E3T Energy. E3T ComTAG. BPA E3T Commercial Buildings Emerging Technology Technical Advisory Group. February 27, 2014 Meeting

Transcription

1 1 E3T ComTAG BPA E3T Commercial Buildings Emerging Technology Technical Advisory Group February 27, 2014 Meeting

2 Commercial Sector The subject of many recent studies and events The focus of state, local, and national agencies More widely adoptable as ZNE-verified The top search term on NEEA s Conduit website

3 ComTAG Members ACEEE Kwatra Sameer Senior Analyst BC Hydro Rehmanji Irfan Commercial Tech Innovation Manager California Institute for Energy and the Environment Johnson Karl Research Coordinator California Lighting Technology Center PapamichaelKonstantinos Co-Director E Source Stein Jay Executive Vice President Ecova Calwell Chris Senior Research Fellow Electric Power Research Institute Siddiqui Omar Director of Energy Lawrence Berkeley National Lab Selkowitz Steve Leader of Window & Envelope Materials Group McDonough Innovation Atienza Jose Director, Senior Designer McDonough Innovation Johnson Dave Partner, Managing Director McKinstry Traube Caroline Energy Engineer National Renewable Energy Laboratory Livingood Bill National Renewable Energy Laboratory Pless Shanti Energy Research Engineer New Buildings Institute Higgins Cathy Research Director

4 ComTAG Members Northwest Energy Alliance Curry Rob Sr. Project Manager Northwest Energy Alliance Jennings John Senior Product Manager Northwest Energy Alliance Rehley Mark Ops Manager, Emerging Tech NYSERDA Savio Peter Program Mgr, Policy, Strategic Planning & Mkt Dev Oregon BEST Brickman Johanna Director of Collaborative Innovation Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Zhang Jian Senior Research Engineer PECI Strecker Cindy Sacramento Municipal Utility District Friedrich Michele Project Manager Seattle City Light Warren Phoebe Energy Management Engineer Supervisor Seattle Integrated Design Lab Pena Rob Building Performance Consultant Sera Architects Turpin Kate Integrated Design Specialist Southern California Edison CTAC Delaney Paul Asset Manager Southface Pullen Jean Principal Engineer for Resource U. of Oregon, Energy Studies in Buildings Brown Lab G.Z. (Charlie) Director

5 Meeting Agenda 9:10 Welcome Rob Penney 9:20 Agenda review, logistics Karen Janowitz 9:30 Goals of today s meeting Karen 9:35 BPA E3T framework Jack Callahan, Allie Robbins Mace 9:50 TAG process Karen 9:55 Ranking and scoring examples Karen 10:05 Review ComTAG scope Rob 10:10 Technologies & strategies Rob 11:40 Technology bundling Rob 11:50 Ranking review Karen 11:55 Wrap-up Rob and Karen

6 ComTAG Members Schedule February 27 Initial meeting March 4 Begin rating March 7 Rating surveys due April 2 Presentation #1 April 4 Presentation #1 scoring surveys due April 16 Presentation #2 April 18 Presentation #2 scoring surveys due April 24 Final meeting and scoring result discussion May TBD Follow-up meeting 6

7 Communications Listserv: Rob Penney, Technical Lead Karen Janowitz, Communications Lead The ComTAG Portal 7

8 E3TNW.org 8

9 Commercial Building Technical Advisory Group E3T Framework Overview 2/27/2014

10 Results Activities E3T Framework Collaboration TAGs Lab & Field Tests Program Design Stage Scan Screen Stage Assess Stage New Measure Gate Gate Gate Documentation E3TNW database Recommendations Savings & Cost benefits Program and Market Adoption 10

11 BPA E3T Emerging Technology Scope An emerging technology (ET) is an innovative technology or solution, not in common use, which promises a quantifiable increase in efficiency of electric energy end-use consumption or distribution within a consumer s facility. Electric end-uses only Energy savings performance features are identifiable and technically sound. Energy - Potential to provide quantifiable, reliable, and cost effective electric energy savings for end-use consumers in the Northwest region. Emerging Technology (starting to appear, arise, occur, or develop) Not yet assessed for nor included in BPA programs or measures

12 TAG Ranking Criteria Emerging Degree to which this technology is newly developing and currently ready for attention in the Northwest (could be proven elsewhere, but have little market penetration or trial in the NW) Energy Degree to which this technology has potential to provide quantifiable, reliable, and cost effective electric energy savings for end-users in the Northwest Customer Need Degree to which this technology is a clear and distinct solution to a customer need Technically Sound Degree to which this technology is expected to deliver its intended performance Ease of Implementation Ease with which BPA or a utility could implement support for this technology

13 Topic Technology Readiness Benefits Ease of Adoption Energy Savings Question TAG Scorecard This scorecard is filled out by TAG members to evaluate the measure for priority consideration. On a scale from 1 5 (1-Poor, 2-OK, 3-Good, 4- Better, 5-Best), rate the measure from the perspective of the consumer: Value Proposition How ready are the products(s) and providers to scale up for widespread use in the Pacific Northwest? How great are the non-energy advantages for the end user for adopting this technology? How easy is it for the end user to change to the proposed technology? How significant and reliable are the energy savings per unit? Considering all costs and all benefits, how good of a buy is this technology for the owner? Score (1-5 scale):

14 Energy Scorecard This scorecard is filled out by Energy staff members to evaluate the measure for priority consideration. On a scale from 1 5 (1-Poor, 2-OK, 3-Good, 4- Better, 5-Best), rate the measure from the perspective of BPA Energy : Topic Question Score Energy Savings Cost Effectiveness Implementation Regional Potential Current Opportunity How predictable and measurable are the energy savings? (considering BPA/RTF approval) Is this a cost-effective resource? (Investment meets BPA s costeffective test and portfolio requirements) Does BPA have the tools? (BPA and its stakeholders can design and implement a cost-effective delivery program.) How broadly does this apply to quickly scale up to regional savings? To what extent is this a timely opportunity considering technology readiness and current BPA situation? Composite (Total / 5 = )

15 BPA Commercial Program Context Commercial program elements: Robust lighting program Targeted grocery refrigeration program Comprehensive custom projects Deemed measure offerings HVAC Commercial kitchens Refrigeration Plug loads Other misc measures

16 Where are programs headed? Harder-to-reach markets and savings Fewer deemed/prescriptive opportunities Improved codes and standards Need to look beyond traditional deemed measure pool

17 What do we hope to get out of the TAG? Insight into new high opportunity measures and strategies Deemed, custom, any type! Technologies for emerging tech research and future programs. Building the pipeline for future program development: Measures, strategies Past TAG successes: Advanced rooftop unit controller LED measure expansion

18 Understand TAG process, and its significance within the E3T framework Review schedule Meeting Goals Discuss technologies & strategies (ETs) Add ETs not on list, if appropriate Begin the ranking process 18

19 Ranking Example Data Center TAG 19

20 Scoring Example Data Center TAG IT Equipment and Power Management Server Virtualization Solid State Drives (Flash Memory) High Efficency UPS Equipment for a Data Center Power Management for IT Equipment Storage Area Network (SAN) and Network Core Consolidation SCORES Legend ENERGY SAVINGS st place NON-ENERGY nd place READINESS rd place ADOPTION EASE VALUE TOTAL SCORES Server Virtualization Solid State Drives (Flash Memory) High Efficency UPS Equipment for a Data Center Power Management for IT Equipment Storage Area Network (SAN) and Network Core Consolidation ENERGY SAVINGS NON-ENERGY READINESS ADOPTION EASE VALUE TOTAL

21 Scoring 21

22 ComTAG Scope Topics: Building envelope Plug loads Daylighting (not lighting controls) Natural ventilation Water heating Bundling technologies to support ZNE, LEED, Living Building Challenge, etc. Integrated design Building Types: Small commercial Small retail Offices Multi-family 22

23 Ranking Criteria Emerging Degree to which this technology is newly developing and currently ready for attention in the Northwest (could be proven elsewhere, but have little market penetration or trial in the NW) Energy Degree to which this technology has potential to provide quantifiable, reliable, and cost effective electric energy savings for end-users in the Northwest Customer Need Degree to which this technology is a clear and distinct solution to a customer need Technically Sound Degree to which this technology is expected to deliver its intended performance Ease of Implementation Ease with which BPA or a utility could implement support for this technology 23

24 Example of Ranking Survey 2013 E3T IT TAG Ranking Air-Side Economizer for Data Centers Using 100% outside air cooling capability in a data center to provide free cooling in an application where outside air would otherwise be provided only to satisfy minimum ventilation requirements. Click here for technology info. Answer Options Response Percent Response Count 0- I do not support this technology 0.0% 0 1- I support this technology with significant reservations 8.3% 1 2- I mildly support this technology 0.0% 0 3- I support this technology 16.7% 2 4- I strongly support this technology 33.3% 4 5- My support for this technology is enthusiastic and unqualified 41.7% 5 Your comments are welcome 7 answered question 12 skipped question 0 24

25 ComTAG THANK YOU! We so appreciate your participation! 25