78989 : 6 7 ;21< ; ;BD >D\"K D D- 4D72A 2& ]L ]& ;< 43V.

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "78989 : 6 7 ;21< ; ;BD >D\"K D D- 4D72A 2& ]L ]& ;< 43V."

Terence Cunningham
5 years ago
Views:

1 59-76 *+, %& 1!"# %5 6! : 6 7 ;21< ; (91/3/20 : 89/8/16 : ) 7231@D E72F5 & 4G B HI % 4 >? 7231@ ;2 472A B C >7 B 47231@D MD% 1LDL< D#4L #4&B "A B 4G ;K3 J2# R@ & 7231@.< 2& K@ 4& N7"1 4& 985 4& 5O2P >D7.>< K@ 4 "1,3 7K1@2& K7K 2S >7 B & 7K & 8L ;2D D< 61D32& DW VD D7K!D& 47231@D D723*ODU TD& D&YD& V X1 7 V 7K B ;7A M% & >7 %G # 47231@LI D#C# & ;2 472A >7 231@LI K@267.(;267) & 1PG < 17K ;DK@D ;BD >D\"K D D- 4D72A 2& ]L ]&.2< M" L _A A 7231^ = ;< 43V.V 7K #C# 7231@ 7B*O 7231@LI aalem@ut.ac.ir :!".1

2 1397 %& 1!"# :2 95: );<-= >?1%2 1( 3 45/ * 6* 7* )85.3 0&/ % &' ( )*+,-%. )*+,-%. 2*A, 1/ ٣ +.-BF >B 1" )-5" )*+,-%. >B 1" 1.2@(7 )*+,-%. 7* D5E4? 3 ٢ C3+-2* >B 7* ):5I >8 D* ),+-, +5T- 3 (Q +HG RS" * )*+,-%. J*+,-%. ).2@* "P*(* C3+-2* J*+,-%. ).2@(7 7X )K V W* 04?.*) JU"*+/ 3 +OK- +HG S/ >+A/14L+ Y. 9? * Z G D54? 3 *)?@(7 (Q G*I RS" * )*+,-%. G*I RS" * )*+,-%. +.*+.?-%. C3+-2* >*+( MNO ^( &* 7* +)..*?]3;.(280.( C4< MN " 3 )5G >+ * -%. +.-BF >*+( )B3.2*/) +[K 1(?@(7 :1384 J1+5S() ( +") J( )G*_-* 3 `S* )*+,-%..() +-S5( 1" * )"+-S 1.2a3 )*+,e4l 7* 1.2a3 )*+,+ 1(?*%) f+;- 3 +; >?U/ 7* )2/9SV +(*+( _5 )-%2a3 cdb 1(.") >*YL.(. +A/+55T D5*I 3 G*I 7* >*1G4g.1 J]5(* J).21S >?1H+G 3 2 P3+2 ).2@(7 7* U+-, ]H1( )*+,-%. G*I RS" )/ Bi D* W4 )*+,-%..45/ * ).218 L 3 ).5. 0+h 3 ).5. )Y-K cdb D* 7* ^( )..* 3 >*_L* 7* 65( >_5V?Z" D* J+5,) +h * )G4-L* 3 >*+( * -%. W&; J6*+, +(?5k+ 3?e 7* 9?*+ ( 1" )?1;Bj ^+() "1( >++5k :1385 J)58 ) ") l?4??-%. ( * % - 3 *A,) 1( ") +m 3 nax Z5<d oi. 7* 1?,F * )G4-L* *_," J)*+,-%. * )G4-L* \. U*4? 3 +,95h% 3 U(%?%..7*+p(?%. 08Bi *+* 3 * *+I )G4-L* W+? 7*+ +(?%. +K3 D*.?) *+I +5Qq d.( Ferdinand de Saussure 2. Lévi-Strauss 3. Louis Althusser

3 61 & a3 #B& Z(I J*U+" T2* r% 1" )?[L 3 58I 1( 1L ( M+H.*).2 ) m 1".* )G4-L* Wh 7* >*15% J-%. 1" 1" * >*+* 7* >7 5( N:-.* J-%.. ) */ )sm 1( 1" *1- * )23 >5I *+* >*7F +( -%..2?*% Pu +? 1*3(]*t 3 )& ):5:X >8 " v+m 7* & :5:X RS" 3 * 5-%* * )4<G )23 1" -2* 5"q &F )23 * )*+,-%. 3 4S* * % C3+-2* >B.(432 :1387 J:5:X) RS" 1( ") nax v5:d 7* * U\. 6: )*+,-%. (?*% DK4.*) )4<G +,* 1".* 1-K D* +( *-.* )*+,-%..7.) +( * U\. 1" F Zx )? (5<") ]Y. 3?_4 7* ) h (!/ J2( *8 ) F 0S* 3 " >?3-. 3?6" 9SV 1(." 9?*+ * 8 * 1" 2( 1-2* L3 5B 3 6" >_5V 1" Y >7( +,24 ) r% l?+ {*37* ];+S 7* +Y%)( +,24 z 1(?6" D* ) 7 &.8 )( U+K *+* >?6" (*)4 >7( D* D5*I ( 3 ),+, +( 9"X >?Wh * 1" 2) *8 3* +h.(218 :1386 J>4X*) 2( %2 Z(I J2 1-%2 &F )3 ]Y. +( 9"X G*I +( +-S5( 3D*7*..* )*+,]H 6YL >+K - 7* )*+,-%. {*+=-.*?%.+( 9"X 7* 1".* 8.") ٢ G*I 3 D5*I J}(*3 D-+, *+I 9? " 7* 1K<( J* )*t@3 )&L3 8 }(*3 0-%.+( * 8 1K<( J* 8 0kk M..* )*+,-%. 5"q ]H.2).2) }(*3 ZO >7.8 >?*_(* +( D5( D* 3 *) G 1".* D* +( 6u+ 3 U( )*+,Z" 7* >+@ *3 )*+,-%..*A,) W:!KG+( J") 1" -5 ) F 3 -? 9-5. Wh D* U+F &F J)G4-L* >?U\. 7* 65/ >3 7* 1" J95"3 Z5 * O >*+( *3 8( 1( >N5 U,F.(95 :1386J)) 50 0? )*+,-%. +() W )*+,-%. )-58I*3 18 L 1" ( :-8 1.2a3 )*+,Z" +( 5"q ( J(2 )* %2 v+m 7* & >+ >?- o5u D5E4?..* *+* L3 1( Z5<: Z(I+5k 1. Formalism 2. Immanent

4 1397 %& 1!"# )* Z4G D+>+ J( :-8 3D*7* J2) ZHX )=2+5k 3 )G4-L* D5*I.") 9?*+ 18 L * 6 F65/ }*+2 3.* )G4-L* +.*+. )-58I*3 ()S"% ZO ) 3?3( 7*.* >*1G4g J18 L 1" W&; v<% ( 95"3 >3 +h 7*.") ), ) * )-7 >y 1" `+-S ].X*.!KG+( 1 2) U*7 5<" z 0(O 1( 18 L 7* J)5x. >+[!" +? 7* 65( )*+,-%.?U/ 08Bi >*+( )=+5k )23 1" * ) _4? a3 ( D5B3* >*+( 1".* ٢ ) 7 * ]8Bi +(*+( 3 +" ).2@(7 *3 )-5B8 1K<( (1857 7)( 3 4g >y.* *+I )= ]8Bi )8 J>*UF 1 3 * >*1-2A, 1 J.* +h 7* % r% G*I 1" *) )G4-L* >& >3..* +,95h% 3 U(% >**+I ) h 3*..* G*I D54? 7* U;-.* b+265/ 3 * * 9? (?U\*3 ]3; )-X 3 by* d 1K<( 1 * 8 3 *) ٣ >+[ 3 -;, )K.+") *+I+( 7* oi. 3 D5(...+") L3L ٤ 7* Z:- 3.* )G4-L* )B3 )H% 3 >+ 6" 1( J2 U* }(.. }. 7* ) &;..* % 3 %. L*3 1" J+ >*+( 1K<( J2)4 U* 5=S >+ -;, Z4G 1".* )G4-L* +5( Z".(dant,1991: 50).* Bs )3+5( / z >8 * * 7* >*1,Y-G* P4-L* z >yg* >52* 1( ]4<" )-5-7/ ).2@(7 3 * D5( 95:- >*1i(* g* 3 B D-+, U 7* ( ]YG?5-7/ ^2 ):< SX D?t >5 95?; ZK2 1(?8.2) 1( 1" )H%1( U2 1-.5/ &F 1( 1" r% 3 )5G >?U\*3 3 )I( r% 3 )5G >?_5V >5 & 1( 3 U+" *31F 3 1+iK BX 7* :1388 JB?) ( >3.* U(7( J>3 ).2@(7.+" ( )G4-L* )-L 3 +; m1(?u\*3 ( :-8...+") Z5<d ]3; 3 1i(* +K<4G 3 1( 1L ( 1. Synchronic 2. Diachronic 3. Parole 4. Langue

5 63 & a3 #B& 8 ( by* 1K<( J-5 *8 % ]*t 1">m1(.-+, +h 52* }(*3 1K<( J+; >52* 1 * 58I*3.. 7* >3+5/ >3 7* 95?; >8 X +? 1(.* 3 -" JU+g/ _5 J«_5»..* %2 _4 WG >8 1( JU. ]YG1(.2) ` ]3;?Z5KS +HG 08Bi (...(110 :1385 J>*4<G )58 ) * L3 f*+-* -%. 3 8 G J+" >H G*I +K<4G 3 8 D5( }(*3 7* M+H 1" * W B 1" +" Z- 9? 1( 1S W&; 0i.*31( ٢.2) Z5KS ]H * ( >**+I 3 >5-%* }(*3.*.. ).2@(7 K* 0-? 8 3 ]H D5( fdb* 3 >5-%* Y 3 7.) >3+u * )Gu >3F ٣ >5-%* \*3.(Dant,1991: 100) U, =2.") =-* 1**7F J?*=( 1" )H z, +" 1K<( ^* J.* U-* L )(7 08 L z 1" >*1S * >+55T 1, 5? )* ٤ 58I*3 1".* >5-%* +h D* 7* )8 J.* U_5[*)( 0S ]H ;, ( 7* *.. 1" ( 1< D* 1,D* *...(100 :1382 0S* J..) * 8 ( )85Ym 5/ 1, 5?.+" 3 )-5-7/ ).2@(7 )*+,+?L.*U2 Z5KS B 3 * 9I 3 7* 7* ) 1" +" B 3 * D5( >+A/ -L* 0i(* * 8 3 2) >(Z; r% >*1,1( 5? )8 J.* >**+I 3 >5-%* )(7 0S )(7 Wh +? 3 * L3.7.).2.1 r% m1( 3 )G4-L* W<G * >.. )*+,-%. ).2a3 1" )" D5-= 65( ( >3.( *+,-%. ).2@* PY C3+-2* >B +7 1;I3)( 1" *) 5-%* 3 U** I Z" 1( * U\. J+( "1( ).2@* 6% 1".?1S 7* 18 L >3 +h 7*..* +5.* )[?+ >?-%. ]5X 08Bi )*+,-%. n? * % " C3+-2* >B..* 1K<( J18 L >.*+ 1.(40 :1386 J`"() +") )+8 )G4-L* ),7?1S 1. Signified 2. Signifier 3. Arbitreaire 4. Immotive

6 1397 %& 1!"# P D* 4G n?..* +K2F 4G* >?-%. RS" 1.2@* 1(..* )G4-L* }(*3 >-%. Z5<d ZO )(7 "1( )*+,-%.?1* 1" 5 D* 0S >-%. Z5<d 7* n? C3+-2* J") D?t 1[V +5m.* 1".* D* 1K<( JS*) 1[V.(malesevic,2002: 2 e<i 58I*3 D* 7* &F L3 }(*3 3 a3" 1( +S( D?t G*I RS" >*+( C3+-2* 3 vi )( _5V +? S/ vi D- * 3* " C.* J@X2 )%+(.3F >3 >3S% >?ZK2 RS" C3+-2* n?.(188 :>4X*) *1-* 8 )( *_, +? S/ 8 D- ) 3 >**+I >?ZY4. S/ `+-S ):i >? +m 3 `+-S >-%. C3+-2* +5m.* vi )-%2a3 U, 7* 05B3* %. -" n? )? 1K<(.(malesevic: 90).2) d >-%. ).+(.?>\Bx* 3?Ui.* D+Z " J5 +5m.* %2 >*+( ) h G*I D- M+H 3 D+v5I >3S% ZK2 6% >365/ >*U +? 1( 1".* >-%. "37. %2 :.* +1*7*3+/<( +65/ D* ( C3+-2* )B3 J4) vi )( 3* +h?ui.*.(184 :>4X*)?). +S( D?t 95K +5m.* vi RS" ( >3 +h 7*..* RB= ]21( + ( *+7 J.* 15(( )4" C3+-2* 0*+,-%. +K; 7* ).5. 2*+(. 0S* J* L3 18 L +55T 3 * +(*+( 1" >*U*_ >?3d L 3 l?+ 1" S*) 1,@4??@* 1K* + ( J.* );- N:* >B.4) Z4& 3 ˆ/ >_5V 9? )-X 1K<( J N:* + &1 J") :B* &F 0;Bj 3 7* 1" ) Wh * +5m.* 3 >3S% }(*3 Jl?+ C3+-2* O m1(.54&).. 1" Wh ZO M:5I J.* *%+( ]3; 3 by* J ZO?6: +[ 7* a_4 3 by* ]H & / >8 >3S% }(*3 3 )-%.@3 }(*3 *7 )G4-L* 3 )[?+ ]s: 3D*7*..* 9& Z(I +?*% 3 /.*)85Ym+5k 3 )*t+5k.3.1 ( u *+m +.-BF.2) b(+ +.-BF >B 1(!" +? 7* 65( *+,-%. 95" oi. 7* * >+ 5?t 3-6% 0*+,-%. 95" >3.( >+h 95 3* 1mX* * &F 1" *) >-I* }(*3 * *+* +.-BF.+" nax Z5<d

7 65 & a3 #B& 9548 * >3+ >3"@*3 0*+,+u 1"1,@4?...* U+".(63 :1388 JB?) 5S=() 9548 *!" 0*+,+u ]d< 9? +.-BF J5S=() 3 )<[? J)-5BFU* J);< 95" Z" )-5" )*+,-%. PY )-5". +.-BF 3 )-5 3* >?>3 " 7( * +k )-5B5-_,*.(276 :1384 J1+5S() *) +Q* r%1(!" )[-=/ NiH* QF *+,-%. 95" 4_G 0i: 1" 1.2+8, dy +5Qq d +.-BF..* 1 +. )8!" 1" ( U5. 1g5- D* 1( J2 P*(* 9<G 0;< }. 7* U5.Œ*1( 95 3* 3 (+x 0S*W% 95B+ 7* a*>+k Š<( Z(I!" QF >*1.2+8, D5V 1" ( :-8 +.-BF..* 1-+, 3 (!" )*L 3 )-5 3* >?1-2 D5( >_4 3.* ).2 1" 5. 1g5- D* 1( U3 D*!".(Hindess,2007: 396F) * L3 6+K )[-=/ }(*3 3?3+5 D* 3 5 )G4-L* }(*3 7* >*1G4g _L +?L ]*t 5B }(*3 3 5B >?3+5 7* d(!" 3D*7* J* >+,D58 6: 1" 5B..* U+" nax * )= 5?t *_," 6: 1, +? 3?) 5=S * );5BK 3 R'3 1[V *+* 1" ( D* +.-BF )..* *j. 5B }(*3 1(..* 1-+, >* L 1" [*) )&( 4_G 0i: 1( 6.+/ D* 1(./ >L3L D* >\Bx* %. 3 >* L.2) 5B7( 1[V >*1 +. )[?+ ]s: 1( D-%*+/ >*+( +.-BF ).+(!" +h 7* * >\Bx* W&; 6.+/ D* 1(./ +.-BF.2 ( e *L >[B* 7* )<"1( +.-BF d( ( >\Bx*. t" )?,F >8 >\Bx* )8 J") >_5V 1K<( J5 t" )?,F +[ >\Bx* >3 7 F ^2) 1-, (3/(+7 7* >\Bx* +.-BF +h 7*.2) 1-2*/ )&( 3 + U,F% 1".*.2) 1& + L3 >+A/18 L *+ 3 )27 F Wh v+m ^5 7* {% ),7 1" 7.) * ); >y 1( >\Bx* ^+5, y D* 14?.(121 :1385 J>*4<G )58 ) * L3 >\Bx* _5V 5? " 1" )8 3?4 J?1S 7* <4 3 )B5% >y J* 58I*3 ( )my* 1" )y 1" )?U52.* :-8 >3.*)G4-L* 3 >-I* J).5. >?%. 5B7( 3 5B J@7 J@*+ ) ") ),7 3 ` * % ]5X U3 &F?@* 1. Capital

8 1397 %& 1!"# }*+2 1( )B5% )-? 1".* >\Bx* z 7* +Qq- 1".* >*+ >\Bx* ^.* )?,F >\Bx* )47( 0B: )8I*3 +( +.-BF _"+4 58u3 ( *+* )B5% by* +[4 >\Bx* J@.D(.7.) +( * + Y.1( 1K<( J5?U* 3+4<I 1( b(+ M+H >\Bx* )8I*3 +.-BF ).2a3 D*.(Williams,2002: 36) * U(*/U\. >[*3 1" ( )*4S* 1<4L 7* 9? 3*.* >*1i(* 3 > Ja*>-%. L3.* 1S >3 ).2%2 )..* 0i(* >3 +h 7*.5S") 6BV 1( * 58I*3 ( D?t 0i.*3)( 0i(* 3 5()4+( 1" )G4-L* M 4 >?+"" (.* ) +h 3 D?t D5(.* + D?t 18 L 7* ei*3.+5,) ZK2 >5-%* 3 1?*=YB m1( >L P +[4 0(O 1( >\Bx*.5 DK4 U+ 1" JB?) )G4-L* ]I >?-%. >*+(.* >+[ qs D5E4? )-58I*3 7* U&G +( a7*+/ 3 %. " 5B 52 +? z\bx* >?U[-..(73 :1380 ( 18 L +..* U2 U3+/ >\Bx* }. 1".* )(7 *7 D?t 3D*7*.* * % 3 7) Z4G 1(. >3 U,F% 1" )K\Bx* >? +65/ v+m 7* z\bx* >?47( J+[ ]YG1(.") )G4-L* *7F *_," (?U\. 1( )5G >?@* v+m D* 7* 3?) ZK2 J)<54d >?-%..(23 :1385 J):B%) ") 5% 1" )*L 1( )8 J2) ;,).. J@F BI * ]Gu 3 _,+( >7**9SV ( 1K<(.(7 :1379 J+B")! ".4.1 :,)..3 >?U7 F J2* * 1( 1,>*% +" +?L >Y +( 1 3 +[K X+(.( )*+,-%. >+h 3-. D+ _( >*1i(* +( 5"q 3 )*7]*t ei*3 1".* )(7 }(*3 0-%. 1K<( J?& 3?*/ ]*t 1 8 )*+,-%. +h 7* 8 3D*7*..* 3 3 _4 3 by* 0-%.+( _5 )(7 0i(* D* % 7* 1K* 1 3 F / *) J)G4-L* 9h )5X ( U*4? 3 % 5<".2( L 65/ 7* 1K* 1 2) 5B 8 1(.(140:@4?) 2( L 65/ DX.") K*?*/ * ]*t 3 +?, 1, +? *+7 J.* )K_5- u 65( 1(+g 3? 1K* J+" -L* 1*+,]*t 9& 7* 1" ( D* )*+,-%.

9 67 & a3 #B& )*+,-% */ >+?L 58I*3 7* )5G W&; z +( )-Y >L3 3? 1" ( D* 1< ei*3 J* L3 % >_5V 1" )*+,-%. +K3.(newman,2007: 5) 2) D558 )3+5( %. z 0i.*31( 1(+g.*R<-= D4 >?@&L ( R<-= >?l?+ D". JR<-= *+* 1" +A/) 7*.+5,) +h )Y >+ 3 l?+ VV * 5N:G )*+,-%. / >-%. 1" F) / )-I3 JU, D* 7* 5N:G.,)4 D=. Žd 5N:G.(116 :1385 J>*4<G )58 ) 2( 1-+, ZK2 )4 9h 3 2( U F #$% &.2 3 5N:G >[*)Y vi J)*+,-%. 0 ** )*+,-%./.2*A, +%q- ).5. 0S* +( )+[2 ]*+5Qq 3 +" Y )K_5- u X 7* 7 * 1H+G D* *+7 JS ).5. *3 M45:- )*+,-%./.* *+I +5Qq d * 1H+G D* )(* +[ >*37 7*.) 4g 3 <- 1(..* )*+,-%. *1BY +5g7 7* 1:<X D5B3* 3 D* >?1kk..* )*+,-%./ 1( 33 )..* >*1hdB )*+,-%. J2) _"+4-?-%. 3 +? 1"*+V J.* +[K 1(S >3X >+K U, 3 : 1( )*+,-%./ * J") U( &F R5H 1( & )*+,-%. >*1-%.+( D?t 95K C3+-2* >B MNO.* 5"q?-%. >+A/Z4d * J+" 5q * 1-K D* )*+,-%./.*) )3 >?Z(: +( )-Y 3 )[?+.+, +h U\. 3: >*+( * )y 1i5X D* :7* *]YG )*+,-%. +(*+( )*+,-%./ 4G >?),3 BH* )*+,-%./ U, 1")BX J+5,) W: +55T +( * ]YQ )*+,-% D* )*+,-%./ )..* n+x )YG1(..* W3* ),+, ( +( *?-%. J)*+,-%..2 ^.* +55T % & 1" 2) 1HN% J") 3d?-%. RS" 1( * % " 3?) o5l+ )*+,-%..3 ^") % *3 _5 )*+,-%./ 1")BX ).+( 0-;52 )*+,-%./ * J.* )<" 3 WG G*I >L3L )4548 )?[ ( ).2a3 D- 1( :-8 3.*+,9<G )*+,-%..4 ^.?)[-.5/ 3?,.2) *3 )4<Gu )8u 7* )*+,-%./ * J)4<G

10 1397 %& 1!"# ") Z4G )*+,-%. 4? >3X 6? +65/ )*+,-%./ 3?]3; v+m 7* & 3.* >**+I 3 >5-%* >+ @3 8 1" *A,) D* +( * + )*+,-%./.() 8?nN-%* 3 3: >*+( )?[L 1" 2) ( ).5. 3 )G4-L* >*U/ >?@4-;, *7 3 )G4-L* 0:G 1( U\...* U\. 7Y 7* U\. ` 1" ( D* )*+,-%. _( DX 1" 2 1-;, D* 7* 65/..* R<-= 0*7]*t 3 )K_5- +5k U[ L 1< D54? 3 *) )(7 M+H * n*+m* }5d ") +K* 1K<( J")4 ); * U[ D* )*+,-%./ J( )*+,-%. +h ( 1K<( J )4 )I(?*/ n+h R5H )*+,-%./.(newman:5).+5,) +h 3* >*+( * : )* JU\. >*+( 5<G 7* )&L3 D-+, 1-(*3 9? 1( )2+[ JU2 n3+8 1EF ei*3.(376 :1386 J>4X*) 3 7* ") )8. X D5G 3.* )*+,-%. - 1( C3+-2* ** *+,-%./ 4S* z 0(O 1( * `*\ O >*+( _5 *+,-%. 4S* 3 D+ _( 7* X D5G )B3 J") "+X C.*+( D?t "37. >+5,ZK2 +( )Y C3+-2* >B + 1( *.3) 421(?* )[S54? PL* Z5B1( _5 *.. ).2@(7 3 ") *3 : J)3 7* YG >*+( an 3 +5,) :-* ( 1( )N8-.* B z 1( +(*+( U*4? 3 5S) ++( )?[L * 3 () _ B *+,-%./ >+K.?) 3: ) )-.*+ }(*3 5YO 3 4 1" * )-5L \. 1:Ym J.K * )*+,-%./ >?2*+( :- :1379 Jl<"F) +A/)4 J2(? Z4d QF ZO ) 2) nax D* U\..-? 8 3 JU\. 7* D5S5/ 1K<( J2)4 )+8 )" (% 3 1VpK * yx )-I3 (" D[4? >*U\. JU\. D* ei*3.2) >-, 3 7B QF Z5 D52 1( 15Y2 z 1 1" JU2)YiI \. z )-X J.* U295: >*U\. 1K<( J5 1VpK 3 1" )8 J") T2* * U2D_[L 3 `+d- J+OK- >?@K 1K<( J@5( D5V >*+( 8.(251 :1380 JB?) ") 7* >-, 3 7B )-2*+( D5V )L3+%.* ),*_ >.1( 3 3 +OK- )<K2 1K<( J5 (Q >*U\. U2+% 3 U5K )<42 ( )= 1K<( 3 1VpK )= JU\ *..* 5? }% 1, +? I 3

11 69 1( *-(*.2) RBj & a3 #B& ).+( ).5. 0S* +( 1*+,-%./ +K3 3 ]*+5Qq 1 ** + 0+h +5Qq!p. 3 97*+/) ).5. 7X )K2UB2 ]*+5Qq.5g. 95?*% ).5. 0+h 7X * ]( ٣ '()*.1.2 >*+,-%./ 4S* J * `*\ }. 1".* )23 3 D JW&; )K2UB2 % * 1"*+V ٤ 0;< ( J 1;) J95") ):< a3 * )K2UB , "1( 3 P*(* >*+ >?& ( U, 5? 3 U, 5? JU2 U5 )K2UB2 1EF :) ٦ ٥ )K2UB2.(Derrida, 1999: 5).* 1-2* u 1;) 6 * ( 3 7* +k 0;< L >?Z(: 3?U7. J?ŽI >L3L J( 1-1S )K_5- +K; 4. 1( >3 _5 ` U* D* 3.* +ux.2?*% +g S% 1( & )K_5- +K; * >+Y" 3 >+TH ] *I* 7* * )K2UB2 * 0S* 7*! +-+" 3 )Y*+ 1<<. ] h 3 ) &; 3 D4y- 1" ") R+8 n? D*+((.(newman:84).* +k 0;< L >?U7. 7* >+,S* D5E4? 1( ( 1" )Gu * J.* +k 0;< )K2UB2 n?.5.k 3 9g 0+h 0x** )G )K2UB2 1".* D* +" 1( +?h 3 G* +? >/ *)( 3 1;I3)( )<"m1( 3 U*4? )K2UB2..* % >?2[*65/ %2 3 D-. )* Z:G 9? 3 >+h 54"X 3?:5:X )& 3 )8iI ` Z:G > D-;2F+( )K2UB2 n?..* 15B3* >?8 )+, -. '()* U*4? )(+k )4<G-);< >?1S* 1".* D* )(+k z_5-1( * : 7kF 0i:.* 58I*3 1".* U2 1-2*/ 8( 3 U+F % 1" *U( )YiI3 +HG )*7 )-5 Jz5 +(*+( ( D* ( 7* * % 1-*- _,+? )K_5-0S* 1. Deconestruction 2. Death of the Author 3. Jacques Derrida 4. institutions as such 5. philosophy as such 6. iscipline as such

12 1397 %& 1!"# _4 J:5:X +(*+( Š3 J. +(*+(. JyX +(*+( 5k J)-? +(*+( J),7 +(*+( + J 3 +(*+( 9L JU +(*+( D?t J>4? +(*+(.* 1-2* L3 (]*t 1( 9xI) 3 Z:- >*1,1( 3 J% >*+( _,+??)YiI3 D*...+ ZH* )4?D*? yx z_5- +-, 1".* )G *.(376 :1386 J>4X*) J+?L J)K_5- Wh )<" m1(..* ZH* e( 3 P+ J),(+[ 3 2).* P+ ),(+[ +5k 3 ZH* _5? 1-2*/.2) 1-2[* 3+5/ J + G 3 ZH*.(103 :1379 J@*+45u) BX 3 >++( >+[ +( ii z U*4? )3 >?Z(: D* 1".* D* 1< +h 1(.a7*)( 3 x*7 >_5V ^2) 1-2*/ +-&" 3 >+[ 3 * )-.*+ 2 95?*% Zx z_5-04sv+. 1( J95" 7kF 1" )3 >?Z(: D* 7* z +? 7* *.") 7kF -;,/-2 )3 7* *+ D* *.95" )*7%. 3 >7.*3 ٢ )N8-.* :5:X 1( Z5 >*+( >*_(* 4? +k -;, >3 5:G 1( ٣ 7* +3+ ZK2 z J-;, 7* `+i% n*+d* z ZO -2 JZ(: 3.* U2 1-2*/ *.(newman: 85).* U2 1-2[* J.* + a+a/ 8-3 1hX += 1" -;, -;, J.* U2 U* o5l+ -2 +( U*4? +k 0;< -;, 1"?) 1 ** )<y8 D*..* -;, 7* ( 3 Z8L 9KX -2 )B3 J2) ):< 1i.*3)( 3 ٤ vi D* Z5B1( * 1;< >3.") 7* * `*\ 1".* n;2 * >+[ 3 +ux * _5V z J*/) 1-SkF * >+[ 3 * >_5V 1" J)-? 0;< 1",) ٥ ) *.") >*A[ yx z_5- J*) k 3 \*3 ( 3 +? 1" +% 3 WN" 8 1" U( D* U*4? + +k D* 1(..* U*% «yx z_5-» * 8 95:- yx 1( 3( D* *..* +ux..* U( yx 1;< z_5- );< +K; 5+ $)/ 01) vi +( 5"q ( >3.S") 6BV 1( _5 *? ),( JyX z_5- : ( * U*4? 1K<( J5 3 U-**L )-L J? z 1".* :-8 ٦ 5<4K 3 fdb* 1. Metaphysics Of Presence 2. Speech 3. Writing 4. Logocentrism 5. logos 6. Supplement

13 71 & a3 #B& J.* >3+u 3 W7s? z >*+( 1" X D5G Z4K D*..* Z4K z 1( 1-(*3!5.q +(? z v<% )K2UB2 n?.2) +m U*4? O >*+( J2) 1-%. *+ 1<<. >Y +( <k* 1" )3; J* Bs ]3; z.(mouffe,2005: 15). D* 7* >* 3 + J5;. 3 U5. J*-d 3 ]H D5( )*t+5k >8 1( D* J.* >+[ L3 W_<-? K2 * 04? ei*3.* L3 D5( D* )B8-? 3D*7*..?? +[ 1(? z )[-SkF 1( & 1" *) )Y*+ 1<<. j *?? +[ +(? z W: vi * ( 1 );< )-. >?y- :) D* % *.2) +g S% 1" 95-? 31(3 >_5 F+&I *+ 1<<. ( 1K<( JZ(:- >?U\*3 _5 F4B )-_4? 3 * }< >+[ +( +[ >?&L 7* ):i )27* +h 7* U\*3 3 )8 _5V +? 7* 65(?)[,3 )K2UB2..* 1-S ++( )?[L.(Derrida,1981:56-57) 0hdB 3 4I U*4? )K_5- >[*]*t D* Z(: * `*\ U[-.% 1" * )? )& 1S54? 1" * L3 ):8 a% )& U, 5?.7**) +5%q 1( J955Y( * D7kF (.+" * vb% -%. J-*) +( 7* >3 7* 1" +" >*8 )G 1" >*U*_, +? S/ >3 +h 7*.(19 :1385 J1 ) 1( 1S54? 8 2 >33 FU* )BO + * 3D*7* J* L3?>3*65/ 3? +65/ J?U[* 7* >*1KY2 J.* 3 32 )-BX B 3 * J* +h C.*+(._+,) >3 ),2K2F 7* 3 -*) v8.* 7* {% )N8-.* B z 1( _,+? * 3 +() )m 1" >L 7* ) * 9* I Derrida,1978: ) +.1( 5. :") WNG* X*+H1(.* U+( +.1( 6=(@54m* 3 D:- >?UB2 >*. U*4? z_5- +K; >*+( )BK* - J1;< <m 4 >?@4-;, 7* * >+[S.+/.(292 1;< *+ 1<<. 3 )K_5- 6BV 1( ( *.*.5. 0H+G S% ( 1-=5 F *+ 1<<. 3 *-I* ( +Y 1( ei*3 J+K; *+ Z" 3 +h 1( 1" >_5V J.* )K_ * D- *+ * n?.3) ).5. 3 )G4-L* +k.5. 1, +? `+-S.* )(+k z_5- )..* +65/ >? +65/ * 5:G 1(.2) +g S% 1( J V 1V 3.* P 7* 1V 1. difference

14 1397 %& 1!"# ") R5H (S% * +k.5. >Y * Z5B D54? 1(.(Kearney,1993:97) * 5:G 1(.2 Zx (+[) )-.5. 1( *+ 1<<. 7* P D* D-2*A, " ( ( 1" 7(l+5 +&V 1".* * ei*3 (Y<m) * W3* 1( D-. 1").(Derrid,1988:147) >*1S* D5V " S* * >*_(* 5N:G 7*.+" R+8 1S54? >*+( * e *L 3?& 3?3( J?. J * J52* 3 )K_5- ii z 1( +[ 1" 2) )Bd.5. *3 * 1".* 1i: D* O * +h 1( 1") 9? ).*+" *+Y5B )-X >3 +h 7*.5 1-(*3 )H% );< C,B 9hG* 6=( ei*3 1( 1 3.* )K_5- >?.5. >+g * +: 3?)-B*G)( )4x* S 7* 1-.%+( Zx *).(495 :1387 J)p "s3t) ).*+" >3 +h 7* +[ )5(* (.* )4x* )& UF G3 3 D 9h ).5. )4\ ]YG 1" (.* +( " )&1( 1 3 U2 " +[ b: 1;Bj >+A/954 +G 7* U, 5? 3 (?*% ٢ U* - ).*+" >3 5:G 1( ( ).*+" ) X * (@ F) X U*4?.(54 :1385 J1 ) 2?*=.* )2+5, ).*+" ( 5/ 1".8 D( 1K<( J5 ).5. 5( *) ).*+" 7 z J1" UG3 D* >+A/Z5<: 5=S 7*.* +*+ ).5. + * 7* 1".* >7* * +h 7* U* ).*+" 3D*7*.(119 :1387 J*).(171 :1385 J*) +5,)4 *+I )yi 3 )I:X 3+4<I +[ 1K* 5YO 3 52* ]*t DK4 +5k?@S )(+k z_5-7* * :-* ]ss-.* ** >*+( "+X J* +h 1(..* ]Gu 3 ]4<"? Z " 3 ] &(* *+7 J2) +g K2 1( <k* (52* ]*t 3 +?L D558 >*+( an) );< * )8iI ]*_4 3 3: J)& 5YO J+" >+5,954 1" > * >7( 3 W&(* Z(:? +( 1" *+,+?L +K; +(*+( *.") =S 3 9&Y * L3 )8 )85Ym 5YO ** 1, 5? 1" ").* DK4 Y1( 3 3d RB= )K2UB2 ei*3.( (98 :1378 J/9X) s-.* J* 5"q?]3; :1384 J+"-.* 3 a ).* *-.* y-i* 3 ]+O" J>+A/)5(65/ )G +( 3 _5 +5; 3 2) :*; ):<. 3 >3*65/ 7* Z:- )<4G D- 9& J)-. z5 +? 1. Undecidability 2. Democracy-to-come

15 73 & a3 #B& 173 D* 7*.2) 3.* RBj 1-+, +h D- ):5:X >8 1( )(5-. h 1( 1-@ 7. )S" : 3 1" 2) 1-2*/ =S 3 1[ >8 >** )- +? );< z5 +? * J.* 1(.2) 7* +*+ U*4? D- >8 )& 5 {*+=-.* >*+( >*1<5.3 *_(* _5 +5; *4? )8 )*+,+OK a+a/ >*+( U* G* " ( )-%2)-? JF) 421( )-%2)-? z5 7* 1" + *, B )-5B8 1S54? 3 5 5B7( M+H 9& 1" 1< D* 7* 3 ") "+X RBj 95" a *+ Y :,) + *, 3 *-I* J+; % RBj +Q* +; _5 58 & Gadamer, ) )B.(Gadamer,1988: 296).* 1-;& 1-K D54? )& +; J") v<% * >+Q* 1" );Bj.2*?*= JU5. 3* 1( +Q* 1" )=2.+5, *+I 58 *)4 ")!K8 % 7* >*+( >**+5k 58L+ J?) 6% +Q* 1( 3* 1" )8 3.* 6% RBj. 1( ٢ * v<8 " ZS5 3 1( 5+1(. D5E4? 3 +5,) * JRBj 1( D- >8 v<8 3 U25B 5V RBj *+I )-%2)-? z5 RBj [* 1" 2 1-;, +Q* 1".* )8 J+5; 3 RBj.(1988:193 + XY + 7 QF D* 3 +? 1".2 +S )BgL J2) RBj D- z C.*+( 1" ( z5.n" z5 +? >_"+ ]5<g 7* RBj + 0+h 1" K* )-%2)-? z5 +? >?U7 F C.*+( 7)( 3 )=+5k >8 M..* *+7 J.* DK4 +5k JD- )& >8 ٣ +K; ]( +h 7*.2 U54& )= v* U*4? ( 8 3 * L3 D- )B3 J.* 9"X >7+ 3 / 0i(* )G1( +Q* 3 RBj -2 >3+5 Y.1( D- ]( 5:G 1(.2) v:d C.*+( 1K<( >*U[* RBj J8 ** Y.1(.(Barthes,1977: 159) D5( 1**1 +. U54& +Q* 7* >*L ei*3 1 D- +OK )8 [* 1"?) o5u «5V RBj» 0B: J.* +OK- M..*.8 ]+O"!; ".") )s" * &F 9.* z 1( 9y ( 1".* >*1 +. *7 >*U+&V ei*3 RBj W 1( 1" >*U52 1( -2 J>*1 3 1( >*U3 7* *A, )8 J* )= J" +5Y8 1(.(RBj * J" U<L )85Ym )-X *+V3@V)( 2 RBj +"") 2)4 9y.") +55T +[ 1. Roland Barthes 2. Michel Foucault 3. Horezon

16 1397 %& 1!"# ".* >*>\Bx* JRBj >\Bx* ]( 5:G 1( J*-I* J)[*/ 7* L ]*...") P 1" X D5G *U+" 9y RBj D- +(.(Foucault,1977: 46) RBj >*+V3@V)( 5 1,D* 0i<. W 1( * % )[4? U*% 3 ]I J5KB * ) _5 +( * ]I 3 )G4-L* >?-%. D- 7**9SV D* 7*.(Barthes, 1977: 145) U*7 )- J.* 1K<( J5 RBj 3 +5; z & d RBj a7+ 1( Y / 1" * % +Q* 1( Y 1( U5YV 3 v<8- _5 )G4-L* P4-L* D-.-? 1" 7* 1") 7 )B3 J?) Z5KS 7)( )-:5:X 1[ 3 * L3 +; +5; J ) )I( 1" >_5V & J+5, ]H )*7RBj 1( J>[*RBj )G4-L* D- (.2) z 5"+ 7* * P4-L* J9? (,3;, 3 +[K ( 1i(* 3 2) >+-( U*4? )G4-L* D- L )8!5"*+/ ( )45:- ( 3D*7*.7.) +( 3 ") 5"+ )K_5- +65/ 5? yx.-5 P4-L* z D- )& >8 > 1" >+5.; J9+() 7* +.1( +5.; 7* 3+/ *) 1" US, +Q* z 4? J.* )* >?6" 7* >*1G4g 0i(* *+7 J* )*3*+ 54?* ) J1< D*.2( Z4G 7* ):< ei*3.* (6% 7 d +55T g* >*+( )* 6" )*) VV 1" )i*+2 1( }: 1".8 D* 1( US, +Q* *5/ L >?PL* ]3;- }*+2 1K<( J5 3d 2) *5/ >L +5(8 3 2) +5; U(3 D- z W: ).5. 6" J+[ ]YG1(.(162 :1385 J>*4<G )58 ) ") < JY *+,-%./ >?1S* +2 3 }( 1B: D* )<H* n? 1( 1*+,-%./ 3 1*+,-%. 7**9SV 7* +,* 1" n? 1K<(.4) 1[V &F J9+[( ).5. 3 )G4-L* >?*/ 1" )-5B5-_,* 3 )-5-7/ >[*U\. 15<G 1" ( >+K )+L )*+,-%. 1?,F )*+,-%..+" "1( P3+2 J( 1-2 Z*3* 3 :5:X a3" 1( 3 ") nax Z5<d oi. 7* * U\. :5:X.7. K2F J.* U2 +HG )5S4? 0i(* 7* 1" * &F )3 ()my*) )-<%?*/ U*4? 1K<( J5 1[ 3 +h

17 75 & a3 #B& z 0(O PL* 0i: Pu D* o+s >*+(.* L G*I & 3 U2 Z5KS )3 }(*3 7* 1" 2) 1-2*/ +,95h% -%. 1,D54? _5 % 08Bi ]Gu <k*..* _4 3 18Bi 1( 1" +.-BF U*% J+") " l?+ Wh >3 1" C3+-2* U*% ^+" %+( >_4 3 )my*.* ).+( Wh 1" ]( U*% 3 %*+/ >\Bx* -%. t=* )-5-7/ >[*]*t 7* Š )2+[ )*+,-%. 2 3 >+K 9? 7* 1" ( >+K )SYL )*+,-%./ 7* *A, >*+( )*+,-%.. 2 J)*+,-%. : 7* *+ >*+( > +; * )*+,-%. 9? JS[7( )*+,-%.-S5/ 58u3 1( )*+,-%. : 0-%.+( z U\.? 1" * 1*+,-%. +65/ D* )*+,-%./.+" U_5BK* *+ * U\. D* )*+,-%..+A/ J2) 0i.*31( 1".* )B3 J( *5/ 6: 1">m J+") 9y? -%. Z5<d >*U\. J1-, >*U\. J*+,-%./ \..+" 5X* +[ nn%+(.* * 3: )* 1K<( J2)4 )<"1( )G1( * U\. )B3 J.* -%.@3 _5 % >*+( )-X *+,-%./ \. J*7F 3 -= JU,F% \. )8 >+[23 \. )B3 J.* {% >3 +-" 0i5X 7* 1" +() +.1( )-58u3 <k* 3.* " 3 n;2 ^(? W&; >*+( )..*.* 3: >* 7( ( )K_5- +5k 3 1*+,]*tu 9& J)*+,-%. _( DX +65/ 1( 1-K D*.* L3 )<5H* 3? 5? +h 7*.7*+p(? ),( : ( 2 3 d * l?+ 18 L 0H+G 2( I 1" * L3 )N8-.* 3? 5? )-X D* 7* 1-2A,." 1( * ]*t z ei*3 3 " R+8 0H+G &F +h 1(..* ]*t z >** % 18 L 1" ") * + D* )BK* D* 1( 1L ( ( >7.954 >*+( >*U** +? J.* >+A/954 0H+G JP4-L*.2 t=* J+A/954 + * 0i5X >+5,954 )8 JPu 1. Resistance

18 1397 %& 1!"# _"+ T<21L7.>+Y?* ]8Bi J):5:X ) KS?3/ :@*+& J) );i._"+._"+ >Ĥ 5 = (:* :@*+& Jg*_ W5/ J1&.(1385) W?*+, JDBF.1 :@*+& J>1 d7c5 1@.(1386) z(( J>4X*.2 04L+ J*^ ;Ke=%=.(1379) ]*-.* Jl<"*.3.) :@*+& J3* { M1L& 42^ ;K7 f75.(1384) D5X J1+5S(.4.U,F :@*+& 04L+ J4 FA 6K2 ;&*-.(1386) ]+(* J`"(.5 0-.*+3 JK 6132 ^)X3 15;H 04L+ J«D- 1( " J](.6.U,F :@*+& Jg1 B a3.(1387) +?2 J):5:X.7. W, :@*+& J2B 3B 4&B *^.(1385) 4X* J):B%.8. W, :@*+& J* >=-* l2?+5 * 04L+ JT7?& 9 4%A.(1387) `*\ J*.9 J@+[3 *52 04L+ J723d" ;B & ;Kh2.(1385) W, :@*+& JML5"32I.U,F :@*+& JW?+/ +I( 04L+ JM1L& 42^,L J)p "s3.11.! +? :@*+& J>;H a3" 04L+ J" J...12.! +? :@*+& J!NK 47I,L ;K7.(1385) 4d. +m :@*+& J)45& S% 04L+ J6K2 = #26 & "1A >7B2,L.! +? :@*+& J>;H a3" 04L+ J J+B".15.1L% * ]*73 :@*+& J>5g 7+Y+ 04L+ J;VCi7 %,.(1386) 1%% JDs.16.@*+& U[S* ]*S-* :@*+& J 7A ;K;2S #j.(1385) +5[&L J>*4<G )58 ><21L7 J@+,3 *52 04L+ J2< 723 d" ;B.(1385) -2 J1.W, :@*+& J *+3 JML5"32I :@*+& 04L+ J7231@LI 7231@,L X7231@2&.(1380) E JB?.19.) N.* 7. >+? 7X! (A 20. Barthes, Roland(1977).image-Music-Text, Stephen Heat(trans),fontana, London. 21. Derrida, Jacques.(1999). Deconstruction in a Nutshell: A Conversation with Jacques Derrida. Edited with a commentary by John D. Caputo. New York: Fordham University Press. 22. Derrida, Jacques.(1981). Positions, The university of Chicago Pres. 23. Derrida, Jacques (1988). Limited Inc, trans. Samuel Weber, Northwestern University Press. 24. Derrida, Jacques(1978).Writing and Difference,trans by A. Bass,London:RKP. 25. Foucault, Michel(1977). «What is an atuthor?», in Josue V.harari(ed) Textual Strategies:prespectives in post-sturacturalist criticism,cornel university press. 26. Gadamer, Hans George(1988). Truth and Method (Ed), G. Barden, J. Cumming, London. 27. HindessT Barry(2007). «Marxism» in A companion to Contemporary political Philosophy, vol1,(ed) Robert e.goodin and Philip pettit,blackwell. 28. Mackenzie, iain and malesevic, sinisa(2002), Ideology After Poststructuralism, plato press. 29. Mouffe,Chantal (2005), on the political, routledge. 30. Newman, saul (2007), Power and politics in poststructuralist theory, routledge. 31. Richard Kearny(1993). Dialogues With Contemporary Continental Thinkers, in Thomas McCarthy, Ideals and Illosion On Deconstruction and Reconstruction in Contemporary Critical Theory.MIT

FLIGHTS TO / FROM CANADA ARE DOMESTIC

MINIMUM CONNECTING TIME Houston, USA FLIGHTS TO / FROM CANADA ARE DOMESTIC IAH (Intercontinental Airport) DOMESTIC TO DOMESTIC :45 AA TO DL :40 CO TO AC :30 AA, UA, US :20 CO :30 DL, WN :25 DOMESTIC TO