCTE, Bhubaneswar. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as reply dated submitted by the institution, the matter was discussed in detail and observed as under: (i) As per VT report, the salary to the teaching faculty and staff is paid on consolidated bases and other benefits like EPF, Medical facilities are not provided. A clarification letter be issued to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee takes final decision (ii).7 Loyola College of Education, Riverview Area, Telco works, Jamshedpur, East Singhbum, Jharkhand (Course: B.Ed.) (Private) (Ranchi University)(Code No.JH-S/E-2/96 & APE00204) A Public Interest Litigation vide W.P. (PIL) No. 327 of 2011 has been filed by Shiv Shankar Munda Vs - Chairperson NCTE & Ors in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. As per direction of the High Court of Jharkhand, the said institution was inspected by the NCTE Hqrs., New Delhi under section 13 of the NCTE Act 1993 and Rule 8 of NCTE Rules. Accordingly, the NCTE Hqrs issued a deficiency letter No.93-67/2014/NCTE/Insp/A86412 dated In response to the deficiency letter issued by the NCTE Hqrs, the institution has not submitted any reply in response to the deficiency letter. The committee considered the report of the NCTE Hqrs as well as deficiency letter issued on observed as under: (i) The institution is required to submit a fresh faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university. (ii) Salary statement of staff last 3 months and EPF deduction to be submitted. A clarification letter be issued to the institution to submit its reply within 30 days from the issue of the letter before the Committee takes final decision. 9

10 ER Appeal Case Presidency College Motbung, Plot No.-152, 151/246, 166/280, 167, St. No.-31, Vill/Tehsil/Taluka-Kanglatongbi, Town/City-Imphal West, Dist.-Senapati, Manipur (Code No:ERCAPP131/2012) In response to the ERC s refusal order No. ERC/ (II).38/2013/17313 dated 05.04/2013, the institution preferred and appeal on to NCTE Hqrs. The NCTE Hqrs vide its order F.No /2013/5 th Meeting-2014-A88753 dated remanded the case back to the ERC, NCTE for necessary action. The committee accepted the direction of the Appeal committee and decided as under: The case will be processed/taken up as per the new Regulation Manoranjan Saha Memorial B Ed College, Street Number-MB Road, Vill-Uttar Mouamari, Tehsil/Taluka/Town/City-Maynaguri, P.O-Bagjan, Dist-Jalpaiguri, West Bengal (B.Ed.)(Private) (University of North Bengal) (Code No:ERCAPP996) In response to the ERC s refusal order No. ERC/ /ERCAPP996 dated , the institution preferred and appeal on to NCTE Hqrs. The NCTE Hqrs vide its order F.No /2013/5 th Meeting-2014-A88753 dated remanded the case back to the ERC, NCTE for necessary action. The committee accepted the direction of the Appeal committee and decided as under: The case will be processed/taken up as per the new Regulation after submission the faculty list duly approved by the Registrar of the concerned university by the institution Aristotle College of Education, Plot No.-125, Vill.-Krishnanagar, P.O.-Mahurapur, Tehsil/Taluka-Rampurhat, Town/City-Mayureswar, Dist.-Birbhum, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (Code No.ERCAPP168/2012) In response to the ERC s refusal order No. ERC/ /ERCAPP168/2012/2013/22943 dated , the institution preferred and appeal on to NCTE Hqrs. The NCTE Hqrs vide its order F.No /2013/6 th Meeting-2014-A88513 dated remanded the case back to the ERC, NCTE for necessary action. The committee accepted the direction of the Appeal committee and decided as under: The case will be processed/taken up as per the new Regulation after receiving the reply from the institution Khalisani Basanti Teachers Academy, Plot No.-673/A, Vill.-Baganbati, P.O.-Khalisani, Tehsil/Taluka-Singur, Town/City-Chandannagar, Dist.-Hooghly, West Bengal (D.El.Ed) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (Code No. ERCAPP1441) In response to the ERC s refusal order No. ERC/ /ERCAPP1441/2013/22026 dated , the institution preferred and appeal on to NCTE Hqrs. The NCTE Hqrs vide its order F.No /2013 Appeal/6 th Meeting-2014-A88369 dated rejected the appeal of the institution and confirmed the order of the ERC. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal committee. 10

11 Chuyapara Swami Vivekananda Primary Teachers Training College, Plot No.-102, 764, 765, 766, Vill.-Chuyapara, P.O.-Fulpur, Tehsil/Taluka- Bhagwangola II, Town/City-Murshidabad, Dist.-Murshidabad, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (Code No.ERCAPP1565) In response to the ERC s refusal order No. ERC/ /ERCAPP1565/2013/22455 dated , the institution preferred and appeal on to NCTE Hqrs. The NCTE Hqrs vide its order F.No /2014 Appeal/6 th Meeting-2014-A88409 dated rejected the appeal of the institution and confirmed the order of the ERC. The committee noted the decision of the Appeal committee. Krishnanagar College of Education, Plot No.-124, Vill.-Krishnanagar, P.O.-Mahurapur, Tehsil/Taluka-Rampurhat, Town/City-Mayureswar, Dist.-Birbhum, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (Code No.ERCAPP171/2012) In response to the ERC s refusal order No. ERC/ /ERCAPP171/2012/2013/22945 dated , the institution preferred and appeal on to NCTE Hqrs. The NCTE Hqrs vide its order F.No /2013 Appeal/6 th Meeting-2014-A88529 dated remanded the case back to the ERC, NCTE for necessary action. The committee accepted the direction of the Appeal committee and decided as under: The case will be processed/taken up as per the new Regulation after receiving the reply from the institution. ER (i) Misc. Cases-(I) (i).8 Vidyasagar Teacher Training College (B.Ed.) Vill - Bhabanandapur, PO - Goda-Annada Dist - Burdwan West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (University of Burdwan) (Code No.APE00759) A complaint received on against the institution regarding illegally setting up of teachers training college during the reign of Left Front Government at the campus of Maharaja s High School, Kalna, Distt- Burdwan and Sarba Shiksha Building of Kalna Maharaja s High School by submitting the forged documents to the ERC. The committee considered the complaint and decided as under: A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to the District Magistrate of the concerned District with a request to inquire the matter and to send the report to ERC, NCTE within 30 days. State Council of Educational Research & Training, Vill - Patna City, (i).9 PO - Mahendru, St. - Ashok Rajpath, City - Patna, Dist - Patna, Bihar (Govt.) (D.El.Ed.-ODL Mode) (Code No.APE00980) A complaint dated received from Sailesh Kumar, Chhapra, Dist- Siwan regarding illegal admission made by the SCERT Patna in the recognised D.El.Ed course (Distance Mode). The committee considered the complaint and decided as under: A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to the Director, SCERT, Patna and Secretary, Bihar Board of Primary Education with a request to inquire the matter and to send the report to ERC, NCTE within 30 days. 11

12 (i).10 Govt. Teachers Training College (College of Teacher Education), Ranchi, Jharkhand (Govt.) (B.Ed.) (Ranchi University) (File No.JH-S/N-6/2001) A complaint dated received from R.K. Jha, ADM Retd., Jora Talab Road, Bariyatu, Ranchi regarding careless transfer/posting of Principal in Govt. T.T. (B.Ed.) College, Ranchi by HRD, Jharkhad. The committee considered the complaint and decided as under: A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to Secretary, Department of Secondary Education, Ministry of HRD, Jharkhand with a request to inquire the matter and to send the report to ERC, NCTE within 30 days (i).11 Mahatma Primary Teachers Training Institute, Plot No.-LR 629, St.No.-Porahgati, Vill.-Porahgati, P.O.-Hogalbaria, Tehsil/Taluka-Andharkota, Town/City-Karimpur, Dist.-Nadia, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (WBBPE) (Code No.ERCAPP1641) A complaint dated received from Md. A Rahaman (Advocate) Kolkata High Court informing that all the land documents of Mahatama PTTI are forged and home made. The committee considered the complaint and decided as under: A copy of the complaint may be forwarded to the District Magistrate of the concerned District along with all land related documents with a request to verify/inquire the documents and to send the report to ERC, NCTE within 30 days (i).12 Chatta Primary Teacher s Training Institute, Po-Chatta Kalikapur, Via-Batanagar, Ps-Maheshtala, Dist-South 24 Parganas, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (WBBPE) (Code No.ERCAPE00771) A Notice dated received from Pinaki Bhattacharya (Advocate) High Court, Kolkata on behalf of SK Meahabub Alam & others in respect of non-action on the previous complaints submitted by the SK Meahabub Alam & others against the Chatta PTTI. The committee considered the notice and observed as under: The complaints dated & submitted by the SK Saiful Alam and another complaint dated submitted by Md. Sabir Mahmood have already been forwarded to the Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education vide letter No dated with a request to inquire the matter by conducting an inspection and submit the report within 30 days. Reply from the Secretary, West Bengal Board of Education is still awaited. The committee considered the complaint and decided as under: A reminder may be sent to the Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education alongwith a copy of present complaint with a request to submit the inquiry report as early as possible. 12

13 ER (ii). Misc. Cases-(II) (ii).1 The NCTE Hqrs. vide letter No.A78554, dated granted relaxation for increase of intake capacity in the existing teacher training institutions in the State of Odisha (F.No.ERC/06-2/OR/2011) The NCTE Hqrs. vide letter No.A78554, dated granted relaxation for increase of intake capacity in the existing teacher training institutions in the State of Odisha. Accordingly, the recognition was granted to all the 69 institutions subject to condition that the deficiencies pointed out by the VT would be completed upto December However, VT letter to all the institutions were issued as per the decision of the ERC, NCTE. The Director, Directorate of Teacher Education and SCERT, Odisha, Bhubaneswar vide letter dated received in this office on informed that the visiting team of NCTE has visited all the Teacher Education Institutions in the State of Odisha except the following 10 institutions with regard to enhancement of seats:- (1) District Institute of Education and Training, Rayagada, Bissamcuttack (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1924) (2) District Institute of Education and Training, Bargarh (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1860) (3) District Resource Centre, Jharsuguda, Panchpara (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1885) (4) District Institute of Education and Training, Sambalpur (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1870) (5) Govt. Secondary Training School, Kishorenagar, Angul (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1914) (6) District Institute of Education and Training (DIET), Angul (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1879) (7) Distrtct Institute of Education & Training, Kandhamal (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1855) (8) Govt. Secondary Training School, Bhanjanagar (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1915) (9) District Resource Centre, Sonepur (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1853) (10) District Institute of Education and Training (DIET), Keonjhar (Course: D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Code No. ERCAPP1859) VT be directed to inspect the institution and submit the report within 20 days. A copy of the letter may be sent to State Govt, Department School and Mass Education alongwith the Director, TE&SCERT for appropriate action. 13

14 (ii).2 School of Bachelor of Education, Plot No. 93, 121, 126/669, Vill/Po.- R.Sitapur, Tehsil- Paralakhemundi, City- Paralakhemundi, Dist.- Gajapati, Orissa (Private) (Centurion University of Technology and Management) (Code No.ERCAPP947) The application of the institution submitted for B.Ed was refused on and appeal of the institution was also refused and the NCTE Hqrs vide order dated 29,11,2011 remanded back the case to ERC with a direction to process the application of the petitioner as and when it submits NOC from the State Government, The Govt of Odisha, School and Mass Education Department submitted a order No /SME dated stating that the State Government has decided that no objection certificate to any private institution can not be issued for B.Ed and D.El.Ed course and as such the case of the appellant is rejected. The committee noted the order of the Hon ble Supreme Court as well as the decision of the Government of Odisha. The meeting ended with vote of thanks. 14